Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Andy Burnham that it’s about time the middle classes took their fair share

1000 replies

Morningteacup2 · 11/08/2026 18:11

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/08/11/burnham-middle-class-areas-must-take-more-hotel-migrants/

Not a huge fan of Labour I must say, but this is well overdue!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
IwouldlikeanewTV · Yesterday 08:15

KateDelRick · Yesterday 08:12

I just want to say that I sympathise with your situation. With the best will in the world, it's going to impact your village. I am sure that some of these men are genuine and law abiding and just want to settle and get jobs. However, some will be chancers, criminals and opportunists. Many of them have been socialised in countries where girls and women have no status and no rights. Large groups of men hanging around with nothing to do is a bad idea.
I'm sure you've contacted your MP, so good luck with any measures taken. When is this going to happen?

It has. Read up about Crowborough.

moonraker0 · Yesterday 08:16

Shouldn’t really be a problem if MN is anything to go by because it’s usually the middle class shouting racist at people like me who already have them and live in an underfunded deprived area. Can’t wait for the threads where people realise the impact of it, have fun being harassed walking down the street, having fights with machetes and knives in the streets and watching them blatantly loot your shops.

KateDelRick · Yesterday 08:17

probablyamunreasonable · Yesterday 08:02

By saying this, Burnham has admitted having asylum seekers In your community is not a positive thing and the burden needs to be shared.

By doing this, the wealthy NIMBYs will realise the reality of what the poorer people have been putting up with and complaining about for a while. They perhaps won’t sneer and call all those against it ‘racist and uneducated’ anymore.

Stopping the boats’ will become a bigger issue for the public than it already is and Burnham and government will be under more pressure than ever.

Edited

That's an interesting thought, isn't it? I live in a pleasant, low crime, middle class suburb. Many people voted Green. My neighbour has displayed "refugees welcome" sign for a while now. I often wonder what would happen if he's literally taken at his word!
We shall see what transpires.

WhatTheHellsGoingOn · Yesterday 08:17

I’d love to hear what the celebs think down in the Cotswolds etc. if a building of this nature was proposed there. Or any other highly affluent area for that matter. How would they argue against it without looking like a racist nob - very much awkward for them I’d have thought.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:17

EnglishRose26 · Yesterday 08:08

Such nasty undertones of real spite and hatred and class war vibes. Is this really what the country needs? More politics of hate and nastiness from the left.

Surely the right thing to do is to acknowledge the huge immigration issues we all face and tell the country Labour are determined to change the law, pull us out of the ECHR and actually deport all illegals. That would have given Burnham the respect of most of the country, and killed off reform and restore's momentous gains, but no, back to the 1970s we go with water and power failures, recession. IMF bailout and another 2/3 millions illegal arrivals. Andy Burnham is going to finish this country off unless we can get him out.

Edited

It wouldn’t give him my respect. I’d feel utterly and completely betrayed.

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 08:18

likelysuspect · Yesterday 07:41

It needs repeating. The 'British', whoever they are, deserve all this, as a job lot because of what 'we' did

However, a group of people who share current anti equal, anti womens rights, anti equal rights, anti western values, must not be veiwed as a 'job lot' and cant assume any one of them is going to behave antisocially or criminally simply because of their historical culture and how they generally behave

Completely contradictory and completely illogical.

That's because they insist they are the intelligent ones. I don't believe it's intelligent to shout free Palestine, put Zios in the ground, hope that murdered politicians were handcuffed to beds, dying in agony, backing a Gaza party, based in the UK, harassing women for being born women, working in the NHS and intimidating Jews etc, sitting in roads, stopping traffic, using sledehammers on policewomen, destroying military aircraft, minimising the racist rapes of young white girls. Protecting Walter Mitty cheating academics because they are not white. Yes, all smacking of outstanding levels of intellect.

TiggyTomCat · Yesterday 08:19

Illegal migration is not "fair" on anyone in any area. At what point does this actually stop? A word of warning to our Andy...if you don't do something very meaningful to stop it rather than just expecting everyone to just stop complaining and suck it up then you will be hero to zero before you know it.

ChattyKnickers · Yesterday 08:19

Shark321 · Yesterday 08:02

Having worked in an inner city school, the white working class boys were the ones running around the building kicking doors, throwing tables and chairs at people, damaging equipment, swearing and being homophobic and racist. The non white British and non British born children were the ones behaving and working hard.

I feel this is a separate issue with legal immigration (usually selected from high skilled backgrounds) with parents who value education

KateDelRick · Yesterday 08:21

IwouldlikeanewTV · Yesterday 08:15

It has. Read up about Crowborough.

Thank you, I will.
Also, I'm interested in what happens with that poster's village.

probablyamunreasonable · Yesterday 08:21

WhatTheHellsGoingOn · Yesterday 08:17

I’d love to hear what the celebs think down in the Cotswolds etc. if a building of this nature was proposed there. Or any other highly affluent area for that matter. How would they argue against it without looking like a racist nob - very much awkward for them I’d have thought.

They will argue against it by saying it will bring ‘far right racist’ protestors in to their town and make it unsafe for the asylum seekers. They will say the infrastructure won’t be able to cope and the asylum seekers won’t be able to access the help and services they need. They will say the accommodation is not adequate for the asylum seekers.

That’s what the left wingers have been saying in Bicester.

YouAreEntitledToMyOpinion · Yesterday 08:23

Burnham is signing Labour's death warrant.

Never thought I'd say it, but I agree with Macron. We need to remove the desire to get to Britain.

The message must be sent that if you enter illegally, you will never be given no British citizenship and will not be allowed to bring any family. If they keep coming, they are sent to a third country or held on floating vessels out at sea.

If they are not happy with this arrangement, then leave.

Plus how did they get that massive boat into the sea?? Who manufacturers them? How did it get transported to the beach? Maybe Macron can put a few rules in place.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:24

Burnham is signing Labour's death warrant.

That’s obviously why they’re topping the polls.

moonraker0 · Yesterday 08:25

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:24

Burnham is signing Labour's death warrant.

That’s obviously why they’re topping the polls.

He’s gone up in my estimation after announcing this.

LancashireButterPie · Yesterday 08:25

Fabulous! So you now arrive on a small boat and get housed in Richmond or Harrogate? That won't exactly discourage more from coming will it?

If Andy B, stands any chance of remaining in power he needs to read the room on this issue. The solution needs to be to improve the speed of processing the refugees and swiftly deporting economic migrants.

I live in a quiet village, we have gangs of young male migrants hanging around the river and canal tow paths now. I would not dream of walking the dog down there, alone, now. This is not a fear based in myth either, a teenager was recently raped in a local park and 2 asylum seekers from a local HMO were charged.

YouAreEntitledToMyOpinion · Yesterday 08:26

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:24

Burnham is signing Labour's death warrant.

That’s obviously why they’re topping the polls.

Let's see what the next poll says.

Wibble128 · Yesterday 08:26

His first job is defence of the realm. That should be his Prime focus. He like his predecessor will do nothing to stop the new Labour voters coming in on the boats. The approach of the Left is short sighted and will ultimately prove destructive to the UK.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:27

YouAreEntitledToMyOpinion · Yesterday 08:26

Let's see what the next poll says.

Yes let’s.

probablyamunreasonable · Yesterday 08:28

LancashireButterPie · Yesterday 08:25

Fabulous! So you now arrive on a small boat and get housed in Richmond or Harrogate? That won't exactly discourage more from coming will it?

If Andy B, stands any chance of remaining in power he needs to read the room on this issue. The solution needs to be to improve the speed of processing the refugees and swiftly deporting economic migrants.

I live in a quiet village, we have gangs of young male migrants hanging around the river and canal tow paths now. I would not dream of walking the dog down there, alone, now. This is not a fear based in myth either, a teenager was recently raped in a local park and 2 asylum seekers from a local HMO were charged.

Most asylum seekers are allowed to stay after they’re processed. Only 4% of small boat arrivals are sent back.

We all know most are economic migrants but know what to say in order to claim asylum - there are lots of reports on people saying they’re gay etc when they are not.

(and yes I know the number of small boat arrivals are a drop in the ocean compared to those who arrive via other means)

OneAmberFinch · Yesterday 08:29

Wibble128 · Yesterday 08:26

His first job is defence of the realm. That should be his Prime focus. He like his predecessor will do nothing to stop the new Labour voters coming in on the boats. The approach of the Left is short sighted and will ultimately prove destructive to the UK.

Agree - there will be no realm if it's not defended - anything else must come second

LancashireButterPie · Yesterday 08:33

HotGrapefruit · 11/08/2026 23:15

The Tories opened the carer’s visa route to ordinary care workers in 2022. If you could wash an arse you could come over. Those workers could initially bring partners and children, and the Conservatives themselves removed that right for new care-worker applicants in March 2024. 90,000 “carers” came over plus their families and dependents. Totally untrained. But had to mop up social care work that EU workers left after Brexit. fucking madness.

Edited

Yes this!

EnglishRose26 · Yesterday 08:34

Let's be clear, Andy has been left with a ticking time bomb courtesy of Reeves and Starmer totally annihilating the economy. To be measured it is a Labour created poison chalice at this point for Burnham. No wonder he isn't moving to London. There is no point uprooting his life and family for the short stint ahead of him.

Andy has taken a good look at the 3 trillion debt mountain, and realised his shopping list isn't going to happen any time soon without an IMF bailout.

He has just seen fuel shortages coming down the line, an incoming deep recession, an explosion of unemployment and benefit claimants forecast as early as next month, and he has decided it might be easier if he just creates a class war as a diversion for the real issues that are about to hit the British people. Divide and conquer used to work a treat.

Labour have created this total shit show. Our economy WAS picking up, we were doing okay and were predicted growth before Reeves and Starmer arrived, and Burnham is going to be even worse, he really has no clue how to 'fix' anything and isn't even bothering to try, but it is nice to play the big dog for a while. Great for his CV.

Well done to anyone that voted for this, small clap for you, however you were completely lied to - so it is not entirely your fault. The worst is very much yet to come, and the 1970s in all ways is going to look like a teddy bears picnic compared to the damage that is just about to be inflicted on us by the toxic combination of total ignorance and incompetence at a time in the world when we can least afford it. Brace yourselves.

DestituteDesperate · Yesterday 08:34

moonraker0 · Yesterday 08:16

Shouldn’t really be a problem if MN is anything to go by because it’s usually the middle class shouting racist at people like me who already have them and live in an underfunded deprived area. Can’t wait for the threads where people realise the impact of it, have fun being harassed walking down the street, having fights with machetes and knives in the streets and watching them blatantly loot your shops.

Quite right.

I’m not white and find it bemusing how many liberal, white, well off women are so quick to play the race card to stifle debate.

Not one person has an issue with legal migration and immigration but when illegals are crossing the channel daily in their hundreds, predominantly males and being given social housing and other such resources, everyone, irrespective of race, ethnicity, religion would agree we have an issue.

That’s not even touching the issues with women and children, especially white under aged girls being targeted.

ChattyKnickers · Yesterday 08:34

I have a friend working at the DHS at the Trump administration. He tells me they just detian and deport. Usually sending back to Mexico or if not that country of origin.

Maisey1991 · Yesterday 08:35

Hoardasurass · 11/08/2026 18:22

Nope they all need to be deported immediately not housed and allowed to stay.
Nobody should have to put up with these men in their community

We have had 0 problems with the asylum seekers in our community, if you think it’s only
men coming here means your thick enough to believe the mass hysteria around it. The only problem we had was when the council estate spread enough rumours around itself and decided to send Molotov cocktails and bricks through the windows of the hotel where terrified children were sleeping :) they then got relocated for their own safety.

MindThePause · Yesterday 08:36

Ignorance is not a crime punishable by rape or death.

The vast majority of people who are blind and deaf to the issue are so due to a knowledge gap.

That was me in 1985. I didn’t deserve what Luton did to me as “just desserts”.

So no. No more avoidable victims. Who are more likely than not going to be women, teenage girls and children. Believe me or don’t believe me, the scales falling from my eyes came at a terrible price that I’ll carry to my grave. I cannot wish that on anybody.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.