Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I threw away a perfectly good relationship

208 replies

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:13

of just under 4 years, and I have to live with my mistake now. It's a lesson learned anyway, I'll try to be a little more patient next time.
I'm 33, and my ex partner is 29, a few months off 30. I left before Christmas as he was reluctant about any sort of commitment and he didn't seem to be 100% sure about me, which hurt.
I just wish I'd waited longer and not given into societal pressures, or panicked about my age as I do still have time.

I believe he did love me, he had autism and ADHD and hadn't been in steady employment for a while as well as suffering with his mental health, so I did whatever I could to support him.

I had previously brought up the subject a year ago, and he wasn't ready. I brought it up again 6 months later, admittedly I was starting to get frustrated. lived with him for 3 years.

I've no interest whatsoever in an expensive ring or wedding, I was more than happy with a registry office. my parents offered to pay for a reception which was very nice of him but the point was that even with these things mentioned, he wasn't interested.
I wasn't saying we had to get married immediately, but I wanted to know if it could come in the next couple of years.
I explained that ideally I'd like to have a child in the next couple of years because of my age, but looking back, I have longer than expected.
I couldn't get a firm answer on any of the above, he kept changing his mind about wanting to get engaged, about 3 or 4 times. it was clear he wasn't ready.
He said it was so final, none of his friends were married and it was like the end of his youth.

He felt he wasn't in a stable financial situation which I do understand, particularly re the children, but it doesn't have to cost anything to be engaged and we could've sorted a small wedding.

ok I thought, maybe I can wait a bit longer. I asked him if I was the one for him and he said he thought so? didn't say yeah of course.
I asked him if he could see himself with me in a few years and he couldn't answer it.

I left. I just went to my parents for a bit to get some space, thinking we might work things out. it wasn't a this is over forever, I just told him there's no point coming back right away as nothing could change.

He didn't seem surprised and told me he wants the above but is scared of responsibility. I did express a lot of remorse to him back in January and say that I still wanted to sort things out. I asked him if he wanted me to come back and he said he couldn't answer it.

so I did try to sort things out fairly soon after. he said he thinks he's put me in a difficult position, I told him I wasn't blaming him at all and he was entitled to not want these things.

we've actually been in touch constantly and are on great terms, just feel like I threw something great away. I should've been more patient and just given it at least another year or two, but it's too late. With hindsight, I'd rather just be with him, the rest doesn't matter.

Does it sound like I was an idiot? also, because of his job situation I paid more of the rent, which put a strain on because I couldn't afford it. However I have a better paid job now and I hoped it would change things.
I'm still supporting him with stuff. breaks seem to work for some but not for me, apparently his Mum and sister hate me, which hurts because I thought we got on really well.
I was an idiot who panicked and compared myself to others.

OP posts:
LionBarPlease · 22/06/2024 17:17

I knew from the title that you hadn’t made a mistake. The only mistake you’re making is wasting more time on this. You were on a hiding to nothing. Listen to the part of you that knows this and made the initial step away.

He can be the nicest man in the world but the only way you’ll be a mother with him is by being a mother to him. You deserve more than that. Honestly, you really do.

GalileoHumpkins · 22/06/2024 17:18

It honestly doesn't sound like a perfectly good relationship, it sounds like hard work with you doing all the running. Do you really want to spend your life cajoling someone into doing stuff they're not interested in?

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:21

I just felt he wasn't totally sure about me after 4 years and living together for 3 which was my driving factor really. I just wish I'd stayed and maybe things could be different. He deserves better. Honestly I am really sorry for what I did and I am broken over it.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 22/06/2024 17:22

You 100% made the right choice. Stop gaslighting yourself. He was not the man for you.

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 22/06/2024 17:22

Seriously, you know why you did what you did, it's just the classic panic now you're single and feeling like 'oh it wasn't that bad' - yes it was. He didn't prioritise you and wasn't that in to you. Find someone who matches your commitment and where you are in life. His mum and sister 'hate' you, how mature.

Hopelesslydevoted2Gu · 22/06/2024 17:23

You 100% did the right thing in breaking up with him.

He's messed you around, changing his mind and not being sure for so long. I'm certain he would have continued doing the same and you'd be having the same conversations in five years.

Don't waste any more time on him. Stop supporting him, stop speaking to him. You need to focus on moving forwards, meeting new people, not being dragged down by him.

If you want kids, you want somebody who isn't scared of responsibility and commitment.

Aquamarine1029 · 22/06/2024 17:23

If his mother and sister hate you now, they never really liked you to begin with.

StormingNorman · 22/06/2024 17:24

You didn’t make a mistake. He doesn’t want the commitment and that could well never change. Ultimately, you still want different things no matter how friendly you are.

Autumntimeagain · 22/06/2024 17:25

OP you've dodged a bullet !

Having already supported him financially and emotionally, he STILL couldn't 'commit' to even saying that he could see himself with you in 5 years ffs, never mind 'forever more, or forsaking all others' !

He was simply a cocklodger, nothing more.

He was happy to use you for his 'supporting act', but had zero desire to even pretend to love you !

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:26

Aquamarine1029 · 22/06/2024 17:23

If his mother and sister hate you now, they never really liked you to begin with.

They haven't said a word to me since, well to be fair maybe I'm being paranoid in what I'm saying. His sister said something about wishing me happiness at Christmas but has since deleted me on everything.

The thing is she recently broke up with her partner very briefly and before that left an ex of 4 years to get with this new man, and admitted she was bored of him, which is perfectly valid, but not a reason to act high and mighty with me.

We got on so well me and him, I've no interest in anyone else. We had so many memories.

OP posts:
Apileofballyhoo · 22/06/2024 17:26

It might not be a bad idea to cut contact.

DrinkUpBabyDown · 22/06/2024 17:26

I don't think it sounds like a great relationship tbf. He sounds very unsure and it doesn't sound like he has gained any clarity or is desperate to get back together. If you got back together, thinking all you want is to be with him, how long would it be before your own feelings about commitment resurfaced? Or would you just suppress them forever and let him have the relationship he wants?

It's really hard if you are a woman approaching your mid 30s. Do you stay and hope for the best, or leave and hope you can find what you want with someone else? I've been there and it was a very painful and confusing time. There's rarely a clear cut right or wrong answer, but for what it's worth I think you've done the "right" thing for you.

TheBottomsOfMyTrousersAreRolled · 22/06/2024 17:27

Yabu. Stop talking to him. He isnt interested in you as a marriage prospect. He is unemployed and thinks marriage is life ending. He isnt ready for marriage and likely wont be until you are well past the point of having children.

CustardPies4 · 22/06/2024 17:27

He didn't want commitment and you are experiencing regret. It doesn't mean that you made the wrong choice but you are ruminating. This is very common for cognitively divergent people and I am wondering if you may be a little bit?

Hopelesslydevoted2Gu · 22/06/2024 17:28

He doesn't deserve better. You've paid his rent, patiently listened to his self-indulgent twaddle for 4 years, and he still "isn't sure". Honestly, he has treated you badly.

It doesn't matter what his reasons are for not wanting responsibility and commitment. However "good" his reasons are doesn't matter. You want to move forwards in life and he doesn't. If he doesn't want this after 4 years, he won't change his mind.

It's really important that you value yourself. Wanting to get married and have kids in your 30s is a really really normal thing to want. Don't let him make out that you are rushing.

ginasevern · 22/06/2024 17:30

He has autism and ADHD and isn't in steady employment - what exactly does that look like - does he ever work? You've basically been supporting him. He also doesn't know whether he wants to be with you or not, erring more on the side of not bothered by the seems of it.

It's not his fault and it's not your fault. He doesn't want to commit and that's fair enough. You can't make him and you shouldn't even try because you will live to regret it.

You're clinging on to something that doesn't exist. It's so easy to think you're in love especially if your biological clock is ticking. You've just got used to him being in your life - his humour, his habits, his smile. It's hard to let go, I really do understand but he isn't in love with you and he values his freedom. Walk away.

FiveTreeHill · 22/06/2024 17:31

He didn't want to marry you. He wasnt not sure, he just didn't want to
He's unemployed, you were supporting him financially when you couldn't

You absolutely did the right thing, don't waste more years of your life with this man.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:33

He is in employment but has been fired a few times and hasn't managed to find full -time work. I did everything I could, I helped with so many job applications and so on. He did pay towards rent etc. Just that I paid more, our old landlord put our rent up by £250 a month which was frustrating as it was difficult to afford alone in worst case scenario, but I earn a lot more now.

OP posts:
TheBottomsOfMyTrousersAreRolled · 22/06/2024 17:34

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:33

He is in employment but has been fired a few times and hasn't managed to find full -time work. I did everything I could, I helped with so many job applications and so on. He did pay towards rent etc. Just that I paid more, our old landlord put our rent up by £250 a month which was frustrating as it was difficult to afford alone in worst case scenario, but I earn a lot more now.

Next time look for men who are self sufficient and dont need to be parented. Youll be less frustrated.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:35

I just feel like he could've been ready in a couple of years, if only I'd been more patient. I don't even care that much about marriage now, I just felt the pressure from constantly seeing people my age or younger doing it.

I have apologised profoundly to him, expressed my regret. He told me he's just having a rubbish time in life because of being ND and his life situation.

OP posts:
Autumntimeagain · 22/06/2024 17:35

' I just wish I'd stayed and maybe things could be different. He deserves better. Honestly I am really sorry for what I did and I am broken over it.'

No OP, you're simply missing the 'rose tinted' version of him that you wanted to have.

The REAL him did not love you. He did not want the same things that you did.

He openly admitted to being scared to grow up and become an adult by saying that marriage would be 'the end of his youth' ffs !

He isn't now, and wasn't then ever interested in getting married and having a family !

You need to stop hoping that somehow he'll 'come to his senses or realize what he lost' etc, because he's already shown you 'who he is' by messing you about and pretending to 'get engaged', then changing his bloody mind again ! Several times.

It's time you started believe his ACTIONS.

ginasevern · 22/06/2024 17:36

Honey, seriously. Give this up. Take a tip from someone who was hell bent on marrying someone not suitable and who didn't (deep down) want to commit to me. You've got him under your skin but after a while of seperation that will fade, it really will, and you will start to see what a terrible mistake it would be. I wish I'd given my younger self this advice.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:37

Your replies are helping me a lot because I've felt so depressed about this. When he couldn't be certain I was the one or that he'd see himself with me in a few years, that really hurt. He told me he can't see that much into the future because of his own situation

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 22/06/2024 17:37

If you were both in your early 20s and still getting to know yourselves as people, then maybe you might have made a mistake.

the truth is that mature individuals don’t need years and years to decide to make a commitment. If you were the one, he would be desperate to marry you. You absolutely could be practical about planning your children, but you would
be talking about how to make it happen and working toward that goal.

what he was doing was future faking. Saying that maybe someday you would have the kind of relationship where you fully commit and build a family. He can string you along, getting to stay in a comfortable relationship until he finds something better. His biological clock doesn’t tick the same way yours does. He may not have been doing it intentionally, but he was still doing it.

MonsteraMama · 22/06/2024 17:39

Have you considered therapy to work on your poor self esteem so you can understand that you deserve better than this? This was a bad relationship OP, you ended it for a valid reason, you are worthy of being treated as an equal partner, not a mummy replacement.

If you'd stayed he'd have continued to be unsure and hemmed and hawwed for years. If he wasn't sure after 4 years he was never going to be.