Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of having to work Christmas because I don't have children

545 replies

boogiewoogie24 · 21/11/2024 08:54

I work in a 24/7 sector so christmas day is a normal working day.

This year we have a new manager and we've been told that apart from christmas day and boxing day, we have to work our normal shifts. Those 2 days, we have to work either christmas or boxing day

I work weds-sun one week and weds-fri the other, so never work Mon and Tues. I've been informed I'm working christmas eve, which is a Tuesday. Of the 3 people who normally work the Tuesday late shift, 2 have very young children so are being allowed to either finish early (normal finish time is 11pm) or just don't have to work. The other person has older kids so is happy to work as normal.
So I've been told I'm working the Tuesday until 11pm. I questioned why when I don't work Tuesdays. Response was "you don't have kids" yeah that'll be because I've had 3 miscarriages over 10 years of trying for a baby.
I'm one of only 3 people who work at my place who don't have children. The other 2 are only in their early 20s so plenty of time for them to have in future. I'm nearly 40.

I'm also having to work both christmas and boxing day because it's Jane's first christmas as a mum so she can have both days off and Jill's got her kids this year and last year they were at their dad's so she can have both days off, and Mary's family are in Scotland (we are south england) so she can have the 2 days off to visit them. No doubt Sue and Karen will go off sick like normal... you get the picture.

I'm rambling I know. But basically I'm being penalised for being unable to have children. It doesn't matter that I find christmas incredibly hard and painful.

OP posts:
Starso · 21/11/2024 09:38

Parker231 · 21/11/2024 09:21

@boogiewoogie24 I’d suggest you submit a formal grievance to your HR team. No one is ever entitled to a preference over holidays because they have children.

Agreed. Don’t tolerate this nonsense. So glad my Workplace isn’t like that. It never even gets mentioned.

Bonjovispjs · 21/11/2024 09:39

Jifmicroliquid · 21/11/2024 09:34

Yes they do. They were deliberately obtuse on another thread I read recently.

Thanks for the heads up, twats shall be ignored in future.

EssentiallyItsTrue · 21/11/2024 09:39

romdowa · 21/11/2024 09:01

At my husbands workplace people with kids are off for Xmas and people without are off for new years. The majority seem to be OK with that system. Will you be off for new years since you've worked Xmas?

That's terrible. I'm suprised people are ok with that.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 21/11/2024 09:40

Always hated NYE even as a young 'un.

Expensive and overrated and so much pressure for it be the most Amaaaaaazing night of the year.

SM must make that pressure even more hellish with all the #FeelingBlessed type bollocks.

user1471538283 · 21/11/2024 09:40

This really annoys me and I'm a mother. When my DS was small I always did my share of Christmas. I chose to have him and I didn't expect others to supplement it.

I work Christmas now because both my DCs are older and they work. But if anything this entitlement to have Christmas off because people are parents is worse. I once worked Christmas and had the first week of the new year off to go away. Upon my return the rest of the team (all parents) had booked every bank holiday week off between them. I complained and I was told it was first come first served. So make sure you book Christmas off next year in the new year!

I was told recently that it was ok for me to have the first week of the new year off as it was quiet. From someone who is having the full two weeks off! I don't know where people get off.

SapphireOpal · 21/11/2024 09:40

ByHardyRubyEagle · 21/11/2024 09:29

I’ve pretty much said when I was in my twenties and did not yet have children, this was my exact situation, and I put up with it! Insensitive my arse.

Just because you put up with a ridiculous policy doesn't mean everyone should have to.

It's totally ridiculous and insensitive to just assume that people won't want to be off at Xmas because they haven't had children.

Parker231 · 21/11/2024 09:41

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:33

I guess you r not being massively unreasonable but in your shoes I'd accept the reasons for the others needing the time off. They seem valid reasons.

If you have no reason to be off, except 'i want to be' then the manager has to make a decision and the other people seem to have more valid reasons and perhaps asked him directly for the time off in advance.

Did you ask a few months ago for leave over Christmas? People with children normally do. If you want leave over Christmas my advice would be to put a request in around August. If it's agreed it can't later be changed.

Holiday approvals aren’t based on the reason you want the time off! There is no difference from someone wanting the time to go on holiday to New York versus someone wanting the time off to do nothing at home. No one has to provide a reason for the time off work

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:41

Jane's first christmas as a mum so she can have both days off

Jill's got her kids this year and last year they were at their dad's so she can have both days off

Mary's family are in Scotland (we are south england) so she can have the 2 days off to visit them.

If I was the colleague of Jane, Jill and Mary I would feel terrible making them work knowing Jane would miss out on this very special first Christmas with her baby, Jill's children have been through such a lot and want to see there mum at Christmas, and she needs to see her children as she didn't have them last year, and poor Mary cannot now visit her family :(

Even though I have kids I'd probably offer to work Christmas if these were my colleagues, so my colleagues could see their children and family. I live near-ish work and my needs are not as great as theirs. I can still see family and children around work. These people really do seem to have good reasons to be off. I really would feel pretty heartless doing anything other than offering to work these shifts for these people.....

Babadookinthewardrobe · 21/11/2024 09:41

romdowa · 21/11/2024 09:01

At my husbands workplace people with kids are off for Xmas and people without are off for new years. The majority seem to be OK with that system. Will you be off for new years since you've worked Xmas?

This wouldn’t be allowed at my workplace. It’s discriminatory.

KimberleyClark · 21/11/2024 09:43

SapphireOpal · 21/11/2024 09:40

Just because you put up with a ridiculous policy doesn't mean everyone should have to.

It's totally ridiculous and insensitive to just assume that people won't want to be off at Xmas because they haven't had children.

And to assume that everyone who doesn’t have kids wants to be out partying on NYE.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 21/11/2024 09:44

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:33

I guess you r not being massively unreasonable but in your shoes I'd accept the reasons for the others needing the time off. They seem valid reasons.

If you have no reason to be off, except 'i want to be' then the manager has to make a decision and the other people seem to have more valid reasons and perhaps asked him directly for the time off in advance.

Did you ask a few months ago for leave over Christmas? People with children normally do. If you want leave over Christmas my advice would be to put a request in around August. If it's agreed it can't later be changed.

This valid reasons idea is a slippery slope from employment law/equitable working conditions POV.

Plus - having kids is a lifestyle choice for most. The decision not to is also a choice. Both are valid but in the context of Christmas time off having kids is no more valid a reason.

NeighSayers · 21/11/2024 09:45

ByHardyRubyEagle · 21/11/2024 09:29

I’ve pretty much said when I was in my twenties and did not yet have children, this was my exact situation, and I put up with it! Insensitive my arse.

So because you worked Christmases in your 20s, OP and others should have to work far more Christmases into their 30s and beyond? How is that fair? How is it "swings and roundabouts" if someone never gets to have children?

You are shockingly insensitive about fertility problems and childlessness.

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:46

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 21/11/2024 09:44

This valid reasons idea is a slippery slope from employment law/equitable working conditions POV.

Plus - having kids is a lifestyle choice for most. The decision not to is also a choice. Both are valid but in the context of Christmas time off having kids is no more valid a reason.

If you had a colleague with a new baby and his would be their first Christmas together, would you really feel happy having the day off and making them work? I'd feel terrible unless I also had a very very good reason to be off.

There is law and what is legally ok. Then there is ethics and what is ethically ok. It might be legally fair for everyone to have equal rights to be off at Christmas, but morally and ethically most decent people recognise when others have needs greater than their own.

Starso · 21/11/2024 09:47

NeighSayers · 21/11/2024 09:45

So because you worked Christmases in your 20s, OP and others should have to work far more Christmases into their 30s and beyond? How is that fair? How is it "swings and roundabouts" if someone never gets to have children?

You are shockingly insensitive about fertility problems and childlessness.

Exactly. I really had no words for this level of insensitivity but you’re spot on. As if not having Christmas off for one decade is the same as someone potentially never having it off ever due to either not wanting kids or not being able to have them.

caringcarer · 21/11/2024 09:48

I used to feel sorry for my foster sons SW. She was the only one at her workplace who didn't have kids. They timetabled her to be the emergency SW every Xmas day for 6 years. The following year she had a baby and was just back from maternity leave and her manager had the nerve to ask if she would do it again as she had just been off for 6 months. She did say no and someone else had to do it.

Marblesbackagain · 21/11/2024 09:49

romdowa · 21/11/2024 09:13

Everyone is quite happy with the arrangement tbh . They all feel its fair

But it clearly isn't. It is so unfair for someone to be told your child status impacts on days off.

So someone never gets Xmas day dinner with their family because of the fertility lottery!

Honestly there are such ignorant managers out there. Challenge it OP how dare they make such sweeping generalisations.

Starso · 21/11/2024 09:49

The thing is because managers or colleagues who are parents in my workplace, don’t act entitled and say insensitive things like that I’d happily work Christmas this year of the choice was between me and someone wanting to spend it with a young child as I have no plans.

Last year I was travelling to visit close friends and family, so I wouldn’t have but this year I could and would.

Again I really don’t think they’re allowed to say things like that nowadays. Everyone should report their managers/workplaces who have these sort of divisive and insensitive policies in place.

Parker231 · 21/11/2024 09:49

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:41

Jane's first christmas as a mum so she can have both days off

Jill's got her kids this year and last year they were at their dad's so she can have both days off

Mary's family are in Scotland (we are south england) so she can have the 2 days off to visit them.

If I was the colleague of Jane, Jill and Mary I would feel terrible making them work knowing Jane would miss out on this very special first Christmas with her baby, Jill's children have been through such a lot and want to see there mum at Christmas, and she needs to see her children as she didn't have them last year, and poor Mary cannot now visit her family :(

Even though I have kids I'd probably offer to work Christmas if these were my colleagues, so my colleagues could see their children and family. I live near-ish work and my needs are not as great as theirs. I can still see family and children around work. These people really do seem to have good reasons to be off. I really would feel pretty heartless doing anything other than offering to work these shifts for these people.....

Holiday approvals aren’t legally based on need or reason . Everyone has the same rights regardless of the circumstances of their own family life.

If the OP works this year to give those with children time off, what happens if those employees leave and three new employees have the same family circumstances. Is the OP expected to work next year as well?

slashlover · 21/11/2024 09:50

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:46

If you had a colleague with a new baby and his would be their first Christmas together, would you really feel happy having the day off and making them work? I'd feel terrible unless I also had a very very good reason to be off.

There is law and what is legally ok. Then there is ethics and what is ethically ok. It might be legally fair for everyone to have equal rights to be off at Christmas, but morally and ethically most decent people recognise when others have needs greater than their own.

It's a baby, it doesn't know if it's Christmas Day or Halloween.

Starso · 21/11/2024 09:51

slashlover · 21/11/2024 09:50

It's a baby, it doesn't know if it's Christmas Day or Halloween.

😂😂 that’s a very good point!

theeyeofdoe · 21/11/2024 09:52

You say, I’m afraid I won’t be able to work both Christmas Day and Boxing Day, nor will I be able to work on my non-working day.

it is discriminatory for the organisation insist on me working both.

I will leave it with you, please let me know which one I will work.

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:53

Parker231 · 21/11/2024 09:49

Holiday approvals aren’t legally based on need or reason . Everyone has the same rights regardless of the circumstances of their own family life.

If the OP works this year to give those with children time off, what happens if those employees leave and three new employees have the same family circumstances. Is the OP expected to work next year as well?

It's about doing what is decent.

I honestly wouldn't enjoy my Christmas day knowing a newborn baby could not be with her mother for her first Christmas, or that children who couldn't see their mum at Christmas last year won't be able to again this year because of me.

If someone is the kind of person that can live with themself and enjoy Christmas despite the impact on others, then sure they can crack on, raise complaints etc.. it's with their 'rights'.

But I personally prefer to live in a world where we do what is right and decent for others and sometimes that means a little self sacrifice. Humanity has become very selfish sadly.

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:54

slashlover · 21/11/2024 09:50

It's a baby, it doesn't know if it's Christmas Day or Halloween.

Wow. That's pretty heartless.

My first Christmas with my baby was one of the most special days I will ever remember.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 21/11/2024 09:55

Sleep in the instance you describe them yes, provided I've not been shafted the last few years (if so, can someone else do it?) with Christmas time off then I would. With an understanding this individual doesn't think think their kids are a passport to never working Christmas again and took their turn.

If it was someone who had this assumption or the situation wasn't being managed properly then I'd challenge.

But it's wrong to assume childless means you don't have priority at Christmas. And I don't agree with your last statement that "but morally and ethically most decent people recognise when others have needs greater than their own." makes this the default.

Parker231 · 21/11/2024 09:55

SleepFinally · 21/11/2024 09:53

It's about doing what is decent.

I honestly wouldn't enjoy my Christmas day knowing a newborn baby could not be with her mother for her first Christmas, or that children who couldn't see their mum at Christmas last year won't be able to again this year because of me.

If someone is the kind of person that can live with themself and enjoy Christmas despite the impact on others, then sure they can crack on, raise complaints etc.. it's with their 'rights'.

But I personally prefer to live in a world where we do what is right and decent for others and sometimes that means a little self sacrifice. Humanity has become very selfish sadly.

So someone without children shouldn’t expect to celebrate Christmas Day?