Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse living with in-laws after our move fell apart?

214 replies

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:25

Okay this is going to be a long post but I am just so mentally exhausted and could really do with some advice.
Some back story: I (American) married my British husband in 2018. I had always told him that I don’t want to permanently settle in the UK, I like the quality of life in America and my family is also there. Unfortunately, we never ended up moving to America. Something which still breaks my heart to this day.
We lived in London for the first year of our marriage I just did not like it. I didn’t like how expensive or congested it was and people were just not friendly. My husband randomly got a job offer for Liverpool and moved there in 2019. We had two beautiful children here and lived a lovely home.
Summer 2025 my husband said that he got a job opportunity in which he could live either in Liverpool or London. We were torn! But then decided to move to London (Aldershot area) in the end. Reasons being, my husband’s family is all there and there is also a really massive Muslim community there, something which was really lacking in Liverpool.
We sold our beautiful house and broke chain to move to London.
The four of us temporarily moved into a tiny one bedroom flat (it was only supposed to be for one month) but our house sale fell through. We were so shocked. We then went for another house. We were meant to move in the first week of January but 4 days before the exchange, it fell through as well. The owners decided they didn’t want to sell anymore. The third time, we went for a new build. It’s going to be ready in July.
Now here is the worst part. The house we are buying is terraced whereas our house in Liverpool was detached. This house is an okay size but obviously smaller than our Liverpool one. I’ve struggled so much in the flat. I wanted to keep my kids in the same school they started at here so it takes me an after house just to get there in the mornings. I spend 2 hours a day doing school runs. All of my belongings and things are in storage. It’s been so hard. All of a sudden now, my husband has come to me and said that he’s miscalculated the finances and we can’t even afford the house we’re buying. He said we’d be paycheck to paycheck IF THAT. He’s now saying to me that why don’t we live with his parents for one year, get financially secure and then move. I can’t tell if he’s doing this because he wants to move back to Liverpool as he literally hates it here. The six years we were in Liverpool, he always used to say he would eventually want to move near his parents. Now that he’s here, he hates it. I would have been happy staying in Liverpool but I knew he wanted to move here and I got sick of trying to stop it from happening. Anyways yeah, after selling our beautiful 4 bedroom home, he’s now saying to me that we should move in with his parents for one year as buying this house would be financially impossible. I have no idea what to do. I’ve recommended we get a smaller house, but mortgage rates have gone up and monthly comes out to be similar. I really don’t want to live with my in-laws. My MIL doesn’t work and can be really overbearing.
I also do not like this area tbh. I loved Liverpool. I loved the friendliness and the convenience and the openness of it. But I’m unsure if we should move back for that reason. Should we stick it out for another few years to see if we end up liking it here? Would buying the house be a bad idea then? After living in a one bedroom flat for a year, would it be worth it to live with my in-laws for ONE YEAR and then just go back? Do I hate it here because of how dead and quiet and expensive it is or do I hate it because of the chaotic year we’ve had? I just don’t know what to do. I’m so upset about everything. I wish I’d never sold my dream home and come here.

OP posts:
CheeseyOnionPie · 26/05/2026 21:51

You need to be more involved in the finances - you should both be calculating them together.
Was he handling all the details of the other houses that fell through? Makes me think he didn’t really want to buy in Aldershot and was just getting you moved to the area so you could end up having to move in with your in-laws, but then I’m a skeptical person.

Aldershot is definitely not London.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 26/05/2026 21:55

TemporarilyCantDoMyself · 26/05/2026 21:36

Correct me if I've misunderstood anything.
You both love Liverpool. You both seem to not love - even to hate- London.
You can afford a decent house in Liverpool. You'll struggle to afford a decent house in London.
Your husband can work from Liverpool or London.
You've sacrificed where you wanted to live for the marriage.

If all of this is broadly correct - let alone the nightmare moving in with your in-laws could be - move back to Liverpool. It seems like a bit of a no brainer?
Very best of luck. Losing houses is so upsetting, we took 2 years to move without any small children and lost 3 houses en route, so I understand how very exhausted you must be and how hard it is to know what to do. 💐

This.

Sounds bizarre how did this come about?

parakeet · 26/05/2026 21:56

I'm bemused by how much you seem to leave really really important life decisions up to your husband, and then just blindly accept things he tells you, when he seems to have made some serious misjudgements here. Like, he says Whoops, we can't afford these mortgage payments after all, soz! And you just say: OK! Didn't you know what the mortgage payments were? Do YOU think they are affordable or not? Plus, he's saying "terraced houses don't sell well in Aldershot"... I mean, you are looking to buy a terraced house in Aldershot so clearly at least some people want them. Sounds ridiculous - any house will sell if the price is right. Why don't you take some responsibility and do some proper research yourself?
And I advise just saying No on living with in-laws. If you are already forseeing problems it will be ten times worse once you're in.

UpDownAllAround1 · 26/05/2026 21:58

As you say - this is confusing. Liverpool has a far larger Muslim community than Aldershot being one thing. Let him live with his parents and you rent somewhere around your work/school needs ip
north

Motnight · 26/05/2026 21:59

ShootsAndBoots · 26/05/2026 21:37

I think you need to take a good close look at the finances because I'm extremely sceptical that he "miscalculated the finances"

I agree with this. I don't understand why you have no idea of the financial situation either, Op. Not a good place to be in.

MauriceTheMussel · 26/05/2026 22:03

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:51

We can’t move back to Liverpool for another two years as he’s in a training program here, he has two years left. I’m just confused what the heck we should do for those two years. Should we buy the house and try to settle here or should we live with his parents and I’ll hate my life but I’d know I’m going back to Liverpool? So confused.

Nooooo, you absolutely don’t know that!

sundaysurfing · 26/05/2026 22:03

I don’t think you should buy in London because it’s true it will be so faffy to then have to sell in a year. I think you maybe should live there for a year and just save the money. But that depends on how bad it will be - Only you know if it is unbearable. But think about the money you’ll save and after one year you will be hopefully able to go back to Liverpool and get a nice house again. One year of sacrifice to get what you want….. You and your husband need to be a team, though!

BeOpalQuail · 26/05/2026 22:05

Is there a reason why you can't rent if after two years you be moving back to Liverpool?

Quitelikeit · 26/05/2026 22:05

Don’t buy a house for the sake of two years

However I’m highly suspicious how a GP somehow managed to miscalculate the finances on a house? It really isn’t that complicated

To manage with two young children in a tiny one bed flat you must have the patience of a saint!

Left · 26/05/2026 22:06

He’s got a year left in training. After that where does he want to work?

Because if Liverpool is an option, and you both want to move there, why not look to buy there again now. By the time you finalise sale there will be six months left of his placement - you can move back to Liverpool with the kids, he can stay with his parents for 6 months.

Agree with others saying you need to review finances with him.

TheMimsy · 26/05/2026 22:07

@MomofAM do you ever wonder if this was his plan all along? I think if you move in with in-laws you will massively regret it within 3 months…

I take it you are a SAHM if the MIL bring at home all day is an issue?

imagine trying to make meals when you want. Relax when are where and how you want. No privacy. No real alone time. Get your own shopping in.. managing around ILs preferences.. trying to mange your own laundry, drying, childcare and children’s routines and discipline. For 365 days. Under their roof.

nope nope nope.

IsthataNo · 26/05/2026 22:07

Move back to Liverpool he can commute and see you

AbzMoz · 26/05/2026 22:09

Why are the only two options Liverpool or london? Do you (could you) work? How old are the dc? This seems like a lot of what ifs and moving around.

If at the end of two years you’ll happily go to Liverpool you might as well go with dc now - it’s 3-4hrs by train and he can stay at his parents.
The background re the US seems unnecessary - if this is really what you want to do then it sounds like you’ve chosen the wrong partner as it’s not an option for him at all.

movinghomeadvice · 26/05/2026 22:11

OP, how much access do you have to the family finances? I know exactly how much we have, down to the cent, and can access all of it, whenever I want. There is no way that I wouldn’t realise that we ‘couldn’t afford’ a house that we’d planned to buy. This part is really strange to me.

Are you sure he has to stay for two years to finish his training? How do you know that?

Ilikewinter · 26/05/2026 22:13

BeOpalQuail · 26/05/2026 22:05

Is there a reason why you can't rent if after two years you be moving back to Liverpool?

This!!

PermanentTemporary · 26/05/2026 22:14

I think you need to get a lot more involved in the decision - take more control of your own life. I also think you as a couple need to game out ALL the options.

Youre a fairly young couple with young children, at least one of you has a very sellable job training (I bet you do too) - you could live absolutely anywhere.

An option that occurs to me immediately is that you as a couple buy a house in Liverpool, you move back there with the kids, he moves in with his parents and finishes his two years’ training, commuting to see you all weekly.

I will be honest and say that I would live almost anywhere in the world before I seriously considered settling in Aldershot.

CluelessAboutBiology · 26/05/2026 22:14

If you’re looking for a large Muslim community, Woking is close to Aldershot….but it’s a lot dearer.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/05/2026 22:16

I think you should rent a two bedroom flat until the job is up then decide where to settle and buy. I also think you maybe should work.

CranberryCandyCane · 26/05/2026 22:16

Sonato · 26/05/2026 21:49

My exact thought

How on earth do you "miscalculate"

If you go for a house that’s at the top end of what a lender will let you borrow it’s easy to overstretch yourself then realise what you can borrow and what you can comfortably borrow can be vastly different.

Hagr1d · 26/05/2026 22:17

MomofAM · 26/05/2026 21:46

Yes I’m South Asian. We moved because a part of him always wanted to live near his family. I have some cousins in London too. And there is a bigger Muslim community which we thought would be nice for the kids. We just didn’t realize we’d hate the lifestyle here. We can’t move back for another 2 years as he’s in GP training here so I just don’t know what to do for those 2 years.

I had a hunch you would be... Dont do it, you say she is 'overbearing' already - this will turn into outright controlling behaviour. Maybe I am projecting my own trauma but Ive see that the older generations cannot let go of the typical 'saas/bahu' type of relationship where as the daughter in law you will always be made to feel subservient and reminded that it is NOT your house. Are you certain that your husband will definitely move after 1 year? I fear that you will end up stuck there once your MIL starts the emotional blackmail with her son...

Corianda · 26/05/2026 22:18

Move back with the DCs and he stays with his parents for 2years

DisforDarkChocolate · 26/05/2026 22:20

Why not move back to Liverpool?

YourWildAmberSloth · 26/05/2026 22:21

You're not in London, Aldershot is not London, not even close. But anyway if you both prefer Liverpool, why did you leave there?

Ophy83 · 26/05/2026 22:21

Rent while he completes his training then move back north. Liverpool if you love it, or the Greater Manchester area if you want somewhere with a higher Muslim population.

Maray1967 · 26/05/2026 22:22

UpDownAllAround1 · 26/05/2026 21:58

As you say - this is confusing. Liverpool has a far larger Muslim community than Aldershot being one thing. Let him live with his parents and you rent somewhere around your work/school needs ip
north

Edited

Yes, that struck me as odd as well. I’m in Liverpool - Muslim community is well over 20,000 here.

OP, I’d let him stay with his parents and you get back up here and buy again.