Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Welfarisation has made people utterly entitled and unable to take responsibility for themselves and their families.

633 replies

hagchic · Yesterday 16:59

I grew up in a working class family. The values I was taught were that you stood on your own two feet and it was no one else's job to do what you could do for yourself.

If you were hurt, you were expected to get up and go and clean yourself up - and stop whining about it unless it was actually serious. If you were ill, you went to bed and if you were lucky some magic lucozade appeared.

If you were sad, then you were sad. If life was unfair then that was just how life was and you needed to deal with it.

You never ever sought charity or took benefits when you were able to work or put up with less. You lived to your own means, not to what you saw on TV or at school - and if you wanted that lifestyle it was up to you to get it.

Today everyone has the expectation that someone must help them, that they are obliged to help them - even before they have made any attempt to actually do the work of helping themselves. They expect luxuries like holidays, pets, new clothes and treats when they do nothing to earn this.

I think self sufficiency is a value that needs to return to our society.

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · Yesterday 18:11

I agree with the OP but for the fact that we are taxed to buggery, so if im paying 1/4 of my income as tax and thats not considering other taxes such as vat, i want some returns when I need them.

Just had to pay privately for a much needed minor op as nhs waiting lists horrendous, so feeling rather sore about it and i don't mind the wound from the op although that is sore too.

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:11

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · Yesterday 18:10

Yep, the abandon the sick at birth club....but obviously there is a lot of us. So we might need to turn a few away.

Do we get a badge?

can I have a clipboard and a tick sheet? Maybe a spreadsheet?

KellySeveride · Yesterday 18:12

It never fails to amaze me that there is a collective on Mumsnet so determined to be politically correct that they’ll deny any sort of benefit fraud. There are LOTS of people quite happy with the state funding their lifestyles. Maybe move out of the leafy burbs and you’ll find them! I’ve said it before I personally know one family who are now 3 generations in of people who have NEVER been in paid employment!

I say this as a recipient of UC despite both me and DH working! DH full time….me I’ve been fighting management for months for the spare 4 hours in the budget that were released in the office by another member of staff reducing their hours - which would take me up to full time too. The red tape that is blocking it is ridiculous!

ABOOO · Yesterday 18:12

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:06

But I get pip which apparently I don’t need according to a poster here?

why is this sort of ableism acceptable?

Correct me if I'm wrong and I genuinely may have made a mistake (I have checked back though)

But didn't you jump on with a sarcastic comment about telling your legs to work, before anyone mentioned disabilities?

I didn't get the impression your comment was in reply to anyone at the time?

Generallychill · Yesterday 18:12

Why is it genuinely disabled people get so wound up about it when these sort of threads or posts come on and cant seem to grasp the concept that its not about them??

People do play the system thats a fact, it doesnt necessarily impact other claimants of benefits but they do.

But back to the entitlement, its even little things, I know 2 people who need jobs done to their house, one needs cupboard doors fixing its literally hanging off its hinges and could be dangerous for her kids but rather than paying someone to do it she'd rather wait weeks for the council to come out and fix it.

whatsit84 · Yesterday 18:13

JuliettaCaeser · Yesterday 17:30

It’s the word “support” that annoys me. Everything is about needing requiring or wanting “support”.

This is my least favourite word. No one says what it actually means. In the workplace it seems to mean ‘shouldn’t have to do all of my job that I’m being paid for’…..

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:13

ABOOO · Yesterday 18:12

Correct me if I'm wrong and I genuinely may have made a mistake (I have checked back though)

But didn't you jump on with a sarcastic comment about telling your legs to work, before anyone mentioned disabilities?

I didn't get the impression your comment was in reply to anyone at the time?

I’m still disabled and I do get welfare benefits.

id have thought having to tell my legs to work was a bit of a clue I was, indeed, disabled?

Anyahyacinth · Yesterday 18:14

I guess this is the attitude that prevailed pre NHS pre Pensions….associated with a far higher infant mortality rate and lower life expectancy. A hugely sick workforce.

Meanwhile you believe self sufficiency will get you through climate change for example OP?

Absolutely laughable

lobwedge · Yesterday 18:15

What's weirder is how the rich want handouts as much as the poor. And get them.

ABOOO · Yesterday 18:16

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:13

I’m still disabled and I do get welfare benefits.

id have thought having to tell my legs to work was a bit of a clue I was, indeed, disabled?

You've misunderstood me.

Someone asked why you brought disability into it when it was clear the OP hadn't.

I think you said it was in reply to others who had.

But I don't think anyone had when you made your first post.

PenelopeJoanSterling · Yesterday 18:16

Cackleandcluck · Yesterday 18:07

I do agree with some of the points. If minimum wage keeps rising, what is the incentive to train in a trade or go to university if you are no better off? Most careers have more pressure, more unsocial hours, more training that minimum wage jobs don’t have but the wage doesn’t rise. I’m at the top in my career but each year I get more responsibility for no more pay. I pay more for everything, travel, union, professional registration, exams etc.
In my job, I see people taking no responsibility for themselves. They complain of long waits but don’t take the medication prescribed, don’t turn up to appointments, expect transport because even though they have a car they don’t want to drive or park. It’s endless and I don’t know where or when it will stop.
Taking responsibility for yourself is more than just claiming benefits. If you are achieving the very best you can then that is different. If you want the very best for your children then it’s about encouraging them to become their best self and doing something that will fulfill them. Benefits should be there for people who need them and not a way of life. Children need to see all kinds of role models and opportunities should be equal across the country. We need to change people’s mindset. Unfortunately this mindset is passed down from generation to generation. PiP absolutely should continue, the assessments are for people who really need them a horrible experience and should never be conducted the way that they are.

but then the cost of living needs to stay the same otherwise business will fold anyway due to only the rich rich being able to use them

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · Yesterday 18:17

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:11

Do we get a badge?

can I have a clipboard and a tick sheet? Maybe a spreadsheet?

Oh yes a badge, a club booklet, and all the benefits of the club you never wanted to be part of...but obviously it is non-negotiable 🤣😬🤣

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:17

ABOOO · Yesterday 18:16

You've misunderstood me.

Someone asked why you brought disability into it when it was clear the OP hadn't.

I think you said it was in reply to others who had.

But I don't think anyone had when you made your first post.

Edited

The whole op was don’t claim benefits. Just get looked after by family. Soldier on. Don’t claim anything. Did you read it?

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:17

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · Yesterday 18:17

Oh yes a badge, a club booklet, and all the benefits of the club you never wanted to be part of...but obviously it is non-negotiable 🤣😬🤣

I can even do a pivot table.

Weeellokthen · Yesterday 18:17

ToKittyornottoKitty · Yesterday 17:07

Sounds like you had mean parents growing up.

😂

cloudtreecarpet · Yesterday 18:17

InterestQ · Yesterday 17:52

Increasing minimum wage would be insane and break even more employers and small businesses than the latest one has.

PIP is fine - unless someone’s getting a car for their self diagnosed alleged ADHD.

work just needs to pay more than not working. It’s very simple. Getting a job should mean you are pleased and proud to be getting more in the bank. Not have you grabbing a calculator and pursing your lips over whether it’s “worth it” or not.

So work needs to pay more than benefits but increasing the NMW must not happen?

Riiiight, that makes sense...

KateSixer · Yesterday 18:18

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:01

In the olden days I’d have been institutionalised from birth most likely and I wouldn’t have been able to ever work or do anything. Is that really what people want to go back to?

where is @hagchic ?

You undermine your own argument.

Your own personal experience does not mean that arguments that the welfare state has been over expanded to an unaffordable level or that there are not a lot of people receiving - honestly or otherwise -benefits who are exploiting the generosity of taxpayers are not valid.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · Yesterday 18:18

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:17

I can even do a pivot table.

Ooh, you're in! 🤣👍😎

Anyahyacinth · Yesterday 18:18

Generallychill · Yesterday 18:12

Why is it genuinely disabled people get so wound up about it when these sort of threads or posts come on and cant seem to grasp the concept that its not about them??

People do play the system thats a fact, it doesnt necessarily impact other claimants of benefits but they do.

But back to the entitlement, its even little things, I know 2 people who need jobs done to their house, one needs cupboard doors fixing its literally hanging off its hinges and could be dangerous for her kids but rather than paying someone to do it she'd rather wait weeks for the council to come out and fix it.

Disabled people get ‘wound up’ because these vile threads are about their literal ability to live and survive.

Lets rush back to Victorian times though and abandon all society.

RudolphTheReindeer · Yesterday 18:18

Today everyone has the expectation that someone must help them, that they are obliged to help them

well yeah, because in some situations the law says they must help them. What's wrong with expecting the law to be adhered too?

sounds like you grew up in a not very nice house tbh if no one even cared when you were hurt or ill. I don't think that's something to aim for.

JustTryingToBeMe · Yesterday 18:18

PurpleLovecats · Yesterday 17:08

Oh good, another benefit bashing thread. And people with MH issues were thrown in institutions, disabled children lived shorter lives due to less input, there were workhouses.
Sounds idyllic.

what in the OP was bashing benefits? The current problem is that benefits aren’t there to support people in a dire emergency; they have become a lifestyle choice. This was not the intention of them and it is grossly unfair on people who do work hard.

ABOOO · Yesterday 18:18

Bbcsounds · Yesterday 18:17

The whole op was don’t claim benefits. Just get looked after by family. Soldier on. Don’t claim anything. Did you read it?

Yes and it doesn't mention disability, you were the first to bring disabilities into it.

Perhaps the OP should've put the usual disclaimer in though.

IDontHateRainbows · Yesterday 18:18

VickyEadie · Yesterday 17:27

"Everyone got free school meals, milk, eye tests, glasses, dentistry, prescriptions...
Unemployment benefit, housing allowance."

Absolutely untrue. I was born in 1958 - apart from children getting free school milk at primary school and eye tests for adults, the rest were not available to everyone. My dad was a coal miner - we never got free meals, which were only for a smaller minority than now. Prescriptions were not free; dentistry was not free; glasses were not free; there was no housing benefit when I was a child and unemployment benefits were very restricted.

By the 1980s glasses were (for kids) the shit nhs issue specs that marked you out as a poor kid+ speccy 4 eyes to boot.

Theunamedcat · Yesterday 18:18

Bring back workhouses and while we are at it institutions for autistic and "disabled" people lord knows we dont want those people around

Fuck my life no wonder they passed assisted suicide bill

I fucking despair

THERE ARE NO FUCKING JOBS IN AREAS OF HIGH UNEMPLOYMENT THE NHS IS SHITE AND PEOPLE ARE CLAIMING DISABILITY BENEFITS WAITING FOR NHS TREATMENT PEOPLE GET DEPRESSED IN THESE SITUATIONS WHICH MAKES EVERYTHING WORSE

I can't understand obvious issues for you if your so keen to throw poor and disabled under the bus I can only hope you learn empathy before you need some help yourself

PenelopeJoanSterling · Yesterday 18:18

lobwedge · Yesterday 18:15

What's weirder is how the rich want handouts as much as the poor. And get them.

because without the rich, and there business empires, there would be hardly any need for the general population