Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this weird of me at work?

334 replies

Handsomesquidward · 02/06/2024 11:32

I'm a straight woman, I work in a semi-formal office environment. We have a young girl there who has beautiful long, blonde Rapunzel hair and who is just beautiful in general.
I haven't really spoken to her as she's in another department. I saw this girl and I just said 'Hi I hope you don't mind me saying, just wanted to say I really love your hair, you look beautiful!'
She seemed really happy I'd said it and appreciated it.
My other colleague was in the toilets too and had heard, she told me it was really weird and creepy id said that.
I feel so embarrassed now and wonder if I shouldn't have said anything. I was just trying to be nice, I imagine some women would be very jealous of her and she gets some cattiness, I don't think I said anything inappropriate.
Just wondered what others think? Surely it's a sad world where you can't compliment people.

OP posts:
PenguinLord · 07/06/2024 17:00

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 03/06/2024 17:27

If you don't get it then you don't but making twattish comments isn't called for.

We're all coming at this from our own perspectives, our lived experiences and they're not going to be the same, are they? I took a colleague to grievance because he kept touching me. Being at a work event with him was excruciating. All he did was introduce me almost as a 'bit of fluff'. I knew those colleagues better than he did having worked with them for years. His comments of my ability and contribution to the business were that I 'looked a million dollars'.

If anybody perceives that as a compliment then so be it. I didn't hence the grievance. The workplace is somewhere that most women are at an immediate detriment purely because they are not men. It's not fair, it's not right and it's nearly always the case that the woman does the job better and is better qualified for it. Framing a compliment in a work setting isn't comparable with doing the same in a pub or supermarket or any other non-work arena.

It is always the person who 'doesn't want' who should prevail. Not just for this but for a host of other situations also. Things that other people want to do or say to other people are at their invitation. I know that complimenting women (particularly) can feel like such a non-event, it's a nice thing to do - and it is. If that person welcomes it. Many women do which is why this thread is popular but some women really don't like it.

For safety then, better to compliment where you know you really will make someone's day. If you're not sure and you batter on regardless and receive a jaded grimace in return, you'll know that they'd rather that you hadn't.

If you've never put a foot wrong in your life then you won't know what I'm talking about but, if you have ever committed a faux pas then perhaps you will understand.

Edited

Firstly, I am sorry for your experiences with sexual harrassment, but you need to stop projecting abnormal situations onto normal interactions and treat inappropriate touching in the same way as someone saying a spontanous one-off comment about your hair. just because you had a horrible experience that is not normal does not mean that the whole world should stop normal interractions between each other.
Am I supposed to ask "Will I make your day with a compliment?" each time before saying anything? You're now being ridiculous.
Id rather chance it and give 99.99% of people have a better day than not say anything to anyone.
If someone says a random 'nice dress'- are you now going to take them all to grievance because of that one experience? If 'for safety' you want to avoid pleasant interactions with people and if you still feel uneasy about people saying genuine and nice stuff, then you need to consider therapy as this is not normal.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/06/2024 11:55

You're so desperate to keep this stupid thread going, PenguinLord. I really don't give a fig what you think about anything and your fake wittering about my experiences.

I'm not going to answer your questions or respond again but stop telling other women how they should feel about your views on complimenting. You don't get it. Got that. I won't be responding but feel free to hector along in this echo-chamber all you like.

PiIIock · 08/06/2024 12:02

You need to wear a badge rather than expecting the whole world to know exactly what you want and change to suit you.

TheEyesOfLucyJordon · 08/06/2024 12:10

HasToStop · 02/06/2024 18:44

As a dyed-in-the wool Gen X, I won't be applying the fundamentals of sexism and infantilism of women, peer reviewed or not, every time I want to pay someone a compliment as long as I know it comes from a good place. The terminally offended can kiss my menopausal behind.

@HasToStop I think you may be my long lost sister ...... ☺️

TheEyesOfLucyJordon · 08/06/2024 12:20

Summerbay23 · 02/06/2024 22:46

Seems like I’m going against the grain but would really people didn’t comment on my physical appearance at work. I’m happy for someone to say ‘nice blouse, where did you get it’. But commenting on my hair looking beautiful I’d feel strange about.

People frequently compliment my hair. I shave my head and then have beautiful, and very colourful, hair art painted in. It would be quite weird if everyone in the office pretended not to notice. I mean, it'd be absolutely fine but people do tend to comment.

Likewise if someone on my team had a dramatic colour change or restyle, it'd feel strange beyond belief for me not to offer a compliment 😮🤷

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 08/06/2024 13:38

DancingNotDrowning · 07/06/2024 07:58

The examples you've listed are nothing like the sort of pass remarkable comment which is under discussion here

They’re similar in brevity, intent and pertenece and as the many posts on MN will attest, people also object to having doors held open and being asked about their weekends.

but they are whether you like it or not part of normal social exchange. To declare having to thank people for compliments as tiresome is really overstating the effort involved in engaging in the cultural contract.

Once again I am convinced that the Venn diagram of people complaining about this nonsense and the myriad posters wondering why they have no friends is a circle.

Edited

The examples given by Pillock are absolutely nothing like making unasked for comments on personal appearance. Pillock seems to have considerable difficulty distinguishing between what are acceptable workplace interactions and what isn't.

Holding a door open or passing over a cup of coffee are helpful actions, intended to be helpful. Of course you would thank the person.

Asking about how someone's weekend was, potentially strays into not acceptable because the questioner may well know nothing about the person's life outside work and it's presumptuous to expect answers. If the response is a one word "fine" - then the questioner should leave it. You (general you) have no right to know anymore about colleagues' life outside work than the colleague chooses to tell you.

On the other hand if the question was "how was the Taylor Swift show" because the questioner knew her colleague was going to it - perfectly fine.

I was discussing this thread with the head of my firm's HR department and the head of our training department last night at a work social event. HR head's advice on "paying compliments" was that the "love your dress/bag/shoes/coat etc, etc" where did you get it?" ones are fine. It's an acknowledgement of something the person being "complimented" on is in control of. The conversation arose partly because of this thread and partly because the male head of training, like many of the female attendees but none of the other male attendees, had made an effort to dress up. His outfit was extremely stylish and he was pleased I commented on it. That comment was on his clothes - not his looks.

In HR head's view the "ooh you're beautiful/ you look beautiful" ones are not acceptable in a work place.

PenguinLord · 08/06/2024 18:14

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/06/2024 11:55

You're so desperate to keep this stupid thread going, PenguinLord. I really don't give a fig what you think about anything and your fake wittering about my experiences.

I'm not going to answer your questions or respond again but stop telling other women how they should feel about your views on complimenting. You don't get it. Got that. I won't be responding but feel free to hector along in this echo-chamber all you like.

Take your own advice about not dictating others what to say and think and jog on with a cookie. 😎

PiIIock · 08/06/2024 18:23

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle just so you know, you claiming that one normal interaction isn't comparable to another normal interaction doesn't make it so.

God knows why you're so averse to compliments and positive social interaction but you do you.

Sounds exhausting to be this bothered about something that probably doesn't happen all that often. If you get one say thank you and move on like everyone else, sheesh.

Wear a badge of it means that much to you and people will steer clear

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 08/06/2024 20:38

PiIIock · 08/06/2024 18:23

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle just so you know, you claiming that one normal interaction isn't comparable to another normal interaction doesn't make it so.

God knows why you're so averse to compliments and positive social interaction but you do you.

Sounds exhausting to be this bothered about something that probably doesn't happen all that often. If you get one say thank you and move on like everyone else, sheesh.

Wear a badge of it means that much to you and people will steer clear

That post is so incomprehensible and incoherent it's actually impossible to respond to. Although it confirms your inability to compare like with like.

You also a quite remarkable capacity for twisting and reinventing what other posters have said; although that capacity may well simply be tied to your lack of understanding what has been written.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread