Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would my house rules be unreasonable? #1 would be No Male Visitors overnight

157 replies

GreenFriedTomato · 29/01/2026 03:58

I'm female and 55. My flatmate may be moving out this summer so I'm considering getting another flatmate/lodger at some point in the future.
I'm a quiet person and generally easygoing but I would have couple of main rules.

No parties. Very occasional small gatherings would be ok like a birthday dinner but no big house party events.

Most importantly, no male visitors (meaning boyfriends/ ONS). Obviously male relatives or a friend coming by for coffee fine. I'm talking about men/dates staying over

I understand the 'no men staying ' may seem old-fashioned but it's related to me having PTSD and the fact is I would be uncomfortable having random guys staying and coming in and out of the home. It's a small 2 bed flat with a small lounge area.
Many single women have partners/boyfriends so they wouldn't be interested in such an ad anyway, but would it even be realistic or acceptable to stipulate a flat share with this condition?

I would probably enjoy the occasional company of a female flatmate, but she would have a life too and I'm not sure many women would accept to live in a place where they couldn't bring any male friends around. On the other hand, I have female acquaintances who flatshare and never take guys back.

I can't recall ever seen an advert stating 'woman wanted for flat share. No male visitors overnight allowed'. Not in this country anyway. Maybe I should forget the idea entirely.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
LittleBitofBread · 01/02/2026 10:25

IcebergRightAhead · 01/02/2026 03:05

YANBU

However, back when I was looking for a flat I would always see one woman advertising for a lodger. She was asking for similar things to you, but the advert made her sound like a nightmare.

She was a teacher and the ad came with a long, long list of rules - including being in bed by 10pm, no coming and going after 9pm, no men at all, etc.

On the surface she had every right to ask for what she wanted but the way she was selling herself on the site painted her in a really poor light.

So I would be brief and meet in person before agreeing to anything.

Was this in Victorian times? Grin She sounds like a petty tyrant.
I've certainly heard though of things like people advertising a room but with no use of the kitchen permitted, all the lodger's belongings must be removed from the room when they're not there etc (this is for Mon–Fri/p-t lodgers).

MiffedatMP · 05/02/2026 16:51

I've lived with lodgers for 27 years. About 100 different people have lived here. I have a rule about this: no casual pickups can be brought back, but if a person is in a long term stable relationship I do not object to the partner staying overnight occasionally - provided there is no noise that keeps others awake. But then again I have a spacious, 3 storey, 4 bed house. In a flat as small as yours, no, I would not allow it at all.

Just make it clear when anyone applies. Don't put it in the ad, though. And advertise on spareroom - it's free.

ChrisMartinsKisskam · 08/02/2026 11:20

You can word things like

it’s a lodger contract not a AST. Please ensure that you understand the difference

it’s not a party house

are you the sort of person who has lots of friends around

do you wfh

no drugs, no smoking,

beadystar · 08/02/2026 11:32

Your house, your rules and I think it’s prudent to not allow random men visitors. Word it carefully though, I worked with a woman in her 30s who couldn’t get a housemate because her ad made her sound like a diktat nun who wanted someone to pay half the rent but not actually live there..

Nantescalling · 17/04/2026 12:48

MsAmerica · 29/01/2026 04:06

I'm not sure the issue is whether you're unreasonable. Yes, it's unreasonable in today's world, but it's not a whim on your part.

The issue is whether you'd even find anyone, unless it was a 95-year-old woman whose friends have all died.

I suggest you ask your current flatmate what she thinks is a good approach. It sounds to me as if you shouldn't even have a flatmate, unless you need the money. To me, no normal person would put up with a landlord who objects to occasional parties.

My suggestion is that you see a therapist, if you're not already seeing one, about the PTSD, and consider short-term rentals, where a person might not object to your restrictions if they're only staying a week or a month.

Gosh, that was harsh. Wanting to keep your privacy in your own home isn't a whim, it's a right.

SweetnsourNZ · 17/04/2026 13:12

I think it sounds fine. Maybe put the part about wanting a quiet flatmate, no parties on the initial advertisement and then elaborate at the interview. I am also a middle aged woman and would love this arrangement.
Another angle in the insurance. By the time you get to our age you tend to have a few valuables and insurance doesn't cover theft for people invited to your home.
The weekday longer is a good idea. Maybe even a student who goes home every weekend if you live near a university.

UrbanFan · 20/04/2026 13:42

I think it's perfectly reasonable. I would not want random strange men in my home at any time.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page