Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If anyone is observing the carnage in Minneapolis.....

1000 replies

MistressoftheDarkSide · 24/01/2026 20:18

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2026/jan/24/minneapolis-shooting-live

Guardian is running a live feed, and a good unbiased source is Agenda Free TV on YouTube also running live feeds from the streets there.

Obviously multiple versions of events being thrown about as it's very fresh.

Sending solidarity across the pond to any US Mumsnetters in the locale and protesting the awful actions of ICE and disregard of your constitution by the "President".

Minneapolis shooting: Governor Tim Walz condemns ‘sickening’ fatal shooting of man believed to be 37-year-old US citizen – live

Minnesota governor decries ‘federal occupation’ after another deadly shooting less than three weeks after ICE officer killed Renee Good in the city

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2026/jan/24/minneapolis-shooting-live

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
Passingthrough123 · 24/01/2026 23:32

MistressoftheDarkSide · 24/01/2026 23:19

What I don't get, having watched several different videos, is the carrying on shooting when the victim is down and unarmed. They shot him after they'd taken his gun FFS. And in not one video have I seen the gun being held by the victim, which means they searched him for it. He was holding a phone, not a gun, and they piled on him as he crouched over someone else on the ground, apparently trying to assist / protect them. I just can't make it make any sort of sense at all. The ICE agents escalated it, not him.

Where are they saying he had the gun? Because he was wearing such form fitting clothing that it surely would be visible in all the other footage if it was holstered under his jacket or in his waistband. I mean, they are claiming it was a semi-automatic handgun and two magazine rounds!

DeepBlueDeer · 24/01/2026 23:33

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

The guy had a gun in his wasteband, lawfully.

He was then pushed to the ground, and the gun seized.

He was then shot and killed.

DdraigGoch · 24/01/2026 23:33

Itstym · 24/01/2026 23:26

That’s terrifying. I’ve recently had a random episode of ill health where I’m now on twice daily medication for the next few months .

I wonder what would happen if someone like me was there in the U.S. and got snatched up by ICE? I doubt they are rushing to provide medical attention or letting people out to pick up their meds.

Surely people are dying under these conditions.

Edited

People are indeed dying in ICE detention. 32 people died in ICE custody last year. Those are just the ones we know about, of course. The conditions in these centres legally amount to torture.

LlttledrummergirI · 24/01/2026 23:33

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:23

No. I was kind of meaning when posters were saying she was an innocent mum who was going to the shops and took a wrong turn. Footage then disproved that theory. And even the Mayor of Minneapolis and his side kick admitted in their speech tonight that there were protestors there today who were definitely not peaceful. That must have stuck in their throat a bit…. No-one deserves to die, but people also have to take responsibility for their own safety and keep out of the tinder point areas.

This really is distasteful. Advocating for state sponsored murder by blaming the victims.

Alltheyellowbirds · 24/01/2026 23:33

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

How was he the aggressor??? Your posts are absolutely batshit.

Donttellempike · 24/01/2026 23:34

Sixseventeen · 24/01/2026 23:28

I’m perfectly entitled to post on this thread. And the situation in America is absolutely not comparable to what’s going on in Iran.

So stop trying to derail it. Start your own thread

Donttellempike · 24/01/2026 23:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Passingthrough123 · 24/01/2026 23:35

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

There is no proof he had a gun though. Maybe you should follow your own advice before jumping to conclusions…

DreamTheMoors · 24/01/2026 23:35

Alltheyellowbirds · 24/01/2026 23:19

What an odd take.

If this was happening in Britain I would bloody hope that every man and woman would be out in the streets trying to stop it and not sitting at home behind their TVs just allowing them to “carry out their job”.

Edited

No shit. I cannot BELIEVE somebody would ACTUALLY THINK OR SAY OUT LOUD ON THE INTERNET that they think those masked vigilantes are doing their jobs.

They’re just this side of the the Nazis cleaning out the Jews from Germany.

In fact, since ICE is going by skin colour, there’s very little difference.

Will somebody PLEASE WAKE US UP.

NamefortheseThreads · 24/01/2026 23:35

DeepBlueDeer · 24/01/2026 23:33

The guy had a gun in his wasteband, lawfully.

He was then pushed to the ground, and the gun seized.

He was then shot and killed.

Videos show him helping the woman that had fallen down next to him and another person on the left. I feel desperately sorry for his family, friends and colleagues. He was reportedly an ICU nurse. I mean WTF

If anyone is observing the carnage in Minneapolis.....
DdraigGoch · 24/01/2026 23:35

Sixseventeen · 24/01/2026 23:28

I’m perfectly entitled to post on this thread. And the situation in America is absolutely not comparable to what’s going on in Iran.

I'm perfectly entitled to make comparisons. The only difference is scale, and how far things have yet to move along.

DeepBlueDeer · 24/01/2026 23:36

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

He was the aggressor??

What do you get out of telling these evil little lies? You aren't winning hearts and minds, people just think you're sick and twisted.

Donttellempike · 24/01/2026 23:37

LlttledrummergirI · 24/01/2026 23:33

This really is distasteful. Advocating for state sponsored murder by blaming the victims.

If you are in the wrong place , particularly if you are the wrong color, gender or sexual identity state execution is fine and to be expected.

We have always been at war with US citizens

Happyjoe · 24/01/2026 23:37

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

Jesus, if I was American and had ICE agents around, I'd carry my gun too, protection. People are allowed to carry guns in most states, including Minneapolis. You actually do not know his intent, you're guessing 100%.

But, in the video I saw, he had no gun drawn (hands were empty and one hand raised) when he was with the woman that was pushed bt ICE agents and he was pepper (?) sprayed and chucked to the ground. Then kicked, then shot. All in seconds.
Please show me where he actually threatened anyone with the gun and justified killing him? Because I couldn't see it.

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:38

GasperyJacquesRoberts · 24/01/2026 23:27

"No-one deserves to die but if you happen to be in the vague area where other people aren't following the rules then it's understandable that you might be 'accidentally' gunned down in the street. That's totally what happens in a healthy and functional society."

Why was the guy carrying a gun? We don’t yet know his background. We don’t know if he was a threat to just ICE or people around him. Had he started firing the gun indiscriminately and shot dead bystanders, then the rhetoric would be ‘why wasn’t he brought down when his gun was spotted’.

GasperyJacquesRoberts · 24/01/2026 23:38

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

Are you not aware of the 2nd Amendment to the US constitution? Or the gun laws of Minnesota where open carry of firearms is explicitly allowed given the possession of an appropriate permit and except under a clearly defined list of restrictions?

Donttellempike · 24/01/2026 23:38

DreamTheMoors · 24/01/2026 23:35

No shit. I cannot BELIEVE somebody would ACTUALLY THINK OR SAY OUT LOUD ON THE INTERNET that they think those masked vigilantes are doing their jobs.

They’re just this side of the the Nazis cleaning out the Jews from Germany.

In fact, since ICE is going by skin colour, there’s very little difference.

Will somebody PLEASE WAKE US UP.

They are indistinguishable from Nazi brown shirts. There is no point of difference

KittyWilkinson · 24/01/2026 23:39

DdraigGoch · 24/01/2026 21:31

This is how it started in Germany in the 1930s. One wonders if the administration will use the reaction to this as their Reichstag Fire moment, as a pretext for clamping down on dissent.

I was reminded of Mussolini's Squadrismo.

GasperyJacquesRoberts · 24/01/2026 23:40

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:38

Why was the guy carrying a gun? We don’t yet know his background. We don’t know if he was a threat to just ICE or people around him. Had he started firing the gun indiscriminately and shot dead bystanders, then the rhetoric would be ‘why wasn’t he brought down when his gun was spotted’.

For someone who talks a lot about the US you seem spectacularly ill-informed about US law in general and US gun regulations in particular.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 24/01/2026 23:40

My God. Seeing the news footage from Iran, and then reading this from the USA. The killings in Iran are equally horrific but not unexpected from a pariah state. Then seeing similar thug-rule violence in the USA, which is a supposed liberal democracy. It's a nightmare.

BlackCrowKing · 24/01/2026 23:40

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:38

Why was the guy carrying a gun? We don’t yet know his background. We don’t know if he was a threat to just ICE or people around him. Had he started firing the gun indiscriminately and shot dead bystanders, then the rhetoric would be ‘why wasn’t he brought down when his gun was spotted’.

Sorry, I thought everyone has the right to bear arms? Or is that just for some people? He was a nurse, by the way. If you watch the footage, he stopped to tend to a woman who seems to have been pepper sprayed and was on the ground. And he didn’t use his weapon. He had his phone in his hand when he was jumped by a pile of ICE agents and repeatedly shot.

LlttledrummergirI · 24/01/2026 23:41

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:32

Not focussing on Renee at all. I’m talking about the subject of this thread - the guy had a gun. He was clearly there not to peacefully protest, but to harm someone if given the opportunity. Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation. The Mayor, who is very much against ICE, even admitted that the protest today had got out of hand.

More fucking lies to blame the victim.

All Pretti, he has a name apparently had a licence to carry a gun. Something that is allowed there.
He had a camera in his hand and was on the floor, being held down by six men having been disarmed (videos seem to show it being removed from its holster, so he hadn't drawn it). They then decided to fire multiple shots at him.

Clearly wasnt carrying a gun to defend himself as he was the aggressor in the situation

This assumption appears to be untrue misinformation being spread to blame the victim.

Fuck off with that rubbish.

DdraigGoch · 24/01/2026 23:41

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:38

Why was the guy carrying a gun? We don’t yet know his background. We don’t know if he was a threat to just ICE or people around him. Had he started firing the gun indiscriminately and shot dead bystanders, then the rhetoric would be ‘why wasn’t he brought down when his gun was spotted’.

People in the US often carry guns. It's not unusual. He had a licence to carry a concealed firearm and therefore was breaking no law. At no point did he threaten the agents, or even touch the gun.

I bet that whenever there's a school shooting you'd be the first to blather that "the second amendment is there to stop a tyrannical government".

Passingthrough123 · 24/01/2026 23:41

Livelovebehappy · 24/01/2026 23:38

Why was the guy carrying a gun? We don’t yet know his background. We don’t know if he was a threat to just ICE or people around him. Had he started firing the gun indiscriminately and shot dead bystanders, then the rhetoric would be ‘why wasn’t he brought down when his gun was spotted’.

We don’t know for sure yet that he was carrying a gun. It’s certainly not clear in any of the videos, nor in the footage beforehand. It’s hard to see where he could have possibly concealed it along with two magazine rounds.

JanuaryJasmine · 24/01/2026 23:41

I just can't believe this is happening in the supposedly civilised world in 2026.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.