Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse living with in-laws after our move fell apart?

214 replies

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:25

Okay this is going to be a long post but I am just so mentally exhausted and could really do with some advice.
Some back story: I (American) married my British husband in 2018. I had always told him that I don’t want to permanently settle in the UK, I like the quality of life in America and my family is also there. Unfortunately, we never ended up moving to America. Something which still breaks my heart to this day.
We lived in London for the first year of our marriage I just did not like it. I didn’t like how expensive or congested it was and people were just not friendly. My husband randomly got a job offer for Liverpool and moved there in 2019. We had two beautiful children here and lived a lovely home.
Summer 2025 my husband said that he got a job opportunity in which he could live either in Liverpool or London. We were torn! But then decided to move to London (Aldershot area) in the end. Reasons being, my husband’s family is all there and there is also a really massive Muslim community there, something which was really lacking in Liverpool.
We sold our beautiful house and broke chain to move to London.
The four of us temporarily moved into a tiny one bedroom flat (it was only supposed to be for one month) but our house sale fell through. We were so shocked. We then went for another house. We were meant to move in the first week of January but 4 days before the exchange, it fell through as well. The owners decided they didn’t want to sell anymore. The third time, we went for a new build. It’s going to be ready in July.
Now here is the worst part. The house we are buying is terraced whereas our house in Liverpool was detached. This house is an okay size but obviously smaller than our Liverpool one. I’ve struggled so much in the flat. I wanted to keep my kids in the same school they started at here so it takes me an after house just to get there in the mornings. I spend 2 hours a day doing school runs. All of my belongings and things are in storage. It’s been so hard. All of a sudden now, my husband has come to me and said that he’s miscalculated the finances and we can’t even afford the house we’re buying. He said we’d be paycheck to paycheck IF THAT. He’s now saying to me that why don’t we live with his parents for one year, get financially secure and then move. I can’t tell if he’s doing this because he wants to move back to Liverpool as he literally hates it here. The six years we were in Liverpool, he always used to say he would eventually want to move near his parents. Now that he’s here, he hates it. I would have been happy staying in Liverpool but I knew he wanted to move here and I got sick of trying to stop it from happening. Anyways yeah, after selling our beautiful 4 bedroom home, he’s now saying to me that we should move in with his parents for one year as buying this house would be financially impossible. I have no idea what to do. I’ve recommended we get a smaller house, but mortgage rates have gone up and monthly comes out to be similar. I really don’t want to live with my in-laws. My MIL doesn’t work and can be really overbearing.
I also do not like this area tbh. I loved Liverpool. I loved the friendliness and the convenience and the openness of it. But I’m unsure if we should move back for that reason. Should we stick it out for another few years to see if we end up liking it here? Would buying the house be a bad idea then? After living in a one bedroom flat for a year, would it be worth it to live with my in-laws for ONE YEAR and then just go back? Do I hate it here because of how dead and quiet and expensive it is or do I hate it because of the chaotic year we’ve had? I just don’t know what to do. I’m so upset about everything. I wish I’d never sold my dream home and come here.

OP posts:
ilikeitwarmbutitstoohotforme · Yesterday 12:48

I have changed my name as I live near to Aldershot. It has some unique elements to it which bring its own problems. I won’t say it’s a shit hole but it’s not the nicest.

it is a military town - although the army are leaving it has a legacy of a transient population of young squaddies causing trouble.

it also ‘welcomed’ lots of Gurkhas to resettle with their family and then absolutely let them down by housing them in shabby HMOs.

SO it’s a difficult place to settle as nobody really chooses to be there. It’s surrounded by expensive Farnham & Fleet so it’s an affordability problem.

I wouldn’t live with my in-laws. I considered it when mine were small but actually just ended up renting instead. I’m glad we did although there was a big financial hit.

I’ve waffled on long enough but I really sympathise.

Branster · Yesterday 12:51

Looking at the way your married life has evolved, I am willing to bet anything I own that your DH will never take you back to Liverpool.
Aldershot is nowhere near London, it’s in the second county south of London.
You really need to be more proactive and find a house in Liverpool (or within a radius of two counties from Liverpool!) and buy it or find an equivalent rental property.
You also need to seriously consider your personal financial situation and do the best you can to earn a decent income. From your posts, it comes across as if you live in a parallel universe to your DH, you have no idea what the household finances are and you don’t even know where you are living exactly.
Don’t be passive and let DH dictate what is happening to you and your children because it looks like he is either planning long term to dump with his parents or he is clueless about what he is supposed to be doing.
Do not move in with his parents.

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 13:05

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:51

We can’t move back to Liverpool for another two years as he’s in a training program here, he has two years left. I’m just confused what the heck we should do for those two years. Should we buy the house and try to settle here or should we live with his parents and I’ll hate my life but I’d know I’m going back to Liverpool? So confused.

Well ‘he’ can’t move back but you can. Wouldn’t the solution be to take your kids back to Liverpool and buy or rent a smaller place and your husband can stay with his parents for his training? I’m very confused about how much autonomy you have in your own life though as it seems like where you’ve ended up isn’t at all what you wanted or want.

Singlemum90 · Yesterday 13:36

Maybe I'm missing something but it seems obvious to me that you and the children move back to Liverpool asap, and your husband moves in with his parents for the 2 years training contract. At that point he moves back into the Liverpool house with you. They are close enough distance he can come back home (to you and the kids in Liverpool) on weekends or when he is off. Yes there will be some expense with travel, but clearly you both prefer Liverpool and 2 years is not a long time to live between 2 homes. You have compromised enough leaving America.

Bigcat25 · Yesterday 13:50

Rent a bigger apartment, don't move in with his parents no matter what. The transaction costs of owning for only two years probably won't be worth it, but I'm not in the UK.

Sorry this founds like a massive hassle for you.

chichi2026 · Yesterday 14:03

This is one of those posts which makes me doubt my comprehension abilites - I'm so confused!!

As a brown woman from London, living in Liverpool, I just wanted to comment on this:

Summer 2025 my husband said that he got a job opportunity in which he could live either in Liverpool or London. We were torn! But then decided to move to London (Aldershot area) in the end. Reasons being, my husband’s family is all there and there is also a really massive Muslim community there, something which was really lacking in Liverpool.

I know you're from the US but you have access to the internet and even a cursory glance would show that Aldershot does not have a "massive Muslim community" - it's got a large Nepalese community (largely due to its ties with the Gurkha regiments) but they would presumably be majority Hindu or Buddhist.

Liverpool has the oldest fully functioning Mosque in Britain. Granted it's not a fully diverse city but there are areas (Toxteth, Wavertree) which are rich in diversity and have large Muslim populations. Generally though, if you avoid certain areas (I live in one of them!) you would be fine and have no reason to worry about living a wonderful live as a Muslim here.

If the money is available, I would be getting back here and saying to husband that he can visit on his days off. However, I've probably not understood anything you've said properly, so there is that!

AlohaRose · Yesterday 14:05

I missed that the medical training was the GP training programme, in which case I don't know why you moved from Liverpool in the first place if he was also offered a place there? Did neither of you research housing costs, factor in selling/buying costs etc? Or if being in an area with a greater Muslim population was important, how did you end up in Aldershot which isn't known for that, although Woking which is about 30 mins from there is and has a large mosque?

I would be cautious about buying again in Liverpool until you see where your husband may end up after his training. My understanding from the children of several friends who have just completed/considered undertaking GP training is that it is a struggle to find a permanent position afterwards because surgery budgets have been cut to the bone. One friend who qualified did a maternity cover for a year and kept his fingers crossed that a permanent position would come up somewhere in that decent-sized town by the time that finished but it was pretty scary for a while. If you can rent instead in Liverpool until you see where your husband ends up, that could be better.

Katemax82 · Yesterday 14:07

UpDownAllAround1 · 26/05/2026 21:32

you lost me after you said the worst part is the house is terraced

I couldn't live in a terraced house

Katemax82 · Yesterday 14:12

Can you rent a 2 bed until you can move back to Liverpool? Or is rent more expensive (I'm guessing it is in London)

Crikeyalmighty · Yesterday 14:26

Katemax82 · Yesterday 14:12

Can you rent a 2 bed until you can move back to Liverpool? Or is rent more expensive (I'm guessing it is in London)

Aldershot is not London - not even that close , rents are considerably less -

whattheysay · Yesterday 14:42

What does a miscalculation of finances actually mean? He thought he earned more money than he does? He forgot he has no savings? I don’t know how after two houses have fallen though, you’re on your third house but he doesn’t know your financial position.
Do you know what money you have and how much the mortgage would be? Because you seem to be just accepting everything he says.
Are you a sahm with no access to the finances?
It sounds like he doesn’t want to buy the house, or any house in aldershot, so moving in with his parents will allow you to have options once his training is over, regardless of what you want.

Livpool · Yesterday 14:43

UpDownAllAround1 · 26/05/2026 21:58

As you say - this is confusing. Liverpool has a far larger Muslim community than Aldershot being one thing. Let him live with his parents and you rent somewhere around your work/school needs ip
north

Edited

I am on Liverpool and think the same (don’t know Aldershot to be fair!). I have Muslim friends and loads of our neighbours are Muslim. There is a lovely mosque is walking distance. And my area isn’t unusual.

Livpool · Yesterday 14:49

I wouldn’t move in with in-laws, you’ll never leave!

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · Yesterday 14:49

Aldershot isn't in London. What part of Liverpool were you in? Manchester?

MyAutumnCrow · Yesterday 14:53

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · Yesterday 12:25

You post this every couple of months with small variations. You never listen to any advice or take any action so what's the point?

Oh.

Does the OP change the locations??

VickyEadie · Yesterday 15:03

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · Yesterday 14:49

Aldershot isn't in London. What part of Liverpool were you in? Manchester?

😂And even if they were in the Manchester area of Liverpool, Manchester still has a bigger Muslim population than (more than 30 miles from London) Aldershot!

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · Yesterday 15:08

MyAutumnCrow · Yesterday 14:53

Oh.

Does the OP change the locations??

Yes, but it's always that she wants to live in the north and her trainee doctor partner wants/needs to live in London. I think America is a new plot twist.

VickyEadie · Yesterday 15:16

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · Yesterday 15:08

Yes, but it's always that she wants to live in the north and her trainee doctor partner wants/needs to live in London. I think America is a new plot twist.

Her being American gives context to the illusion she's under that Aldershot is part of London, however - many Americans think the South of England/UK is all "London".

I once took my American friend to York from London and she asked me, on the day we were just about to drive back to London (actual London, not Aldershot) if we could "just pop to the Lake District".

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · Yesterday 15:23

VickyEadie · Yesterday 15:03

😂And even if they were in the Manchester area of Liverpool, Manchester still has a bigger Muslim population than (more than 30 miles from London) Aldershot!

The population of Manchester is about 550,000 greater than the population of Aldershot. Not sure where you'd get a training hospital near there. Nearest hospital is Frimley Park.

AndrewMountbattenWindsor · Yesterday 15:25

VickyEadie · Yesterday 15:16

Her being American gives context to the illusion she's under that Aldershot is part of London, however - many Americans think the South of England/UK is all "London".

I once took my American friend to York from London and she asked me, on the day we were just about to drive back to London (actual London, not Aldershot) if we could "just pop to the Lake District".

Smile. They also seem to think that Scotland and Wales are in England.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Yesterday 15:28

onmylastnerveseriously · 26/05/2026 21:45

Aldershot is NOT London. Does your husband think it is or did he lie?

Was coming on here to say just this.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Yesterday 15:29

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · Yesterday 15:08

Yes, but it's always that she wants to live in the north and her trainee doctor partner wants/needs to live in London. I think America is a new plot twist.

Damn, it's her. Oh dear, missed the signs on this one.

VickyEadie · Yesterday 15:31

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Yesterday 15:28

Was coming on here to say just this.

You'd think she'd have found this out for herself by now, though! I mean - she can't see Buckingham Palace OR Big Ben.

BoredZelda · Yesterday 15:34

Katemax82 · Yesterday 14:07

I couldn't live in a terraced house

Same. I used to and it was ok, but having lived in a detached house, I’d struggle to go back to it.

neilyoungismyhero · Yesterday 15:35

I think it's worrying the OP and people seen to think Aldershot is London?