Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I threw away a perfectly good relationship

208 replies

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:13

of just under 4 years, and I have to live with my mistake now. It's a lesson learned anyway, I'll try to be a little more patient next time.
I'm 33, and my ex partner is 29, a few months off 30. I left before Christmas as he was reluctant about any sort of commitment and he didn't seem to be 100% sure about me, which hurt.
I just wish I'd waited longer and not given into societal pressures, or panicked about my age as I do still have time.

I believe he did love me, he had autism and ADHD and hadn't been in steady employment for a while as well as suffering with his mental health, so I did whatever I could to support him.

I had previously brought up the subject a year ago, and he wasn't ready. I brought it up again 6 months later, admittedly I was starting to get frustrated. lived with him for 3 years.

I've no interest whatsoever in an expensive ring or wedding, I was more than happy with a registry office. my parents offered to pay for a reception which was very nice of him but the point was that even with these things mentioned, he wasn't interested.
I wasn't saying we had to get married immediately, but I wanted to know if it could come in the next couple of years.
I explained that ideally I'd like to have a child in the next couple of years because of my age, but looking back, I have longer than expected.
I couldn't get a firm answer on any of the above, he kept changing his mind about wanting to get engaged, about 3 or 4 times. it was clear he wasn't ready.
He said it was so final, none of his friends were married and it was like the end of his youth.

He felt he wasn't in a stable financial situation which I do understand, particularly re the children, but it doesn't have to cost anything to be engaged and we could've sorted a small wedding.

ok I thought, maybe I can wait a bit longer. I asked him if I was the one for him and he said he thought so? didn't say yeah of course.
I asked him if he could see himself with me in a few years and he couldn't answer it.

I left. I just went to my parents for a bit to get some space, thinking we might work things out. it wasn't a this is over forever, I just told him there's no point coming back right away as nothing could change.

He didn't seem surprised and told me he wants the above but is scared of responsibility. I did express a lot of remorse to him back in January and say that I still wanted to sort things out. I asked him if he wanted me to come back and he said he couldn't answer it.

so I did try to sort things out fairly soon after. he said he thinks he's put me in a difficult position, I told him I wasn't blaming him at all and he was entitled to not want these things.

we've actually been in touch constantly and are on great terms, just feel like I threw something great away. I should've been more patient and just given it at least another year or two, but it's too late. With hindsight, I'd rather just be with him, the rest doesn't matter.

Does it sound like I was an idiot? also, because of his job situation I paid more of the rent, which put a strain on because I couldn't afford it. However I have a better paid job now and I hoped it would change things.
I'm still supporting him with stuff. breaks seem to work for some but not for me, apparently his Mum and sister hate me, which hurts because I thought we got on really well.
I was an idiot who panicked and compared myself to others.

OP posts:
VikingsandDragons · 22/06/2024 19:59

You sound like you've fallen into the trap of rose tinted glasses. Having a lot of memories is not a reason to be with someone, shared life goals, aspirations, drive and interests is. And that's a all of he above list not 'well we have 50% and thats enough' - it won't be long term, it just pushes the problem further down the road.

Click 'see all' on your first post and just look at the number of excuses you give for how he acts, the flaws you're willing to look the other way to in order to be with him, but he's not making any effort to say 'breaking up was a huge mistake, you're the love of my life'. Sometimes you need to listen to what isn't being said as much as what is.

You are not a repair facility for broken men, you will never be truely happy with a half life of compromises and you would always be looking over your shoulder for him to grow bored and move on since he's at best warm towards your relationship when after 4 years it shouldn't be so much work.

BusyBeeBee82 · 22/06/2024 20:03

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 18:57

You are right. I am trying to kid myself that I'd be ok with waiting another 2,3,4+ years but the truth is that I'd probably feel resentful seeing people around me progressing, going to weddings and so on.
I think he did see marriage as signing his life away, but I just wonder why he stayed with me 4 years.

When I left, he got a little teary and said he missed me so much and was looking at houses, but that was it.

Hi Op,

I think you did the right thing ending it.

Questioning why he stayed with you for 4 years - from the sounds of it, he had a very comfortable life with you - you doing housework, paying a higher share of the household bills etc. I’m sorry to say is probably one of the reasons he stayed. He’s had a really easy life with you from what you’ve said.

Are you still supporting him financially? Don’t let him string you along.

There is time for you to meet someone else who values and appreciates you, rather than using you as a cash cow/housemaid.

TheRealKatnissEverdeen · 22/06/2024 20:18

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 19:42

Just feel like he'd never want to give me a second chance because I left him and hurt him.

But he's happily still taking your money.

Orangeandgold · 22/06/2024 20:21

I haven’t read all of the comments but I agree with the first lot. I think HE has missed out on a good thing and I think you’ve had a lucky escape. Sorry but after 4 years he should know what he wants. And maybe he does but his other issues are clouding his judgement. Either way, it doesn’t sound like a 2 way relationship. You are doing so much more for him and I’m wondering what he is doing for you.

It is very very tough now and you are human for feeling this way but you will look back and find that you are better off without this.

Please also make time to work on yourself.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 20:24

Orangeandgold · 22/06/2024 20:21

I haven’t read all of the comments but I agree with the first lot. I think HE has missed out on a good thing and I think you’ve had a lucky escape. Sorry but after 4 years he should know what he wants. And maybe he does but his other issues are clouding his judgement. Either way, it doesn’t sound like a 2 way relationship. You are doing so much more for him and I’m wondering what he is doing for you.

It is very very tough now and you are human for feeling this way but you will look back and find that you are better off without this.

Please also make time to work on yourself.

Thank you. I am not supporting him financially, just with employment prospects and such.
He's just saying he can't see past his current life situation, I don't know if it's excuses or not.

OP posts:
marmitegirl01 · 22/06/2024 20:27

Nope you called it right. Stick to your decision.
You'll be ok x

CustardPies4 · 22/06/2024 20:32

I think you have a deep affection for him but honestly if I had one word of advice for younger me - choosing your life partner is an emotional and a rational decision. It has to be both especially in this modern day and age.

He doesn't sound like he would cope well with the demands of fatherhood.

LocalHobo · 22/06/2024 20:37

I wouldn't make a lifelong commitment with anyone who wasn't blown away by the possibility of me becoming their significant other.
The thing is I've seen it quite a few times on here where men do take longer sometimes, 6/7 years if not more, and the women wait but it all works out in the end. "works out" ? You want more than that, you want overwhelming happiness of being together.
Don't settle.
I speak as a happily married person of many years, and DH proposed aged 21, way before any of his peer group.

BabyFedUp445 · 22/06/2024 20:37

He would absolutely not make a good husband and father. You are excusing A LOT of bad behaviour because he is ND.

It doesn't matter who is getting married or why. The truth is you were doing so much for him, you probably want something in return, which in your head was commitment. But in reality he was not nice to you, you did way too much for him.and deep down you know it wasn't right.

Stop all contact. Take some time to yourself. Build up your self esteem. Then start dating again. You'll be kicking yourself for wasting so much time on this loser.

ZellyFitzgerald · 22/06/2024 20:38

Oh god OP, I was with one of these for a few years. We split up thankfully, even though I was devastated.

He's only finally ready for kids and settling down now at the age of 46.

I'm 40 now, and if I'd waited for him I would have lost my chance to have kids. Men have the luxury of waiting, women don't.

Please don't doubt your decision, you did the right thing even if it doesn't feel like it right now.

CheekyHobson · 22/06/2024 20:40

I left one like this. For the first year afterwards I went back and forth in my head but then stuck with my decision. He had a lovely girlfriend for years after me and I thought she was going to be the one who he gave everything I wanted, but no, they broke up. Then he got married and I thought, so yeah, he was ready eventually. They divorced, no kids from the marriage. He’s had a series of short-term girlfriends since then.

i don’t think these kinds of guys really change.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 21:01

I may never find anyone else who wants to commit. And I'll have still thrown away a good relationship.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 22/06/2024 21:05

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 21:01

I may never find anyone else who wants to commit. And I'll have still thrown away a good relationship.

You already hadn't found anyone who wanted to commit, so you threw away nothing.

That's if any of this is real, which seems unlikely.

TheStateOfTheArt · 22/06/2024 21:09

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 21:01

I may never find anyone else who wants to commit. And I'll have still thrown away a good relationship.

He didn’t want to commit. And if you are really honest with yourself, it was t even close to being a good relationship from what you have described both here and in your previous threads.

ShouldhavebeencalledAppollo · 22/06/2024 21:11

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 21:01

I may never find anyone else who wants to commit. And I'll have still thrown away a good relationship.

Oh come on. It wasnt a good relationship and he doesn't want to commit to you.

Yes you are likely to struggle to meet some one. Because you are still so involved with your ex. You won't move on properly and to be honest someone being so involved with their ex and unable to let go, is a massive red flag

PyramidsOfMarsBar · 22/06/2024 21:20

I think you are over-romanticising that relationship in hindsight, and that you will find someone who is more aligned with your current needs and ambitions for a relationship and family life.

tothelefttotheleft · 22/06/2024 21:21

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:21

I just felt he wasn't totally sure about me after 4 years and living together for 3 which was my driving factor really. I just wish I'd stayed and maybe things could be different. He deserves better. Honestly I am really sorry for what I did and I am broken over it.

Frankly you deserve better.

JawJaw · 22/06/2024 21:23

I am not sure OP is really interested in our responses. She just wants to keep describing the awful relationship. It’s a bit like the click bait news articles which are designed to annoy people so that they comment.

Duckswaddle · 22/06/2024 21:25

IT WAS NEVER A GOOD RELATIONSHIP THOUGH

I’m going to stop reading now because you’re winding me up. Stop pining after something that never was.

Paganna · 22/06/2024 21:34

You are able to love someone but they aren’t right for you. I’d focus your attention on what you want, desire, what a happy, fulfilling relationship looks like to you. Write it down, find time to do this in a quiet place. Don’t censor yourself, put it all down on paper. You say you want a family - Get your fertility checked too - things can change fairly quickly btw 30s to 40s, without wanting to be negative. We make decisions based on the present, what we need and want now, and what we want to have and how we want to live our lives in the future. You sound like you are very fond and love your ex but it does sound like you and he have different visions of the future, of lifestyles. He is having a difficult time and it’s hard to see someone we love go through that. You are allowed to be happy, loved, fulfilled and if you want to be married, be married and have a family. Even if this man is your love I’d advise having three months of space so you can clear your head and really trust your feelings. Take care.

Olika · 22/06/2024 21:38

Listen, loving someone is not enough! In your 30s you should know by now that you don't have time to waste. You need to be with someone who you are compatible with and wants same things with same timeline. Someone who has those traits and qualities that you need in a life partner, someone who makes a great husband and father. You pining after a crap relationship with a man that isn't right is just wasting your time. And the more you waste time with wrong person the less time you have left with the right one.

Paganna · 22/06/2024 21:45

Btw - your user name: is that from the billy idol song / or the film les yeux sans visage?

pandasorous · 22/06/2024 22:04

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 21:01

I may never find anyone else who wants to commit. And I'll have still thrown away a good relationship.

so what? its better to be happy and single than unhappy and in a couple

frankly he sounds like an awful person who was treating you really badly. your cooking wasn't good enough? you weren't transparent with money? - all the while when you were subsidising him?

tbh that would be enough for me to tell him to fuck off. if he wants food cooked from scratch, he should do it himself.

you need therapy to find out why you have such low self esteem?

he was never going to committ to you. move on. block him. give yourself some time and therapy to not be such a pushover in the future and then think about relationships again.

being ND doesn't excuse him being awful to you.

and tbh what is making you feel depressed is your own circular thought process of wishing things were different and keeping fixated on the past. let go. go on a holiday. block him on every platform. take a deep breath. you deserve so much better

countcalculia · 22/06/2024 22:48

OP, he’s talking to you and using you for support until his dream woman comes along.

Don’t let him use like this. Block and delete him.

DorisDoesDoncaster · 22/06/2024 22:53

You did the right thing, you were not compatible with each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread