Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Starmer thinks I am an enemy of the state

1000 replies

Bumblebee72 · 01/10/2025 10:14

So we have it Starmer has declared at conference because I support Reform I am now an enemy of his Government.

Who would have thought it, a middle class British worker, now an enemy in the country I was born. And they say Reform is the party of Fascists. Yet we also now have the Home Secretary saying "In solving this crisis, you may not always like what I do. We will have to question some of the assumptions and legal constraints that have lasted for a generation and more". Maybe the Home Secretary too will be deemed an enemy of the state.

Am I being unreasonable to think this should be seen as a rallying cry to get this Government out at the first opportunity.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 12:13

EasternStandard · 01/10/2025 12:07

They’re going in strong. Starmer asked them to. Tell everyone they’re snowflakes and post memes.

Suggesting posters are bots is against Talk guidelines.

Mamatheo · 01/10/2025 12:13

He’s right. You support a racist party who want to destroy the good things in this country- NHS; tolerance; fairness. If like Farage you are a racist and hate the country and never have a good word to say about it then keep on supporting a racist party. If, however, you are merely racist then there’s still the Tories. They’re racist too- see Kendrick- but at least have some-not many- redeeming qualities.

JamieCannister · 01/10/2025 12:13

sunandfizz · 01/10/2025 11:55

@Bumblebee72 - why don't you listen again to his speech and actually try understanding it?

He gave a story of when he went into some elderly woman's house who he had been told was a 'far right supporter" and he was baffled why she started showing him photos of herself at an Indian wedding.

It was only later, after he left, that it dawned in him what she had been trying to do - that she was a working class woman who felt she needed to prove to a Labour politician she wasn't racist.

She had lived in the same street all her life. Of course the "I'm not racist me, look I've even got black / Muslim / whatever friends" would make most people cringe, but this was all she knew and the only way she could say it.

So when she then told him a story about how she didn't like it when some 'migrants' had been sitting on nextdoor's wall, spitting (or something like that), he could totally relate to her concern - her direct experience is understandable in HER context.

He agrees we need to get control of illegal immigration and understands people's valid concerns here need to be listened to.

But if you feel his calling out of people who hate someone just based on the colour of their skin - making no distinction between legal immigrants or people who live and work here - if you feel that applies to you, well, yes, you are racist and you are shameful.

So what exactly triggered you about the speech @Bumblebee72 ? Were you planning to paint racist graffiti? Hoping you could shout racism in the street and get away with it? What exactly?

Edited

It is not racist to think that we have had far too many legal immigrants as a result of government policies that were never given a democratic mandate by the voting population, nor is it racist to wish to do something about it.

It is also not racist to not want any extremists, islamists, criminals or people who reject basic western liberal democratic values to be in the country, whether born here or not, nor is it racist to focus deportation efforts on those who are not wanted and not British (whereas trying to deport british criminals is much much harder).

Honish · 01/10/2025 12:14

The irony being that Starmer while calling other political parties fascists, is the first PM to jail people, mothers of young children and pensioners, for social media posts.

sunandfizz · 01/10/2025 12:14

Farage was almost expelled from the prestigious public-school, Dulwich college as a teenager for racist bullying of another student and openly expressing sympathy and a weird fascination with Nazis.

After a stint in banking, he spent his adult life agitating for Brexit.

The day after the Brexit vote - well, you would think he'd be fighting to stay in politics to show people the Brexit wonders that await.. The sum of his life's amibition - show us the way then Nigel? But no. What did he do? RESIGNS FROM POLITICAL LIFE.

He knew Brexit would be the utter shitshow it has been and he didn't want to be held accountable. He knew better than anyone. So he ran away. Then he gets a slot in LBC to pontificate and whinge about how everyone else is "doing Brexit wrong." Tiy couid t make it up. Can people's memories really be this short?

He will do exactly the same again if elected PM. Just watch, Being an agitator is one thing. But actually having to do the job and take accountability - no way. He will run for the hills. Swivel-eyed snake that he is. Truly a nasty piece of work.

JamieCannister · 01/10/2025 12:14

Summerhillsquare · 01/10/2025 12:10

Thank you for introducing the facts!

The fact that Starmer is a liar you mean?

Bumblebee72 · 01/10/2025 12:14

TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 12:09

Can you point me to where Mahmood said she would be rescinding ILR from those already awarded it? Thanks.

"In solving this crisis, you may not always like what I do. We will have to question some of the assumptions and legal constraints that have lasted for a generation and more."

As she said you won't like what she's going to do.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 01/10/2025 12:16

TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 10:24

He didn't call you or anyone else an enemy of the state. This is what he said:

Controlling migration is a reasonable goal.

But if you throw bricks and smash up private property…

That’s not legitimate – that’s thuggery.

Free speech is a British value – and we have guarded it for centuries.

But if you incite racist violence and hatred…

That’s not expressing concern – it’s criminal.

This party, this great party, is proud of our flags…

Yet if they are painted alongside graffiti…

Telling a Chinese takeaway owner to “go home”…

That’s not pride – that’s racism.

And if you say or imply…

That people cannot be English or British…

Because of the colour of their skin…

That mixed heritage families owe you an explanation…

And that people who have lived here for generations…

Raised their children here…

Built lives in their communities…

Working in our schools, our hospitals, running businesses…

Our neighbours…

If you say they should now be deported…

Then mark my words…

We will fight you with everything we have…

Because you are an enemy of national renewal

Exactly. I agree with that.

HPFA · 01/10/2025 12:16

LetItRainLetItBePeaceful · 01/10/2025 10:24

KS is sounding increasingly desperate and like a man backed into a corner who knows time is running out for him.

I wouldn't worry about what he says.

I'm a white, female, born here and thinking of voting reform too.

The news is overun with high inflation, low growth, immigration problems, failing services and yesterday RR says something about increasing benefits re child benefit cap. I mean seriously. Debt is increasing each month, interest on goverment bonds is high as the UK is no longer seen as a safe place to invest.

Just get the fuck out of parliament both of you and let someone with some balls take over.

I used to vote Tory. I've never voted labour and I never considered reform until this year.

So you presumably voted Tory over the last fourteen years and now you're blaming Labour for the state of the country?

That's the Labour Party that have been in power for a little over....one year.

HelenaWaiting · 01/10/2025 12:17

Bumblebee72 · 01/10/2025 10:14

So we have it Starmer has declared at conference because I support Reform I am now an enemy of his Government.

Who would have thought it, a middle class British worker, now an enemy in the country I was born. And they say Reform is the party of Fascists. Yet we also now have the Home Secretary saying "In solving this crisis, you may not always like what I do. We will have to question some of the assumptions and legal constraints that have lasted for a generation and more". Maybe the Home Secretary too will be deemed an enemy of the state.

Am I being unreasonable to think this should be seen as a rallying cry to get this Government out at the first opportunity.

If you support Reform, you are an enemy of the state. If you vote for a fascist party, you're a fascist. If you support racist parties, you are racist. You may bibble on about Labour "dancing to Reform's tune" but no one in the government is advocating getting rid of Indefinite Leave to Remain. No one in the Labour Party is getting all excited at the prospect of rounding up and deporting, en masse, people who are not white or who were born abroad. Others may make excuses for you; I won't. The Prime Minister may declare you "not racist"; I won't. As far as I'm concerned, Reform supporter = scum of the earth. That's the message that those who don't want to live in a sad, racially "pure" dictatorship should be putting out. It's time to stop walking on eggshells around Reform and their supporters and shove them back under the rock they crawled out from.

EasternStandard · 01/10/2025 12:17

TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 12:13

Suggesting posters are bots is against Talk guidelines.

I didn’t use that term you did.

Starmer wants to ‘fight’ some will pick up on that, however they wish.

persephonia · 01/10/2025 12:18

EasternStandard · 01/10/2025 12:11

I think you’ve pulled this out of nowhere. And is in your head alone.

Labour are changing policy because they don’t want to lose. They are aware of where voters are going. It’s not unheard of in politics.

No... It's been from you misinterpreting what I say on other threads. People can keep saying "we don't think people are wrong to be concerned about immigration. However openly racist rhetoric is wrong and targeting people because of their skin colour is wrong." And you and Bumblebee will hear "blah blah blah we want open borders blah blah you are all racist thickoa of you don't".
Labour,.for all their faults, said they would do something about immigration before being elected, said they would try to crack down on the gangs running small boats etc. Now they are. They might be successful, they might not. Time will tell. But it's odd to see that as a bad thing/a sign of defeat when it's what you said you wanted. And it's what they said they would do. The very worst charge you could make is that they have decided to stick by/toughen their policies presumably after listening to people. It surely that would be a good thing.
By the way. by centring Reform in everything, you are also decentring any agency that ordinary people like yourself might have. So you will always feel disempowered and ignored no matter what.

Pigeonpoodle · 01/10/2025 12:19

R0ckandHardPlace · 01/10/2025 10:22

But if people align and march with a party who have clear fascist views, they must take responsibility for educating themselves about the aims and views of that organisation. You can’t say “I’m not racist, I’m happy for people to come here and live and work legally; it’s just the ones coming on boats that I don’t agree with” when Farage has made it clear that he wants to deport EVERYONE who isn’t British born. Even families that have lived and worked here for decades.

Do you agree with that?

NF hasn’t said anything of the sort. If you want to win the argument, you’ll never do so with such ridiculous distortions and exaggerations. It just makes you look stupid.

DuncinToffee · 01/10/2025 12:19

Honish · 01/10/2025 12:14

The irony being that Starmer while calling other political parties fascists, is the first PM to jail people, mothers of young children and pensioners, for social media posts.

Is he?

One of those mothers was jailed for inciting violence something she confessed to.

Bananaandmangosmoothie · 01/10/2025 12:19

Reform supporters are really keen to emphasise their British identity and British birth location. Do you not have much else going for you?

TheNewWasp · 01/10/2025 12:19

And I wholeheartedly agree with him. UK reform it is an enemy what we have to combat with all our might with whatever means necessary.

ExpressCheckout · 01/10/2025 12:19

WateringCans · 01/10/2025 11:05

I used to, but their stance on TWAW really concerns me.

I don't disagree, although I think they're currently debating their stance.

TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 12:20

HelenaWaiting · 01/10/2025 12:17

If you support Reform, you are an enemy of the state. If you vote for a fascist party, you're a fascist. If you support racist parties, you are racist. You may bibble on about Labour "dancing to Reform's tune" but no one in the government is advocating getting rid of Indefinite Leave to Remain. No one in the Labour Party is getting all excited at the prospect of rounding up and deporting, en masse, people who are not white or who were born abroad. Others may make excuses for you; I won't. The Prime Minister may declare you "not racist"; I won't. As far as I'm concerned, Reform supporter = scum of the earth. That's the message that those who don't want to live in a sad, racially "pure" dictatorship should be putting out. It's time to stop walking on eggshells around Reform and their supporters and shove them back under the rock they crawled out from.

You are not allowed to say any of this as apparently it makes more people turn to Reform, or makes them vote harder for Reform or something. Poor dears.

Obeseandashamed · 01/10/2025 12:20

TwistyTales · 01/10/2025 10:24

He didn't call you or anyone else an enemy of the state. This is what he said:

Controlling migration is a reasonable goal.

But if you throw bricks and smash up private property…

That’s not legitimate – that’s thuggery.

Free speech is a British value – and we have guarded it for centuries.

But if you incite racist violence and hatred…

That’s not expressing concern – it’s criminal.

This party, this great party, is proud of our flags…

Yet if they are painted alongside graffiti…

Telling a Chinese takeaway owner to “go home”…

That’s not pride – that’s racism.

And if you say or imply…

That people cannot be English or British…

Because of the colour of their skin…

That mixed heritage families owe you an explanation…

And that people who have lived here for generations…

Raised their children here…

Built lives in their communities…

Working in our schools, our hospitals, running businesses…

Our neighbours…

If you say they should now be deported…

Then mark my words…

We will fight you with everything we have…

Because you are an enemy of national renewal

I dislike starmer but this speech is very well written and sends a strong message with the right sentiment. Unfortunately many will cherry pick what they want from it without understanding what he’s actually saying.

WildLeader · 01/10/2025 12:20

ExpressCheckout · 01/10/2025 10:24

@Bumblebee72 Did you bother listening to the whole speech? That's not what he said at all. Perhaps watch it all before rushing to judgement or listening to Farage's exaggerated response.

If @Bumblebee72 actually had the wisdom to listen to the whole speech, she’d not be daft enough to fall for the dog whistle BS of Farage.

EasternStandard · 01/10/2025 12:21

persephonia · 01/10/2025 12:18

No... It's been from you misinterpreting what I say on other threads. People can keep saying "we don't think people are wrong to be concerned about immigration. However openly racist rhetoric is wrong and targeting people because of their skin colour is wrong." And you and Bumblebee will hear "blah blah blah we want open borders blah blah you are all racist thickoa of you don't".
Labour,.for all their faults, said they would do something about immigration before being elected, said they would try to crack down on the gangs running small boats etc. Now they are. They might be successful, they might not. Time will tell. But it's odd to see that as a bad thing/a sign of defeat when it's what you said you wanted. And it's what they said they would do. The very worst charge you could make is that they have decided to stick by/toughen their policies presumably after listening to people. It surely that would be a good thing.
By the way. by centring Reform in everything, you are also decentring any agency that ordinary people like yourself might have. So you will always feel disempowered and ignored no matter what.

What are you talking about?

It’s hard to know what is getting to you. Labour have clearly shifted on policy and rhetoric.

HPFA · 01/10/2025 12:22

Honish · 01/10/2025 12:14

The irony being that Starmer while calling other political parties fascists, is the first PM to jail people, mothers of young children and pensioners, for social media posts.

The irony being that people who thought it was fine to call for innocents to be burned to death are now getting all touchy whiny about someone calling Reform's racist deportation policy racist.

Threatening to deport people who have been given a legal right to be here, who entered the country legally, have committed no crime, is morally wrong and (given that Europeans are being exempted) pretty clearly racist too.

Go on Twitter and look at all the posts celebrating the policy because it will "get rid of low quality migrants from Third World countries" - that's the nicest translation I can give them.

If you support this policy you're a shit human being.

Bumblebee72 · 01/10/2025 12:22

Farage has managed to get the Government to change the policy on IDR to

"For that reason, we will soon increase the time in which someone must have lived in this country to earn “indefinite leave to remain” from five years to 10.
.... I will be proposing a series of new tests, such as: being in work; making national insurance contributions; not taking a penny in benefits; learning English to a high standard; having no criminal record; and finally, that you have truly given back to your community, such as by volunteering your time to a local cause."

This is a massive shift in policy. Effective opposition.

OP posts:
kerstina · 01/10/2025 12:22

sunandfizz · 01/10/2025 11:27

I did not vote Labour, but I thought Stsrner's speech was great. At last! Let call out the snake Farage for what he is. The man is a truly vile individual. He speaks to the lowest common denominators of human nature - fear, selfishness, xenophobia hatred - and is manipulating the most dispossessed in society for his own twisted view of the world. The fact is, the man is a public school, ex-banker and media-manipulator extraordinaire. But he will shaft the poor so hard they have no idea what's coming. Just give them a little plastic flag and get them pointing their finger at brown people in the hope they don't notice. It's pitiful to watch.

Agree poor people voting reform is like Turkey’s voting for Christmas.

JamieCannister · 01/10/2025 12:25

SeriaMau · 01/10/2025 12:00

And just out of interest, did you have a problem with Thatcher describing Labour and the organised working classes as ‘the enemy within’? No? I thought not…

I would have had a problem with those words back in the 1980s - but with unions pushing queer theory and an end to women's rights I do genuinely believe that they are now an enemy within (and would say so depite thinking there is a risk with using the word "enemy" because enemies are there to be killed, unlike political opponents.)

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.