Best Amazon Prime Day deals: Mumsnet favourites

Best Amazon Prime Day deals:
Mumsnet favourites

Shop now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Andy Burnham is smug?

489 replies

Lyra25 · 22/06/2026 12:28

To think Andy Burnham is smug and presumptuous. Just that really and I have no particular political preference, disillusioned with the lot!

OP posts:
MulberryBrandy · Yesterday 12:06

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 12:01

Yes there is a difference, and I understand your wish for a utopian political system.

But I think being realistic about human society/politics is important - is there a democratic nation you can point to that has declining living standards, a cost of living issue, reduced public services but has NO political parties focusing on scapegoats?

The secretive wealth that is tolerated in our constitutional monarchy makes it harder to stomach that we are now being allocated a second coronation within our parliamentary democracy.

CandidOP · Yesterday 12:11

So, as far as I understand it Starmer's popularity had improved quite a bit in recent polls although still pretty dire. This surely must have been a gradual realisation of the policies he has been putting through which genuinely help renting, working class people, particularly those with young children. I think the MP's were pretty dumb to get rid of him because in another three years with more time and more of the same even the rabid right wing press might have failed to drown out his achievements. If you start to notice things getting better even the papers and social media telling you it's all getting worse would have less breakthrough. They will all start on Burnham immediately. He will initially also make stupid mistakes and a good year will be wasted while he gets a bit of experience under his belt. Tony Blair always said that the time a PM is at their worst is immediately after gaining power and the time they are at their best is when they leave. This country really doesn't have a year to waste.

5128gap · Yesterday 12:45

Great response from Burnham to Badenoch's personal nastiness. No retaliation. Just humour, good grace and a good camera angle. Excellent example of what he can bring to a personality based political arena that Starmer couldn't.

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 14:59

CandidOP · Yesterday 12:11

So, as far as I understand it Starmer's popularity had improved quite a bit in recent polls although still pretty dire. This surely must have been a gradual realisation of the policies he has been putting through which genuinely help renting, working class people, particularly those with young children. I think the MP's were pretty dumb to get rid of him because in another three years with more time and more of the same even the rabid right wing press might have failed to drown out his achievements. If you start to notice things getting better even the papers and social media telling you it's all getting worse would have less breakthrough. They will all start on Burnham immediately. He will initially also make stupid mistakes and a good year will be wasted while he gets a bit of experience under his belt. Tony Blair always said that the time a PM is at their worst is immediately after gaining power and the time they are at their best is when they leave. This country really doesn't have a year to waste.

It was a little improved.
But still very low, currently about -45 against a worst rating of -50?
Those numbers are not politically sustainable.

Whether anyone can ever get better numbers long term is a very good question!

BlueMinded · Yesterday 16:34

MulberryBrandy · Yesterday 09:27

It is surely best for the country if we level the playing field?

As much as I loathe the privilege afforded middle class kids education simply due to their parents finances, you're talking pie in the sky if you believe we can level the playing field by reducing private school places. Classism is baked into our society and will ever be thus. You get a young graduate with a home counties RP accent with a second class degree from a former poly, but who presents and speaks well vs Gregg from a Birmingham council estate with a first class honours from a Russel group uni but speaks with a thick, local dialect and lacks self esteem- who'd you think would get the job? Money also buys confidence and connections. Working class kids will never be able to compete. But it's ALWAYS been that way.

MulberryBrandy · Yesterday 16:45

BlueMinded · Yesterday 16:34

As much as I loathe the privilege afforded middle class kids education simply due to their parents finances, you're talking pie in the sky if you believe we can level the playing field by reducing private school places. Classism is baked into our society and will ever be thus. You get a young graduate with a home counties RP accent with a second class degree from a former poly, but who presents and speaks well vs Gregg from a Birmingham council estate with a first class honours from a Russel group uni but speaks with a thick, local dialect and lacks self esteem- who'd you think would get the job? Money also buys confidence and connections. Working class kids will never be able to compete. But it's ALWAYS been that way.

People that I know don't fit into such distinct groups as that. For instance, someone who went to a comp before being first in the family to go to uni. Dad self-employed manual work, mum a cleaner and got into The Civil Service Fast Track. I am just talking about keeping that initial gateway wide re: the conversation earlier in the thread.

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 17:37

BlueMinded · Yesterday 16:34

As much as I loathe the privilege afforded middle class kids education simply due to their parents finances, you're talking pie in the sky if you believe we can level the playing field by reducing private school places. Classism is baked into our society and will ever be thus. You get a young graduate with a home counties RP accent with a second class degree from a former poly, but who presents and speaks well vs Gregg from a Birmingham council estate with a first class honours from a Russel group uni but speaks with a thick, local dialect and lacks self esteem- who'd you think would get the job? Money also buys confidence and connections. Working class kids will never be able to compete. But it's ALWAYS been that way.

But it's ALWAYS been that way.

If you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got.

If it shouldn't be that way, then efforts should be made to change it.

BlueMinded · Yesterday 17:56

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 17:37

But it's ALWAYS been that way.

If you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got.

If it shouldn't be that way, then efforts should be made to change it.

Nice sentiment, but how do you propose we do this? Nothing's changed for millennia, don't you think of it were possible, change would have happened by now?

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 18:11

BlueMinded · Yesterday 17:56

Nice sentiment, but how do you propose we do this? Nothing's changed for millennia, don't you think of it were possible, change would have happened by now?

That's precisely what people said/say about all prejudice and inequality.
There's nothing else I can say.

BlueMinded · Yesterday 18:23

concertinacornflake · Yesterday 18:11

That's precisely what people said/say about all prejudice and inequality.
There's nothing else I can say.

Spoken like a true sixth form sociology student. Sorry. I too was once you, full paid up member of the socialist workers party. Until you reach middle age and accept it for what it is - you get by with the few chinks of light and success stories. But society is rotten to the core and regardless of who is in power, that's capitalism for you.

user1484264563 · Yesterday 21:11

AmberSpy · 22/06/2026 12:29

Shall we let the man have five minutes in office before we start tearing him to shreds?

He doesn't need any introduction, previously an MP and several years as Manchester mayor where he's been responsible for quite a few project fails wasting tens of millions £ and his nepotism is shocking with the wife heading companies that won valuable contracts within the city.

BananaPeels · Today 09:40

BlueMinded · Yesterday 16:34

As much as I loathe the privilege afforded middle class kids education simply due to their parents finances, you're talking pie in the sky if you believe we can level the playing field by reducing private school places. Classism is baked into our society and will ever be thus. You get a young graduate with a home counties RP accent with a second class degree from a former poly, but who presents and speaks well vs Gregg from a Birmingham council estate with a first class honours from a Russel group uni but speaks with a thick, local dialect and lacks self esteem- who'd you think would get the job? Money also buys confidence and connections. Working class kids will never be able to compete. But it's ALWAYS been that way.

I do t agree with you. My grandfather was a miner from the north. Both his children went to local school and then onto London Russell group universities. When asked how they did it, they just said we applied and got in. They didn’t see any barrier to entry at all.

Dolphinnoises · Today 10:00

user1484264563 · Yesterday 21:11

He doesn't need any introduction, previously an MP and several years as Manchester mayor where he's been responsible for quite a few project fails wasting tens of millions £ and his nepotism is shocking with the wife heading companies that won valuable contracts within the city.

That thing about his wife is disinformation.

bookist80 · Today 12:50

5128gap · Yesterday 12:45

Great response from Burnham to Badenoch's personal nastiness. No retaliation. Just humour, good grace and a good camera angle. Excellent example of what he can bring to a personality based political arena that Starmer couldn't.

Edited

This.

I actually think she fancies him and he will use it to his advantage. I look forward to their exchanges.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page