Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AAAAGH Reform. Are people ignoring the racist?

1000 replies

Peasnbeans · 02/05/2025 23:01

And that he's no economist skills yet promising the impossible. And a racist. And mysoginist.

If Mumsnet is full of women, how is no-one talking about Reform and limiting women's rights?
I know I'll get flamed for this, but it is a boiling frog situation! Jump out!
And I didn't choose the AIBU board but I looked down all the Current Threads and this didn't feature.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
Azdcgbjml · 04/05/2025 09:16

hattie43 · 03/05/2025 12:44

I find that very hard to believe , not even Amsterdam had any . 10.8% nah .

You do understand that white people can be immigrants too?

springbirdss · 04/05/2025 09:17

EasternStandard · 04/05/2025 09:14

That’s not the case. We spend more pp than other G7 countries by 2.5 times.

And this

The UK spends significantly more on asylum seeker costs than other G7 nations, with a per capita cost 150% higher than the next highest G7 country

This is copy and pasted from SWVG, feel free to fact check:

Is the UK under more pressure from asylum seekers and refugees than other countries?

No it is not, in spite of the picture painted by some of our politicians and media.
Out of 28 member states in the EU, the UK ranks ninth in terms of numbers of applications. In 2015, the UK received just fewer than 40 thousand asylum applications. Germany had over 400 thousand, ten times as many.

(Germany still takes the most, followed by France, Spain and Italy I believe)

And because the UK gets relatively few asylum applicants, we host fewer refugees – less than 1% of the global total.

marshmallowmix · 04/05/2025 09:18

It’s very dangerous we are letting in young men from the Middle East and african countries …we don’t know who they are and many come from countries that don’t treat women as equals and dislike the West and our values…

Just seen on the news that police have arrested 4 Iranians on terrorism threats …

we’ve no idea who we are allowing in every day on the boats … 10,000 this year …it’s sheer madness

EasternStandard · 04/05/2025 09:21

springbirdss · 04/05/2025 09:17

This is copy and pasted from SWVG, feel free to fact check:

Is the UK under more pressure from asylum seekers and refugees than other countries?

No it is not, in spite of the picture painted by some of our politicians and media.
Out of 28 member states in the EU, the UK ranks ninth in terms of numbers of applications. In 2015, the UK received just fewer than 40 thousand asylum applications. Germany had over 400 thousand, ten times as many.

(Germany still takes the most, followed by France, Spain and Italy I believe)

And because the UK gets relatively few asylum applicants, we host fewer refugees – less than 1% of the global total.

Edited

Yes and as I’ve posted costs not numbers. We spend more pp. And you can check figures on overall cost.

We are ‘doing our bit’. We spend a lot more on each claim.

marshmallowmix · 04/05/2025 09:22

that should say 7 Iranians not 4!

Iranians are one of the top nationalities arriving by boat …

bellsanddogwhistles · 04/05/2025 09:25

marshmallowmix · 04/05/2025 09:18

It’s very dangerous we are letting in young men from the Middle East and african countries …we don’t know who they are and many come from countries that don’t treat women as equals and dislike the West and our values…

Just seen on the news that police have arrested 4 Iranians on terrorism threats …

we’ve no idea who we are allowing in every day on the boats … 10,000 this year …it’s sheer madness

Edited

Hence the upsurge in Reform members

People are both angry and scared.

Meanwhile the Government won't release crime figures of asylum seekers

www.ons.gov.uk/aboutus/transparencyandgovernance/freedomofinformationfoi/crimesbyasylumseekerstotheuk

JohnAmendAll · 04/05/2025 09:29

StrawberryWater · 03/05/2025 04:02

Reform are just a bunch of Tories and blowhard establishment types (not to mention racists, bigots and people with questionable backgrounds) who helped ruin the country.

It astounds me that anyone would think they would bring about change. You're just voting back in the people you wanted rid of!

Couldn't make it up. Like turkeys voting for Christmas.

It's not that people think they will bring about change, it's that people know the existing 2 main parties can't or won't.

Labour is sitting on a massive majority. So far it has done sod all with it - and the little it has done has been uniformly negative (at any rate in the public's perception).

Labour needs to up it's game, NOW.

Somerford · 04/05/2025 09:30

springbirdss · 04/05/2025 09:17

This is copy and pasted from SWVG, feel free to fact check:

Is the UK under more pressure from asylum seekers and refugees than other countries?

No it is not, in spite of the picture painted by some of our politicians and media.
Out of 28 member states in the EU, the UK ranks ninth in terms of numbers of applications. In 2015, the UK received just fewer than 40 thousand asylum applications. Germany had over 400 thousand, ten times as many.

(Germany still takes the most, followed by France, Spain and Italy I believe)

And because the UK gets relatively few asylum applicants, we host fewer refugees – less than 1% of the global total.

Edited

Germany made the choice to say "refugees welcome" and they got swamped. It's no surprise that they still top the list.

CunningLinguist1 · 04/05/2025 09:37

steff13 · 02/05/2025 23:37

There was a thread about it this morning. I was under the impression "Reform" was a party, not a person, though.

Reform’s a corporation

CunningLinguist1 · 04/05/2025 09:38

Keirawr · 03/05/2025 03:34

You are not making any sense, try again.

But let’s see…

As far as being an economist goes, everyone is an economist if the Mickey Mouse chancellor who lied on her CV, plagiarized books and was accused of fiddling her expenses while working in the private sector is anything to go by. The bar is so low, that anything would be an improvement on that.

And wanting to limit immigration is not racist. You are behind the times. Squealing that people are racist for perfectly valid views is no longer enough to shame them and shut them up.

“Squealing”?
You sound fucking delightful

CrazyAboutFurBabies · 04/05/2025 09:39

randomchap · 03/05/2025 00:13

They're just another populist party, promoting simple solutions to complex problems. Solutions that won't actually work.

They have realised that there is a significant proportion of the UK population who have failed at life. People with poor education, dead end jobs, and limited means.

They are aggressively targeting these people, telling them that it's not their fault. It's the immigrants, the woke, the lgbtq, who are the cause of their misfortune.

With the fptp system, if you can get these people to vote for you then you may be able to get power.

The cynical part of me thinks that they will be delighted to get so many councils under Reform control. Not so that they can try to improve people's lives, but so that they can do massive damage. Damage that they can say is the fault of the Labour government.

In my area one of their candidates promised to fix all potholes, and go back to weekly bin collections. When they fail in this, they will simply blame central government, and tell their acolytes that voting in Reform in the GE will fix it. It's obvious but very hard to counter.

So you are saying that people who vote Reform are:

Lacking in intelligence (thick) and/or on benefits/low incomes feeling sorry for their lives with nothing else going for them?

Bit insulting isn’t it?

What about all the people that have just had enough of the state of the country they want change? Maybe they can live up to their promises, maybe they can’t like ALL politicians.

Normal working class British people are just maybe looking for a little bit of hope that it’s all not going down the bloody pan. You cannot let millions of people into the country every year it’s just not sustainable it’s ruining us, and quite frankly ; me not wanting undocumented male migrants all between the ages of 16 and 40 coming in their thousands every month makes me racist then so be it. That word has lost all meaning.

marshmallowmix · 04/05/2025 09:40

Labour and the conservatives have done zero to stop the boats…zilch!

Hence Reform’s popularity they will take action …no one else wants to at present.

“Smash the gangs” is laughable by Starmer he’s overseen the largest influx ever this year…and it’s dangerous never mind the financial expense …

CunningLinguist1 · 04/05/2025 09:41

Moveanymountain · 03/05/2025 04:16

Because people cannot stomach 500+ “migrants” coming to the UK illegally every day but getting food, housing, health care etc while citizens pay more and more tax for poorer services.

i know this is going to come across as a racist, hateful post but we are a small island and we cannot just keep endlessly shelling out for illegals.

that’s why right wing groups are gaining all over Europe .

Drinking the KoolAid then… and yes, you’re a racist buying a stack of populist soundbites w little foundation in truth.

bellsanddogwhistles · 04/05/2025 09:46

CrazyAboutFurBabies · 04/05/2025 09:39

So you are saying that people who vote Reform are:

Lacking in intelligence (thick) and/or on benefits/low incomes feeling sorry for their lives with nothing else going for them?

Bit insulting isn’t it?

What about all the people that have just had enough of the state of the country they want change? Maybe they can live up to their promises, maybe they can’t like ALL politicians.

Normal working class British people are just maybe looking for a little bit of hope that it’s all not going down the bloody pan. You cannot let millions of people into the country every year it’s just not sustainable it’s ruining us, and quite frankly ; me not wanting undocumented male migrants all between the ages of 16 and 40 coming in their thousands every month makes me racist then so be it. That word has lost all meaning.

They insulted UKIP as well, calling their Members "swivel-eyed loons" !

And guess what, UKIP survived !

Azdcgbjml · 04/05/2025 09:53

Idontsweat · 03/05/2025 16:14

I do not believe Trump is for "remigration". However he is all for deporting illegal migrants and all countries should be and most countries are. But with millions of people and possibly hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants in countries like USA and UK it's difficult to find all the illegal immigrants and deport them so governments have given up and they can't be arsed. Good on Trump for trying to protect his citizens and their borders. Even third world countries deport illegal migrants, but the lefties choose to single out Trump so that they can do what they like doing best-name calling.

Trump is cheerfully deporting and sending to foreign prisons anyone he doesn't like the look of with no legal process being followed. Is that what you want here?

Somerford · 04/05/2025 09:53

springbirdss · 04/05/2025 09:17

This is copy and pasted from SWVG, feel free to fact check:

Is the UK under more pressure from asylum seekers and refugees than other countries?

No it is not, in spite of the picture painted by some of our politicians and media.
Out of 28 member states in the EU, the UK ranks ninth in terms of numbers of applications. In 2015, the UK received just fewer than 40 thousand asylum applications. Germany had over 400 thousand, ten times as many.

(Germany still takes the most, followed by France, Spain and Italy I believe)

And because the UK gets relatively few asylum applicants, we host fewer refugees – less than 1% of the global total.

Edited

Less than 1% of the global total - why do you think we should be taking more than that? There are nearly 200 recognised countries in the world, we're 0.5% of the total countries.

Despite asylum seekers making up a small percentage of of population, in the space of a few years they've brought us the Manchester Arena bombing and the Southport murders. You may feel aghast at the apparent lack of compassion inherent in the shift towards Reform, but we've tried compassion. And they repaid us by raising their children to hate us so much that they dedicated their lives to killing us and our children. Add that to the terrorism, gang rapes, acid attacks, honour killings etc going on all over Europe...it shouldn't be a shock to anyone that people are voting for the only party willing to promise to put a stop to it. Labour will be dragged to the right on this issue for the next 3 years also which is a nice bonus before they head back into the wilderness for another 20 years.

hattie43 · 04/05/2025 09:55

Look at what Denmark has done . If labour or tories were serious they would have done the same. Existing parties do not want to address migration , they think platitudes of smash the gangs will work whilst every sane person laughs . There’s also a belief that the figures are fudged , the claims are going down , yes of course they are when you just grant asylum to take those people off the list .That’s why Reform got in , people hope it’s third time lucky .
i can’t understand why the left think insulting people is going to get them to change their mind on immigration. I’d love to see how many supporting mass immigration would pay extra tax to support them or open their doors to house them . It’s all very well shouting from the rooftops from your middle class enclaves when it doesn’t affect you but you love virtual signalling your support . Try imagining being having absolutely nothing , no money, no housing , no hope no jobs , a futile existence. The podcast trapped talks of the scandalous housing of people trapped in tenement flats with water pouring through the ceiling and walls covered in thick black mould and you see boatloads of young men put up in clean safe hotels . How would you feel . No wonder people are bloody angry .

bellsanddogwhistles · 04/05/2025 09:55

cherryade8 · 03/05/2025 07:11

But has Starmer 'smashed the gangs' yet?

He's raised taxes and done nothing about illegal immigration?

Labour voters are angry.

All voters are angry !

My local Reform group started with 15 members in a disused room above a pub a year ago.

Now we have had to move to a Social Club and we take over all the ground floor. In fact the organiser was concerned we might have to limit numbers due to Fire Regulations.

The last meeting was very energetic and we met our new candidates and made plans for canvassing and leafleting.

Result - Reform now have control of the local Council.

CrazyAboutFurBabies · 04/05/2025 09:57

CunningLinguist1 · 04/05/2025 09:41

Drinking the KoolAid then… and yes, you’re a racist buying a stack of populist soundbites w little foundation in truth.

Where are the untruths in what @Moveanymountain has said?

MasterBeth · 04/05/2025 09:59

OneAmberFinch · 04/05/2025 07:08

I have a general question to those participating in the thread who are determined to minimise every negative experience posters are reporting.

Are there any negative effects to the existing community (potential or actual) that you acknowledge? Or is immigration just an unmitigated good in your mind so the only possible reason anyone could complain is that they are evil racist scum?

Of course people interacting with other people can always have the potential to be a problem. New neighbours don't always understand each other from the start. It can take time for different communities to get on.

But... our country is in a mess. The rich are getting richer while ordinary people's wages have stagnated. Our towns and cities suffer from chronic under-investment in public services. Housing is expensive or unavailable. Life is very difficult for lots of people right now. This is not the fault of migration.

I completely understand that if you believe that incomers are being given opportunities or handouts that are unavailable to you, you will see it as unfair.

And, of course, if someone moves in next door to you and behaves in an antisocial way then of course that has a negative effect. But to blame their behaviour on their ethnicity is, bluntly, racist.

Someone earlier up the thread when I asked her about "purpose built asylum seeker accomodation" wouldn't share any examples she said she knew about (and said she had even been in). She did the classic conspiracy theory "do your own research" cliche). So I have.

My searching can't find ANY purpose-built asylum seeker accomodation in the UK. There was the Bibby barge that was shut down because it became dangerous. There were plans for two military bases to be taken over and plans to rent out a student block in Huddersfield (student rooms are literally not deemed large enough for normal working people to live in). No purpose-built accomodation, as far as I can see. (Feel free to show me I'm wrong.)

It's the same with "nice hotels". Congratulations if you've found a counter- example. But mostly, asylum seekers have been stuffed into the cheapest, shittiest places that can be found. Legally, they are not allowed to work. They are given £49 a week to survive on: www.gov.uk/asylum-support/what-youll-get It's just not the typical experience of an asylum-seeker to be swanning around the Crowne Plaza swimming pool living a life of luxury.

So anecdotes and myths. All this "you can't even celebrate Christmas any more in case you offend them" bullshit. And it's fed by people who should and do know better.

Don't forget, the same people who told you that the EU/Brussels was the cause of all these problems is now telling you that immigration is the cause of all these problems.

Farage is a grifter, a racist, a public school banker and a man of huge wealth who has no idea how ordinary working class people live. His Brexit has made a huge amount of money for him and his banker friends off the back of the huge hit to our economy - billions and billions of pounds every year! And he dares blame migrants in small boats for our problems! It's shocking scapegoating of vulnerable people.

ComeAsYouAreAsAFriend · 04/05/2025 10:01

hattie43 · 04/05/2025 09:55

Look at what Denmark has done . If labour or tories were serious they would have done the same. Existing parties do not want to address migration , they think platitudes of smash the gangs will work whilst every sane person laughs . There’s also a belief that the figures are fudged , the claims are going down , yes of course they are when you just grant asylum to take those people off the list .That’s why Reform got in , people hope it’s third time lucky .
i can’t understand why the left think insulting people is going to get them to change their mind on immigration. I’d love to see how many supporting mass immigration would pay extra tax to support them or open their doors to house them . It’s all very well shouting from the rooftops from your middle class enclaves when it doesn’t affect you but you love virtual signalling your support . Try imagining being having absolutely nothing , no money, no housing , no hope no jobs , a futile existence. The podcast trapped talks of the scandalous housing of people trapped in tenement flats with water pouring through the ceiling and walls covered in thick black mould and you see boatloads of young men put up in clean safe hotels . How would you feel . No wonder people are bloody angry .

Try imagining being having absolutely nothing , no money, no housing , no hope no jobs , a futile existence.

Who is to blame for this futile existence? Absolutely be angry but make sure your anger is directed at the right issue. Whose fault is it that people have no jobs? Why are they unemployable? What has happened in their lives that has got them to this point? Where and how have they been failed? Is it as simple as solving the immigration problem or maybe is it more complex than that? Also really delve in and see if reform have the policies to address and change any of this

Allergictoironing · 04/05/2025 10:01

I would quite like to see immigration reduced to a) the potentially economically active or b) genuine asylum seeker. However I still haven't seen a proposal by Reform of how they will do this, apart from some (hopefully facetious) comments about letting them all drown in the Channel.

The Conservatives were slated because despite saying they would reduce illegal immigration they didn't, and now Labour are being condemned for "Smash the Gangs" as being just a soundbite. Can we please have something concrete, or at least a suggestion of a plan, that Reform have thoughts on how to do this in a humane manner?

MasterBeth · 04/05/2025 10:03

Somerford · 04/05/2025 09:53

Less than 1% of the global total - why do you think we should be taking more than that? There are nearly 200 recognised countries in the world, we're 0.5% of the total countries.

Despite asylum seekers making up a small percentage of of population, in the space of a few years they've brought us the Manchester Arena bombing and the Southport murders. You may feel aghast at the apparent lack of compassion inherent in the shift towards Reform, but we've tried compassion. And they repaid us by raising their children to hate us so much that they dedicated their lives to killing us and our children. Add that to the terrorism, gang rapes, acid attacks, honour killings etc going on all over Europe...it shouldn't be a shock to anyone that people are voting for the only party willing to promise to put a stop to it. Labour will be dragged to the right on this issue for the next 3 years also which is a nice bonus before they head back into the wilderness for another 20 years.

Despite asylum seekers making up a small percentage of of population, in the space of a few years they've brought us the Manchester Arena bombing and the Southport murders.

There you go, scapegoating, myths and lies.

The Southport murderer was a British citizen, born in Cardiff.

EasternStandard · 04/05/2025 10:05

MasterBeth · 04/05/2025 09:59

Of course people interacting with other people can always have the potential to be a problem. New neighbours don't always understand each other from the start. It can take time for different communities to get on.

But... our country is in a mess. The rich are getting richer while ordinary people's wages have stagnated. Our towns and cities suffer from chronic under-investment in public services. Housing is expensive or unavailable. Life is very difficult for lots of people right now. This is not the fault of migration.

I completely understand that if you believe that incomers are being given opportunities or handouts that are unavailable to you, you will see it as unfair.

And, of course, if someone moves in next door to you and behaves in an antisocial way then of course that has a negative effect. But to blame their behaviour on their ethnicity is, bluntly, racist.

Someone earlier up the thread when I asked her about "purpose built asylum seeker accomodation" wouldn't share any examples she said she knew about (and said she had even been in). She did the classic conspiracy theory "do your own research" cliche). So I have.

My searching can't find ANY purpose-built asylum seeker accomodation in the UK. There was the Bibby barge that was shut down because it became dangerous. There were plans for two military bases to be taken over and plans to rent out a student block in Huddersfield (student rooms are literally not deemed large enough for normal working people to live in). No purpose-built accomodation, as far as I can see. (Feel free to show me I'm wrong.)

It's the same with "nice hotels". Congratulations if you've found a counter- example. But mostly, asylum seekers have been stuffed into the cheapest, shittiest places that can be found. Legally, they are not allowed to work. They are given £49 a week to survive on: www.gov.uk/asylum-support/what-youll-get It's just not the typical experience of an asylum-seeker to be swanning around the Crowne Plaza swimming pool living a life of luxury.

So anecdotes and myths. All this "you can't even celebrate Christmas any more in case you offend them" bullshit. And it's fed by people who should and do know better.

Don't forget, the same people who told you that the EU/Brussels was the cause of all these problems is now telling you that immigration is the cause of all these problems.

Farage is a grifter, a racist, a public school banker and a man of huge wealth who has no idea how ordinary working class people live. His Brexit has made a huge amount of money for him and his banker friends off the back of the huge hit to our economy - billions and billions of pounds every year! And he dares blame migrants in small boats for our problems! It's shocking scapegoating of vulnerable people.

The idea that we don’t spend much pp isn’t shown in figures. Were higher pp than all G7 countries by 2.5 times.

Whether it’s built for accommodation or hotels it’s a higher cost pp than alternatives elsewhere.

On any downsides at all, do you think borders should exist or should there be the ability to live anywhere you like?

Somerford · 04/05/2025 10:07

MasterBeth · 04/05/2025 10:03

Despite asylum seekers making up a small percentage of of population, in the space of a few years they've brought us the Manchester Arena bombing and the Southport murders.

There you go, scapegoating, myths and lies.

The Southport murderer was a British citizen, born in Cardiff.

Edited

And he was the child of asylum seekers. Just like the Manchester Arena bomber who blew himself up to murder as many children as possible, while his brother continues to behave like a feral animal.to this day.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread