Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse living with in-laws after our move fell apart?

224 replies

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:25

Okay this is going to be a long post but I am just so mentally exhausted and could really do with some advice.
Some back story: I (American) married my British husband in 2018. I had always told him that I don’t want to permanently settle in the UK, I like the quality of life in America and my family is also there. Unfortunately, we never ended up moving to America. Something which still breaks my heart to this day.
We lived in London for the first year of our marriage I just did not like it. I didn’t like how expensive or congested it was and people were just not friendly. My husband randomly got a job offer for Liverpool and moved there in 2019. We had two beautiful children here and lived a lovely home.
Summer 2025 my husband said that he got a job opportunity in which he could live either in Liverpool or London. We were torn! But then decided to move to London (Aldershot area) in the end. Reasons being, my husband’s family is all there and there is also a really massive Muslim community there, something which was really lacking in Liverpool.
We sold our beautiful house and broke chain to move to London.
The four of us temporarily moved into a tiny one bedroom flat (it was only supposed to be for one month) but our house sale fell through. We were so shocked. We then went for another house. We were meant to move in the first week of January but 4 days before the exchange, it fell through as well. The owners decided they didn’t want to sell anymore. The third time, we went for a new build. It’s going to be ready in July.
Now here is the worst part. The house we are buying is terraced whereas our house in Liverpool was detached. This house is an okay size but obviously smaller than our Liverpool one. I’ve struggled so much in the flat. I wanted to keep my kids in the same school they started at here so it takes me an after house just to get there in the mornings. I spend 2 hours a day doing school runs. All of my belongings and things are in storage. It’s been so hard. All of a sudden now, my husband has come to me and said that he’s miscalculated the finances and we can’t even afford the house we’re buying. He said we’d be paycheck to paycheck IF THAT. He’s now saying to me that why don’t we live with his parents for one year, get financially secure and then move. I can’t tell if he’s doing this because he wants to move back to Liverpool as he literally hates it here. The six years we were in Liverpool, he always used to say he would eventually want to move near his parents. Now that he’s here, he hates it. I would have been happy staying in Liverpool but I knew he wanted to move here and I got sick of trying to stop it from happening. Anyways yeah, after selling our beautiful 4 bedroom home, he’s now saying to me that we should move in with his parents for one year as buying this house would be financially impossible. I have no idea what to do. I’ve recommended we get a smaller house, but mortgage rates have gone up and monthly comes out to be similar. I really don’t want to live with my in-laws. My MIL doesn’t work and can be really overbearing.
I also do not like this area tbh. I loved Liverpool. I loved the friendliness and the convenience and the openness of it. But I’m unsure if we should move back for that reason. Should we stick it out for another few years to see if we end up liking it here? Would buying the house be a bad idea then? After living in a one bedroom flat for a year, would it be worth it to live with my in-laws for ONE YEAR and then just go back? Do I hate it here because of how dead and quiet and expensive it is or do I hate it because of the chaotic year we’ve had? I just don’t know what to do. I’m so upset about everything. I wish I’d never sold my dream home and come here.

OP posts:
raisinglittlepeople12 · 28/05/2026 13:23

Aldershot isn’t London

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 28/05/2026 13:23

I also think the Liverpool fast train is a good idea if he will agree to it

Traveltart · 28/05/2026 13:24

Don’t buy a flat or a new build. Neither have great resale potential. Your husband is right that you can’t afford this house anyway. Mortgage costs shouldn’t be more than a third of your salary as it makes life very uncomfortable. Can you rent in a cheaper area for two years? I would invest your deposit into two stocks and shares ISAs, focusing on low cost all market ETFs. Please make sure you’re on top of the details of your finances: all the more essential if you’re the lower earner. You should research what your husband would get paid in the US as a doctor vs the UK. Then show him how many millions (yes really) he could stand to make over a 20 year career there vs here. He may change his tune about retraining in the US… Trump won’t be in power forever so the hostile environment for Muslims will hopefully ease.

TheSquareMile · 28/05/2026 13:41

OP, do you think that it's possible that he had an agreement with his parents that, after med school and training, he would relocate to the Aldershot area with his wife and children, so that everyone was close by?

I can imagine the family wanting to chip in financially to make this a reality.

columnatedruinsdomino · 28/05/2026 13:53

Non-negotiable living with ILs, it will become easy for him to come up with excuses not to leave.

Best option, buy in Liverpool, he commutes from ILs for the duration of training.
Absolutely no way buy a new build to sell again after such a short time.
Last thought - do you know 100% he a) asked to transfer his training and b) got turned down?

Sensiblesal · 28/05/2026 13:54

Live with his parents.

he said he can’t afford the house & needs a year to save. Or you could get a job or increase your financial contributions

Dillydollydingdong · 28/05/2026 13:59

Property is cheaper in the north, so houses more affordable. And I wouldn't call Aldershot "London". It's nowhere near London. Can you afford to rent?

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 28/05/2026 14:05

Dillydollydingdong · 28/05/2026 13:59

Property is cheaper in the north, so houses more affordable. And I wouldn't call Aldershot "London". It's nowhere near London. Can you afford to rent?

It's about 32 miles from London.

Stoicandhappy · 28/05/2026 14:05

Tell him tough. You aren’t moving in with his parents. He either accepts the temporary separation or you split up permanently.

ItsOkItsDarkChocolate · 28/05/2026 14:12

@MomofAM

What a horrible position you are in!

Do not move in with the MiL’s! You will not like who he becomes!

Renting somewhere else is not a waste of money if it ultimately saves your marriage!

He is not being fair with his views and options he is leaving you with.

Given you have not been able to move back to America, which was the plan, I think needs to do a much bigger compromise gesture. He’s being a bit of a selfish, spoilt, prick if I’m honest.

You’ve relocated, again, for his work and his career, you DO get a say on how/where you live for it!

Good luck!

UpDownAllAround1 · 28/05/2026 14:47

When anyone says renting is a waste of money they have been listening to their parents imo

NotThisShitAgain121 · 28/05/2026 15:05

Do not move in with the inlaws. Big no no. Sod that.

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 28/05/2026 15:58

UpDownAllAround1 · 28/05/2026 14:47

When anyone says renting is a waste of money they have been listening to their parents imo

Or friends with rich parents.

ShhhhhItsASurprise · 28/05/2026 16:53

Again, as I don’t think OP has responded, are you not legally committed to buy the new build already? You usually exchange quite quickly on new builds even though completion can be some time away. If you have exchanged, you risk losing your deposit if you walk away.

this is a key consideration.

Donsyb · 28/05/2026 22:04

UpDownAllAround1 · 28/05/2026 14:47

When anyone says renting is a waste of money they have been listening to their parents imo

Well I think it’s right in most cases - you are paying someone else’s mortgage when you rent, rather than paying down your own. If you never buy somewhere, you also have to face paying rent until you die.

However, there are occasions where renting can make more sense, such as only planning to live in an area for a short time.

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 28/05/2026 22:08

You are paying for a roof over your family's head, that's not a 'waste of money'.

Donsyb · 29/05/2026 07:12

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 28/05/2026 22:08

You are paying for a roof over your family's head, that's not a 'waste of money'.

It’s almost always better to be paying off a mortgage to own your home rather than renting.

of course not everyone can afford that, and that’s not their fault. But if you can, and plan to live somewhere medium to long term, buying makes much more sense than renting.

Bigcat25 · 29/05/2026 12:09

@Donsyb But that's not the case here. By the time they close it would be just under two years.

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 29/05/2026 12:24

Donsyb · 29/05/2026 07:12

It’s almost always better to be paying off a mortgage to own your home rather than renting.

of course not everyone can afford that, and that’s not their fault. But if you can, and plan to live somewhere medium to long term, buying makes much more sense than renting.

In terms of financial investment, yes, but not if you are moving to an area for a short term.

You need a roof over your family's head and that's a separate sort of investment.
You might be renting to get into good schools etc.

Your mortgage might commit you into living in an area where you don't want to be.

It's more complicated than a 'renting is paying off someone's mortgage'.

OP doesn't want to live in the area. They might be relocating in 2 -5 years' time. They'd be buying brand new where new houses are being built, and the house would lose the brand new premium. They'd be affected by stamp duty etc.

Being told that you are throwing money down the drain when you can't afford to buy is downright insulting.

Vaxtable · 29/05/2026 12:33

I would tell him you ll need to move back to Liverpool. He can the stay with his parents during the week for his course and travel home to Liverpool at the weekends and holidays

i certainly would not be moving in with his parents

Timeandtune · 29/05/2026 12:41

Just a thought… could you extend the term of your mortgage to lower the monthly repayments?

KiwiFall · 29/05/2026 12:41

Move to Liverpool and stop wasting more money on moving. He stays with parents to do his course and commutes when he can up to you. Get to understand your finances as he doesn’t sound like you can rely on him for not looking at the finances but making sensible decisions for you as a family as a whole.

BigSkies2022 · 29/05/2026 12:42

Am I being thick here? Why don’t you rent if you have to stay for the duration of his GP training? You can get something more comfortable, maintain your privacy and independence and stay light on your feet until you can decide London v Liverpool for the longer term.

Donsyb · 30/05/2026 07:12

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · 29/05/2026 12:24

In terms of financial investment, yes, but not if you are moving to an area for a short term.

You need a roof over your family's head and that's a separate sort of investment.
You might be renting to get into good schools etc.

Your mortgage might commit you into living in an area where you don't want to be.

It's more complicated than a 'renting is paying off someone's mortgage'.

OP doesn't want to live in the area. They might be relocating in 2 -5 years' time. They'd be buying brand new where new houses are being built, and the house would lose the brand new premium. They'd be affected by stamp duty etc.

Being told that you are throwing money down the drain when you can't afford to buy is downright insulting.

That’s what I said!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page