Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reform want to cut PIP

1000 replies

Daygloboo · 16/08/2026 09:15

Reform want to cut benefits for disabled people. They want businesses to pay more towards sickness etc. I find it repulsive that they want to do this. When will people understand that they are a bunch of self interested sharks who want to make a stack of dosh for themselves while in govt and that they font give a damn about anyone in need. Why cant the most vulnerable ppl who vote for them see thus. It's astonishing. It's ac joke. I eish ppl who get what Reform.iscreally about and how it manipulates would make sn extra effort to tslk to.ppl who dont seem to get it.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Morethanadecade · 16/08/2026 16:30

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:24

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/success-rates

This is a disability advocacy website.

This is a list of the % of successful claims for 500 claimed for disability conditions.

If you go to how to claim each individual condition it tells you how that condition is rated in the list.

Mixed anxiety and depression is the MOST CLAIMED for main conditions successfully awarded PIP.

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/pip-health-conditions/claim-pip-for-mixed-anxiety-and-depression

People seriously need to do some research before they claim things on MN.

Anxiety alone is 17/500. Adult ADHD a condition not even recognised by the NHS till 2000 is 14/500. Depression alone is 17/500. Writers cramp is included on the list as a main condition receiving an award.

And before anyone says 'that doesn't mean main condition/s', it's just categorised alphabetically so ADHD, Anxiety, and Autism look like the main condition because A lbut that's not not the main reason for the award because there's usually lots of other things.

Not true. I mean it's true that often there are other conditions but the DWP categorise it on what the form said was the main disabling condition. If it said cancer and ADHD but the reasons for impairment were that the person said ADHD was causing them more impairment, the DWP list that as the main condition.

It might fall into that category, but it would need a psychiatrist involvement and a mental health team. A gp’s say-so counts for nothing, nor would cbt or any form of “counselling”. You need to prove the effect on your life.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2026 16:33

KeepPumping · 16/08/2026 15:56

That assumes that they are all thick and don"t understand that the country is bankrupt? Reform know that the people who vote for them are way smarter than the diddies who keep voting for the virtue signaling parties that think they have a free money tree in the back garden.

Yep, paying profit making care companies £3k a week for a care placement so their carer family members can go out to work makes much more sense than paying £400/month in DLA. The problem with removing the benefit is that it doesn’t remove the need, it just passes it on to another, more expensive, part of the system.

The country may well be bankrupt, it won’t be less bankrupt by paying to support disabled people in the community through formal care arrangements.

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:34

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2026 16:27

I’ve posted about this list many times before. It’s intended for professional disability support workers and misinterpreted a LOT. The main disabling in many cases is not the only condition. And you need to look at the number of people claiming as well as the success rate. Because if only four people are claiming for a particular disability and the success rate is 50% then that means that two people are claiming.

Yeah. We know how statistics work.

I already said in my post it wasn't the only condition but the DWP categorise it as the main condition since it's the one the claimant mostly reports as causing their disability.

Do you have an explanation for why mixed anxiety and depression is the most awarded disabling conditions when they literally can't be proven because they rely on what the person says rather than any medical evidence?

Do you think it's possible that because of that, this benefit may be being abused?

KeepPumping · 16/08/2026 16:35

Tedsnan1 · 16/08/2026 15:59

Really? Under Reform?

Possibly Reform doing a deal with the Tories and Restore in the mix, but there is a strong chance Farage could be PM IMO, the present fuck up is a Tory/Labour problem but yet people still seem to want to cling to these parties and resist change, wonder why?

x2boys · 16/08/2026 16:35

Gooseling · 16/08/2026 16:00

If a persons symptoms from their anxiety disorder or depression affect their daily life and stops them from doing tasks independently and safely then yes they are entitled to PIP.

PIP is not awarded on a diagnosis of “anxiety” or “depression”. It is awarded by how much your symptoms affect your daily life.

People seem to think you can apply for PIP and say “I’m anxious/depressed” and you get PIP. That is not the case at all.

Its frustating isnt it ?
I have just done my sons PIP form recently as he was 16 in may so hes moving over from DLA
Hea severly autistic in a special school for children with severe and profound learning disabillities and i have sent off a copy of his EHCP
Risk assesmennt from school for when he needs restraint
Copies if incidents from when hes needed restraint
And a comprehensive risk assement and care plan from his respite provision
Maybe i shouldnt have bothered if
As appaerently its so easy to get it without evidence 🤔

pigsDOfly · 16/08/2026 16:36

winter8090 · 16/08/2026 10:09

Too many people are claiming disability benefits when they could be working. The stories about mobility paying for luxury cars understandably aggravates those who work hard and pay high taxes.
Also people with school age children claiming universal credit and working part time not increasing hours because they lose credit and therefore there is no incentive. The system needs reformed whilst protecting our most vulnerable.

I beleive this is who reform wil go after.

Surely under the mobility scheme cars are leased for three years and paid for by a combination of the pip payments, which can mean the whole pip payment depending of the cost of the car, and the user's own money as anything on top of their pip allowance is paid by the person using the car.

So anyone who gets a 'luxury' car under the scheme would be paying the vast majority of the cost of the car themselves.

They are not being bought luxury cars by the mobility scheme.

It's rather similar to all the amazing perks a reform supporter was telling me about recently that asylum seekers are supposedly given.

It's what Farage and his followers want people to believe because encouraging anger and division between different factions of society suits his narrative.

Starpaper · 16/08/2026 16:37

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:24

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/success-rates

This is a disability advocacy website.

This is a list of the % of successful claims for 500 claimed for disability conditions.

If you go to how to claim each individual condition it tells you how that condition is rated in the list.

Mixed anxiety and depression is the MOST CLAIMED for main conditions successfully awarded PIP.

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/pip-health-conditions/claim-pip-for-mixed-anxiety-and-depression

People seriously need to do some research before they claim things on MN.

Anxiety alone is 17/500. Adult ADHD a condition not even recognised by the NHS till 2000 is 14/500. Depression alone is 17/500. Writers cramp is included on the list as a main condition receiving an award.

And before anyone says 'that doesn't mean main condition/s', it's just categorised alphabetically so ADHD, Anxiety, and Autism look like the main condition because A lbut that's not not the main reason for the award because there's usually lots of other things.

Not true. I mean it's true that often there are other conditions but the DWP categorise it on what the form said was the main disabling condition. If it said cancer and ADHD but the reasons for impairment were that the person said ADHD was causing them more impairment, the DWP list that as the main condition.

Oh dear. Hate to burst your bubble but people have to pay for that service and they are trying to get clients.Anxiety and depression is not the most successful condition on their list and for those that have it and claim pip many like
my daughter will a have a list of additional serious conditions too.For some their anxiety and depression will be so severe they’ll need high level of services and support which is hard to get and will come with a lot of evidence that well qualifies them for pip.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2026 16:38

FreshCarnations · 16/08/2026 16:28

I work with people with long term conditions (predominantly serious mental health conditions). I would say 90% claim PIP; 5% of the people who claim and I work with are looking to use that to support them into work/travel etc, 95% of my clients DON'T work and use the PIP money for other purposes, they spend it on food/cigarettes/alcohol/hobbies.

System needs rebooting in some way.

Edited

There is nothing to say how PIP is spent though. If people work how do you gauge how much of their income is spent on the things you mention, and how much is actually supporting the extra cost of disability ? A hobby for someone with a MH condition may be an important part of their life, so is a viable disability related cost.

This is the problem with most people’s perception of disability related costs. Upthread someone mentioned having to provide receipts for extra costs and put in a claim for the expense. How do you do that if you’re incontinent and your energy bills are higher for the amount of bathing/showering/laundry, or you have to pay for incontinence protection ? I had people on my caseload who lived alone and had severe mobility problems. Everything from mowing the grass to changing a lightbulb was beyond their capability. When you’re living with substantial disability, everything costs money and not all of it is quantifiable. That’s why disability benefits are not assessed by direct cost - the level of disability is a good indicator of how much extra living with that disability is likely to cost.

Starpaper · 16/08/2026 16:40

Howlerhog · 16/08/2026 16:24

They are prepared to recognise and try to address the issue. Labour are doing f-all, not even recognising the issue. Recognising the issue is always the first step (see also violence in schools, soaring immigration, lack of housing). I want to see the government acknowledging that paying every more for improbably high rises in PIP is an issue.

Borrowing is growing massively. 10% of all the UK spends is on interest repayments and Labour is increasing this debt, not reducing it. How’s that being grown up?

Every party has recognised the issue. Other parties aren’t coming out with dumb ideas that will put huge numbers of people out of work and bankrupt companies alongside leaving every one of us at the mercy of who employs us should we fall ill long term.

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:40

Starpaper · 16/08/2026 16:37

Oh dear. Hate to burst your bubble but people have to pay for that service and they are trying to get clients.Anxiety and depression is not the most successful condition on their list and for those that have it and claim pip many like
my daughter will a have a list of additional serious conditions too.For some their anxiety and depression will be so severe they’ll need high level of services and support which is hard to get and will come with a lot of evidence that well qualifies them for pip.

What are you talking about?

What service?

This is a disability advocacy website.

They don't offer any services to anyone.

MsGreying · 16/08/2026 16:40

Interesting so many people think Reform voters are all on pip.

KnittingBasket · 16/08/2026 16:42

Livelovebehappy · 16/08/2026 13:16

Of course we currently have all those things. But cant you see how everything is falling apart? Entire infrastructure is falling apart in plain sight. Its inevitable how all this is going to end.

No, everything is not falling apart in plain sight.
My town this week has been full of crews repairing the road.
I caught the bus to the nearest city and then took a train to London last week.
Used the underground. All working perfectly.
I drove my brother to the big NHS hospital near him last week. He was treated brilliantly by the staff there.
Firefighters and emergency workers have been dealing with fires across the country all week.
The TV, radio, utility, communications networks all worked perfectly all week.
Millions of people went out and volunteered.
Millions of people went to work and came home safely.
Millions of people flew off on holiday and came home safely.
The schools will welcome a whole new year of students in a few weeks time.

Honestly - you're not looking and are just churning out 'like a third world country' cliches because it's nonsense you've heard other people say.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2026 16:42

Starpaper · 16/08/2026 16:37

Oh dear. Hate to burst your bubble but people have to pay for that service and they are trying to get clients.Anxiety and depression is not the most successful condition on their list and for those that have it and claim pip many like
my daughter will a have a list of additional serious conditions too.For some their anxiety and depression will be so severe they’ll need high level of services and support which is hard to get and will come with a lot of evidence that well qualifies them for pip.

That list comes up again and again. It wasn’t meant for the consumption of the general judgmental public. It’s for professional outreach workers who know how to interpret the data. As one of those professionals I can tell you that the only successful PIP claims for primary care treated anxiety and depression I had on my caseload were those who also had other physical disability. DWP classify the main disabling condition from the PIP claim but as with everything else, it’s the interpretation that matters, and it’s not always correct.

Starpaper · 16/08/2026 16:42

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:40

What are you talking about?

What service?

This is a disability advocacy website.

They don't offer any services to anyone.

You have to pay for their services and advice.

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/how-to-subscribe

How to subscribe

Get the benefits you're entitled to: help with personal independence payment (PIP), universal credit (UC), employment and support allowance (ESA),disability living allowance (DLA). Claims, assessments, reviews, appeals.

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/how-to-subscribe

KnittingBasket · 16/08/2026 16:44

Olive123456 · 16/08/2026 14:49

Because the tax threshold hasn't increased for years but minimum wage increases mean more people end up paying tax.

True in part.
But my reply was to someone saying the percentage of people paying tax has dropped. It has not.

Helllllooooooooooo · 16/08/2026 16:44

PIP should be means tested, and the savings should be reinvested in social care and for those who needed it the most.

I have a friend whose husband claims PIP whilst doing the same job as me, he has a blue badge too, despite zero mobility issues, he gets almost a thousand pounds a month. My friend uses the blue badge for free parking at work or in town when shopping in their expensive brand new Audi. He doesn’t need the extra money for care, his condition is controlled by medication, my friend got savvy though and used the Facebook groups etc to fill out the forms and get him the maximum.

I have just returned from holiday and every other disabled space had an Audi or Mercedes parked in it, including some tosser with a blue badge who parked there £70k Mercedes on a lifeboat reserved area, with kayaks and surf boards on the roof..

I have no issue with supporting people who need it, and I am sorry for people who find it hard to claim what they need, but blame the idiots like my friend and others who absolutely abuse the system, and have no shame hiding it either

BlueDillieDillie · 16/08/2026 16:44

ClarkeandNewman · 16/08/2026 16:16

The "welfare" (benefits) bill is stable as a percentage of GDP so to claim that it's about to bankrupt the nation is nothing but scaremongering.

Maybe it is a stable percentage of GDP but it would be nicer if it were a smaller percentage to give the tax payers a bit of a rest. Tax thresholds have been fixed for many years now for several tax paying classes that affect ordinary working people and retirement pensioners.
Perhaps we just freeze the benefit rate including PIP for a few years. Sauce for the goose - sauce for the gander.
(discuss)😃

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2026 16:44

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:40

What are you talking about?

What service?

This is a disability advocacy website.

They don't offer any services to anyone.

And to be a member and benefit from all their services you have to pay a subscription. And yes they do offer services - help with form filling and advice on how to make the best disability benefit claim, being among them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2026 16:45

Rosscameasdoody · 16/08/2026 16:21

The quote from that poster specifically linked menopause to claiming PIP.

No, she said that making employers responsible for the first two years sickness costs would impact their recruitment decisions, meaning women of child bearing age, menopausal women (and others) would be less likely to be employed. She didn’t suggest menopausal women can or should claim PIP, she listed groups that would be inadvertently adversely affected by such a policy.

Marroon · 16/08/2026 16:46

BySunnyJadeEagle · 16/08/2026 16:24

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/success-rates

This is a disability advocacy website.

This is a list of the % of successful claims for 500 claimed for disability conditions.

If you go to how to claim each individual condition it tells you how that condition is rated in the list.

Mixed anxiety and depression is the MOST CLAIMED for main conditions successfully awarded PIP.

https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/pip-health-conditions/claim-pip-for-mixed-anxiety-and-depression

People seriously need to do some research before they claim things on MN.

Anxiety alone is 17/500. Adult ADHD a condition not even recognised by the NHS till 2000 is 14/500. Depression alone is 17/500. Writers cramp is included on the list as a main condition receiving an award.

And before anyone says 'that doesn't mean main condition/s', it's just categorised alphabetically so ADHD, Anxiety, and Autism look like the main condition because A lbut that's not not the main reason for the award because there's usually lots of other things.

Not true. I mean it's true that often there are other conditions but the DWP categorise it on what the form said was the main disabling condition. If it said cancer and ADHD but the reasons for impairment were that the person said ADHD was causing them more impairment, the DWP list that as the main condition.

The condition is irrelevant, you don’t need to be diagnosed with a condition to receive PIP, that’s not even a requirement. You don’t get disability benefits for having a certain condition, not least anxiety, you get awarded it for how severely your daily life is affected and your ability to perform basic care tasks.

This is only awarded after filing out 40something pages of lengthy answers and pages and pages of supporting evidence.

KnittingBasket · 16/08/2026 16:52

Monty36 · 16/08/2026 11:04

Yes but how do the figures match with how much has the population increased in ten years ? That was my query.

More people should be more tax. In the 1960’s there were fewer people. So less tax you would expect comparative to today. Because of the fewer people.
So has the taxpayers paying tax increased in line with the population increase ?

You asked how the percentage of tax payers had changed.
I told you this -
10 years ago 52% of the UK population paid tax.
Now it's 64%.

Do you understand how percentages work?

It's a measure of the part of people who pay tax in relation to the whole number of people.

Crikey.

hedgeknight · 16/08/2026 16:54

KeepPumping · 16/08/2026 16:35

Possibly Reform doing a deal with the Tories and Restore in the mix, but there is a strong chance Farage could be PM IMO, the present fuck up is a Tory/Labour problem but yet people still seem to want to cling to these parties and resist change, wonder why?

Restore, the party that accepts donations from neo nazi who wants another Hitler? You remember how they saw disabled people?

Gooseling · 16/08/2026 16:55

x2boys · 16/08/2026 16:35

Its frustating isnt it ?
I have just done my sons PIP form recently as he was 16 in may so hes moving over from DLA
Hea severly autistic in a special school for children with severe and profound learning disabillities and i have sent off a copy of his EHCP
Risk assesmennt from school for when he needs restraint
Copies if incidents from when hes needed restraint
And a comprehensive risk assement and care plan from his respite provision
Maybe i shouldnt have bothered if
As appaerently its so easy to get it without evidence 🤔

They really have no idea! I bet all your paper work was so stressful. It’s such a kick in the teeth when we’re called “scroungers”.

itsgettingweird · 16/08/2026 17:03

KeepPumping · 16/08/2026 16:35

Possibly Reform doing a deal with the Tories and Restore in the mix, but there is a strong chance Farage could be PM IMO, the present fuck up is a Tory/Labour problem but yet people still seem to want to cling to these parties and resist change, wonder why?

Luckily it’s just your opinion.

Reform have 5 MPs.

How that translates to having enough with Restores 1 and all the loss of faith in the Tories who put is here is a stretch of the imagination!

Especially when nearly all the Tory’s defected to Reform why would they do a coalition? They don’t think the Tory party did enough?

EasternStandard · 16/08/2026 17:06

itsgettingweird · 16/08/2026 17:03

Luckily it’s just your opinion.

Reform have 5 MPs.

How that translates to having enough with Restores 1 and all the loss of faith in the Tories who put is here is a stretch of the imagination!

Especially when nearly all the Tory’s defected to Reform why would they do a coalition? They don’t think the Tory party did enough?

Idk who will win the next GE but surely it’ll be based on numbers of MPs then not 2024

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.