Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lasted 1 week living with MIL.

220 replies

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:04

Bit of background: I’m 34, have a 9-year-old DS and am 29 weeks pregnant on maternity leave. Me and DP have sold our house and are waiting to move into a new one, so to tide us over we stayed at MIL’s. We expected to be there 8–9 weeks but only lasted one week.

We moved in last Thursday and within days it became clear she was smoking and drinking in the house every night. I knew she smoked, but I thought it was just at weekends outside while she had a little glass of wine. Instead, she smoked in the kitchen every night while we were upstairs with the door shut trying to escape it. DS said he felt sick from the smoke one evening. I thought as I’m pregnant and have a child, she’d smoke outside, but when DP raised it she just moved to standing outside directly under our bedroom window. She even made a snide comment to DP’s brother and his girlfriend that she’d “been told off for smoking.” She hadn’t, she just asked why we sat upstairs all the time and my partner said it’s because of the smoke.

As well as the smoking she was quite overbearing with me. She would try to do my DS’s breakfast on a morning before school and make his packed lunches. Then in the evening she would want to make us all dinner which I said was really lovely, but my partner and I said politely we will make our own food. Partly because her portion sizes were huge and she’d serve desserts that we wouldn’t touch. We had two roast dinners in the space of three days followed by cakes and cheesecakes. I said that we’d cook for ourselves and she didn’t need to make my son’s lunches or breakfast as I enjoy doing it.

I would buy the food to make our meals and my partners work lunches etc and she would always say I’ll do the shopping which I didn’t need her to as it gave me something to do in the afternoon as I was on maternity and I was bored. I did communicate all this with her but she didn’t seem to like it.

I could understand if we were there visiting over the holidays, but we’ve moved in with her to live there. I wasn’t a guest and I didn’t need to be mothered. It felt like she was taking away any independence I had left. I appreciate she wanted to help me, but it was becoming too much. I couldn’t even do my own washing or feed my own child. When I made my partner‘s lunches, she would say that I “spoiled him” but it felt like deep down she wanted to be the one making it. She was always telling me to sit down but she knows I really enjoy cooking.

On top of this, I’ve also struggled to watch her speak to her husband who has got Parkinson’s. She constantly belittled him and swore at him. I told my partner as it was very upsetting.

Yesterday, everything came to a head. DP called her at 1:30pm to say we’d be going back to our old house, mainly due to the smoking. He made sure to say there’s no hard feelings and we were just struggling a little bit as a family not having our own space. She said “yeah ok if that’s what you want.” he called me after to say there was no hard feelings and she’s okay.

When I came back from the school run DP was already there and DP’s cousin was visiting with her children. As soon as I got to the door MIL started a blazing row with me in front of everyone. She told me she was “very cross with me!” which felt so belittling — talking to me like a child. DP stepped in straight away and said “don’t speak to her like that, why are you doing this you said everything was fine earlier?” but MIL just said “well it’s not fine this hasn’t gone through way I planned!” and carried on blaming me. She was shouting at me saying I knew she smoked and I said I didn’t know that and if I had have I wouldn’t have come. But she continued to shout at me saying yes you did know etc.

I ended up going upstairs, packing up mine and DS’s things, and leaving. She then had a massive row with DP, saying everything was my fault. She even said about me “she didn’t have a problem with me smoking when I watched her son for her,” which shocked me because I had no idea she smoked around DS when he stayed there — and I don’t understand how she thinks that’s okay.

AIBU to feel shocked, angry and like I’ve done nothing wrong here?

All I wanted was to get through a few weeks until our move. We’ve had the house move from hell which has been dragging on for the past three months. I’m due a baby in 11 weeks, the house we’re moving into needs work doing before we can live in it and my partner is currently working two jobs. This really is the last thing he or I needed. I just don’t understand how she can say she’s angry? At what? If anything I should be angry at her for smoking round us but rather than making her feel like a guest in her own home we’ve chosen to leave so she can continue her life.

OP posts:
PumpkinSeasonOctober · 04/10/2025 19:10

She was good to let you stay in the first place. You cannot dictate how she lives in her own house.

ThisLivelyRaven · 04/10/2025 19:10

its sound as like you didn’t handle things very well at all! You should of explained the health risks around smoking around children not just hide upstairs sulking!

Also she was being very kind making you dinner, lunches etc and you sound quite ungrateful! She was also being kind letting you stay with her and you stating that you’d do your cooking, shopping etc! If your that bor ed you go do some work before the baby arrives if you are able too or you could of got a hobby out the house so you weren’t around as much

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 04/10/2025 19:12

You were rude. Would it really have killed you to have eaten her meals. My mil did large dinners we joked that the plates were like concrete to lift. But we were fed and it was a meal that came with love.

Toofficeornot · 04/10/2025 19:12

YABU for everything except the smoking.
I would have left for the smoking. Everything else seems like she was going to a lot of effort to try and be the perfect host and make things as stress free for you as possible.
Going on about portion sizes and deserts is silly. Just don't eat them. Put them in the fridge for later etc.
The smoking is the issue here.
A family member I am close with had another family member who we are close with also come to stay for an extended period.. they don't talk anymore which is sad. It was very petty but escalated.

Secretsrevealed · 04/10/2025 19:14

Gosh I'd love someone to make two roasts for me in three days. You can always eat a smaller portion of what's on your plate and decline dessert? Surely that's what most people do when someone else is cooking when not every part of the meal is to their taste? İf you love cooking so much could you not have just done a nice lunch sometimes to keep that hobby up?

londongirl12 · 04/10/2025 19:15

Not sure how you can’t tell she smokes in the house? I can smell it at my PIL as soon as I walk in the house. A hour max visit is all I can stand.

therealduchess · 04/10/2025 19:22

I'm curious aa to why you moved in with her if there was the option to stay in your own place? Also, do you get on well at other times?
Sounds like she was looking forward to spoiling you all & make life easier.

Turnups · 04/10/2025 19:26

The smoking is a problem, but firstly I find it very hard to believe you didn’t know she smoked - you can always smell it on people in my experience. And anyway, if she goes outside her own home to smoke you’re still complaining! Why not just shut the bedroom window?

Everything else you complain about is ridiculous and you are being the kind of ungrateful cf who gives daughters-in-law a bad name, Your MIL was trying to be a good hostess. If she serves you meals that are too big, why don’t you just leave what you don't want? If you don’t want dessert, why don’t you (or, better, your partner) just say, in plenty of time, "we're not used to eating dessert and won’t want any, so please don’t make one"? If you don’t eat it, she'll soon get the message.

She was doing you a favour and you sound very ungrateful and unreasonable.

Worried198423 · 04/10/2025 19:35

I think smoking where kids are is terrible.

The food on the other hand I think you were ungrateful.
She was excited to have you stay and probably wanted to spoil you all.

In cases like these you have to lay ground rule before you move in.
Saves all this hassle.

LBFseBrom · 04/10/2025 19:36

Well said, Turnups.

Intothesunshine · 04/10/2025 19:38

How ungrateful are you !! FFS 😡😡😡

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 04/10/2025 19:42

Surely you must have known she smoked in the house? We always know when DH’s parents have started smoking in their house again (generally as it gets colder and more unpleasant to be outside or in the garage doing so) because it utterly stinks.

I also find it hard to believe you did not smell it on your DS when she had him? It’s such a detectable (and gross) smell after all, when we see DH parents without SS I always moan how we come away stinking!!!!

We lived with my mum for 9 months through COVID when the build on our new house stopped. We all compromised a lot, working together to rota cooking and chores and work out expenses being covered to ensure everything ran as smoothly as possible. It’s not easy, but there does have to be a huge amount of respect for the fact that it is the other persons home and their way of living does have to be respected when you do this (and there has to be some biting of tongues here and there). So, from your remarks, I think you tried to push for a bit too much control OP, sorry.

tiredangry · 04/10/2025 19:50

Catpiece · 03/10/2025 14:50

It’s her house. She can do what she likes.

A poor justification for smoking around a child, don’t you think?

Howwilliknow122 · 04/10/2025 19:54

Op why on earth did you leave your home if its still yours to stay in. You said you sold your house and waiting to move in to your new one, you should have just stayed in your home!! Im sure you knew she was an indoor smoker as the house would already smell.

Haribomum7 · 04/10/2025 19:56

I totally get you about the smoking but I would be sooo grateful if someone cooked my dinner and made my child’s lunchboxes. I think you are being very ungrateful. You just need to thank her and say that as you will be staying there for a while, you will so your own dinners.

PaperRhino · 04/10/2025 20:01

If you could go back to your old house I don’t understand why you moved in with your MIL in the first place as you clearly don’t like her. Yes it is completely wrong to smoke around young children and pregnant women but apart from that you sound horrible and entitled, wanting to live in her house but like a completely separate family and being snotty about her food and refusing to eat with her. I bet she’s glad to see the back of you.

Mcoco · 04/10/2025 20:06

I think you should have just allowed your MIL to cook for all of you as a family. It is her home and that is how things generally work. If the portions were too large simple ask for smaller or leave what you can't eat. You are heavily pregnant and she wanted to help you.

As for smoking yes it is wrong but it sounds like she was making an effort to smoke elsewhere.

dcthatsme · 04/10/2025 20:08

Her house – her rules. Presumably you knew she's a smoker beforehand? I don't think you can expect someone who behaves like this to suddenly change their ways. Presumably she always smokes in her own home? It's not healthy or considerate and it's no longer culturally acceptable to smoke where there are young children but surely you knew this about her before moving in with her? Expecting to make separate food is quite unreasonable on your part - it's not a student flatshare - and although you don't like her cooking you don't have to eat every mouthful of her huge portions. She was trying to be helpful by cooking for you. I don't think you and your DH thought this through beforehand. I hope you can bridge this gap. It would be sad to fall out over this. It's not like either of you intended to fall out. It's probably best to see her for relatively short periods of time going forward (ie a meal here or there or out in the park etc). Life is too short to fall out with her over this.

80smonster · 04/10/2025 20:10

Wow. The levels of entitlement are off the chart here. You said in your OP that you knew MIL smoked, what ever gave you the idea this was weekend or garden-based? If it bothered you so much, which it clearly does, why didn’t you clarify before arriving? You would have known if she did smoke inside as it would always have smelled that way. Honestly I think you’re being pregnant and a bit mental. Also if your old house was always available for use, why weren’t you there to begin with?

Jerkchinken · 04/10/2025 20:12

YABU for ever thinking you could live in someone else's house whilst calling the shots, it's her house she can do what she likes. She is a massive twat though for smoking around you.
She knows that it's stupid to, anyone with half a brain would, she's waited til she's got her rottweiler s round her before causing a ruccus, that's what mine used to do, nice as pie just me and her. Utter cunt.
Don't engage in the drama just withdraw and take your husband and kids with you.

SleepQuest33 · 04/10/2025 20:24

I couldn’t live under the same roof as a smoker, I would have left as well. Especially with young children.

I think even though it is her house, surely she realises how horrible it is to spoil those young lungs like that?

It is unfortunate this has happened but perhaps for the sake of the family and your DH try to contact her and apologise about leaving early and explain you were concerned about DS’s health.

birling16 · 04/10/2025 20:27

Sad for her and her puddings.

3isthemagicnumber3 · 04/10/2025 20:29

You sound hard work. I feel really sorry for MIL, it sounds like she was trying by cooking, making lunches and you wanted to control everything. Smoking around children and pregnant women is not ok but you said she went outside ‘under your window’ could you not have just closed the window? It sounds like she couldn’t do any right and you sound ungrateful.

Imisscoffee2021 · 04/10/2025 20:32

Smoking is of course very bad for people so that's something she should have accommodated for when accepting hosting you all, or offering to host you all.

However, it sounds like she was quite excited to have you all there and was doing what mothers do when their kids have grown and flown the nest but visit for a while, namely jumping at the chance to do motherly things again like packed lunches and roast dinners. Could you not have just gone with the flow for a few weeks and let equilibrium take place, which it would have most likely.

You could have had this grace period of a week or two and THEN gently assert yourself. Fair enough you want to do your sons care and food but the other stuff, large dinners, puddings, wanting to shop etc sounds pretty normal. My mums like that when ny husband and I visit with our kid. When there's too much food we just ...leave it on the plate. Perhaps your MIL hadn't slipped immediately into "long term visitor" mode but you weren't housemates either, you were a long term guest.

I agree with you on the smoking and she needed to take a step back from bathing and doing your sons packed lunch but honestly everything else was pretty low stakes stuff, shame to have a blow up.

Lovehascomeandgone · 04/10/2025 20:49

LandOfFruitAndNut · 03/10/2025 14:07

YABU wanting to control what someone does in their own house.

Don’t be ridiculous, she wasn’t trying to control. Sounds like MIL has been less than transparent about the extent of the smoking and wanted to control everything. Glad they got out of there.