Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel Christmas unless I'm given a present?

1000 replies

Grinch123 · 09/12/2024 16:41

It's a long one! I've name changed.

Backstory ~

Abusive upbringing. I'm the oldest sibling and always kind of looked after everyone, including parents who both have mental health issues. Parents, and 2 siblings (DSis1 and DB) have never worked and claimed benefits. 1 sibling (DSis2) is on minimum wage. I've worked my way up and am on a nice salary well into 6 figures.

Christmas was shit growing up, no money and lots of manipulation and drama. When I moved out I started hosting everyone and trying to recreate those amazing Christmases in movies. Lots of food, tree heaving with gifts, overflowing stockings. Family always seem happy and have a ball, though there are always digs about my salary and how I could do more - I cave and each year it gets bigger and better. No one contributes at all (I haven't asked, they haven't offered).

Family are shit with my feelings or acknowledging birthdays etc. I'm aware money is ridiculously tight for them all, however I'm talking completely ignored my graduation (first one in my family), I didn't even get a text/card for my 30th. I go all out for them, and have always 'forgiven' anything hurtful based on the fact we've been through a lot and I want to treat them and put effort into having relationships. I also feel guilty that I'm financially secure, and they are not - they don't want budgeting advice etc (fair enough!) but I do help them out with money fairly often.

The issue, or more like the straw that broke this camels back:

Every year I buy loads of gifts for under the tree - everything anyone asks for, plus lots I research and find that I think they'll like - my point is, it's not just money I'm throwing at it! Everyone also buys each other one small gift, a token really. Something like a box of chocolates. I love those moments of opening gifts together, although I have far less than the others! But it's so much fun and I work so hard to try and get things everyone will love.

This year, DB has announced in the family WhatsApp that we're doing Secret Santa for the adults in the family, so we don't have to buy gifts for each other. He (and everyone) knows I'm done with my shopping and everything they've asked me for is wrapped and under the tree already. He's included an uncle I have never met - pretty sure he has me because this weekend my gift arrived in an unmarked Amazon box (so took me a good few days to figure out who had sent me a bottle of whiskey - I don't drink).

I was really hurt, by that and by the fact I won't have any gifts under the tree (I've brought for myself before and family laugh at me, I've also unwrapped gifts friends have given me, and again got made fun of because they were expensive). I talked to my best friend and decided to have conversations with the family. I spoke to all of them, one by one, and explained honestly I was disappointed because I like something to open, and would love if we could exchange gifts as I've bought for them already. I highlighted I'd be happy with something small - just a token gift. Broadly speaking the response I got was : you're being ridiculous, adults don't need gifts, we're broke and you can afford anything you want! Along with lots of hurtful digs and mean comments.

I'm now fuming and want to cancel everything and never see anyone again. I feel like they take advantage of my generosity (which I know they do!) however this cements the fact in my mind that they don't actually care about me or my feelings at all. I understand times are tough, I try and be as supportive as I can be - but am I crazy to think if you're being hosted for a week, having hundreds of pounds worth of gifts bought for you (that you've asked for! Including practical things you need and would have to buy for yourself if I didn't!), that you can afford a cheap £5 box of chocolates to humour your daughter/sister?

OP posts:
ChicBee · 10/12/2024 09:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BibbityBobbityToo · 10/12/2024 09:21

You are the odd one out here, they aren't ever going to change so stop, just bloody stop being such a mug. Do you even need them in your life?

Get rid of all the other gifts, try and get refunds otherwise use them for your friends or keep for bday presents throughout the year etc. Can you use the whisky for your secret santa recipient?

DowntonFlabbie · 10/12/2024 09:21

RedToothBrush · 09/12/2024 17:04

Knowing that they never get you anything, why have you persisted in buying things for them when they've been ungrateful in the past?

Why have you persisting in trying to do an movie style Christmas, which tbh is all for show, when you know it's no one else's reality?

Why have you decided that's what you should be doing?

Tbh, you almost are insensitive to their circumstances and seem to be flaunting your good fortune at them.

I'm not surprised there's a certain amount of tension here.

The suggestion of a secret Santa strikes me as someone else actually trying to deescalate an ever growing Christmas works rather than demanding more.

The alternative is almost making yourself into a Christmas martyr.

I don't get your mindset at all.

Just stop it.

You sound like one of her awful family.

evilharpy · 10/12/2024 09:22

Change your locks, OP. It's very quick and easy to change the lock barrel yourself.

Apolloneuro · 10/12/2024 09:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Maybe they could, I don’t know, get jobs?

Plastictrees · 10/12/2024 09:23

DowntonFlabbie · 10/12/2024 09:21

You sound like one of her awful family.

Indeed. It’s quite bizarre how this poster is hellbent on making excuses for the terrible behaviour of the family. There is always one I suppose!

Appleberrybloom · 10/12/2024 09:23

Not read all the responses, but you sound like a really lovely person who wants the best for their family, you absolutely should not be forgotten. Please return their gifts and treat yourself. Xx

DowntonNabby · 10/12/2024 09:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I love how you know OP's family better than she does.

DSis arrived (I opened the door because she has a key and would've let herself in anyway - I know, I probably need to change the locks) and pulled out all the stops - lots of tears, lots of 'it doesn't matter about the presents, we just want to be together' (I know this wouldn't hold up). I almost caved - I'm sure this is why she turned up and not anyone else, because we've always had a stronger bond. But then I asked her how she and family were discussing this if not on the family group, she got a bit shady and then admitted there was another group chat, but I wouldn't want to see what was on there. That helped rebuild my 'do not give a fuck'eryness.

She knows their intentions are toxic. They sent the sister because they thought she could emotionally manipulate OP. If OP thought they were genuinely concerned about being with her and not the presents, she'd be handing them over regardless before the trip. But she's not because she knows.

LazyArsedMagician · 10/12/2024 09:23

Just read through all of your posts @Grinch123 - it has actually made me quite emotional thinking of these selfish fuckers asking you for hundreds of pounds of specific gifts, knowing they're going to spring Secret Santa on you when you've already bought everything.

And those saying it's not clear they're still expecting the gifts - errm, you don't send round a crying Flying Monkey to try and guilt that person to still give them, OR even just have a list ready to go of £400+ items if you're not expecting them under any circs!

crochetandshit · 10/12/2024 09:23

OP I saw a wonderful thread on Reddit where a DIL decided to drop the rope of always being expected to provide/host with no other contact from the inlaws at any time. She simply started replying "no thank you" when she was asked or told to host/bring/buy whatever.
I think this sentence could come in very handy for you!

Merry Christmas op and DD 🎄

ChicBee · 10/12/2024 09:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mrsredlipstick · 10/12/2024 09:25

Great work OP on booking your holiday.
As I said up thread I had years of hosting.

I now do a curry party between Christmas and new year. It's mainly for nieces and nephews as my family have passed. I buy children presents, that's it.
It will be interesting this year to see what people bring, usually nothing. I'm on medical leave and haven't had my big salary. They all know.

I would have loved to have taken my DC to lapland. I had poorly parents so never got the option I'll have to wait for DGC now.
Keep strong and if they start arguing the toss tell them you're tired and that's that.

Apolloneuro · 10/12/2024 09:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I don’t know. You seem pretty chilled about coming to all sorts of conclusions.

DowntonFlabbie · 10/12/2024 09:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Maybe they should get jobs then 🤷‍♀️

Giftss · 10/12/2024 09:26

Grinch123 · 09/12/2024 16:59

Thank you. Giving to charity sounds like a good idea, the thought of sending it all back seems hard and honestly it's probably stuff someone down on their luck would love!

More expensive bits they've asked for (there's lots of smaller bits they've mentioned throughout the year or sent me links to)

Ugg Tasmans
North Face Puffer
A £400 Lego set (this one almost didn't get bought!)
AirPods
Perfumes (Gucci/Marc Jacobs etc... fairly pricey ones)
A Cineworld subscription thing
Coldplay tickets (if I do go nuclear, I'm keeping these!)
Generous gift cards for Starbucks/Costa etc

Admittedly it's gotten out of hand, but it's stuff I can afford and I know they have no other way of getting so I've never minded splashing out... until now. Suddenly I'm filled with rage 😂

I'm glad you've cancelled and going on holiday instead! Please return the presents (except the Coldplay tickets as you can go and Starbucks you can use) and get your money back. You can use that money for your child seeing as no one else buys her anything!

andthat · 10/12/2024 09:27

RockOrAHardplace · 10/12/2024 00:20

I hope you are alright! Do a winter wonderland type trip with your little one - you couldn't get much more Chrismassy!

I am going to say something now that will probably be very unpopular but please bear with me.

Mum and Dad divorced when I was a kid and we were on the breadline, money was very tight. Christmas was always lovely, Mum half killed herself to make sure we all had something but it wasn't the massive splurge lots of families have.

My eldest sister, (quite a bit older than me), eventually got a good job and married well and her income for a month was more than our entire annual income for 4 of us.

She started hosting Christmas, she tried to create a Christmas worthy of a glitzy American film. No expense was spared. If her kids were asked for a list of what they wanted for Christmas, which we were duly presented with, we knew full well it would be beyond our financial ability and that anything we didn't buy, my sister would. She wanted us to have a good time too and she was very generous but too extravagant and we just couldn't compete. I gave up.

It all came from a good place and she wanted us to have a magical time but for all the nice things she bought me, whilst part of me was thrilled, part of me also felt dejected as I just couldn't compete. What I could buy her kids just wasn't up to the mark and I felt that neither they or my sister understood how demoralising it was. What do you buy the woman who has everything. I spent more on my sister than I did on everyone else combined and then whatever I bought was never seen again. I'd buy posh Belgium choccies amongst other things and she would hand them around the room or add them to the big pile of posh goodies she had in her cupboard.

I never asked to borrow money, she never bailed us out, it was just the Christmas and birthday extravagances that got out of hand.

The problem was that my sister had started the ball rolling and every year it got bigger and bigger and yeah I enjoyed the gifts but I also felt I could never reciprocate as did my Mum and siblings. We knew that we couldn't replicate the standard she had set, which her kids were now well and truly attuned to. Anything we offered would seem poor by comparison.

There inability to buy a little something for you, as the generous host, let alone a family member, is wrong and is very thoughtless, they certainly need pulling up on this.

But you do need to pull back on the opulence and extravagant gifting as you are the one creating this, but they are wrong to take advantage of you. You are also bringing your child up to these expectations, like my sister and her kids. How are your family supposed to compete? Christmas is about being together and having friends and family to have a nice time with. This is what your child should be enjoying.

Your deep seated desire to give them a wonderful time, is creating the very monster you are complaining about. You offer it on a plate and they take it.

Your family will be upset by your message as you have basically held a mirror up to them about their behaviour which does need to change, but you have a part in this too, you helped create this monster. You set their expectations, and you react to their none too subtle hints at what they want....its a self fulfilling prophecy with the end result that you feel unappreciated.

I say this with kindness, you are a very generous woman and your love for your family is very obvious, but the issues you need to address is not just their behaviour, its your also your own.

You need to set boundaries and expectations, not just for them but for you too.

I know I will get lambasted for this.

This is an excellent, well balanced post.

Plastictrees · 10/12/2024 09:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Indeed. But we’d have to know a heck of a lot more to make that conclusion.

ChicBee · 10/12/2024 09:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ChicBee · 10/12/2024 09:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Plastictrees · 10/12/2024 09:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Why not ‘throw out there’ some good wishes to the OP, wishing her a fantastic holiday? That seems a better use of time than making excuses for her toxic family.

pimplebum · 10/12/2024 09:34

just send a message “ that’s a great idea! Ok so I just buy one secret Santa for xxx what’s the buget ? £10? Christmas us all about the s being together do looking forward to this!

I need a bit of help this year here are done jobs for the week like secret Santa I’ve pulled names out of a hat
prepping veg - sister 1

wasjing up sister2
taking out bins- brother
dog walking - uncle

RadFs · 10/12/2024 09:35

@Grinch123 it seems like your siblings are on benefits for no reason at all. You seem to be funding their lifestyle and they’re taking advantage of you and the rest comes from the state. I would return all those expensive presents. From what you’ve been saying they don’t really like you they’re in for the freebies and I guess they also make you feel guilty for earning so much. Had they wanted they would have got a job but they’re really just scroungers.

Oodydoody · 10/12/2024 09:35

If you don't have a video door bell, I would get one.
Interesting to see if your family try and enter your home knowing you won't be there!

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 10/12/2024 09:35

Enjoy your holiday OP.

For the future, if any mention of Christmas pops up, you might want to say that now your daughter is old enough to enjoy it more you are going to concentrate on having a small family (just the 2 of you) Christmas so they know the good old days are not coming back.

Silvers11 · 10/12/2024 09:35

@Grinch123 Very glad to read your updates since last night. First thing I looked for this morning. I agree with others though. Get the locks changed ASAP, and consider getting a ring doorbell, before you go away, so you can check if they try to come round while you are away?

I hope you have a great time with your daughter. If you can be bothered, it would be good to get updates from you as to how things are going over Christmas, but you will need to start a 2nd thread for that, as this one is going to fill up today, I'm pretty certain!

There will be fall out from family, I have no doubt, but stay strong. You are doing the right thing.

If you don't want to start a second thread, I'll just wish you and your daughter, now, a lovely Christmas when it arrives.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread