@ThejoyofNC
The difference is vast, they are too completely different ethnicities. It's Irish travellers who have the huge suicide rate and DV. They also tend to get married younger on average, though the average age for gypsies is still lower than the UK age.
It's strange that you would use the term fail to protect their children from marriage, when marriage is something we aspire to. Getting married, having children and living a happy life is our absolute ideal.
Thanks: I understand that they are different ethnicities, I was grouping them together because they have similar lifestyles and seem to have similar positions on the role of women in the family and society. I'm sorry if you felt I was putting it crudely, that wasn't my intention, but they are similar in their approach to this so it is legitimate to make that comparison.
But I would take issue with your position on marriage being something which automatically protects children. Marriage isn't a universal good for women.
At its best, marriage strengthens families, supports people in raising children, protects wealth and provides support and comfort etc. But this isn't automatically the case. Marriage can also be a cover for the disempowerment of women by men and a trap for women if it results in them being stuck in a cycle of producing children and caring for the home. Yes some women want this but some don't. The less educated a woman is, the more likely she is to be taken advantage of by a man because she has less insight, less money, less power.
My core argument is that if you allow girls to at least complete standard secondary education they are in a position to choose the life they want. If they want a traditional family life, all power to them. But by forcing them out of education when they are not yet sentient enough to make an informed choice you are disempowering them. It's all very well to say I don't understand the society you come from, and you're right, I don't, but that doesn't justify something which deprives people of agency. Just because "the community" deems something to be the right path, doesn't make it so for everyone.