Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lasted 1 week living with MIL.

220 replies

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:04

Bit of background: I’m 34, have a 9-year-old DS and am 29 weeks pregnant on maternity leave. Me and DP have sold our house and are waiting to move into a new one, so to tide us over we stayed at MIL’s. We expected to be there 8–9 weeks but only lasted one week.

We moved in last Thursday and within days it became clear she was smoking and drinking in the house every night. I knew she smoked, but I thought it was just at weekends outside while she had a little glass of wine. Instead, she smoked in the kitchen every night while we were upstairs with the door shut trying to escape it. DS said he felt sick from the smoke one evening. I thought as I’m pregnant and have a child, she’d smoke outside, but when DP raised it she just moved to standing outside directly under our bedroom window. She even made a snide comment to DP’s brother and his girlfriend that she’d “been told off for smoking.” She hadn’t, she just asked why we sat upstairs all the time and my partner said it’s because of the smoke.

As well as the smoking she was quite overbearing with me. She would try to do my DS’s breakfast on a morning before school and make his packed lunches. Then in the evening she would want to make us all dinner which I said was really lovely, but my partner and I said politely we will make our own food. Partly because her portion sizes were huge and she’d serve desserts that we wouldn’t touch. We had two roast dinners in the space of three days followed by cakes and cheesecakes. I said that we’d cook for ourselves and she didn’t need to make my son’s lunches or breakfast as I enjoy doing it.

I would buy the food to make our meals and my partners work lunches etc and she would always say I’ll do the shopping which I didn’t need her to as it gave me something to do in the afternoon as I was on maternity and I was bored. I did communicate all this with her but she didn’t seem to like it.

I could understand if we were there visiting over the holidays, but we’ve moved in with her to live there. I wasn’t a guest and I didn’t need to be mothered. It felt like she was taking away any independence I had left. I appreciate she wanted to help me, but it was becoming too much. I couldn’t even do my own washing or feed my own child. When I made my partner‘s lunches, she would say that I “spoiled him” but it felt like deep down she wanted to be the one making it. She was always telling me to sit down but she knows I really enjoy cooking.

On top of this, I’ve also struggled to watch her speak to her husband who has got Parkinson’s. She constantly belittled him and swore at him. I told my partner as it was very upsetting.

Yesterday, everything came to a head. DP called her at 1:30pm to say we’d be going back to our old house, mainly due to the smoking. He made sure to say there’s no hard feelings and we were just struggling a little bit as a family not having our own space. She said “yeah ok if that’s what you want.” he called me after to say there was no hard feelings and she’s okay.

When I came back from the school run DP was already there and DP’s cousin was visiting with her children. As soon as I got to the door MIL started a blazing row with me in front of everyone. She told me she was “very cross with me!” which felt so belittling — talking to me like a child. DP stepped in straight away and said “don’t speak to her like that, why are you doing this you said everything was fine earlier?” but MIL just said “well it’s not fine this hasn’t gone through way I planned!” and carried on blaming me. She was shouting at me saying I knew she smoked and I said I didn’t know that and if I had have I wouldn’t have come. But she continued to shout at me saying yes you did know etc.

I ended up going upstairs, packing up mine and DS’s things, and leaving. She then had a massive row with DP, saying everything was my fault. She even said about me “she didn’t have a problem with me smoking when I watched her son for her,” which shocked me because I had no idea she smoked around DS when he stayed there — and I don’t understand how she thinks that’s okay.

AIBU to feel shocked, angry and like I’ve done nothing wrong here?

All I wanted was to get through a few weeks until our move. We’ve had the house move from hell which has been dragging on for the past three months. I’m due a baby in 11 weeks, the house we’re moving into needs work doing before we can live in it and my partner is currently working two jobs. This really is the last thing he or I needed. I just don’t understand how she can say she’s angry? At what? If anything I should be angry at her for smoking round us but rather than making her feel like a guest in her own home we’ve chosen to leave so she can continue her life.

OP posts:
Happyjoe · 03/10/2025 17:32

I guess she just wanted to try and help and it ended up being overwhelming and overbearing and she should have perhaps have checked with you on making packed lunches etc.. but everyone lives differently and handles things the way they know.

The only thing I really agree with you on is the amount of smoking. She should be allowed to smoke in her own home but knowing a young child and a pregnant lady were staying, let alone other guests then she should've just gone outside from the off.

BetterWithPockets · 03/10/2025 17:34

bunnypenny · 03/10/2025 14:53

“I wasn’t a guest”

yes, yes you were.

This!

CopperWhite · 03/10/2025 17:39

I expect it was one week too long for your poor MIL who was only having you to stay to do you a favour in the first place.

Imagine, someone having the audacity to sort breakfast for their guests, make sure they have enough food and having a glass of wine and a cigarette of an evening in their own kitchen. Shocking behaviour. Don’t know why it’s not illegal.

Mcmf · 03/10/2025 17:39

I have lived with my MIL before and found it quite stressful, you don’t have much control living in someone else’s house. But you have to suck it up especially if you are staying somewhere for a long period for free. They are doing you a favour, you can’t have things your own way or make the home owner feel like a spare part who is in the way. Bear in mind your MIL is inconvenienced by having three extra people in her space and has tried to do things to help you to be nice, as other have said she was probably overexcited. It sounds like you moved in before you really needed to if you can go back to your old house?

I think a lot of the issues (breakfasts, lunches, cooking) are compounded by the fact you are bored and don’t want to be looked after, why are you already on maternity leave OP especially if your DP needs to work two jobs?

TBC99 · 03/10/2025 17:55

It might have been a good idea to discuss the ground rules before you moved in.
The outcome sounds upsetting for you all tbh

Silvers11 · 03/10/2025 17:56

@OneBluntApple I'm a bit confused. You sold your house, but you were able to go back to it, so why did you move in with the In Laws when you did? I don't understand

warmapplepies · 03/10/2025 17:58

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:09

How so?

Um, because it's not your house?

LostPEKitAgain · 03/10/2025 18:00

I get the smoking and the way she spoke to your FIL. The cooking and the lunches, that sounds like someone just trying to be nice.

Topseyt123 · 03/10/2025 18:03

Silvers11 · 03/10/2025 17:56

@OneBluntApple I'm a bit confused. You sold your house, but you were able to go back to it, so why did you move in with the In Laws when you did? I don't understand

Neither do I. You've either sold your house and completed the transaction (in which case it now belongs to someone else and is no longer available to you) or you haven't. In which case why move in with MIL?

I doubt that OP will be back to clarify though. She was looking for total validation and quite rightly hasn't received it.

Cornishclio · 03/10/2025 18:08

Tricky one but staying with relatives for 8/9 weeks especially if you are pregnant was never going to end well. The smoking is an issue but in fairness to MIL you knew she smoked and her drinking in her own house is not your problem. The cooking etc I would have accommodated that but it sounds like it was never going to work because you both sound hard work and not easy to get along with.

SixtySomething · 03/10/2025 18:09

When I see posts like this, I start off feeling sympathetic with the poster.
Then the post starts to drag on, with too much detail, and it starts to read like a piece of fiction.

MIL is being so awful that I don't believe in it all any longer.
The writing is so long, but so perfect without mistakes or changes in tone.
How does anyone have time to write all this in such a calm way?
I've read too many posts like this.
It's all AI, isn't it?

UndecidedHouse · 03/10/2025 18:15

When people smoke in the house it fucking reeks. Dont blame you for not staying.

Tesremos82 · 03/10/2025 18:15

poetryandwine · 03/10/2025 15:08

Where are PP getting the idea that OP has a house to go to? She has sold snd can’t move to her new place for a few more weeks.

OP, I think you were naive not to work on an agreement around MIL’s smoking before moving in or leaving DS in her care. I suspect the tension around this and around the move is colouring your view of some of MIL’s other actions, which could be interpreted as attempts to be helpful. Also, you are not forced to eat the massive portions and nightly puddings she plops in front of you.

I agree at this stage it’s better for everyone if your family can make other arrangements but I think there are two sides here.

Probably from reading the first post where the OP states they moved back to their old house!!

Middlemarch123 · 03/10/2025 18:21

SixtySomething · 03/10/2025 18:09

When I see posts like this, I start off feeling sympathetic with the poster.
Then the post starts to drag on, with too much detail, and it starts to read like a piece of fiction.

MIL is being so awful that I don't believe in it all any longer.
The writing is so long, but so perfect without mistakes or changes in tone.
How does anyone have time to write all this in such a calm way?
I've read too many posts like this.
It's all AI, isn't it?

Yep

ThatCyanJoker · 03/10/2025 18:27

You sound really ungrateful. MIL was obviously trying to make things nice and you moan because she’s cooked a roast dinner and puddings for you all. You knew she smoked, and went ahead with the arrangement anyway.

JLou08 · 03/10/2025 18:35

It seems a bit naive to think she only smoked at the weekend. How often did you see her? Could you not smell it in her house, on her clothes, on your DS when he came home? No ash trays around the house? Smoking is really addictive, there are some social smokers but not many would get to the age of being a grandparent and be able to just smoke at the weekend. Surely your DH knew his mother's smoking habits.
I does seem like you were using the house but wanting to live separate lives in the house whereas your MIL seems like she wanted to enjoy having children in the home again and be mothering them. I don't think either of them are wrong but I also think the homeowner who is doing you a favour should get more of a say in how things run. There was no need to finish your plate or eat dessert. I never finish my ILs huge portions, they usually decline the desert I offer, it's no big deal.

GAJLY · 03/10/2025 18:44

LandOfFruitAndNut · 03/10/2025 14:07

YABU wanting to control what someone does in their own house.

Agree with this 👆 You shouldn't stay there for long and never let her baby sit again, because of the dangers of second hand smoke.

poetryandwine · 03/10/2025 20:15

Tesremos82 · 03/10/2025 18:15

Probably from reading the first post where the OP states they moved back to their old house!!

Thanks. Hopefully you noticed that I corrected myself immediately

poetryandwine · 03/10/2025 20:19

Silvers11 · 03/10/2025 17:56

@OneBluntApple I'm a bit confused. You sold your house, but you were able to go back to it, so why did you move in with the In Laws when you did? I don't understand

I also wonder about this. I love DH’s family but would never plan to leave our home prematurely in order to move in with them

BlueMum16 · 03/10/2025 20:24

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:14

I did suggest this to her. I said I will cook for us tonight and she said no you just cook for yourselves. My partner kind of mentioned to her that dinners she were making a very large portions. We weren’t rude about it. Like the puddings after every meal he said to her we don’t really eat like that. We try to communicate everything really nicely and politely.

The smoking issue YANBU.

Everything else you sound really ungrateful.

Ponoka7 · 04/10/2025 12:00

As if older people who smoke, only smoke of a weekend. Social/alcohol smoking is a thing, but not for the majority of smokers. I think that your DH should have went through a lot of points before moving in. She's losing her husband, while having to be his carer, that isn't easy. I think more compromise on your part was needed.

Ponoka7 · 04/10/2025 12:02

SixtySomething · 03/10/2025 18:09

When I see posts like this, I start off feeling sympathetic with the poster.
Then the post starts to drag on, with too much detail, and it starts to read like a piece of fiction.

MIL is being so awful that I don't believe in it all any longer.
The writing is so long, but so perfect without mistakes or changes in tone.
How does anyone have time to write all this in such a calm way?
I've read too many posts like this.
It's all AI, isn't it?

Not necessarily. Those of us who've had jobs that require report writing, medical admin and statements for court etc, do it naturally.

Shmee1988 · 04/10/2025 13:00

When it comes to the smoking, YANBU for not wanting her to do it in the house.

As for the rest of it, YABU, imo. Youre annoyed because youre a pregnant mother of a young child, currently in between houses and your MIL wants to help ease it all a bit. Presumably yoire all living in her house, rent free (guessing obvs) and shes offering to buy the food, cook the food and help with your DS? I get the very natural instinct to scream 'im pregnant, not incapacitated'but come off it.
I dont know you but your post reads as though if shed have done sod all and watched you do it all without her lifting a finger, you'd moan about that too. You shoukd think yourself lucky that you have a MIL that wants to help.

NeonFish · 04/10/2025 13:05

YANBU She sounds like a narcissist and manipulator. But whose bright idea was it to sell a perfectly good house and move into one that needs a lot of work when you're heavily pregnant? It sounds batshit to me.

JSMill · 04/10/2025 15:34

The only thing you are right about is the smoking, but even then she did try to compromise. It sounds like she was trying to be hospitable with cooking large meals. You could have been polite and gone along with it.