Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this CF or AIBU?

299 replies

CFornot123 · 27/05/2024 18:25

It’s a money one!

Recently came into some money (not insignificant to me but not significant either). I haven’t made it widely known and only told a couple of very close relatives (let’s call one of them relative A) but asked them not to tell anyone. Yesterday at Sunday lunch, relative B was telling me about a new hobby (an expensive one) they’ve decided to start but they’re struggling to afford to buy the required equipment.
This morning I got a message from relative B asking if I’d mind buying them the equipment they need for their hobby as a gift (approx 2k in all). Turns out relative A told them all about the windfall, how much and told relative B I’d buy them what they needed.
AIBU to think both A and B are out of order? I asked A not to tell anyone and had no reason to assume they would. Why should I fund B’s new expensive hobby? If they can’t afford it then choose something different? Or should I give them the money they need?

edited to add that relative B wasn’t one of the people I personally told so should not have known

OP posts:
Springwatch123 · 28/05/2024 12:50

greenpolarbear · 28/05/2024 12:10

How about some hobbies for the under 60s

Don’t be agist! I’m sure there’s plenty of 75 year old burlesque dancers out there!

TinyTear · 28/05/2024 12:53

I would think A a parent and B the golden child sibling...

or A golden child sibling and B the nephew / niece

sunnyday81 · 28/05/2024 12:57

I would not be funding a hobby. Partly as a hobby is a luxury and not needed, partly they asked (you didn’t offer) and partly as you wouldn’t see the money back and it’s a lot!!! Where will it end? Will another relative expect money for their hobby / cost of living rising. I think Relative B is very cheeky and I wouldn’t be sharing anything personal with relative A again.

Hi relative B, lovely to see you. Relative A might have got her wires crossed. Unfortunately, I don’t have lots of money spare. I’ve invested some money recently but this is money I can’t access for a few years, while I save for a medical procedure / home improvements / dentistry / trip of a lifetime that I’ve always dreamed off (insert reason here that fits you - doesn’t have to be truthful!)

gardenmusic · 28/05/2024 12:58

If OP simply refuses the hobby, there will be further CF invasions.

Where is OP's line in the sand? Education, Medical? Bailiffs? Car repairs?
Being evicted? Can't have the heating on? Insert your own sob story.
Really, best if 'the money has gone', or 'cannot be accessed'.
OP, save yourself from yourself.

CFs are CFs by nature, they will not miss an opportunity, and all the time they think the money is there, they will want it. In their minds it is already due to them.

I would be surprised if B is the only person A has told.

Nanaof1 · 28/05/2024 13:09

gardenmusic · 28/05/2024 12:58

If OP simply refuses the hobby, there will be further CF invasions.

Where is OP's line in the sand? Education, Medical? Bailiffs? Car repairs?
Being evicted? Can't have the heating on? Insert your own sob story.
Really, best if 'the money has gone', or 'cannot be accessed'.
OP, save yourself from yourself.

CFs are CFs by nature, they will not miss an opportunity, and all the time they think the money is there, they will want it. In their minds it is already due to them.

I would be surprised if B is the only person A has told.

I agree💯. Betting that A has done everything but put out a TV news blurb.

I also agree that if OP just says "no" to the hobby, that more needs/wants/begs will emerge until the OP falls for some scheme.

Saying "I have invested it, paid off debts/mortgage or put it into my pension" releases OP from any other beggary that might ensue.

KanyeJohnWestTuna · 28/05/2024 13:18

Once you’ve said “no” to the cheekiness, you’ll feel stronger about saying no in future.

Nazzywish · 28/05/2024 13:39

I think you know the answer and can't believe your even asking. Both to be told where to go.

Nazzywish · 28/05/2024 13:40

If you say yes. Be prepared for it to be the first of many requests from every person known to you

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/05/2024 13:47

Definitely say no. I would agree with those suggesting saying something that precludes
further requests - “the money is all earmarked to go towards my mortgage/ investments/pension” or whatever, or better that it has already gone to those things.

I also would like to hear from @CFornot123 again to see what the relationship is!

LaWench · 28/05/2024 14:08

Your Mum shouldn't have told your Brother (I'm assuming). but YANBU to tell them both to sod off.

YorkNew · 28/05/2024 14:19

I wouldn’t even answer relative B’s message and never ever mention money to relative A again.

Silvers11 · 28/05/2024 14:20

YANBU

But you know now you can't trust A!

Viviennemary · 28/05/2024 14:28

Well if you didn't want folk to know you shouldn't have told anybody. But even so they are incredibly out of order expecting you to pay for stuff for them.

ArrrMeHearties · 28/05/2024 14:29

Both are cheeky fuckers. Relative a for opening their mouth and relative b for thinking that you will happily buy them a 2k gift

SirAlfredSpatchcock · 28/05/2024 14:37

Viviennemary · 28/05/2024 14:28

Well if you didn't want folk to know you shouldn't have told anybody. But even so they are incredibly out of order expecting you to pay for stuff for them.

I know it's probably more discreet not to say anything, but why shouldn't you be able to mention to somebody that you've come into a bit of money without them taking that as code for 'you must have some of it'?

After all, if you tell people you've just got married, nobody takes that as you telling them that they can have a go on your husband!

Mothership4two · 28/05/2024 14:38

"err yes I would mind actually, so no". Did either of them give a reason why you should be expected to pay for it OP?

I'd also be having words with A about confidentiality and never confide in them again.

Penguinfeet24 · 28/05/2024 14:46

Easy one - both CF's!! Id' be telling B that no, I will not be funding their hobby, if they can't afford it then they can't take it up, and telling A that they have now caused an argument with B because they can't keep their mouth shut. Nice work dickhead 🙄

WhereYouLeftIt · 28/05/2024 14:58

StripeyDeckchair · 27/05/2024 18:44

Both are out of order
A for not respecting your confidence (& now you know never to tell them anything again)
B for thinking anyone except themselves might fund their expensive hobby.

Both need to be firmly put in their place.

  • Dear A, I am upset & disappointed you did not respect my privacy & told B of my news.
  • Dear B, I hope you enjoy your expensive new hobby. I fail to see why you think I should fund this hobby - I certainly won't.
I have placed my recent inheritance in long term investments for my future.

Excellent responses to two Cheeky Fuckers.

"relative A told them all about the windfall, how much and told relative B I’d buy them what they needed."
I might also tell relative B (Golden Child sibling?) that surely relative A (narcissistic parent?) must have meant that they themselves would be funding B's new hobby, surely? I'd be sowing dissent between them (just for fun, you understandGrin).

"Why should I fund B’s new expensive hobby? If they can’t afford it then choose something different? Or should I give them the money they need?"
For starters, there is no "need" here, none whatsoever - there is only a 'want'. You should definitely not be funding this Cheeky Fucker's wants. Also, be aware that if you were to give them so much as a brass farthing, it would be the first of many requests they'd make, until they bled you dry. Relative A has, after all, informed them of the total amount of your windfall. They'd clearly feel entitled to it all. So be smart and send them off with a flea in their ear.

Soddingcat · 28/05/2024 15:00

UPDATE PLEASE !!!!

WomanMumLoverDaughterStepmumFriend · 28/05/2024 15:08

Absolutely not ok to expect others to pay hobbies for you ! The fact they assumed they could ask makes me wonder how good they are as people !

XiCi · 28/05/2024 15:12

I think we need to know who the close relatives are. I'd think differently about it if close relative B was your own child. Teen dd would definitely chance her luck at me buying her something expensive if I had a windfall 🤣 and tbh I'd want to share my good fortune with her. If you're talking about an aunty, cousin etc then yes they're a CF and I'd just message with a "haha, good try" or something similar

Sillystrumpet · 28/05/2024 15:12

Soddingcat · 28/05/2024 15:00

UPDATE PLEASE !!!!

Oh my 😱

SirAlfredSpatchcock · 28/05/2024 15:14

greenpolarbear · 28/05/2024 12:10

How about some hobbies for the under 60s

I Mumsnet as a hobby and I'm under 60.

I don't even earn anywhere near a six-figure salary!

TheDumpling · 28/05/2024 15:14

What a pair of entitles arseholes they are!

DON'T give B any money at all. B chose to take up such an expensive hobby and they want you to cough up 2 grand?

Tell them both to get stuffed and block them both from your life permanently.

MzHz · 28/05/2024 15:15

alibongo5 · 27/05/2024 18:31

No don't give B anything at all. And tell A that they are completely out of order for discussing your money when you had specifically told them not to.

Absolutely this. Make sure they both know how outrageously CF they have been, and tell them that you think differently of them as a result.