To wish we had someone like Mamdani in UK politics?

[LostInManhattan]

Someone who’s passionate, young and willing to break the rules in politics, all while caring about his city and the people in it. I wish we had someone like that here.

Does show the extent to which Zac benefits from his sister Jemima's image, that you thought of him and not Polanski.

Oh so any concern raised about his financial proposals are not about that but because of his “ethno-religious background.”
I see the card you are trying to play.

Isn’t that the same as “racist” will lose all meaning if people keep that up.

So no evidence then.

I have no ideas what you are on about saying I should leave MN because I said the debate is getting like the Brexit referendum era and I don’t like to see shills for Reform stirring up shit on here. I totally stand by what I said.
I’m not going anywhere thanks.

“Studies agree with me not you.” Bit childish, but you do you.
I notice you didn’t comment on the other things the poster mentioned.

People can post as you do. It doesn’t mean they are ‘shills’.

He wants to make it easier for children to poison themselves with puberty blockers and cross sex hormones, (as does Polanski) so, no.

Why would I be providing evidence, I think you meant to reply to another poster.

He doesn't recognise it as a Jewish state. Which is what it is, so I'm not sure what would make him 'recognise' Israel, why it's any of his business how they run their own country (in regards to its Jewish identity), and whether he's been outspoken about any other countries with a specific ethnic group or religious identity 🤷🏼‍♀️. It's all sophistry.

Yup, couldn’t agree more, I’m all for real people who use MN posting. whatever their political views, if within MN guidelines. Otherwise it’s an echo chamber which would be rubbish.

But a lot of the aggro pro Brexit posters before the referendum disappeared as soon as it was done, so that seemed fishy.
This site isn’t immune to shills any more than anywhere else is, why wouldn’t it be?

It’s important to say that they exist so that people realise. I happen not to like seeing them in action because its highly manipulative. This is a site where the users contribute the content for free so the quality of the debate totally relies on people’s participation and good will to participate in good faith.

So which study shows the city air isn't cleaner?

Why is the onus on me rather than on that poster for posting lies?

So why bring up racism?

We did, Corbyn. And the MSM lost their shit.

I don’t agree with him on that by the way, Israel clearly is a Jewish state. I don’t agree with Israel’s government but have no actual problem with Israel itself and I find it ridiculous that people would have a problem with it being a Jewish state.

I do know he believes Israel doesn’t perhaps treat citizens who are not Jewish as equals so thats his reasoning/excuse for not recognising it as a Jewish state

I do wonder why he is expected to have certain views on Israel and why he is questioned so much on it? He is not campaigning to be the president. Why is he held to such a different standard to other candidates? I doubt there would much criticism from Trump etc if he criticised China

Jews from New York are completely separate from Israel, they are Americans and I believe he has pledge a lot of support to them no?

Perhaps from all parties, the general rule is to report to mnhq if you think they are rather than call everyone who votes differently shills.

I only really see it from Labour supporters about Reform, Tory or Greens. I want to read more than Labour posts. Plus polling shows more support for Reform so it’s not surprising views will be somewhat reflected on a public site. Not as much as elsewhere granted because of the shill accusations etc

Type the query into Google...

What do you think I can’t find anything online means Edith?

I didn’t mention a study, and why is it lies just because someone has a different opinion to you.

Because it's scientifically proven the air is cleaner, ergo, she's lying.

If she told you in her opinion the Earth is flat, would you pander to her delusions?

In reply to your “anti semitism” will lose all meaning.

You did reply to the wrong poster didn’t you.

In what context though? You're just throwing around words for no rhyme or reason.

Looking closer, it seems he plays both sides. See here:
https://www.jpost.com/opinion/article-872544
On the one hand, he says he does condemn Hamas (apologies, I'd not found that before), but on the other he supports convicted terrorists with links to Hamas. So which side of his mouth do we believe?

No, I didn't. You've involved yourself in the chain of posts, not sure why.