Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Daily mail article, integration has failed in Germany. Aibu to agree with article?

483 replies

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 12:00

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13687565/Children-radicalised-mosques-11-knives-crime-verdict-German-child-refugee-charity-integration-failed-asylum-seekers.html?ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490&ito=

Aibu to agree to an extent?

German refugee charity warns 'integration has FAILED'

In a bombshell interview, staff at a leading youth organisation in Germany have said the continuing influx of refugees means the system is at breaking point. They called for a 'freeze' in admissions.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13687565/Children-radicalised-mosques-11-knives-crime-verdict-German-child-refugee-charity-integration-failed-asylum-seekers.html?ito=social-twitter_mailonline&ns_campaign=1490&ns_mchannel=rss

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Mimififi · 31/07/2024 13:59

Saschka · 31/07/2024 13:57

And yet despite your superior googling skills, you were only able to find a list of places where Catholics were at risk of drug crime. Perhaps this list is difficult to locate because expat Christians aren’t actually at particularly high risk of persecution anywhere?

(I also don’t see why OP thinks this is a “gotcha” for problems with refugees integrating, but since she does, I’m going to refute it).

Well you got your list, your welcome!

OP posts:
JaneVtwaddle · 31/07/2024 14:00

@Bushmillsbabe it's quite common and also common for community leaders to knowingly or unknowingly contribute to a two tiered system in the UK.
Eg a girl in papers years ago was suffering abuse, she eventually bravely ran away, the police spoke to a community elder and she went back and was abused possibly killed I can't remember.

It's very important to help women in communities where they may feel trapped and obligated, don't speak English, don't know their rights to support them. But unfortunately this can only come from within the community.
I know there are lots of charities trying to help.

Saschka · 31/07/2024 14:00

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 13:58

No I merely pointed out immigration & integration works both ways. As a Christian I should be able to practice my religion freely & safely in any of the countries listed on the list I linked.
If they want to practice their religion in mine & be able to make demands regarding their religious beliefs in my country I should be able to do the same in theirs
If immigration & integration is to work it must be both ways. Can't have one rule for thee, one for me

So, provide me with this list of places where, if you moved to them, you’d be unable to freely practice Christianity.

And are you seriously suggesting that because Catholics in Mexico are at risk of drug crime, we should ban Muslims from worship in the U.K. or Germany? How about Hindus and Jews? How is that logical?

JaneVtwaddle · 31/07/2024 14:01

@Saschka I've glanced at that list.

Saudi amazingly has 2 million Christians. The risk there is from extreme Islam.
Clans (whatever that is)

Tootjaskoot · 31/07/2024 14:01

I am now convinced that the purpose of this thread and so many like it is to be as exhausting as possible so that The Left gradually give up the will to fight for a just world. Spoiler: we won’t give up.

Lalalalalaaaa · 31/07/2024 14:04

If I moved to many countries my religion would not be accepted, I could be persecuted & I definitely would not be able to practice my Christianity or access a church

I shouldn't bite but I can't help it. OP you've provided a list of the top 50 countries where Christians are most at risk of persecution (out of the 150 that organization surveys). Apart from the fact that this is a ranking, and doesn't mean a Christian is actually at any material risk in country (and most definitely doesn't mean a Christian can't practice or access a church), this doesn't support the statement that you have made unless you converted from Islam - for the majority of the countries which are listed as 'extreme' the risk to Christians isn't because they're Christian, but because they've converted from Islam. Did you convert or do you actually have any source that supports your actual statement?

In a lot of countries there are militant groups and terrorist organizations that specifically target people different to them and yes, with Islamist groups, this can be Christians. Are you seriously suggesting that because extremist groups (the same groups that refugees themselves are often running from) don't accept something, we shouldn't either?

As a general comment, given how many refugees non-European countries like Lebanon and Jordan take in, to suggest Germany (or the UK) is overloaded is laughable in my view.

Grapesichord · 31/07/2024 14:04

Not wanting to enter this debate but there has been a lot of reporting this year about Christians being the most persecuted group world wide. The evidence is from the House of Commons Library
https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2024-0017/

EasternStandard · 31/07/2024 14:04

At some point politicians will notice enough of this tension and think about what to do. I’m
not sure just dismissal will work out well

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:04

Saschka · 31/07/2024 14:00

So, provide me with this list of places where, if you moved to them, you’d be unable to freely practice Christianity.

And are you seriously suggesting that because Catholics in Mexico are at risk of drug crime, we should ban Muslims from worship in the U.K. or Germany? How about Hindus and Jews? How is that logical?

I'm not suggesting they shouldn't but as a Christian I want the liberty of practising my catholicism anywhere without fear of persecution. I'd like those counteries to build me a church if there was none in the locality.

OP posts:
Saschka · 31/07/2024 14:04

JaneVtwaddle · 31/07/2024 14:01

@Saschka I've glanced at that list.

Saudi amazingly has 2 million Christians. The risk there is from extreme Islam.
Clans (whatever that is)

Quite. Even in the most repressive countries, the issue is generally persecution of apostates (or supposed apostates) and expats are generally left alone to do whatever they want religion-wise.

And none of that has any bearing on whether Muslims should be “allowed” to practice Islam in the U.K, which apparently OP doesn’t agree with.

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:05

Grapesichord · 31/07/2024 14:04

Not wanting to enter this debate but there has been a lot of reporting this year about Christians being the most persecuted group world wide. The evidence is from the House of Commons Library
https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2024-0017/

The Olympic opening ceremony was evidence of this.

OP posts:
pointythings · 31/07/2024 14:05

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 13:58

No I merely pointed out immigration & integration works both ways. As a Christian I should be able to practice my religion freely & safely in any of the countries listed on the list I linked.
If they want to practice their religion in mine & be able to make demands regarding their religious beliefs in my country I should be able to do the same in theirs
If immigration & integration is to work it must be both ways. Can't have one rule for thee, one for me

There are also over 70 countries where it is illegal to be gay, and where being gay can land you in prison or with a death sentence. By your logic, those countries are also failing. Yes, I know this is a tangent - but sauce for the goose, eh?

A lot of problems with asylum seekers would be resolved by allowing them to work. We have labour shortages in many areas of Europe. It's extremely shortsighted not to see the opportunity here - and it would absolutely improve integration if you give people a stake in the country they have come to.

The Daily Mail and its readership would oppose this.

Saschka · 31/07/2024 14:06

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:04

I'm not suggesting they shouldn't but as a Christian I want the liberty of practising my catholicism anywhere without fear of persecution. I'd like those counteries to build me a church if there was none in the locality.

Why would a state be building you a church? Do you think churches in the UK are built by the government 🤣

HowardTJMoon · 31/07/2024 14:06

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:05

The Olympic opening ceremony was evidence of this.

When you're accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression

Dulra · 31/07/2024 14:06

Saschka · 31/07/2024 14:00

So, provide me with this list of places where, if you moved to them, you’d be unable to freely practice Christianity.

And are you seriously suggesting that because Catholics in Mexico are at risk of drug crime, we should ban Muslims from worship in the U.K. or Germany? How about Hindus and Jews? How is that logical?

How is that logical?
None of this is logical.
There are countries where you are at risk for practicing Christianity, North Korea is the worst, there would also be a whole raft of other human rights issues in these countries too and many being persecuted would flee and look for asylum in safe countries, but I have no idea why the op is using that as a reason to back up why integration in Germany is failing? They also said open drug use and a failing education system were examples but hasn't quite joined up the dots as to why.

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:06

https://adfinternational.org/commentary/nigeria-most-dangerous-country-christians

Also a quick Google provides many articles of how Christians are persecuted in Nigeria. That is why many Nigerians need to seek asylum. It is simply not safe for them to remain as they are Christians.

Why Nigeria is the Most Dangerous Country in the World for Christians

Rampant persecution of Christians makes Nigeria the most dangerous country in the world for followers of Jesus. Learn why.

https://adfinternational.org/commentary/nigeria-most-dangerous-country-christians

OP posts:
cupcaske123 · 31/07/2024 14:07

Bushmillsbabe · 31/07/2024 13:52

But is it as absolute as it is or isn't working? Some immigrants come to this (or any) country bringing skills and knowledge and are massively valuable.

My NHS team is 16 is made up of 3 British, 1 Greek, 2 Malaysian, 1 Portuguese, 4 Indian, 2 Sri Lankan, 2 South African and 1 Australian. Covering all 5 major religions. 13 out of 16 not born here. Without these immigrants my team would be completely stuffed, and the local commuinity would be worse off. They have all integrated, working and contributing.

Where integration doesn't work is often where there is a language barrier, it's really hard to integrate if you cannot communicate. There are language classes available, but there are often barriers to women in particular attending these, due to lack of available childcare, traditional expectations placed on them by their communities to stay home and care for the house and children and that they don't need to learn the language of the place they are living to do this. There are so many cases of domestic violence we have come across but can't do anything as the women won't disclose to us via an interpreter as they think that interpreter will take that information back to their commuinity and put them at greater risk. We so often suspect but cannot do anything to help due to the commuinication barriers, which is terrible for both the women and children involved.

It blows my mind that people can live in a country for 20 years and not be able to communicate in the language of that country. IMHO the focus should be on developing language, even if it has to be made compulsory. If it was a legal obligation, then women would have to be allowed to attend, childcare would have to be provided, and women could then get jobs and provide for their families and work their way out of poverty, acheive greater independence etc.

These are also the problems I found with lack of integration. I worked in a very diverse area where there were generations of poverty. Women in particular were very badly effected. Due to cultural norms they didn't learn English and therefore could not live independently. They brought their children to interpret for them and could not navigate any aspect of life such as filling out forms, speaking to a Dr or worst, getting help for domestic abuse.

The victims of abuse did not want to approach culturally specific organisations because they were afraid of it getting back to their families and they were completely trapped. They could not get a job because they couldn't speak English, they had no idea of their rights and had nowhere to go.

dottiehens · 31/07/2024 14:08

Tootjaskoot · 31/07/2024 14:01

I am now convinced that the purpose of this thread and so many like it is to be as exhausting as possible so that The Left gradually give up the will to fight for a just world. Spoiler: we won’t give up.

Of course you won’t give up. Some would say you live in fantasy land but carry on while you can.

shams05 · 31/07/2024 14:08

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:04

I'm not suggesting they shouldn't but as a Christian I want the liberty of practising my catholicism anywhere without fear of persecution. I'd like those counteries to build me a church if there was none in the locality.

Muslims don't expect the UK to build their mosques for them, why would you expect your chosen country to build you a church?
You should expect them to allow you to build your church as is allowed by our government here in the UK to Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and those of other religions.

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:08

Tootjaskoot · 31/07/2024 14:01

I am now convinced that the purpose of this thread and so many like it is to be as exhausting as possible so that The Left gradually give up the will to fight for a just world. Spoiler: we won’t give up.

And you won't silence debate either!!

OP posts:
Wellieswithsocks · 31/07/2024 14:09

LadyKenya · 31/07/2024 13:17

Yes, plenty of dog whistle racism, in answer to your question. And no, I will not be providing examples, just in case that is what you will be asking next.

If you are unable to produce the examples you should probably retract the accusation.

Dulra · 31/07/2024 14:10

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:04

I'm not suggesting they shouldn't but as a Christian I want the liberty of practising my catholicism anywhere without fear of persecution. I'd like those counteries to build me a church if there was none in the locality.

Build your own church!!! The government doesn't build any places of worship.

Religious persecution is one of the reasons why people flee and look for asylum elsewhere. If you want to emigrate to a country that you knowingly would persecute you that's on you

Midnightalready · 31/07/2024 14:11

ilovesooty · 31/07/2024 13:38

Very interesting. "The tide has turned". How, exactly?

Edited

Many people are now talking about the problems of mass immigration, despite the slurs hurled at them to get them to shut up. (If we'd been able to have a proper conversation about it ten years ago, it's unlikely we'd have voted ourselves out of the EU.)

Dulra · 31/07/2024 14:12

Mimififi · 31/07/2024 14:06

https://adfinternational.org/commentary/nigeria-most-dangerous-country-christians

Also a quick Google provides many articles of how Christians are persecuted in Nigeria. That is why many Nigerians need to seek asylum. It is simply not safe for them to remain as they are Christians.

Why don't you change your thread title to global persecution of Christians because none of this has anything to do with your original post or thread title

JaneVtwaddle · 31/07/2024 14:13

@Dulra
I think it's obvious as to what eh

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread