Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Andy Burnham that it’s about time the middle classes took their fair share

1000 replies

Morningteacup2 · Yesterday 18:11

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/08/11/burnham-middle-class-areas-must-take-more-hotel-migrants/

Not a huge fan of Labour I must say, but this is well overdue!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
DebbieSavage · Today 12:39

Everanewbie · Today 12:35

Would you tell Japanese people the same? Or is it just white Europeans that don’t have a right to a homeland?

What homeland? We aren't indigenous to these Islands you know, we came to the UK and forcibly displaced the previous inhabitants. We are every bit the migrants you want to stop peacefully coming to our shores.

SpaceRaccoon · Today 12:40

DebbieSavage · Today 12:39

What homeland? We aren't indigenous to these Islands you know, we came to the UK and forcibly displaced the previous inhabitants. We are every bit the migrants you want to stop peacefully coming to our shores.

Here it is, the "white people can't be indigenous" trope.

Must have just been dropped on earth by aliens.

EasternStandard · Today 12:41

DebbieSavage · Today 12:39

What homeland? We aren't indigenous to these Islands you know, we came to the UK and forcibly displaced the previous inhabitants. We are every bit the migrants you want to stop peacefully coming to our shores.

Not sure if you’re being sincere but would you have any limits on who could arrive?

Persephonia1966 · Today 12:41

Windsurf · Today 12:35

Apparently asylum seekers are legal immigrants so the category was changed by the people telling us that.

Asylum seeker is a legal status. It is a subset of immigrant.

All asylum seekers are classed as immigrants.
Not all immigrants are classed as asylum seekers.

People starting talking about small boats, then using numbers about overall immigration to make it sound more scary (because bigger number) then when it's pointed out that many of those immigrants are doing important jobs scoffing and saying that they don't think the men arriving on small boats will be doctors... Those people are being deliberately dishonest.

I think it's possible for two people to disagree fundamentally with each other and still be honest and have good points. Life isn't a logic puzzle with one correct answer. But when people engage in very obviously bad faith arguments and techniques it undermines any trust in the points they are making.

Windsurf · Today 12:42

DebbieSavage · Today 12:30

Oh my days you are like the fourth person to go on about 'white majority' this and that, it's so bloomin tiresome.

The sooner Britain does become majority ethnic British the better because then simply we can get past all the immigration/nativist arguing and get on with making a positive community that really inspires thinking from a globalist (rather than insular) perspective.

What is an inspiring globalist perspective and where is that operating successfully?

What do you want to happen to those that aren't inspired by this?

Everanewbie · Today 12:44

DebbieSavage · Today 12:39

What homeland? We aren't indigenous to these Islands you know, we came to the UK and forcibly displaced the previous inhabitants. We are every bit the migrants you want to stop peacefully coming to our shores.

What migration are you referencing here? Norman? Viking? Roman? None of those groups impacted our genetic make up en masse. The last great replacement was the beaker people of the early Bronze Age.

MaidOfSteel · Today 12:45

LakieLady · Today 10:30

Have you got a source for that, please?

I've known 4 people who entered the UK as asylum seekers and got refugee status (3 as clients and one I know socially). All of them are working and earning decent money (one is a psychiatrist working in the NHS, another a surveyor, the third was a TEFL teacher). The friend who is the 4th one came here as an asylum seeker, got an archaelogy degree while waiting for her asylum application to be determined and is now running the education programme for a museum and two historic buildings. All working, paying tax and contributing to society.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/refugee-integration-outcomes-rio-employment-from-2015-to-2023

Refugee Integration Outcomes (RIO): Employment from 2015 to 2023

Employment rate, working hours and earnings of asylum refugees and resettlement refugees between 2015 and 2023.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/refugee-integration-outcomes-rio-employment-from-2015-to-2023

Windsurf · Today 12:45

DebbieSavage · Today 12:39

What homeland? We aren't indigenous to these Islands you know, we came to the UK and forcibly displaced the previous inhabitants. We are every bit the migrants you want to stop peacefully coming to our shores.

Comical

BadPennyReturns · Today 12:46

Andy Burnham: the man to bring Somalia to our shires.

What message does this send to other hopefuls wondering if a ticket on the next Burnham Big Boat is worth the risk?

Of course it is. In fact, the gang members will say jump aboard lads. Gets better and better for you. Fancy a nice village location? Busman Burnham is in charge now. Nice middle class area and no doubt he will lay on free (disclaimer: funded by the British taxpayer) bus passes for you to get to meet your mates in the less well heeled areas.

Tell all your mates and do lots of tik toks to show off your new home.

PinkBottle75 · Today 12:49

Bushmillsbabe · Today 12:34

This was many years ago, after the Vietnam war, her parents are in their 70's/80's. I was giving this as an example that as a country we are generally welcoming to families, but attitudes towards refugees are being affected negatively by the number who come here as single young males

Is it useful to give examples from 50 years ago?

Not really.

The country wasn't full at that point and ethnic minorities hadn't undermined our way of life and peace.

DebbieSavage · Today 12:49

Everanewbie · Today 12:44

What migration are you referencing here? Norman? Viking? Roman? None of those groups impacted our genetic make up en masse. The last great replacement was the beaker people of the early Bronze Age.

Anglo Saxon migration. Did you even go to school?

Windsurf · Today 12:52

Everanewbie · Today 12:44

What migration are you referencing here? Norman? Viking? Roman? None of those groups impacted our genetic make up en masse. The last great replacement was the beaker people of the early Bronze Age.

Debbie should accept that we have been sufficiently globalised already in that case and we created a stable inspiring globalist population many centuries ago.

She is in fact contradictory as usual with the inconsistent patchwork of omnicause she's adeptly rolling through.

She has clarified however that the inspiring goal for the Anglosphere is permanent instability which is where we already are.

PinkBottle75 · Today 12:52

DebbieSavage · Today 12:49

Anglo Saxon migration. Did you even go to school?

That migration was a battle against the people already living here. Did you not learn that in your class at school? There were no avenues for 'refugees'.

So would you be OK if we take over our country again and kill off those we don't want- because by your logic, of 'Anglo Saxon migration' that's exactly what happened then so it's OK to do it now?

Everanewbie · Today 12:52

DebbieSavage · Today 12:49

Anglo Saxon migration. Did you even go to school?

More and more research in generics is pointing towards a cultural shift with little evidence of a mass migration of Germanic tribes, and certainly no evidence of the warfare described by Bede. What we learned in school was already out of date when it was taught to us.

Bushmillsbabe · Today 12:52

ginasevern · Today 12:37

I expect a lot of posters are too young to remember the Vietnamese boat people but I'm not. They fled their country in 1975 after the Vietnam war ended and Saigon fell to the Communists. They would have faced confiscation of property and extreme persecution had they stayed. Most were settled in America but some made it here by small boats and many died. They were largely warmly welcomed and housed in old army bases and the like. They were almost entirely made up of families with young children and shortly after arriving they worked very, very hard to rebuild their lives. They were an example to us all in many respects.

Thank you, yes thats what I meant.
They rebuilt their lives as families, worked hard, learnt English.
It was clearly so dangerous to stay that they didn't leave anyone in their family behind. Unlike many of today's asylum seekers

Scarlettpixie · Today 12:54

YABU to put up an article that is behind a pay wall.

Windsurf · Today 12:56

DebbieSavage · Today 12:49

Anglo Saxon migration. Did you even go to school?

I'm not Anglo Saxon. I'm still here. We were not forcibly displaced.

However you seem to be supporting forced displacement as your globalist inspiration. Do you think force is likely to be met with force?

LakieLady · Today 12:57

TheOutlier · Today 09:46

So why did you move from this Utopia?

Because I got a significant promotion to a job in Sussex and I didn't fancy a 90+ mile commute every day; and houses were a fair bit cheaper, too, so I was able to reduce my mortgage.

Hellokitty0 · Today 12:58

BadPennyReturns · Today 12:46

Andy Burnham: the man to bring Somalia to our shires.

What message does this send to other hopefuls wondering if a ticket on the next Burnham Big Boat is worth the risk?

Of course it is. In fact, the gang members will say jump aboard lads. Gets better and better for you. Fancy a nice village location? Busman Burnham is in charge now. Nice middle class area and no doubt he will lay on free (disclaimer: funded by the British taxpayer) bus passes for you to get to meet your mates in the less well heeled areas.

Tell all your mates and do lots of tik toks to show off your new home.

A lot of people are making fortunes out of this human smuggling economy. It is a billion pound economy. It’s not just the boat smugglers - it is all of the institutions providing housing, transport, food and entertainment services. All paid by British taxpayers while our economy nose dives and our unique culture is sneered at and changed. Developers will be given approval to build on ‘grey belt’ aka green belt as long as there is sufficient social housing - probably earmarked for these new arrivals to take them out of hotels.

ginasevern · Today 13:05

Bushmillsbabe · Today 12:52

Thank you, yes thats what I meant.
They rebuilt their lives as families, worked hard, learnt English.
It was clearly so dangerous to stay that they didn't leave anyone in their family behind. Unlike many of today's asylum seekers

Agreed. They bought homes, built businesses, learnt English and integrated very quickly indeed. They were very much an asset to the country and I remember everyone loved them!

MrsMavisPike · Today 13:06

LakieLady · Today 12:57

Because I got a significant promotion to a job in Sussex and I didn't fancy a 90+ mile commute every day; and houses were a fair bit cheaper, too, so I was able to reduce my mortgage.

You're surely not saying that a reduced mortgage outweighs the benefits of living in a diverse area!

And why on earth did you apply for a promotion away from the wonderfully diverse area that you lived in?

No, I can't believe that you put your personal finances above the Utopia you described so vividly; complete with children playing together as if they were in an advert for peaceful race relations and a school where white British children were the minority and English was not the first language of most pupils.

Surely, surely, surely, you couldn't be so shallow! Grubbing for money before the wonderful diversity that you believed in and loved so much.

I am so disillusioned.

MaturingCheeseball · Today 13:07

Oh, how I agree about the gravy train. A recent case in my local courts involved ten defendants . Each had an interpreter despite coming from the same country because they had different dialects.

The English language is going to be an issue soon; people used to have to speak English to get by - now with internet/phones/critical mass it is possible to live in a sealed bubble. Dn teaches in inner London, she says that the keenness to learn and “get on” has declined and there is a push for “personalised” schooling (ie girls not participating).

Newname26 · Today 13:08

RosesAndPeoniesAndIrises · Today 11:31

Traditionally if there were shortages of workers in an industry, wages rose. Now we can just import cheap labour. Problem solved (for some).

Thats the issue exactly. Care homes can't recuit because they don't pay enough.

Who wants to wipe someone else's backside when they could earn the same in a supermarket?

EasternStandard · Today 13:09

LakieLady · Today 12:57

Because I got a significant promotion to a job in Sussex and I didn't fancy a 90+ mile commute every day; and houses were a fair bit cheaper, too, so I was able to reduce my mortgage.

Was it worth it for the lack of diversity?

DebbieSavage · Today 13:11

MrsMavisPike · Today 13:06

You're surely not saying that a reduced mortgage outweighs the benefits of living in a diverse area!

And why on earth did you apply for a promotion away from the wonderfully diverse area that you lived in?

No, I can't believe that you put your personal finances above the Utopia you described so vividly; complete with children playing together as if they were in an advert for peaceful race relations and a school where white British children were the minority and English was not the first language of most pupils.

Surely, surely, surely, you couldn't be so shallow! Grubbing for money before the wonderful diversity that you believed in and loved so much.

I am so disillusioned.

Stop being so disingenuous. The good thing is that, now that she has moved to somewhere less diverse from somewhere that benefitted from diversity, she will vote for somebody who will help bring diversity to where she lives now so that everybody else can also enjoy the life she used to have.

So in your vain attempt to belittle that poster, you have failed to realise that she is going to do a good thing for a whole new group of people who still live in disgusting homogeneity. 😚

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.