Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So upset by elopement

376 replies

Jaffacakedigestive · 28/09/2026 22:24

I found out today my DSis eloped at the weekend & married the father of her children. I'm so so upset. Not by her wedding, people can have whatever wedding they choose, but by the fact she never told anyone? My poor mum does so much for her & we all speak daily. I thought we were close but obviously not and I feel like all the trust has gone.
AIBU to be hurt?

OP posts:
Karmaiscool · 29/09/2026 13:05

@Jaffacakedigestive is it really such a major life event when you've already got the home and children etc?
Given all the family wedding dramas on here I have sympathy with people who decide to just do the deed without any fuss. It's clearly not a big deal to them, presumably more tying up loose legal ends in a low key way.
Can you and your mum not just respect their decision and wish them well?

pigmygoatsinjumpers · 29/09/2026 13:11

OP, your sister evidently had her reasons for choosing the type of wedding she had.

If she had told you what her plans were, then she would have had to decide whether or not she also told your mum.

Perhaps she worried that if she did tell your mother there might be pressure from your mum to have a family wedding.

Perhaps she also felt that if you knew, she would be placing a burden of secrecy on you and that afterwards, your mum might have been upset that you knew about your sister's plans but she did not.

For a number of reasons, I had a semi-secret registry office wedding with two friends as witnesses; we were 34 and 40 and expecting a planned baby.

My side of the family knew what our plans were and knew which day we would be getting married but my late husband's side of the family (a bedbound grandmother, a difficult mother who would not leave the house because my husband's sister, who had never left home, was in the throws of another mental health crisis) were not told in advance but told the day after.

The day after our wedding, my husband spent much of the day driving his mother to a psych hospital to collect his sister who had voluntarily admitted herself on the day we got wed but then decided she did not like being on a psych ward and wanted to be fetched home. In the midst of all this, we told his mum that we had some good news to share that a) we got married at a registry office, yesterday and b) we are expecting a baby in May - so you'll be a grandma. Her reaction to this news was: "Oh, it's not the right time."

So, if we had decided to invite both sides of the family, his sister would not have come as she was having a mental health crisis; his mother would not have come because she would not leave his sister in the house on her own, and the grandma was bedbound anyway. As it was, the first day after our marriage was spent sorting out his family's problems.

On my side of the family, my mother had initially said she understood the situation with my late husband's family and why we were thinking about not having any quests. Then a week or two later, she said if you need help with wedding expenses, we can help you. Then she told me she had bought an outfit - even though she knew that we were not planning to have quests.

Then my late sister said that every wedding that she and her husband had been to every single couple had since split up and she and my brother-in-law were not prepared to go to any more weddings. (So that meant that if we had decided on a small family gathering, not only would my husband's family not have attended but my sister and her family would not have come, either.)

The day after our wedding, I phoned my sister to thank her for a JL gift voucher she had sent and how our plans to spend the day had been scuppered by his family's problems and my brother-in-law, said: You do realise that your mother was very upset about not being able to attend your wedding and was threatening to pitch up at the registry office, anyway, and we had to persuade her not to? Which I would rather have not known about, especially as she had a sent a very nice Inter Flora flower arrangement to us on the morning we were getting married.

So it was all a bit of a mess. But I don't regret doing it that way.

Just ask your sister gently why she decided not to tell anyone.

ginasevern · 29/09/2026 13:43

@Jaffacakedigestive When you've been living together for years and produced a couple of kids, a wedding is hardly the great big life event that you're making it out to be. The horse has already bolted! Besides, a wedding is about 2 people's choices not just one. Maybe that's what her now husband wanted. And elopements have become very common these days. Seriously, I suggest you get a grip.

wherearemypeople · 29/09/2026 13:59

I can see how you feel OP, you would probably feel fine if she had told you that's what they were planning but not necessarily the actual date, but it feels weird to have close family plan something big without mentioning it.

Weddings do affect family relationships so it's not something entirely private between the couple.

Laurmolonlabe · 29/09/2026 14:36

If you want to elope you cannot mention it before the event,that is what eloping means-it is her life and her wedding ,you admit to not being close so why are you taking this so personally?

Mischance · 29/09/2026 14:42

My feeling is that you are taking this too personally... be happy for her. Send some flowers and tell her how delighted you are for her. Meet for coffee, give her a hug, ask all about it and share her excitement.

You can be close but she does not have to tell you everything.

You need to be generous spirited here, both because that is the right thing to do and because you want to maintain a good relationship into the future.

RoobarbsCustard · 29/09/2026 15:50

Jaffacakedigestive · 28/09/2026 22:54

Of COURSE I would have loved to have been there, see her marry, for my mum to get to be mother of the bride etc but that really would be all about our feelings. But it's the fact she didn't even mention it that hurts the most.

I don’t think people like the poster you’re replying to are going to understand the subtleties here…

CoddledEgos · 29/09/2026 15:54

RoobarbsCustard · 29/09/2026 15:50

I don’t think people like the poster you’re replying to are going to understand the subtleties here…

Because there aren't any 'subtleties' to understand. It's not that deep. All of the OP's melodramatic, Major Life Event posts on the thread show precisely why her sister didn't want to tell her in advance of marrying her longterm partner and the father of her children. Because it wasn't a big deal to the couple themselves, and they wanted to keep it like that.

HowardsWahey · 29/09/2026 17:08

Jaffacakedigestive · 29/09/2026 09:05

I know it's not about me, which is why I haven't said any of this to her. But when she phones me twice a day to share the absolute minutei of her day every day (whether I want to listen to it or not) it's bloody weird to not mention the fact they've decided to book to go away & get married!

Honestly, I'm trying to feel sympathetic, but every post makes you sound harder work. You keep talking about how close you are and how you talk all the time - so presumably she knows YOU pretty well as well as vice versa? And therefore maybe knew how you'd react to her decision?

Ultimately, it isn't up to you whether she tells you, your mother or anyone else what she's planning. Would your mother really have been fine about not being there if she'd known in advance she wasn't going to be there? And if yes, why does it matter that she didn't know in advance? The outcome is the same either way.

The only reason I can see to be bothered is because you now can't voice your opinion as to whether she should have a private wedding or not. If you genuinely wouldn't have minded not being there had she told you it was happening, why did you need to know it was happening?

EmpressStorm · 29/09/2026 17:12

Jaffacakedigestive · 29/09/2026 08:34

I actually was there both times she gave birth
Her choice.

She could have had the low key wedding but still had the decency to let her own mother know it was happening.

But your mum isn’t bothered.

do you have a social circle ? Support outside your mum and sister?

HowardsWahey · 29/09/2026 17:19

wherearemypeople · 29/09/2026 13:59

I can see how you feel OP, you would probably feel fine if she had told you that's what they were planning but not necessarily the actual date, but it feels weird to have close family plan something big without mentioning it.

Weddings do affect family relationships so it's not something entirely private between the couple.

But ultimately it's down to the bride and groom. And if you know the rest of the family is going to have opinions whether you want to hear them or not, sometimes it's best just to present a fait accompli.

It's not as if OP's sister turned up with a stranger and said, "I'd like to introduce Steve - my husband" like in a soap opera cliffhanger. She's got kids with the man, for heaven's sake! It sounds like a formalisation of their existing arrangement if nothing else.

HowardsWahey · 29/09/2026 17:31

batt3nb3rg · 28/09/2026 23:58

No matter how hard people try, this sort of faux confusion when people suggest that they have any feelings on the actions of others will never convince me that it's okay to behave however you want while expecting others to have no reaction. Everyone is completely within their rights to have a very private wedding, but those they have close relationships with will almost certainly be hurt and confused and they have as much right to feel as they do as you have to act as you wish. Without some serious mitigating factors, it is appalling to get married without telling people in your family with whom you have close, loving relationships. You don't have to invite them if you don't want to, but you do absolutely owe it to them to tell them and explain your reasoning in advance instead of being a coward and putting off dealing with the consequences of your actions until later.

But why did the OP and her wider family need to know their reasoning in advance if they were genuinely happy to accept the sister and BIL's decision? What difference would knowing in advance make?

I don't think there's any faux confusion here. I think people understand very well why OP wanted to know in advance.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 29/09/2026 17:45

HowardsWahey · 29/09/2026 17:31

But why did the OP and her wider family need to know their reasoning in advance if they were genuinely happy to accept the sister and BIL's decision? What difference would knowing in advance make?

I don't think there's any faux confusion here. I think people understand very well why OP wanted to know in advance.

💯. Exactly.
Love your name by the way, even if it does make me feel like I need to get my homework done before school tomorrow!

Nobu · 29/09/2026 17:55

If you tell people, it isn't an elopement. Its just a quiet wedding.
I didn't tell anyone. That way nobody coukd say they were kept out of the news.
It was perfect.
If anyone complained we could say 'we didn't tell anyone'.

hmmdunno · 29/09/2026 18:22

I think it kind of depends on whether they have expectations of you about this. If they are “phew, that’s done, the end” then YABU a bit. If they are now expecting you all to go “hey, wow, congratulations, PARTY, have a dishwasher!” Then I think that is a bit much.

Puhpuhpuhpuh · 29/09/2026 18:33

I didn’t tell anyone. Register office wedding. Our teenage dc were the witnesses. We’d been together over 20 years, bought a house then, had kids. Getting married was not a major life event. We didn’t dress up. No flowers or photos. We went on the bus. It was a legal appointment, much like going to see a solicitor.

gullgal · 29/09/2026 18:37

Jaffacakedigestive · 28/09/2026 22:31

This is EXACTLY how I'm feeling. I thought she was the person I could trust the most but that trust has gone.

I just can't relate to this in the slightest. They wanted a low key private ceremony. Big deal.

mcmooberry · 29/09/2026 18:41

I can understand exactly why you are upset, you probably feel a bit stupid/duped that she was telling you every last thing about her life and then - eh voila! The whole point is you wouldn't even have cared and there was zero need not to tell you. It's not exactly a bombshell the secrecy is just annoying.

MorrisseysMisery · 29/09/2026 19:01

CoddledEgos · 28/09/2026 22:42

To avoid precisely this level of WHAT DO YOU MEAN WE’RE NOT INVITED???WE INVITED YOU TO OURS! YOU’LL BREAK YOUR FATHER/MOTHER/ GRANNY’S HEART! I CANT BELIEVE YOU’RE HAVING YOUR SPECIAL DAY WITHOUT US!!!

This is what I have been trying to verbalise for the last 10 minutes while reading this thread!
I get the feeling they did it on purpose to avoid an irritating family who seem to think they have a right to know everything!
I'm happy that they had the day they wanted.
DP and I have discussed the same thing and we only want my grandma there!

MoominMai · 29/09/2026 19:12

Jaffacakedigestive · 28/09/2026 22:31

This is EXACTLY how I'm feeling. I thought she was the person I could trust the most but that trust has gone.

You are being so dramatic. Your sister obviously had her own reasons and decided to get married privately. It’s not like she had a huge party somewhere and deliberately missed you out. What’s with all the “ooh what else isn’t she telling me” nonsense 🤦🏻‍♀️. Just congratulate her and tell her you wish she had the day she wanted and move on - life’s so short and your spinning away time on this?!

BeGutsyGoldMoose · 29/09/2026 19:14

Maybe they just didn't want a huge fuss. Big Weddings cost money and maybe they didn't want to get into debt over one day. Why don't you offer to throw a family party/ dinner to celebrate their Union. Ultimately it is their choice as they were paying for their marriage.

Thegirlwhowent · 29/09/2026 19:16

DangerousThingsILove · 29/09/2026 08:32

This.

i don’t understand the posters saying it’s not a big deal and OP is wrong to be upset. It is a big deal and OP’s feelings are justified.

She didn't hide the marriage. She just kept the wedding ceremony private. There's a big difference. People can choose how they get married and it doesn't have to be a big, public affair.

YorksMa · 29/09/2026 19:18

There's always a disproportionate amount of 'it's not about you' messaging on mumsnet, whereas I think in real life, the majority of people would be at least a little bit upset if a close family member kept something like this from them - even if they chose not to show it. I totally get why you are upset. There is a difference between 'private' and 'secret'. If my sibling wanted a small, private ceremony, just them and their witnesses, I'd be sorry to miss it but excited for them and respectful of their choice. But if they kept the fact of the wedding a secret, had a load of fake convos with me to avoid mentioning what was really happening and chose to exclude me from even knowing about the wedding, I would be devastated. Of course, the other thing you have to remember is that with siblings in particular, there is a vast difference in 'closeness'. I'm very close to mine, as it seems you are, but other people are virtual strangers to their siblings, so would probably care a lot less.

pigmygoatsinjumpers · 29/09/2026 19:20

OP, have you actually asked your sister why they decided not to tell anyone in advance? You can keep it casual and non confrontational.

ThatOchreHedgehog · 29/09/2026 19:40

We eloped. It doesn’t mean I love my family any less or am any less close to them. We wanted something just for us and no fuss.