Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lasted 1 week living with MIL.

220 replies

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:04

Bit of background: I’m 34, have a 9-year-old DS and am 29 weeks pregnant on maternity leave. Me and DP have sold our house and are waiting to move into a new one, so to tide us over we stayed at MIL’s. We expected to be there 8–9 weeks but only lasted one week.

We moved in last Thursday and within days it became clear she was smoking and drinking in the house every night. I knew she smoked, but I thought it was just at weekends outside while she had a little glass of wine. Instead, she smoked in the kitchen every night while we were upstairs with the door shut trying to escape it. DS said he felt sick from the smoke one evening. I thought as I’m pregnant and have a child, she’d smoke outside, but when DP raised it she just moved to standing outside directly under our bedroom window. She even made a snide comment to DP’s brother and his girlfriend that she’d “been told off for smoking.” She hadn’t, she just asked why we sat upstairs all the time and my partner said it’s because of the smoke.

As well as the smoking she was quite overbearing with me. She would try to do my DS’s breakfast on a morning before school and make his packed lunches. Then in the evening she would want to make us all dinner which I said was really lovely, but my partner and I said politely we will make our own food. Partly because her portion sizes were huge and she’d serve desserts that we wouldn’t touch. We had two roast dinners in the space of three days followed by cakes and cheesecakes. I said that we’d cook for ourselves and she didn’t need to make my son’s lunches or breakfast as I enjoy doing it.

I would buy the food to make our meals and my partners work lunches etc and she would always say I’ll do the shopping which I didn’t need her to as it gave me something to do in the afternoon as I was on maternity and I was bored. I did communicate all this with her but she didn’t seem to like it.

I could understand if we were there visiting over the holidays, but we’ve moved in with her to live there. I wasn’t a guest and I didn’t need to be mothered. It felt like she was taking away any independence I had left. I appreciate she wanted to help me, but it was becoming too much. I couldn’t even do my own washing or feed my own child. When I made my partner‘s lunches, she would say that I “spoiled him” but it felt like deep down she wanted to be the one making it. She was always telling me to sit down but she knows I really enjoy cooking.

On top of this, I’ve also struggled to watch her speak to her husband who has got Parkinson’s. She constantly belittled him and swore at him. I told my partner as it was very upsetting.

Yesterday, everything came to a head. DP called her at 1:30pm to say we’d be going back to our old house, mainly due to the smoking. He made sure to say there’s no hard feelings and we were just struggling a little bit as a family not having our own space. She said “yeah ok if that’s what you want.” he called me after to say there was no hard feelings and she’s okay.

When I came back from the school run DP was already there and DP’s cousin was visiting with her children. As soon as I got to the door MIL started a blazing row with me in front of everyone. She told me she was “very cross with me!” which felt so belittling — talking to me like a child. DP stepped in straight away and said “don’t speak to her like that, why are you doing this you said everything was fine earlier?” but MIL just said “well it’s not fine this hasn’t gone through way I planned!” and carried on blaming me. She was shouting at me saying I knew she smoked and I said I didn’t know that and if I had have I wouldn’t have come. But she continued to shout at me saying yes you did know etc.

I ended up going upstairs, packing up mine and DS’s things, and leaving. She then had a massive row with DP, saying everything was my fault. She even said about me “she didn’t have a problem with me smoking when I watched her son for her,” which shocked me because I had no idea she smoked around DS when he stayed there — and I don’t understand how she thinks that’s okay.

AIBU to feel shocked, angry and like I’ve done nothing wrong here?

All I wanted was to get through a few weeks until our move. We’ve had the house move from hell which has been dragging on for the past three months. I’m due a baby in 11 weeks, the house we’re moving into needs work doing before we can live in it and my partner is currently working two jobs. This really is the last thing he or I needed. I just don’t understand how she can say she’s angry? At what? If anything I should be angry at her for smoking round us but rather than making her feel like a guest in her own home we’ve chosen to leave so she can continue her life.

OP posts:
Blodyneighbour · 03/10/2025 16:40

Well by the looks of it OP. You need to apologise to her. Buy her nice bottle of wine {lol}
Tell her you are sorry. I could be that MIL and would be so pissed off with all your requirements while I was doing a nice thing trying to help. She actually sounds amazing and quite involved in you DC life. Do not BU anymore and be thankful she is actually a very helpful woman. Please see the bigger picture OP.

Nandina · 03/10/2025 16:41

YABU to have moved in with someone who smoked.

Tiredofwhataboutery · 03/10/2025 16:42

YANBU sbout the smoke but it’s really rude to go and stay with someone and insist on making your own food etc

Middlemarch123 · 03/10/2025 16:43

QuinoafromKew · 03/10/2025 16:17

I'm think you going back to your old house will be a bit of a surprise for the new owner OP.
YANBU for the smoking
YABU on the rest.
If someone is kind enough to take you all in then you go with the flow while you are there.

Especially if the new owners welcome OP with open arms, light up a fag and insist on feeding them a roast dinner followed by cheesecake!😉

Skybluepinky · 03/10/2025 16:46

You chose the cheap option then turned into a dictator!

Blueskiesandrainbows · 03/10/2025 16:47

Total overreaction on your part OP.
Smoking …as others have said, just close your window, it’s not rocket science, your MIL didn’t have to leave her own home and stand outside to smoke.
You sound very whiny and looking for an argument, it should have been a treat to have your meals cooked for you, but you turned it into complaint by whinging about it when it was a lovely gesture from your MIL.
You need to grow up and learn be a lot more tolerant, especially when someone has done you a massive favour and has been kind enough to put you up when you apparently still have a house to live in!!

pilates · 03/10/2025 16:48

YANBU
How did you not know she was smoking around your son?

NannyOggsScones · 03/10/2025 16:49

I’d be mighty pissed off if someone came to stay in my house and didn’t want to eat with me and wanted to cook their own food. I couldn’t bear the kitchen being in continual use for one thing. It’s your MiL’s home not a self catering rental. I can’t imagine you’d be very relaxed about someone doing that in your home. Your language is very uptight and snobby. Was she forcing food into your mouth? My MiL is a dreadful cook but I’ve eaten 100s of meals in her house because I’m not rude. I dread to think what kind of MIL you’re going to be in the future. You owe your MIL an apology.

Luddite26 · 03/10/2025 16:49

Smoking alone is enough imo.
Yes it's her house.
Have you not smelt it before. Houses where people still smoke inside them stink.

CharlieKirkRIP · 03/10/2025 16:51

She was doing you a massive favour and you knew beforehand that she smoked, so your uptight attitude towards is surprising.

Smoking is gross but it’s gee home and you have to fit in with her not the other way round!

DinaofCloud9 · 03/10/2025 16:52

Apart from the smoking it sounds like she was trying to look after you all and you kept throwing it back in her face.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/10/2025 16:53

She sounds nuts!

I think it’s rarely a good idea to move in with family like that

Ellmau · 03/10/2025 16:53

The smoking is awful and unbearable so I don't blame you for not feeling able to stay.

But your MIL was being a kind host cooking for you and you come across as very ungrateful. It might be different if any of you were allergic to the things she was making, but you didn't say that, just that you don't like puddings every day.

toiletpaperthief · 03/10/2025 16:57

You're treating her home as a free airbnb and her as an unwelcome guest. It's her home, you don't get to mandate or make the rules.

MO0N · 03/10/2025 16:57

You dont have a leg to stand on here OP, her house her rules.
Obviously if she ever needs a favour from you then you should serve her back exactly what she dished out to you...

bouncydog · 03/10/2025 16:58

You are being unreasonable in my view. Yes you quite rightly had an issue with her smoking so this element should have been discussed prior to you moving in and boundaries set so you were all clear on where she would smoke. That was the point to say you would stay elsewhere. However she just wanted to take the load off you whilst you are pregnant. I would personally be very upset if my DD and her family moved in with us in similar circumstances to yourself and wouldn't let me do anything to help take the load off her. Your poor MIL is already coping with your FIL who is unwell which must be very difficult for her, seeing him become very different to the man she married. She was probably looking forward to your visit. I don't blame her having a glass of wine in the evenings as she doesn't seem as if she has much going for her otherwise. A bottle of wine and a bunch of flowers and a chat in calm surroundings might be helpful.

VIOLETPUGH · 03/10/2025 17:02

YABU - ungrateful and precious, your time will come when your little boy grows up and lets hope his partner is more grateful and less demanding than you !

MonGrainDeSel · 03/10/2025 17:05

How on earth is it precious not to want people to smoke around your small child and your pregnant self?

the7Vabo · 03/10/2025 17:06

Your DP is your MIL’s grown-up little boy. Maybe she was pleased to feel she was looking after him & his family.

She gave you a house to live in between moves (a lot to ask anyone), and you picked apart everything she did.

Smoking and cursing aside (the former of which you knew about), it’s her house you can’t expect to be treated like a co-tenant.

AlohaRose · 03/10/2025 17:07

I don't understand why you ever moved in if your old house was still available for you to live in??? Also how could you not realise she was smoking around your 9-year old? Even if he never mentioned it, he must have reeked of smoke when he came back. It's selfish that she couldn't not smoke for the time you were there but I think you were naive to think that she could so easily stop.

MushMonster · 03/10/2025 17:12

You and your DP are quite in the wrong here.
Your MIL smoking with the children in the house, I would ask her to spare them the smoke. Which she did. You knew she smokes. And it is her house. So, yes she was unreasonable but she corrected. You could show her the video about the smoke coming in when you are hust at the door frame. I am positive there was sn add against smoking about that.

The cooking, breakfast and shopping. She is being lovely yo you. Now you want to take over her kitchen and fridge? That is crazy. Why did you not cook with her and go shopping with her? Let her spoil her grandson and son for a few weeks. You are 100% wrong there.

The way she talks to her husband, well no one knows how he talked to her in the past and if there is any resentment there. I get you struggle with that, of course. She is unreasonable to talk to him sharply if he is talking to her politely. But in long lasting relationships, we all have moments when we do not communicate the best. I would not judge her just yet.

She is unreasonable to blame it all on you. Your partner is to blame too.
You both come accross to me as unfrateful, judgy and lacking of good communication skills.
You have made quite a mess for yourselves with the house move and created quite a rift in the family.
Instead of enjoying being a bit spoiled by your MIL cooking and navigate a few family issues, like smoke and tone/ words used.

PalePurplePumpkin · 03/10/2025 17:12

SoOriginal · 03/10/2025 16:22

The smoking is a firm no for me, but you’re making a fuss over nothing with the rest.

She’s a woman, living on her own, caring for a disabled husband (which can be extremely stressful and isolating). She had her son and grandson to stay and she got overexcited. She probably felt like she had a greater purpose for a short while. I couldn’t have begrudged her that honestly.

Agreed.

I don't think the OP comes across as a very nice person really.

Topseyt123 · 03/10/2025 17:15

MonGrainDeSel · 03/10/2025 17:05

How on earth is it precious not to want people to smoke around your small child and your pregnant self?

It's not. That's not what people are saying at all. They are agreeing with OP on that.

However, they are pointing out that OP knowingly moved into the house of a smoker and then expected to be able to dictate everything, even after said smoker had compromised and agreed to smoke outside.

OP even whinged about MIL cooking them meals and making her child's packed lunch, which was very ungrateful really.

MushMonster · 03/10/2025 17:15

Oh, I missed the glass of wine.....
She is not looking after the children, you are. So why do you think you can have any opinion on her having a drink whenever she wants to?

PumpkinSparkleFairy · 03/10/2025 17:22

I wouldn’t have moved in with someone who smoked if I had my DC with me and/or was pregnant. You knew she smoked - the whole place and her clothes must stink.

Not sure why you couldn’t just let your MIL make your son’s lunches to keep her happy, though.

Why were you even there if your old house was still available to you? Were you planning to stay with MIL until after the birth? All a bit odd tbh.