Why not? Does it not concern you. Or is it more the politics here that is taking up your interest
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 14:16
On Mumsnet?
I do laugh when I see how the UK media reports on what is going on in France. It's like they desperately need to believe that France is constantly on the verge of collapse.
Edited
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 14:16
Great. France isn’t doing so well, do you post about that?
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 14:14
I'm much better off here than I would be in the UK.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 14:11
Are you in France then? Surely you must be concerned about the issues there.
Quoting HedwigEliza
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 14:09
I am also an immigrant, from the UK to another country.
And the reason it's that way round is because the country I now live in respects our family's right to live together, whereas the UK doesn't.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
HedwigEliza ·
29/09/2025 14:06
I’m speaking as an immigrant myself, and I completely disagree with you. A nation’s first duty is to its citizens, not the ‘human rights’ of everyone who wishes to move there. It’s wishful thinking.
Quoting HedwigEliza
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 14:04
A country which would kick someone out after they've contributed, put down roots, perhaps married and had children with a citizen, is a country with no respect for human rights.
Which is, of course, what Reform wants the UK to be.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
HedwigEliza ·
29/09/2025 13:59
It’s not callous - it’s reasonable. I got the benefit of living in that country, they had the perfect right to say goodbye to me if I became a burden to them. This is a transactional relationship - we both have to get something out of it.
Quoting HedwigEliza
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:57
Wow. How incredibly callous.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
HedwigEliza ·
29/09/2025 13:55
Didn’t matter. If they’d decided they didn’t want me once I was no longer useful, they would have sent me packing. A nation’s first duty is to its citizens, not to those of other countries. An immigrant has the benefit of living in that country for that amount of time - it’s not a one sided relationship where the country gives nothing to the immigrant.
Quoting HedwigEliza
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:52
I think not granting someone a visa in the first place is a very different kettle of fish to requiring them to leave once they are no longer useful to you, no matter how long they've been contributing and how many roots they've put down.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
HedwigEliza ·
29/09/2025 13:51
When I was an immigrant the first time around, and had to do all the various health testing, they sure as hell didn’t want me if I was ill or disabled. I would have been a drain on their resources, a financial liability. That seems perfectly fair and reasonable to me. If I had a problem with it - I could have gone somewhere else.
Quoting Toastandbutterand
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:49
Or someone who was earning £60k and paying taxes their whole working life and is now retired? Or disabled?
What about people who are married to and parents of British citizens? Fuck their right to a family life, right?
Quoting Bumblebee72
Toastandbutterand ·
29/09/2025 13:47
And the people who have spent their entire working lives here who will have their pensions removed? You think that's ok?
Do you think, fundamentally, that thats a fair policy? Or do you just view the immigrants as slaves to the British economy?
Quoting PandoraSocks
Bumblebee72 ·
29/09/2025 13:44
Nope. If they are contributing they will be able to stay, if not they can go back home. You know when you're a piss taker. and can plan accordingly.
Quoting Bumblebee72
PandoraSocks ·
29/09/2025 13:41
What about all the people who will have their ILR rescinded? Don't you think they should be worried?
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
Bumblebee72 ·
29/09/2025 13:35
It is already certain with this government, and a possibility with Farage. I'd take the chance on some possibility of a better outcome. The only people who really need to worry about a Farage government are those who are taking the piss and will have their benefits cut if they don't accept a job offer.
Quoting Bumblebee72
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:25
It's always possible to be even more fucked.
If you want to guarantee it, vote for Farage.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
Bumblebee72 ·
29/09/2025 13:23
Well we might as well try. We're fucked under this government.
Edited
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:21
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 13:20
Ok great I hope it helps you somehow. If what you’re saying happens they are more likely to get in.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:15
People who think it's clever to vote for more Farage are dimwits. They deserve to be insulted.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 13:09
Whatever. If it makes you feel better to post insults. Don’t you have your own issues in France?
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 13:07
Yes, OK. Whose votes? Dimwits who think Farage'll fix it?
Like I said, FAFO.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 13:03
You keep responding to things I haven’t posted. If Macron is out and we get a flood of what you call ‘undesirables’ it will be Starmer who is still in.
If that happens it will impact votes for our GE.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 12:59
What on earth makes you think Reform will be able to deliver where Labour can't?
Farage famously can't even be arsed to go to meetings.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 12:18
Macron is out first. If what you’re saying re ‘undesirables’ will happen then it’s Labour still in not delivering mode.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 12:14
What could be the solution to Farage not delivering? Oh yes, more Farage.
FAFO.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 12:11
Ok I haven’t seen that, their policy was pretty tough on R4 recently. We’ll see what the French decide.
And if they do ‘dump all their undesirables’ as you put it that will only drive up voter reaction here.
Edited
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 12:09
Oh, trust me, the French far right would be absolutely delighted if they can dump all their undesirables in the UK.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 12:08
We’ll see. Depends who the French elect. It could be to the right and their policies are tough on the channel.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 12:07
For EU member states, border control is an EU wide issue. The UK is now on its own.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 12:06
No one is doing anyone favours. If Germany or anywhere else gets a gov that has a mandate to have strict border control they will do the same.
Plus wait to see the policies, to the right here and there could change things anyway.
Edited
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 12:03
Brexit means they owe us fuck all and have no incentive to do us any favours.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:59
You keep diverging. Yes a new French President will have policies that their electorate want. It won’t be Macron. It could change things a lot. It’s nothing to do with Brexit still. Each new PM in the EU impacts others as it means borders are more hardline or not.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:53
Yes, OK, which means that France is full of migrants whom right wing parties in particular are desperate to get rid of.
Do you honestly think that Le Pen would say, "Oh, we have to keep them here and stop them from travelling to the UK because of the Le Touquet agreement?"
She'd probably charter a ferry and pay for it herself.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:51
Ditto for your posts. EU countries are all
facing the same pressures, none have left the EU. It is down to border control which each imposes as much as they can.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:49
Not sure what you mean by that tbh.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:48
What are you talking about? Your initial point on Brexit doesn’t stand even with Macron out soon.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:47
Did you miss the part about Macron's days being numbered?
Brexit means that no one will really care if France stops cooperating with the UK over this.
Edited
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:46
Is that you realising yes the French do do a lot now. Switch to this.
And of course it could change, it probably will a fair bit, still nothing to do with Brexit or not.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:41
Macron has 18 months left as President. Do you really think any of the candidates who might replace him are going to be interested in stopping migrants they don't want in France from travelling to the UK?
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:37
Obviously that’s not true. Drones, surveillance, police in riot gear. The French did a few photo ops with tear gas and knifing boats but there’s no way this kind of force should fall to them.
Any EU country that has lowered numbers has used barriers at their borders. Nothing to do with the EU or Brexit, more outside that.
Quoting EasternStandard
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:32
The difference is that we can now no longer count on any cooperation from France at all to stop people crossing the channel in small boats.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
EasternStandard ·
29/09/2025 11:24
Are you sure? Why are other countries still in the EU facing the same pressures? Which of those countries have lowered the numbers, take a look at borders
Quoting BundleBoogie
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 11:21
Well now we have even less ability to control it than we did before, thanks to Brexit.
Slow hand clap for Farage.
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
BundleBoogie ·
29/09/2025 11:20
Europe was being used as a route into this country by people from those Islamic countries. But as we were part of the whole, we couldn’t control our borders at all.
Now we at least have the possibility of control if our government took it.
Quoting Uggbootsforever
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 10:53
Goodness me, so why did Nigel Farage spend more than 20 years campaigning for the UK to leave the predominantly white, Judeo-Christian EU then?
Why was that a priority if the real threat to our way of life is people from Islamic countries?
Quoting MissScarletInTheBallroom
Uggbootsforever ·
29/09/2025 10:48
Because the alternative to Reform is such high levels of immigration from predominantly Islamic countries than an eventual change is Islam could well be in the future of the UK?
Quoting Uggbootsforever
MissScarletInTheBallroom ·
29/09/2025 10:46
Why is that your comparator?
Quoting ChocolateMagnum
Uggbootsforever ·
29/09/2025 10:46
More or less fascist than the Islamic countries in your view?
ChocolateMagnum ·
29/09/2025 10:45
So those of you voting Reform because Labour and the Conservatives are crap; and you're worried about immigration are happy with the risk that a Reform government is highly likely to lead to a fascist state?
Edited