Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling with son's girlfriends personality

944 replies

Bluebrownies · 10/02/2025 23:28

Hi all, so my son is 23, in August he set off to go travelling, he met a girl on the trip and they are now dating. He came home last Monday, just for 3 weeks, then they are going to her parents for 3 weeks before setting off around Europe. We live in London so they are staying with us which is great as we missed him a lot, plus they are keeping themselves busy with museums/theatre etc.
She lives abroad and a lot more rural so that will be a nice change of pace for them when they stop with her family.
The issue is I'm really struggling with his girlfriend's personality, she is respectful but I find her quite "a lot". She is very confident, I thought it might be a front as she was nervous but I'm now thinking she is just naturally very self-assured. Obviously there is nothing wrong with confidence but I've also found her to be very judgemental, she has said multiple times that brits are all so fat (as someone with a higher BMI I feel like this is targeted) and she has said several times British girls are ugly, in front of my impressionable teen girls (13 and 16). She usually follows with "not you guys but generally". I also feel like she is just overly opinionated in general, be it the food I cook, what I'm drinking etc. she has something to say about everything.
We also seem to be having a massive PDA issue, I know this is my son too but he has never been like this before, I feel like they are always touching in some way, she constantly plays with his hair or his hands, they kiss all the time, be it pecks or longer kisses it seems to be every 5 minutes, we went out to the pub for rugby on Saturday and despite their being plenty of seats she insisted on sitting on his lap, even feeding him food off her plate like he was a toddler. It all just makes me little uncomfortable, nothing against hand holding, odd kiss here and there but it's relentless, even when I'm trying to talk to them.
There are other things I dislike but I know aren't really any of my business (her dress sense is very revealing for one).

I'm finding it quite draining as obviously she is always with my son and I don't enjoy her presence so I almost avoid them both. I was so looking forward to having him home but now I'm looking forward to them going). My husband thinks it's just cultural and I will learn to love her but AIBU to feel like this because of these things?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BigDahliaFan · 11/02/2025 10:20

It's 3 weeks, put up with it. Or suggest they go visit Auntie x in Rye or whatever for the weekend. Or you go away for the weekend.

The one bit I think is anything other that a bit annoying is that you aren't getting any time alone with your son. Can you find a way to have a morning with him alone and a catch up?

Mrsdyna · 11/02/2025 10:23

Manners exist to make others feel more comfortable and at ease. She clearly was not brought up very well. Someone who wants to make others feel uncomfortable or insecure is not a very nice person.

Frostynoman · 11/02/2025 10:23

Let’s hope it’s the confidence and naivety of youth in her delivery. She does have a point about the coffee - love an Italian coffee! It sounds like she’s experiencing a culture shock - lots of processed foods etc and perhaps she’s used to fresh cooking. She does sound rude about the fat and ugly comments but having described the lack of fresh ruffage and the coke, do you think she’s hit a nerve which rather shit delivery?

Radiatorvalves · 11/02/2025 10:23

Bluebrownies · 11/02/2025 01:54

I asked my husband to read some of the comments here and he feels like I have painted her badly. I don't think I have but he thinks I should clarify the "insults".

The critique on my food -

  1. I used a jar of pasta sauce to make Bolognese, she commented that it wasn't very nice and full of preservatives and "not really bolognese".
  2. I made Jacket potatoes and she commented 3 times "no vegetables"
  3. I had weetabix for breakfast and she said "no fruit, you should have some fruit"
Critique on drinks -
  1. Several times saying we all drink so much cola then listing how unhealthy it is
  2. She has said several times how much she doesn't like British coffee - almost everytime I drink it

The fat comment was first when I asked her what her perception of brits was and she said fat, don't dress well etc.

Then several times she's commented on how many fat people she has seen out and how so many brits are fat.

I don't think this changes anything but my husband does so I will give the extra context.

I’m afraid that I would agree with everything she said, although I wouldn’t say it to someone who was hosting me. I do think she sounds hard work though. Sorry OP.

Zanzara · 11/02/2025 10:29

Galdownunder · 11/02/2025 02:23

My husband is Portuguese so I visit there every 18ontjs or so. Most of the young women (under 30) are conventionally slim but the majority of older married women are grey and fat. Remind her of what she’ll look like thanks to her genetics 🤣

I was thinking that. At least if they stay together OP, one day she may turn overnight into a little fat mama with a flowery overall and Flyflots and you can chuckle maniacally up your sleeve! 😳😂

Redpeach · 11/02/2025 10:30

mikulkin · 11/02/2025 10:11

I am sorry I can see your husband's point of view. Yes, she sounds rude but I do think it is a bit cultural - southern europeans are much more open in expressing their opinions and given examples you quoted I have to say all her comments are valid, though I probably wouldn't have said them just thought about them.
Don't misunderstand me I do drink diet coke and use sometimes cans but all what you listed is pretty unhealthy and Italian coffee is much better than British one (I am not from Southern Europe by the way). Italians are very proud of their pasta, my Italian friend was horrified when my son poured ketchup on pasta so seeing bolognese from can is driving them mad.
I do understand it is annoying but perhaps if I was you I would explain to her that while you understand she might have valid comments you would prefer she doesn't express them as it hurts you.
I am not English though lived here for the past 20 years and when I saw first time jacket potato without any vegetables served it horrified me. I didn't say anything though.
When it comes to PDA it is as much her fault as your son's, so you have to take it with your son rather than her. My DS had a girlfriend and they constantly kissed and hugged when visiting us - I took him aside and said it makes us uncomfortable and they should stop, he did.

'Horrified'? Blimey! what vegetables should one be serving with baked potato?

Sickandtiredofthisbullshit · 11/02/2025 10:32

Ophy83 · 11/02/2025 09:39

Give her a bit of time, she may be being a bit "over-performative" at the moment to demonstrate to your ds that she is better than local competition..

It also sounds like she's in the early-20s stage of knowing better than anyone else and feeling the need to educate everyone on this. When my niece hit her early 20s she was constantly criticising her parents' food choices. It takes a level of maturity to keep those thoughts to yourself!

Lol! This is so true. I was probably insufferable at that age. Thought I had it all worked out

Cringe.

Happyhippos123 · 11/02/2025 10:36

Can you just tell her next time she makes a rude comment that it is rude - something on the lines of 'I'm sure you don't mean to be rude, but it does sound very rude when you criticise British coffee every day. I know that you don't like it, but I do, so please don't criticise it every morning'.

Same with commenting on people who are overweight 'I'm sure you don't mean to be rude or sound judgmental, but it does sound very rude when you talk about the size of people you see every time you are out. I'm a bit overweight and you make me feel very judged every time you do it, so please stop, there are so many more things to talk about'

And say it every single time, in a pleasant tone.

Happyhippos123 · 11/02/2025 10:37

And congrats on your patience so far - she sounds like a complete pain.

MxFlibble · 11/02/2025 10:38

Just because it's true, doesn't mean you have to say it - that's manners. I'm a bit surprised at the Portuguese family - my Portuguese friends are the best hosts I've ever met, they'd do anything for guests.

And I lived in Italy for a bit - their diet was also atrocious, just differently atrocious - the standard adult breakfast for people in my office was coffee/pick at a pastry and a cigarette (more smokers than I've seen in years). The son of one of my colleagues would only eat pasta with plain tomato sauce (he was 6) and it didn't even occur to her to serve him something else - if they came round, he'd just wait and eat when he got home.

She was astounded when we all went out for sushi, and I had my kids try stuff to see what they wanted to eat - she seemed to think it was normal for the kids to just eat something plain (a kind of version of everything beige, but Italian)

AlexP24 · 11/02/2025 10:46

The PDAs would upset me greatly. I would find that incredibly disrespectful. Is she staying in his room? I know I sound terribly old fashioned but I think that gives them the idea that anything goes, frankly. I would have to say to my son that I find a girl sitting on his lap and feeding him, the constant kissing, very poor taste in front of his mother. I can't imagine my son doing this and not saying anything to him. I think I'd just say to him 'stop fucking kissing, what's the matter with you - it's gross'. Can't you just be honest about that. Also, your husband is pretty out of order not understanding where you are coming from. At least it's cold at the moment - she sounds the sort of person who would wander around with a bikini on in hot weather...(the over confidence, the PDA's in front of you and his dad etc). Mention the PDA, then hope they break up soon...

MrsEG · 11/02/2025 10:46

Ophy83 · 11/02/2025 09:39

Give her a bit of time, she may be being a bit "over-performative" at the moment to demonstrate to your ds that she is better than local competition..

It also sounds like she's in the early-20s stage of knowing better than anyone else and feeling the need to educate everyone on this. When my niece hit her early 20s she was constantly criticising her parents' food choices. It takes a level of maturity to keep those thoughts to yourself!

I totally agree with this OP. Also, I’m guessing they haven’t been together long at all if they met travelling so they’re in the throes of young love / early romance.
You’ve also mentioned she’s polite, intelligent, etc - as such I’m tempted to agree with your husband and just keep the peace for the short time they’re with you. They could be short lived, or this girl could become your DIL and maybe you’ll all laugh about this first meeting in years to come (my MIL still gives me grief about me saying drinking tea is disgusting on our first meet!)

Duckyfondant · 11/02/2025 10:48

I think any stranger staying in your house for 3 weeks would wind you up, and likewise for her. She doesn't sound that bad to me. I quite like bluntness though.
I agree with your husband generally. You'll grow to like her over time.

MercurialButton · 11/02/2025 10:48

We had a horrible overstaying houseguest … a man. In my opinion, he thought I was catering for him, when in fact, I was making meals for my family and he was just there. He was opposite - HE didn’t like celery, fruit/veg or rabbit food (salad). Etc
He wanted a roast and potatoes all the time.

There were 2 things I did that made me feel better.

  1. when he complained during food prep, the he didn’t like celery: “I’m making my meals, my way. Happy for you to make your own meals - but after I serve my family. “
  2. When he mouthed off about stuff mainly women … I would snap my fingers and this got attention. I’d say or “” tone it down” or “we keep it positive in our house”. (My kids loved the finger snaps followed by shade)

I felt like I was taking charge. And he got the messsge.

If she does cook … you can watch and tell her off for scratching your no stick, abusing your knives, and not cleaning her mess.

Ponoka7 · 11/02/2025 10:48

washerr · 11/02/2025 08:53

It's not 'manners' though, it's spinelessness, meekness and people pleasing. Absolute lack of character. That's definitely not a good thing, in case I wasn't clear.

How many times I read on here: my MIL gifts me men's size XXL boxers for the past 15 Xmas, I'm a woman size 10, I just smile, thank and wave. OR: I visited my friend and was offered coffee, I don't like coffee, but she was out of tea and insisted we'd have a cup of coffee, so I accepted it, smile, grin&bear it and was sick afterwards. Etc etc etc. So many examples

That's not 'manners', that's stupidity. Same here, OP thinks the girlfriend is a rude cow. And seethes quietly, complaining here, to her husband, but not saying a word to her or the son. Why? Because you're ' a gracious host and don't want to alienate your son'? No, it's because you don't have the balls. Just own it.

No Italian mother would sit meekly in her own house being attacked by some girl, she'd give it to her both barrels, loudly and clearly, the girl would run bawling. And no good Italian son would sit quietly whilst his girlfriend is thrashing her mother.

I'm Eastern European, only the Dutch rival us in the directness stakes. I'd tell her straight in her face, to pack in the lap-sitting and munching each others faces off, we're not a brothel or a porn set, we have our rooms for that, no one ones to see their raging hormones at the breakfast table.

As for fat Brits and shit food, well that's the honest truth. It's not 'Italians', everyone in Europe think that. And why? Because it's the truth. I couldn't with good concience deny it, so I wouldn't call her out on it. Brits are fat, not good looking (being polite) and the food is shit. Jar sauce, countless cokes and instant coffee. And for an Italian, no less? That's just abysmal. But shit, I'm as blunt and ballsy as they come, but I wouldn't cook pasta for an Italian, that's something, hats off to you for that, OP.

And again, she's factually completely correct in all her assertions, but if you don't like it, just give it to her straight: we don't comment about people's appearances in this house, it's rude to critique host's country in this way over here, my health, food and weight is not your businesss, so STFU.

God help you OP, if the next girlfriend will be Dutch of EE. Also tall, slim and beautiful, but far more opinionated and not afraid to say it. At all. You'll kill yourself if you keep quiet all the time, this way.

Haha you really made me laugh. I bet you'd be fun company. Not sarcastic, I mean it !

Have you been to Liverpool on a night out? You'll see some of the most beautiful girls in the world and nearly all will be fine weight wise.
I don't know were you are all from, but it's ridiculous to say people from the UK are ugly. I don't know who people are classing as British, we are mostly mongrals, especially in Liverpool or any major port. As for dressing badly, women from the UK don't see the need to dress up like dollies, or over sexualise themselves. I have a lot of friends from around the world and they like the casual vibe in the UK. A lot of my African friends like not having to wear wigs and be natural. It's ironic that in Nigeria a lot of women are judged if they have natural close cuts, but can work anywhere here and not be pulled up on it. There's issues with sexism across Italy and France, which means issues with DV.
As for Italians being one people, ask the Southern Italians why the North put egg in their pasta and they'll tell you it's because they can't cook. It's easy to cook vegan pasta recipes. I had an Italian Step Granddad, he was one of the beautifully mannered, gentle Italians, but he wasn't conventually attractive, was quite short and stocky. They come in all shapes and sizes, as you will see on the Italian gangster films.

Redpeach · 11/02/2025 10:53

I wonder what her mum.is like

luckylavender · 11/02/2025 10:53

She sounds challenging. However based on my experience. I think you were courting trouble using a jar of bolognese. I wouldn't be cooking anything Italian for an Italian.

TunipTheVegimal24 · 11/02/2025 10:57

It'll pass. My poor parents had to put up with some right dickheads when I was in my teens and early 20s x

TheCheeseTax · 11/02/2025 10:59

Next time she says something out the box, look her in the eye and say "stop it".

Then leave the room. Next time you see her, be normal.

She's an adult. She is being superior, remind her who the elder is here.

JandamiHash · 11/02/2025 11:01

SchoolDilemma17 · 11/02/2025 09:16

Maybe the overweight MIL who eats junk food and drinks cola and has never even been to Italy is intimidated by a healthy, young, and beautiful, well traveled Italian.

as you said most judgemental people are insecure.

So weird how many people are jumping to defend a nasty house guest.

ProfessionalPirate · 11/02/2025 11:01

BreezyScroller · 11/02/2025 10:13

do you take every comment as personally?

That's a lot of anger towards something that wasn't adressed to you, that you haven't heard directly, from someone you don't know and will likely never meet in your life 😂

Is this your first time on an internet forum?

JandamiHash · 11/02/2025 11:02

TheyAreNotAngelsTheyDontCareAtAll · 11/02/2025 09:19

Hear, hear!
Don't judge yet another GF, or at least give the son a set of parameters that are acceptable in a GF!
I read on MN last year that parents are supposed to be the welcoming committee, not the interview panel.

A welcoming committee wouldn’t stand for rudeness and xenophobia

HRHTheQueenMuffinTop · 11/02/2025 11:04

MxFlibble · 11/02/2025 10:38

Just because it's true, doesn't mean you have to say it - that's manners. I'm a bit surprised at the Portuguese family - my Portuguese friends are the best hosts I've ever met, they'd do anything for guests.

And I lived in Italy for a bit - their diet was also atrocious, just differently atrocious - the standard adult breakfast for people in my office was coffee/pick at a pastry and a cigarette (more smokers than I've seen in years). The son of one of my colleagues would only eat pasta with plain tomato sauce (he was 6) and it didn't even occur to her to serve him something else - if they came round, he'd just wait and eat when he got home.

She was astounded when we all went out for sushi, and I had my kids try stuff to see what they wanted to eat - she seemed to think it was normal for the kids to just eat something plain (a kind of version of everything beige, but Italian)

Just to add, I certainly thought I knew it all when i was that age. My phase of being insufferable lasted a good few years sadly, not least because i worked for a very long time abroad in 7 different countries so thought I was a bit of all that. (Spoiler- I wasn't). Grin

I am obsessed with food though and one of my favourite downtimes is watching youtube videos- often about what people from all over the world eat. I have a couple of favourite youtubers who live in the US but when they go home to their families in Italy they will do vlogs showing what they ate for a week etc. It's glorious food, cooked gloriously, but mostly quite samey. Pasta in a tomato based sauce in various ways, but ultimately all the same. Courgettes, aubergine, legumes etc seafood all feature and it all looks amazing, but there is actually not a great deal of true variety.Do you want your fried courgettes with pasta or with cheese and bread? I am not actually from the UK (Brought up in New Zealand, but with English and Eastern European background) and I think that one of the wonderful things about British / Anglo countries is how we have embraced the foods of other countries. We are not particularly parochial in that sense,I believe.

I expect the OP's guest is suffering from a bit of culture shock. As well as suffering from a case of the aged 20s. We all mostly get through it I think. But I do think a quiet word about not talking about how British people are all ugly would be a good start. That's very seriously rude.

Crazycatlady79 · 11/02/2025 11:05

Bluebrownies · 11/02/2025 00:51

Really struggling as my husband is now fully defending her. I just suggested we should talk to her tomorrow about the fat/ugly comments and he got very very defensive of her saying "There are more fat people in the UK, that's just true, and no it's not healthy" he then basically went off on a rant about how he thinks it's fine for her to point that out and he agrees with her that there are too many fat people. He then said "who cares if she thinks brits are ugly, she's the one dating a brit so she can't think we are that bad".

Does your husband fancy her?!

Thelnebriati · 11/02/2025 11:06

She sounds desperately insecure, devaluing everyone your son is connected to, and marking her territory. I'd be disappointed if my son was dating someone this rude.