Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hubs won't get the snip!!

1000 replies

241719robs · 13/01/2025 09:20

Am I being unreasonable that my hubby wont even consider getting the snip? He just replies with 'maybe one day'.

We have children already and I am 99% DONE. My body has been through enough and mentally Im burnt out. After contraception for years, pregnancy, birth, and breastfeeding I dont want to go back on contraception or risk condoms etc. I know vasectomies are not 100% but better than me having to go through invasive procedures again. Im also late for my period and after 2 negative pregnancy tests Ive explained how unfair it is for me to be worrying about this every month. He basically ignored me as he knew what I was getting at.

Am I being a b*tch? Hes not had to go through anything physically and its not like I’m asking him to chop his bits off 🥲

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Fluufer · 13/01/2025 10:33

Pamelaaaaarrr · 13/01/2025 10:31

Accidental pregnancy is not nearly as common as people think, more likely it's down to user error. I've had 30 years using either the pill or condoms and never had an accidental pregnancy. I've had three children and got pregnant on the first month of 'trying' so clearly no issue with fertility, but never had a whoops moment. I literally have never worried about get pregnant.

Stupid thing to say. "User error" is the "accident". That's why there is typical use and perfect use.

Grammarnut · 13/01/2025 10:34

Sdpbody · 13/01/2025 10:33

That is simply not true.

1/100 men experience pain at the 3 month point (the point in which pain becomes chronic).

Within the 1% of men, in 9/10 men, a reversal of the procedure cures the pain. So 0.001 of men have pain at the 1 year mark after having a vasectomy.

In 2022/23, 10,710 men had a vasectomy, meaning 0.1071% of men in that year felt pain at the 1 year mark.... So not even a whole man.

Do not spread misinformation.

My ex did have some pain. I was pretty unsympathetic as he had the snip when I had wanted more children.

Pamelaaaaarrr · 13/01/2025 10:36

Fluufer · 13/01/2025 10:33

Stupid thing to say. "User error" is the "accident". That's why there is typical use and perfect use.

Well duh, that's what I mean.

Use it properly, you won't get pregnant.

The accidents are because of user error, not contraceptive failure.

Nobody should be using contraceptive 'typically' if they don't want to get pregnant.

Charcol · 13/01/2025 10:36

Speaking from a Male point of view.. I asked the Mrs to use contraceptions after 3 kids, she refused and had many reasons for doing so. Some i didnt agree with but its her body.
So i took the decision to do the snip, she wasnt fully on board with that either. She considered it extreme. But I knew i didnt want anymore and went and did it. We about 6 months on from it now, and everyones happy.

Someone just has to be the bigger person and take a stand. But defo communicate rather than avoid the topic!
To not use protection, is a plan to have more kids! (pullout game isnt 100% - trust me, i know!)

Alondra · 13/01/2025 10:36

241719robs · 13/01/2025 09:25

@boulevardofbrokendreamss great response. Im worried if I did this our relationship would dwindle

Your relationship is not so great if your husband won't take the snip when your body and mental health won't take more contraceptives.

He needs to take responsibility for stopping a new pregnancy when you've done it for years. Some men have mental blocks with it comes to vasectomies - they see it as part of their manhood, which is beyond ridiculous in this day and age.

I'd have a calm conversation with your DH saying clearly you'll no longer take contraception or accept condoms. Put the pressure on him. Don't get into the blame game he'll try to put on you, just calmly say : "My body can't longer continue what I've doing to it for many years" and walk away.

If he's a good husband caring for you, he'll come around to discuss it. If he's an arsehole only caring about himself, you have a bigger problem than just a vasectomy.

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 10:37

Elyat · 13/01/2025 10:16

I used to feel more strongly about this, but am now in a position where my DH doesn't want to get a vasectomy. And I understand, he doesn't want surgery and it would not be right to force it either through demanding or through giving him a hard time until he capitulates - that's not real consent. And his bodily autonomy is as important as mine.

Equally I didn't want to take hormones anymore and while of course I would use condoms, I don't like the feel of them.

So for the last 5 years we've used natural family planning. Both our kids we got pregnant first month of trying so we're definitely very fertile. But there's not been a single scare in 5 years. It's also been really empowering for me to understand my body better. I now have years of my menstrual cycle tracked which is useful data as I approach menopause and things start changing. I track via an app called 'Read your body' which costs £10-£15 or so per year.

The percentage success rates of natural family planning are hard to quantify as they rely on you understanding things and taking a little time to track things. If you don't do that properly then the effectiveness will of course reduce. I will say we have always erred very strongly on the side of caution, if I'm not totally sure, he won't finish during intercourse. And it involves full trust between us of course. It's been positive for our sex life too, we're more creative, and when we can freely have sex which is more of the month than not, it's more enjoyable.

Just thought I'd share this experience because it doesn't have to be reduced to vasectomy or hormones only which is kind of a false dichotomy that can really end up being tough on relationships.

Edited to add, it also feels like a joint project - DH understands my body better and we are careful and risk averse together. So it's also an option that hasn't felt like all the work or responsibility is on me.

Edited

You're still taking a big risk of pregnancy though. Personally, I wouldn't be happy to roll the dice like you are doing. I don't think this is a reasonable alternative to a vasectomy for a couple that definitely does not want to get pregnant.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/01/2025 10:37

Fuhjutvb · 13/01/2025 09:22

You have zero input when it comes to someone elses body.

So why is it OK for him to disengage from the issue and expect OP to take responsibility ? What about her body ?

SleeplikeababyTonight · 13/01/2025 10:37

Pamelaaaaarrr · 13/01/2025 10:28

You can't get full enjoyment it on birth control? I can understand not wanting to take birth control but can't see how it would stop full enjoyment.

I am mid40s and take the mini-pill, I love it for a variety of reasons - not least because it completely stops my periods, you'd have to prize it from cold dead heads before I'd give it up.

Hormones for a lot of women can kill their sex drive, and cause a whole host of unpleasant side effects.

JennyTals · 13/01/2025 10:37

NorthernGirl1981 · 13/01/2025 09:44

YANBU at all.

After my second baby I asked DH to get the snip and he kept saying no and played deaf to all of my reasons. I knew he didn’t want any more children either, he was just being a wuss about having a minor procedure.

During this time we were using condoms and I was always worried about falling pregnant but for some reason he didn’t have the same worry. I genuinely think that some men don’t take the issue of contraception seriously enough and think “it won’t happen to me” when it comes to accidental pregnancies or they think we’ll just get a termination and it will be as simple as that.

After about 6 months of having the conversation and getting the same response I decided to change tactic…

I didn’t mention it for months on end and then I decided to tell him that after doing lots of thinking I wanted us to consider having a third baby (a lie, obviously). I said that he can’t be fully against the idea as he was happy to rely on condoms and because didn’t want to commit to a vasectomy, so maybe we should actively TTC and listed all the reasons why I thought having a third baby would be so wonderful. He was horrified at this suggestion. I kept raising the topic about all the benefits of having another baby and how it wouldn’t be the end of the world if I did accidentally fall pregnant because another baby would be such a lovely addition to the family. As I made him really believe I wanted another baby he probably started to have images of me poking needles through the condoms and he booked himself an appointment at the clinic very, very quickly.

Maybe it was blackmail and manipulation, I’m sure I will be accused of doing that.

Some people will say a woman should just tell the guy she wont have sex with him anymore as she doesn’t want to risk pregnancy,” but that could be classed as just another form of blackmail or manipulation.

Yes, I understand it’s their body and they shouldn’t be forced to have a medical procedure etc etc but men who are happy for their partner to carry all the burden of contraception when we are the ones who are generally fucked if an accidental pregnancy occurs are pretty shitty. Men like this are selfish and they need to stand up and play their part.

Prior to having these discussions with my husband I’d gone through YEARS of awful contraceptive issues, two high risk pregnancies and 6 years of breastfeeding. I was DONE!

Men who won’t have vasectomies, which are simple procedures that take 5 minutes to carry out, are either selfish, scared or don’t want to commit to the idea of never being able to father another baby in case they meet someone else.

Im sure many won’t agree with my actions or opinions but men who refuse to do this and expect the woman to take all the risks with contraception side effects and deal with any accidental pregnancies absolutely infuriate me.

I think that the fact women have to resort to blackmail and ultimatums in order to get the man to take some responsibility, says more about the males of the species than it does the females.

How can you actually live and respect him now tho ? Now you know that he thought you’d dearly want another baby and went and had the snip to make sure that didn’t happen, thinking he’s doing that against your wishes

and he wouldn’t have the snip when you simply wanted more protection from the risk of pregnancy/termination

i just wouldn’t be able to respect him let alone love him
after his treated you so selfishly
what a prick he is

Caerulea · 13/01/2025 10:37

NorthernGirl1981 · 13/01/2025 10:05

I think a huge amount of men would change their mind if abstinence was put in place so this is probably the most effective way!

However, all that does is reinforce the selfishness of men: they will have the procedure to have their sexual needs met, but they won’t do it out of respect for their partner.

This seems depressingly true in a lot of these cases, it's really awful when you think about it. What shitty, shallow creatures.

Schleep · 13/01/2025 10:37

You can only control your body.
Which includes not having sex if you have contraceptive concerns.

You need to make it clear that it's his choice whether to have a vasectomy - but you are no longer willing to take the stress and risk of contraception so unless he does, sex is off the cards.

WomenInConstruction · 13/01/2025 10:37

The problem is that men take recreational sex for granted.

Before the days of the pill and durex etc... there were condoms made of goat guts or whatever - mm thick not micro mm, you had to wash and reuse like a mooncup! They were issued to soldiers and counted in the weight of their pack!

It was better understood that if you had sex, you might get a baby and preventing that baby took a lot more effort for both the man and the woman... The men would have to get condoms at the barbers, there was a time when women couldn't even buy them, it was a man's job!

So it was far less taken for granted that it's her problem to solve.

Now it's flipped and some men have gone too far, mentally washed their hands of it and still expect sex on tap.

He needs a history lesson and a reality check.

And if you don't want sex because you're sick of contraception and pregnancy that wrecks your body, that's not manipulation because that's not your motive. It's self protection!

AnonymousBleep · 13/01/2025 10:39

Fluufer · 13/01/2025 10:33

Stupid thing to say. "User error" is the "accident". That's why there is typical use and perfect use.

Exactly. I had a condom fail - obviously no idea whether it was user error or the condom not working correctly, the only reason I knew there'd been any kind of fail was because I was pregnant!

Sheaintheavyshesmymother · 13/01/2025 10:40

obsessedwithfreshbread · 13/01/2025 09:41

But what if he wants a second family with a woman that doesn't use sex as a bargaining tool?

Refusing to risk pregnancy after putting body through multiple pregnancies = “Using sex as a bargaining tool” 🤣

Blanketpolicy · 13/01/2025 10:41

Sit down and have an open discussion on both your concerns and contraceptive options and what you both agree on. Vasectomy is an option he should at least agree to explore/research (by himself), but if after researching he decides he still doesn't want to, for whatever reason, that needs to be respected.

You don't get to pull the "I went through hormonal contraception/pregnancy/birth card", as you freely made those choices.

Think of the problem you are trying to solve together - would condoms and one of cycle tracking/cap/diaphragm/spermacide to give double protection and not require invasive surgery be amenable to both of you?

Juiceinacup · 13/01/2025 10:41

Bloody hell have we gone back to the pre contraceptive times where men were entitled to their conjugal rights and women weren’t allowed to say no even after 7 or 8 children. Luckily it’s now recognised women do not owe men sex ever, saying no to sex ( for whatever reason) is perfectly justified are PP’s who trot out the “ it’s his body his choice” rhetoric not aware that it is also OP’s “ it’s her body it’s her choice”. There is a word for sex that women feel unable to say no to ( for whatever reason and fear of pregnancy is a big reason in my view). Condoms are all very well but what if something goes wrong, again it’s on the woman to source and take the MAP or if a pregnancy where to occur, consider having a termination or having an unplanned child ( both difficult situations that the woman never wanted to find herself in). If my DH couldn’t understand all this I would be considering my marriage, and the thought of him keeping his options open just in case, would be a major part of that consideration.

ShinyShona · 13/01/2025 10:43

@241719robs His body, his choice.

Crazycatlady79 · 13/01/2025 10:44

Does hubs yearn for more bubs? 🤔🙃

SleeplikeababyTonight · 13/01/2025 10:45

Caerulea · 13/01/2025 10:37

This seems depressingly true in a lot of these cases, it's really awful when you think about it. What shitty, shallow creatures.

It is absolutely disgusting, and a real man cares, and will do the lowest risk most logical thing for his partner. Any man who suggests female sterilisation is not a man, but a pathetic, selfish and ignorant human being. I could not have sex with a man that suggested this. The latter would be a major turn off, so there would no longer be an issue, we wouldn't be together; pregnancy solution found!

CandidRaven · 13/01/2025 10:45

I have 4 children and when I got pregnant with my 4th we discussed vasectomy but my husband was very nervous of having it done because he'd seen horror stories, so I took it upon myself to be sterilised during my c-section instead as I was already having surgery and it only added 5 minutes onto it, i didn't want to be pregnant again so I took control of it so now I know I won't be and I don't have to pressure my husband to do something he was too nervous about and ultimately would likely end up with us having a 5th child which I really didn't want

SleeplikeababyTonight · 13/01/2025 10:45

ShinyShona · 13/01/2025 10:43

@241719robs His body, his choice.

Her body, her choice.

WomenInConstruction · 13/01/2025 10:46

ShinyShona · 13/01/2025 10:43

@241719robs His body, his choice.

Ditto for her.

So stalemate.

So a conversation might be worth having, perhaps he should at least consider a discussion.

Otherwise their joint life cannot be joint in this department anymore.

crumpet · 13/01/2025 10:47

Soontobe60 · 13/01/2025 09:30

What’s with the threat of withholding sex as a way of getting someone to do something to their body that they don't want to do? “get the snip and I’ll let you shag me” isn't the persuasive argument people seem to think it is. In fact, it could be seen as coercive and controlling behaviour!

But why should the op put herself at risk of pregnancy? She is entitled to not have sex. To suggest otherwise is coercion.

NorthernGirl1981 · 13/01/2025 10:48

JennyTals · 13/01/2025 10:37

How can you actually live and respect him now tho ? Now you know that he thought you’d dearly want another baby and went and had the snip to make sure that didn’t happen, thinking he’s doing that against your wishes

and he wouldn’t have the snip when you simply wanted more protection from the risk of pregnancy/termination

i just wouldn’t be able to respect him let alone love him
after his treated you so selfishly
what a prick he is

He didn’t go off and have it done behind my back!

After months of me talking about having another baby (pretending I wanted one) we sat down together and he explained that me making him think about having another baby only made him realise how much he didn’t want another and he said it also made him see how much he didn’t want to risk a pregnancy. I told him I understood why he felt like that and he said that perhaps getting a vasectomy was the best option. I nodded along and told him I respected his feelings on the matter and that if he really didn’t want another baby then I would support him in his decision to be sterilised.

Of course I was annoyed with him for not going ahead and doing it when I had initially asked him, but like I said, sometimes men bury their hands in the sand about such matters, and if my approach was enough to make him think about the reality of having another baby and result in him having a vasectomy, then I was happy enough with that.

MsPossibly · 13/01/2025 10:48

This "withholding" stuff is nonsese - it's about sharing a job over the course of a marriage. She's done it up until now, and it's his turn to take over the responsibilty from here on.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.