Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I threw away a perfectly good relationship

208 replies

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:13

of just under 4 years, and I have to live with my mistake now. It's a lesson learned anyway, I'll try to be a little more patient next time.
I'm 33, and my ex partner is 29, a few months off 30. I left before Christmas as he was reluctant about any sort of commitment and he didn't seem to be 100% sure about me, which hurt.
I just wish I'd waited longer and not given into societal pressures, or panicked about my age as I do still have time.

I believe he did love me, he had autism and ADHD and hadn't been in steady employment for a while as well as suffering with his mental health, so I did whatever I could to support him.

I had previously brought up the subject a year ago, and he wasn't ready. I brought it up again 6 months later, admittedly I was starting to get frustrated. lived with him for 3 years.

I've no interest whatsoever in an expensive ring or wedding, I was more than happy with a registry office. my parents offered to pay for a reception which was very nice of him but the point was that even with these things mentioned, he wasn't interested.
I wasn't saying we had to get married immediately, but I wanted to know if it could come in the next couple of years.
I explained that ideally I'd like to have a child in the next couple of years because of my age, but looking back, I have longer than expected.
I couldn't get a firm answer on any of the above, he kept changing his mind about wanting to get engaged, about 3 or 4 times. it was clear he wasn't ready.
He said it was so final, none of his friends were married and it was like the end of his youth.

He felt he wasn't in a stable financial situation which I do understand, particularly re the children, but it doesn't have to cost anything to be engaged and we could've sorted a small wedding.

ok I thought, maybe I can wait a bit longer. I asked him if I was the one for him and he said he thought so? didn't say yeah of course.
I asked him if he could see himself with me in a few years and he couldn't answer it.

I left. I just went to my parents for a bit to get some space, thinking we might work things out. it wasn't a this is over forever, I just told him there's no point coming back right away as nothing could change.

He didn't seem surprised and told me he wants the above but is scared of responsibility. I did express a lot of remorse to him back in January and say that I still wanted to sort things out. I asked him if he wanted me to come back and he said he couldn't answer it.

so I did try to sort things out fairly soon after. he said he thinks he's put me in a difficult position, I told him I wasn't blaming him at all and he was entitled to not want these things.

we've actually been in touch constantly and are on great terms, just feel like I threw something great away. I should've been more patient and just given it at least another year or two, but it's too late. With hindsight, I'd rather just be with him, the rest doesn't matter.

Does it sound like I was an idiot? also, because of his job situation I paid more of the rent, which put a strain on because I couldn't afford it. However I have a better paid job now and I hoped it would change things.
I'm still supporting him with stuff. breaks seem to work for some but not for me, apparently his Mum and sister hate me, which hurts because I thought we got on really well.
I was an idiot who panicked and compared myself to others.

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 22/06/2024 18:50

You made the right decision. He was using you. Yes, it’s easy to have fantasies about how it would all have been different blah blah but it wouldn’t have been. In your dreams he’s a different person, in real life the problems he has would remain. Personally it sounds like he’s using his ND as an excuse.

Cut contact. If you feel unkind doing it all at once, do it over a few weeks, reducing the talk to every other day, then twice a week, once a week, leave it a fortnight, then cut things entirely. Your image of him sounds nothing like the reality. Forget the good times you had. Even loser and users can be good company sometimes.

You deserve better.

TheStateOfTheArt · 22/06/2024 18:50

You’ve posted about him before, haven’t you? The plan comment, I’m sure I remember that. If you are the same poster, you’ve done the right thing. He would never change and never give you what you want.

RIP the band aid off and go no contact. Get out and see friends, have fun. Someone lovely will turn your head and you will wonder what the hell you ever saw in him.

Whiskeywithoutice · 22/06/2024 18:56

Most men who want to marry you don't muck you around for four years and tell you that they're still not ready. They want to put a ring on your finger and get you off the market.

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 18:57

You are right. I am trying to kid myself that I'd be ok with waiting another 2,3,4+ years but the truth is that I'd probably feel resentful seeing people around me progressing, going to weddings and so on.
I think he did see marriage as signing his life away, but I just wonder why he stayed with me 4 years.

When I left, he got a little teary and said he missed me so much and was looking at houses, but that was it.

OP posts:
NotSoHotMess24 · 22/06/2024 18:58

Sounds like you dodged a bullet tbh. Better to go it alone re motherhood, than be shackled to some feckless twat.

On a practical note, might be a good idea to get your ovarian reserve checked, if you are definite you want children. Chances are you "still have time", as you put it. But some unlucky people at 33 are on the decline, fertility wise.

TheaBrandt · 22/06/2024 18:58

If he wanted to marry you he would have. Dh was dropping hints about marriage 3 months in. Also he sounds like an absolute loser so not sure why you are pining about him.

GinForBreakfast · 22/06/2024 18:59

You definitely did the right thing! Look to the future, it's going to be good, I promise!

AlpineMuesli · 22/06/2024 18:59

Sunk cost fallacy. Except at least with a dodgy car when you sell it you get some money back.

AlpineMuesli · 22/06/2024 19:01

I just wonder why he stayed with me 4 years.

Because it was easier for him.

mountaingoatsarehairy · 22/06/2024 19:04

‘When I left, he got a little teary and said he missed me so much and was looking at houses, but that was it’

lol after four years ! A little teary?!

if this is real then please get some help to unpick why you settled for this relationship. Where you did 80% of the work.

WitcheryDivine · 22/06/2024 19:04

Can I ask, does he smoke a lot of weed? He sounds uncannily like an ex of mine who did. That combined with his MH issues sapped any planning for the future at that point. I’m so glad that I didn’t hang around what turned out to be another decade to sort himself out and I went on to meet someone who was a) absolutely delightful and self sufficient b) ready to propose 2 years in.

You need to bite the bullet and stop messaging him every day, he’s still occupying your boyfriend seat so you can’t find someone else or see what a lucky escape you’ve had. Anyone who can even say that about you not cooking from scratch with a straight face is a complete pillock, unless you are both professional athletes and he cooked beautiful meals from scratch at least 50% of the time. Did he?

LionBarPlease · 22/06/2024 19:06

I just wanted something, anything

Evidently. This is your problem.

I just wonder why he stayed with me 4 years

Why not? You subsidised him emotionally, financially and physically with nothing in return. No issue for him to continue with the status quo even when knowing he’s destroying your chances of having a family. True love eh? Now you’re showing him you’re willing to come back for round two, so you’ve truly given up.

JawJaw · 22/06/2024 19:07

AlpineMuesli · 22/06/2024 19:01

I just wonder why he stayed with me 4 years.

Because it was easier for him.

Maybe because it was easier for him. Maybe because you are an interesting, attractive and supportive person. A lovable person. He probably loved you, maybe still does. But how does that change anything ? You are incompatible. You do not want the same things and he did not put as much into the relationship as you. You could have been madly in love with each other but that does not change the fact that you are really unsuited.

Starseeking · 22/06/2024 19:15

You've been together 4 years, 3 of those living together, and he's not sure whether he wants to get married?

You did the right thing in leaving him OP.

He may want to get married down the line, however it's clear from his actions that he doesn't want to marry you.

Your best bet is to move on from this man, ideally block his number as you are waiting and hoping in vain that he will change his mind. Find a man who loves being with you and can't wait to marry you, not someone who is reluctant.

TheShiningCarpet · 22/06/2024 19:17

You did not make a mistake…the only mistake is to stay connected with this guy, get some therapy and explore your self esteem…you deserve better. Don’t waste any more time being his maybe person.

Frangipanyoul8r · 22/06/2024 19:21

You did the right thing, you deserve someone who shouts from the rooftops about how much they love you. Not someone who just isn’t sure.

OperationDinnerout · 22/06/2024 19:25

i made a mistake of a lovley relationship 20 years ago, if things had been different then it would be the whole package by now.

Monkin · 22/06/2024 19:30

OP when they love someone men are generally pretty clear about what they want. Don’t waste any more time on this person who is not that into you. He is a classic candidate for stringing you along for several more years until you’re too old to have children, then falling for someone ten years younger than you, marrying them & having children with them in quick succession, leaving you behind in the dust (as happened to 2 friends of mine who hung on in similar situations). If you move on now, there’s a strong chance there’s someone out there who’s right for you & who will want you & all the things you want -don’t miss out on that by hanging on to this. You’ve been very sensible and dodged a bullet here. Of course you’re going to miss him & wonder if you’ve done the right thing - but know you have. There’s no upside to staying with someone who has shown you this clearly that he is not that into you. How can you help yourself move on?

CreamStick · 22/06/2024 19:37

His mother and sister hate you because they didn't want him living back home and I bet they are seething because they now have to deal with him .

RedHelenB · 22/06/2024 19:41

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 17:35

I just feel like he could've been ready in a couple of years, if only I'd been more patient. I don't even care that much about marriage now, I just felt the pressure from constantly seeing people my age or younger doing it.

I have apologised profoundly to him, expressed my regret. He told me he's just having a rubbish time in life because of being ND and his life situation.

So listen to what he's saying. He's not saying he wants to be with you is he?

youreeyeswithoutaface · 22/06/2024 19:42

RedHelenB · 22/06/2024 19:41

So listen to what he's saying. He's not saying he wants to be with you is he?

Just feel like he'd never want to give me a second chance because I left him and hurt him.

OP posts:
TheArtfulWriter · 22/06/2024 19:45

Sorry OP but I've seen so many posts like yours 'ND' me that I have to be blunt. It's a bullshit excuse.
I have ADHD, married to an autistic man. He has a great job, kind, committed proposed after 2 years and basically amazing 😍 I mean yeah he has his flaws, don't we all.
But he's never pulled any of the crap I read on here that erm NT men also do!

You deserve better.

Also even if you have a great maternity package. You don't know how the birth will go. Or how your child will be. Autism and ADHD are highly hereditary. If he cannot even commit or hold down a job. How is he going to cope pulling his weight with a special needs child. You could be injured or take a long time to recover post birth, etc.

If your relationship isn't even strong at the beginning there's no chance of it surviving any of these challenges I'm afraid. It's better to be alone than be burdened with someone incompetent

Fatportfolio65 · 22/06/2024 19:51

The thing is op, love is not enough.

You can love someone but if the timing isn’t right, one of you isn’t financially stable, one of you requires a lot of emotional support, then it’s not a viable relationship in which to bring dc.

You did the right thing 💐

itsmabeline · 22/06/2024 19:57

What if you had waited and got to 36, 37, 38, 39, 40 and he still didn't want to marry you?
Who can you have kids with after that? Still a chance but much much less likely.

You did yourself a favour.

And what does "I'm still supporting him with stuff." mean? Do you mean you are still financially supporting him with stuff?

He was getting all the benefit without the commitment so it would be convenient for him to just continue the arrangement indefinitely. You might have never married and never had kids and thrown away your chance at a family because of him.

You saved yourself and got out.
Now make sure in future relationships that the general idea of getting married and having kids is something they would consider or expect in the first 4 years.

molotovcupcakes · 22/06/2024 19:57

You will end up mothering him at your expense.
40% of men do not have children and many of them don’t want children. Sounds like he is in the 40% and there’s nothing you can do about it.