To me amazing is someone with a really great and admirable character that I click with! And by character I don’t just mean sparkling personality. Personality to me is like the cover of the book but character is the
substance of the person. I have met many men with fun personalities and great charisma who are lacking in character!
A few important character traits I can think of the top of my head would be : humility, confidence, kindness, has integrity, honest, principled, empathetic, transparent, strong communicator (listening and expressing feelings).
I do like a good personality too although these things are less important to me than character, so personality wise - funny, shares a few similar interests to me, adventurous, good conversation skills, is a foodie, well read. Being ambitious would be good too.
And obviously I’d want said man to think I’m amazing too!
I thought the guy I mentioned was “amazing” initially but slowly his misogyny began to show and I saw he was using me as an ego boost plus he tried to trauma dump which I now see was probably in an effort to manipulate me.