Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lasted 1 week living with MIL.

220 replies

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:04

Bit of background: I’m 34, have a 9-year-old DS and am 29 weeks pregnant on maternity leave. Me and DP have sold our house and are waiting to move into a new one, so to tide us over we stayed at MIL’s. We expected to be there 8–9 weeks but only lasted one week.

We moved in last Thursday and within days it became clear she was smoking and drinking in the house every night. I knew she smoked, but I thought it was just at weekends outside while she had a little glass of wine. Instead, she smoked in the kitchen every night while we were upstairs with the door shut trying to escape it. DS said he felt sick from the smoke one evening. I thought as I’m pregnant and have a child, she’d smoke outside, but when DP raised it she just moved to standing outside directly under our bedroom window. She even made a snide comment to DP’s brother and his girlfriend that she’d “been told off for smoking.” She hadn’t, she just asked why we sat upstairs all the time and my partner said it’s because of the smoke.

As well as the smoking she was quite overbearing with me. She would try to do my DS’s breakfast on a morning before school and make his packed lunches. Then in the evening she would want to make us all dinner which I said was really lovely, but my partner and I said politely we will make our own food. Partly because her portion sizes were huge and she’d serve desserts that we wouldn’t touch. We had two roast dinners in the space of three days followed by cakes and cheesecakes. I said that we’d cook for ourselves and she didn’t need to make my son’s lunches or breakfast as I enjoy doing it.

I would buy the food to make our meals and my partners work lunches etc and she would always say I’ll do the shopping which I didn’t need her to as it gave me something to do in the afternoon as I was on maternity and I was bored. I did communicate all this with her but she didn’t seem to like it.

I could understand if we were there visiting over the holidays, but we’ve moved in with her to live there. I wasn’t a guest and I didn’t need to be mothered. It felt like she was taking away any independence I had left. I appreciate she wanted to help me, but it was becoming too much. I couldn’t even do my own washing or feed my own child. When I made my partner‘s lunches, she would say that I “spoiled him” but it felt like deep down she wanted to be the one making it. She was always telling me to sit down but she knows I really enjoy cooking.

On top of this, I’ve also struggled to watch her speak to her husband who has got Parkinson’s. She constantly belittled him and swore at him. I told my partner as it was very upsetting.

Yesterday, everything came to a head. DP called her at 1:30pm to say we’d be going back to our old house, mainly due to the smoking. He made sure to say there’s no hard feelings and we were just struggling a little bit as a family not having our own space. She said “yeah ok if that’s what you want.” he called me after to say there was no hard feelings and she’s okay.

When I came back from the school run DP was already there and DP’s cousin was visiting with her children. As soon as I got to the door MIL started a blazing row with me in front of everyone. She told me she was “very cross with me!” which felt so belittling — talking to me like a child. DP stepped in straight away and said “don’t speak to her like that, why are you doing this you said everything was fine earlier?” but MIL just said “well it’s not fine this hasn’t gone through way I planned!” and carried on blaming me. She was shouting at me saying I knew she smoked and I said I didn’t know that and if I had have I wouldn’t have come. But she continued to shout at me saying yes you did know etc.

I ended up going upstairs, packing up mine and DS’s things, and leaving. She then had a massive row with DP, saying everything was my fault. She even said about me “she didn’t have a problem with me smoking when I watched her son for her,” which shocked me because I had no idea she smoked around DS when he stayed there — and I don’t understand how she thinks that’s okay.

AIBU to feel shocked, angry and like I’ve done nothing wrong here?

All I wanted was to get through a few weeks until our move. We’ve had the house move from hell which has been dragging on for the past three months. I’m due a baby in 11 weeks, the house we’re moving into needs work doing before we can live in it and my partner is currently working two jobs. This really is the last thing he or I needed. I just don’t understand how she can say she’s angry? At what? If anything I should be angry at her for smoking round us but rather than making her feel like a guest in her own home we’ve chosen to leave so she can continue her life.

OP posts:
JulianFawcettMP · 03/10/2025 16:00

I can't believe the bitch made food for you. Go no contact.

IAmThePrettiestManOnMyIsland · 03/10/2025 16:01

LBFseBrom · 03/10/2025 15:55

I agree. She is entitled to smoke in her own home, she didn't smoke in the same room as you and the smell wafting up won't hurt you.

Because she cooked too much for your taste, you didn't have to eat it all. She was trying to help. What's wrong with having a pudding after main course? Most people do and enjoy it.

You could have negotiated smaller portions.

A week is not very long, it takes a bit of time to get used to different ways.

Yeah, I kind of feel sorry for the MIL, she's probably feeling judged and criticised for offering her hospitality. I don't think they should have moved into the home of a smoker if they had problems with smoking. I don't buy the 'I thought she only smoked outside' excuse either. How would her son not know that she smokes inside the home.

I don't like smoking myself, but it doesn't mean I dictate to my parents when I visit because they do smoke.

Leilaandtheloggerheads · 03/10/2025 16:02

Two questions…

  1. if you’ve sold your old house and had to move out, how have you managed to “go back there”? Why did you move in the first place if it wasn’t sold?
  2. if she was smoking around your child while babysitting, how did you not smell it on him?
Epidote · 03/10/2025 16:03

I haven't vote because I understand your annoyance and also a bit of hers.
You want the things your way she wants the things her way and those ways are very different.
You have say the last thing we need is..... I'm sure the last thing she needed was what happened also.
Give time if you want to settle the relationship. Otherwise you are better on your own place, it will be quieter and you won't be dealing with her. Focus on your stuff and take it slowly. There are many changes right now in your life.
Congratulations on the baby and the bigger house.

Nestingbirds · 03/10/2025 16:04

I think the issue is she saw it as an opportunity to look after you all, and you have insulted her portions and food, berated her smoking even if she is outside, your son’s packed lunches etc - it must feel very hurtful to her op.

IAmThePrettiestManOnMyIsland · 03/10/2025 16:04

Leilaandtheloggerheads · 03/10/2025 16:02

Two questions…

  1. if you’ve sold your old house and had to move out, how have you managed to “go back there”? Why did you move in the first place if it wasn’t sold?
  2. if she was smoking around your child while babysitting, how did you not smell it on him?

curiouser and curiouser 😂

ginasevern · 03/10/2025 16:05

Poor you having to eat roast dinners and cheesecake for pudding. She must be a right bitch serving up food like that. I can only imagine how "politely" you pointed her failings out to her OP. Never mind, you'll know in future never to ask her for any favours ever again won't you.

Nestingbirds · 03/10/2025 16:05

I think I would apologise for being seemingly ungrateful and tell her your pregnancy is affecting you, and the move is stressful and hope she is gracious.

SixtyTwoPercent · 03/10/2025 16:06

Sorry OP, from what you have written you sound hard work & quite controlling.

I totally understand how you feel about smoking. But if someone offered to do my kids lunches I would collapse in grateful tears.

It was as massive a deal for her to open her home to you, as it was for you to move into someone else's space.

You frankly sound rude and dismissive of the care she was attempting to show to you all (cooking, lunches) because eew, big portions and you like cooking. Really?

That said, what3words username always makes me eye threads with suspicion.

Izzywizzy85 · 03/10/2025 16:12

In fairness, you DID know she smoked-you say so in your OP! Expecting her to not to smoke around her grandchild is fair, I don’t know many grandparents who would have a problem with this.
YABVU over the meals. Just eat what you want and leave the rest? And you don’t “touch” her puddings? Honestly your language sounds a little snobby and that you think you’re better than her. I know you’ll deny this, but that’s how you come across here and I’m sure you came across like this to her. She was trying to be hospitable and look after you and you’ve turned your nose up at her.
She didn’t deal with it in the best way when you told her you were leaving, it sounds like she was embarrassed and upset and handled it wrong.
I think you’re both unreasonable.

Hiptothisjive · 03/10/2025 16:13

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:09

How so?

OP your complete and total inability to see any of this from her side is staggering.

I agree with her on a number of things. I am astounded at your entitled behaviour when clearly she was trying to help and all you did was complain, criticise and control - in someone else’s house.

Luckyingame · 03/10/2025 16:14

LandOfFruitAndNut · 03/10/2025 14:07

YABU wanting to control what someone does in their own house.

This.

QuinoafromKew · 03/10/2025 16:17

I'm think you going back to your old house will be a bit of a surprise for the new owner OP.
YANBU for the smoking
YABU on the rest.
If someone is kind enough to take you all in then you go with the flow while you are there.

ainsleysanob · 03/10/2025 16:21

No, I’m sorry, but it’s her house and she can smoke where she wants. You knew she smoked so you should have found somewhere else to go if you don’t (understandably) want to be around the fumes.

i think you are bro g way out of order making a song and dance about her cooking. So what if she makes huge portions. Just leave what you don’t want. Oh no, she was making puddings and cakes for you all, how ghastly of her.

SoOriginal · 03/10/2025 16:22

The smoking is a firm no for me, but you’re making a fuss over nothing with the rest.

She’s a woman, living on her own, caring for a disabled husband (which can be extremely stressful and isolating). She had her son and grandson to stay and she got overexcited. She probably felt like she had a greater purpose for a short while. I couldn’t have begrudged her that honestly.

SilverCamellia · 03/10/2025 16:26

You sound quite touchy. She probably thought she was doing a favour by helping with the lunches and breakfasts. You don't sound very gracious. The smoking is unacceptable though.

DrowningInSyrup · 03/10/2025 16:26

Smoking no, but you asked her to smoke outside and she did, which is good of her. Shut the window if that bothered you. The way she speaks to her husband is unpleasant, but not really any of your business and as for the meals and pack lunches, sounds lovely and that she is just trying to help. Saying you'll buy all your own food etc seems really ungrateful and cold. Seems you trampled all over her a bit. She shouldn't have shouted at you in front of everyone, but I think she is completely within her rights to be angry and upset.

beencaughttrollin · 03/10/2025 16:28

LandOfFruitAndNut · 03/10/2025 14:07

YABU wanting to control what someone does in their own house.

For everyone "yesing" and "thising" this comment - what would you recommend someone do if they've been invited and accepted an invitation believing they'd be staying in a non-smoking household, and discover that there actually is quite a bit of smoking, which poses a specific problem because of both pregnancy and the young son's discomfort? Rather than demanding that MIL stop (which WOULD have been controlling), OP and her partner have said thanks very much, sorry for the inconvenience, and left the house. Are you suggesting they should have stayed, or ...?

Personally, I'd have been a lot clearer on the ground rules, including making sure there would be no smoking in the house, before I moved in, but I don't see how saying sorry this can't work, we'll have to go is controlling what anyone else does.

itsgettingweird · 03/10/2025 16:30

Yanbu wanting to leave because of the smoking.

YABU over the breakfasts and lunches as she was just being nice and helpful and if you are staying in someone’s home you don’t get to dictate what they do.

Yanbu about the yelling. That was unacceptable.

YourFairCyanReader · 03/10/2025 16:32

OP, you know how you want to do things for your son and look after him and take care of him? Well your MIL still has some of those feelings for your DH. She will have been really excited thinking the three of you are there for 6-8 weeks, stocking up on food, cooking and baking. It wouldn't have killed you to let her mother you all for a bit and she would probably have ran out of energy soon anyway.

If you knew she smoked outside and she ended up smoking outside then that's exactly what was expected and shouldn't have been an issue, MIL is right.

Why are you not yet secure enough as a wife and mum to let MIL take control for a bit? You could have had a lovely break!

EmeraldShamrock000 · 03/10/2025 16:32

35965a · 03/10/2025 15:22

Smoking when she visits OP is different though, she abides by OPs house rules and doesn’t smoke when she visits.

MIL did smoke outside when OP moaned about it then moaned again because it was under OPs bedroom window.

MIL did try to be more accommodating with it yet still got complained about.

Good point.

Ohmygodthepain · 03/10/2025 16:34

Why did you move in with her if you still have your old home?

tripleginandtonic · 03/10/2025 16:37

LandOfFruitAndNut · 03/10/2025 14:07

YABU wanting to control what someone does in their own house.

This. I'd have tucked it up and let her cook amd make the packed lunches, she'd probably get fed up of it in another week or so.

BrightLightTonight · 03/10/2025 16:38

Sorry - but I think you sound horrible. So MIL was trying to do nice things for you, cooking, preparing lunches etc.
sh3 stopped smoking in the house as you asked, but that still wasn’t good enough for you.
I hope you don’t need anything else from her in the future

Boomer55 · 03/10/2025 16:39

OneBluntApple · 03/10/2025 14:09

How so?

Her house. Her rules. 🤷‍♀️