Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Manchester terrorist attack today shows the growing Anti-Semitism

1000 replies

Longingdreamer · 02/10/2025 21:17

... and how Jews are not protected in this country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
miserableandworried · 03/10/2025 12:48

nomas · 03/10/2025 12:42

This doesn’t make any sense? You can’t believe stupidity that you’re predicting?

The police had to make a difficult decision. The only one to blame for the murders is the murderer, not the police trying to prevent them.

That’s exactly what I’m saying. The terrorist attacked and the police have mistakenly killed an innocent.

People on social media are now insinuating that the Mossad have something to do with orchestrating this attack. An inside job, if you will.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:50

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:28

None of it is credible, just one group of people calling themselves 'chosen' in some way by a higher power who thinks that anyone with different beliefs is going to whichever version of 'hell' they have ... and people are being murdered over this nonsense. A handful here a handful there or in the instance in Gaza in their tens of thousands.

What the actual fuck am I reading????? You are openly and disgustingly antisemitic. Shame on you. Bat Zona.

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 03/10/2025 12:51

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:45

'I’m all for religious education to be dropped and for it to be taught in the historical context in a critical way. Not as a belief system that should be respected but one that is open to criticism and study.'

In our DCs schools they don't teach 'religion' they have Philosophy & Ethics twice a week until the kids leave school. They cover everything from World religions to philosophy to PSHE subjects. Much better way to do it IMHO. Rather than being a a religious school where other faiths might get a mention but THE faith of the school is portrayed as the right or most important one in some way.
And I say that as someone who attended faith schools from age 5-18.

Yes my son’s school does this and focuses largely on Christianity because it is the faith on which this country is founded. But I would like to see a bit more open discussion critiquing faiths. I went to a Catholic school all through my school years.the knowledge of Christianity is extremely helpful (although, and perhaps because if this I can pull it apart at the drop of a hat). We need to move from respecting all religions to respecting individuals but being able to openly be critical of those religions.

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 12:51

Absolutely nuts-we don’t ask British Chinese people to condemn the Chinese government, nor British Indians or Pakistanis to condemn anything those governments are involved in. So why is it different for Jews?

I've never seen answer or even acknowledgment that it's different for jews

Verv · 03/10/2025 12:51

samthepigeon · 03/10/2025 12:32

I know many Muslims and this is a gross and dangerous generalisation. It does nothing to make an argument, and does you a disservice. Do you really believe this?

Having watched the streets crawl with keffiyes chanting from the river to the sea, daubing jewish homes, shuls, and businesses with graffiti and watching a chap named Jihad murder jews in their place of worship only yesterday, yes, I do believe it.
And if we're going to start denying that misogyny is a deep rooted part of that particular religion then I'd direct you towards the Casey review as a starting point.

PraisebetoGod · 03/10/2025 12:52

samthepigeon · 03/10/2025 12:48

I am not sure you would love it. You implied I wouldn't listen to your arguments. I said I would, and I tried to engage you in a discussion. You are now saying you won't listen to what I have to say, even before I have said it.
Are the quotes you gave about the Koran out of context? I don't have a vast expertise in the Koran. I am thinking you might. I am not a Biblical scholar either, but have more knowledge of that. Do you?

I am being completely genuine when I say this Sam. Please read the Koran. I have. It is not a book that promotes tolerance. I could give you quote after quote and you could quite rightly tell me I'm cherry picking. Which is why my advice is to read the entire book to understand what i am saying. This is not the place and right now I don't have the time. I genuinely would love for you to do that. You will then come to your conclusion. Anyway, either way I wish you well!

Andouillette · 03/10/2025 12:52

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 09:51

I don’t know why I’m commenting because some of your posts are utterly horrifying. I bet you all the money that if a Jew had killed 2 people in a mosque during Ramadan these comments would be wildly different. Shame on any one who dares to justify the Islamic terror attack on my community during their day of worship. Condemn it, offer condolences. Stand up for us, support us, say not in my name. It just looks like Jewish lives don’t matter because we don’t deserve your compassion. Bunch of vile hypocrites. I should be shocked but I’m not.

Great comment. Please know that there are loads of us out here who support you, who are appalled by yesterday's events and who utterly condemn the mealy-mouthed, cat-bum faced, moral highgrounding shite that some posters are coming out with. Sending you love and deepest sympathy.

IAmThePrettiestManOnMyIsland · 03/10/2025 12:52

Without a doubt antisemitism has got worse, most likely due to the Palestine/Israel conflict. Imagine being a Jew living in any major city, dealing with the relentless Palestine protests, you just wouldn't feel safe to leave your home at the weekend. It's a disgrace!

The politicians and mainstream media have all played their part in it too.

isitmyturn · 03/10/2025 12:52

I'm not reading 800 replies but shocking that 30% voted YABU.

samthepigeon · 03/10/2025 12:53

SidekickSylvia · 03/10/2025 09:02

There's a link on the first page, it includes the statistics. The threat to the UK from Islam is 'substantial'. 'Islamist terrorism remains the primary terrorist threat to the UK' etc. It also includes the horrifying statistic that 13% of MI5's list are under 18 years old, and that 48 late stage planned attacks have been disrupted.
It must be a truly terrifying time to be Jewish in this country.

Yes it is high. And scary. But I am not sure it is right to assume that all the threats are targeted at Jewish people.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:53

Juniperberry55 · 03/10/2025 12:41

I think if the aibu unreasonable was ' did anyone else think the terrorist incident in Manchester was horrific ' must people on here would have agreed it was horrific and tragic. But the Jewish population are protected in this country, the police responded quickly. Without having armed guards accompanying each Jewish person, the police couldn't have done much more.
There will obviously always be a few people that have disgusting views but I doubt it's nearly 1/3 people who voted

Do you know why the police responded quickly? Do you know there were armed police 4 minutes away? Do you know that Jewish schools, synagogues and community centres need to be guarded by private or volunteer staff 24/7? Damn right they should be protected. The fact that Jews need this kind of fucking protection in the first place is the issue here! How this doesn’t make you furious is beyond my comprehension,

DialSquare · 03/10/2025 12:54

nomas · 03/10/2025 11:02

So your response to someone saying immigrants don't integrate is that you left when brown people moved in to your area?

No, I’m saying that mass immigration (including white immigrants btw) in a short period of time, makes it very hard for any integration to take place, and has a big affect on the longstanding community that was there. And seeing as some of the brown people in my community also moved out, and shock horror, there are brown people living in the area I moved to, please kindly fuck off with whatever it is you are trying to insinuate.

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:55

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:50

What the actual fuck am I reading????? You are openly and disgustingly antisemitic. Shame on you. Bat Zona.

To be clear I think ALL religions are absolute bullshit - including the one I was brought up in. The major ones are ALL recruiting with the same ' our religion is THE true one, we're the ones god loves' nonsense... and extremists adhering to these beliefs are dangerous.
dangerous to other religions, to other culture, to non-believers. So no, I'm not antisemitic, thanks, nor am I an Islamophobe or anti Christian.
Just sick to death of people using fairy stories to justify oppressing women, gay people, other nationalities or religions or starting wars over it or committing genocide.

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 12:56

But I am not sure it is right to assume that all the threats are targeted at Jewish people.

Why would all the attacks need to target Jewish people in order for Jewish people to be scared?

**

Juniperberry55 · 03/10/2025 12:57

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 03/10/2025 12:46

I’m sorry, but you’re sticking your head in the sand. Given the rhetoric on here I can quite believe those figures.

Really??? You actually think that because the police responded to a terrorist incident that means that Jews are protected? It’s hard to believe you could think that if you think Jews should be treated equally. If Jews were protected and hate against them wasnt allowed to go unpunished then there would not have been any incident for the police to respond to!! Are you one of the 29%?

I don't think anyone can be protected 100%. Women still get sexually assaulted and raped, but they are protected by laws to an extent, do I think more can be done, yes. But I don't think they're less protected than any other religion, you've only got to look at the news articles about mosques being attacked too, to see it is a problem bigger than just one religion being attacked.
I think people should be safe to practice whichever religion they want. There will always be some extremists and none of them are acceptable in my view.
From my own experience in life I don't think most people in this country are anti semetic. I do believe there is growing intolerance in general for difference races and religions and there needs to be more done

Would you consider me anti semetic from anything I have said?
I have grown up and atheist, I grew up with an education that taught me about different religions and cultures and although interesting, I don't follow a religion myself, but am tolerant and have friends and colleagues that come from all sorts of backgrounds and don't judge them or treat them any differently because of it.
I have been to a concentration camp to learn about the history and intolerance that led to such horrors. Although I don't understand everything, I do understand that when you pit people against each other based off religious stereotypes, it doesn't end well

IAmThePrettiestManOnMyIsland · 03/10/2025 12:57

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 12:51

Absolutely nuts-we don’t ask British Chinese people to condemn the Chinese government, nor British Indians or Pakistanis to condemn anything those governments are involved in. So why is it different for Jews?

I've never seen answer or even acknowledgment that it's different for jews

Really? Any Jew that doesn't condemn Israel is immediately written off as a Zionist, and we all know the chants aimed at them.

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:57

Oh, and also Bat Zona? get a grip. and don't assume gender either.

LittleMG · 03/10/2025 12:57

Unfortunately extremism is on the rise. Extreme Islamists are a problem here, extreme Christians are a problem in America and extremist Jews are a problem in Gaza. (Just minimum examples) Maybe it’s a problem with religion. I don’t think you can say that Jewish people are not protected worse than other groups. Maybe they feel more vulnerable because of the hate coming their way due to the genocide in Gaza. But the police were there and dealt with it they couldn’t have been quicker could they.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:57

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:55

To be clear I think ALL religions are absolute bullshit - including the one I was brought up in. The major ones are ALL recruiting with the same ' our religion is THE true one, we're the ones god loves' nonsense... and extremists adhering to these beliefs are dangerous.
dangerous to other religions, to other culture, to non-believers. So no, I'm not antisemitic, thanks, nor am I an Islamophobe or anti Christian.
Just sick to death of people using fairy stories to justify oppressing women, gay people, other nationalities or religions or starting wars over it or committing genocide.

Don’t you dare tell me that you’re not antisemitic when you’ve included at least 3 blatant antisemitic tropes. Shame on you. Shame.

samthepigeon · 03/10/2025 12:58

Lazytiger · 03/10/2025 11:30

Western values come from the (Judeo-Christian) teachings of the Bible.

Jesus is a prophet in Islam. There are massive overlaps. Values of the family, of charity, of compassion. Values of honesty, humility. More in common than not.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:59

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 12:57

Oh, and also Bat Zona? get a grip. and don't assume gender either.

Ok Ben zona, better?

LittleMG · 03/10/2025 12:59

IAmThePrettiestManOnMyIsland · 03/10/2025 12:57

Really? Any Jew that doesn't condemn Israel is immediately written off as a Zionist, and we all know the chants aimed at them.

I think it’s the responsibility of Jewish people to call out Israel actually it’s not something you can stay silent on it’s gone past that. Silence is edging towards complicity now.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 13:00

LittleMG · 03/10/2025 12:57

Unfortunately extremism is on the rise. Extreme Islamists are a problem here, extreme Christians are a problem in America and extremist Jews are a problem in Gaza. (Just minimum examples) Maybe it’s a problem with religion. I don’t think you can say that Jewish people are not protected worse than other groups. Maybe they feel more vulnerable because of the hate coming their way due to the genocide in Gaza. But the police were there and dealt with it they couldn’t have been quicker could they.

The only Jews in Gaza are the hostages. Gaza and any future Palestinian state will be judenrein. Imagine that. People supporting the creation of a state where no Jews are allowed.

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 13:01

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 12:57

Don’t you dare tell me that you’re not antisemitic when you’ve included at least 3 blatant antisemitic tropes. Shame on you. Shame.

batzona, doll.

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 03/10/2025 13:01

Shakeoffyourchains · 03/10/2025 12:45

it is MAINLY Muslims that are carrying out terrorist attached.

That's partly because of institutional bias in how terrorism is defined and prosecuted. CREST carried out a study on this and found that, of the 809 people convicted of terror related offences between 2001 and 2022, 61.7% were Islamists, but also found that non-muslims were significantly less likely to be charged with terror related offences than Muslims, even for the same crimes, which made the statistics unreliable.

Derek Bird killed 12 people in a gun attack, but wasn't classed as a terrorist, while Ali Harbi Ali killed one person in a knife attack and was classed as a terrorist.

Ryan McGee killed no one but was involved with the British far right, had prescribed terrorist literature in his possession and had made a viable IED, but wasn't classed as a terrorist. While Abu Izzadeen killed no one but was involved with the islamic far right, including fundraising, and was classed as a terrorist.

I’ve seen it all now. Are you basically saying you think the definition. Of terrorism should be changed to make fewer Muslim terrorist fall within the definition????

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.