Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother-in-law wants me to formula feed and let her feed my baby

384 replies

Artmumcreative · 01/05/2024 21:34

I plan to exclusively breastfeed and have had this plan since before DH and I conceived. MIL came over today when DH was at work and told me that I need to have a bottle and formula. She desperately wants to feed my baby (once she's born!!!) but I want to breastfeed and I always have wanted to. I have friends that exclusively formula-feed and that's totally fine, they have medical reasons for not breastfeeding, and I appreciate that some people don't want to or can't breastfeed. I feel like MIL wants to take over my role as my baby's mother. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
AxolotlEars · 02/05/2024 17:15

Nope. I have a few kids and have breast fed and bottle fed. I actually treat bottle feeding like breast feeding, in that I'm the one who does it!

ItsAStateOfMind · 02/05/2024 17:20

Grow a stubborn streak, and quick.

No, I’ll be BFing “MY” baby.

Elphamouche · 02/05/2024 17:29

Runningbird43 · 02/05/2024 17:04

I actually found it the other way.

i didn’t have formula ready. I figured if breastfeeding didn’t go as planned, either the hospital would have some or Dh would be able to nip to a supermarket and get some. There’s usually a petrol station open 24 hr somewhere.

i am glad I didn’t. I had so much pressure to give formula, I’d probably have given in. Even in hospital, with bf going well, when a m/w saw my breastfeeding again (!) I got the spiel about giving formula so I could “have a break”- how? Dh wasn’t there, I didn’t see her volunteering, and not to “make it difficult for myself”. When I said I hadn’t brought formula she went off on one, saying how did I know I could bf, when I was clearly sat in front of her breastfeeding! Then she went and got the lady next door a ready made bottle when she ran out of what she’d brought, no drama.

when I got home yes it was as hard, but I found cluster feeding on an evening I’d promise myself we’d go get formula tomorrow and I’d quit. Then the next day didn’t seem so bad, so I’d give it one more day. “One more day” got me to 4 weeks, then 8, then 12, by then it was easy and I didn’t even think about it.

if I’d had formula in I think I’d have weakened and given in. I’m glad I didn’t, as I bf for nearly 2 years in the end, and once over the difficult first few weeks it was really easy.

I couldn’t physically hold my baby up after giving birth, people had to try and hold her to my breast which was really difficult.

She became dehydrated and really jaundice. We also really struggled (5 supermarkets!) one day to get the bottles when we were running out. So personally I would recommend having them for your peace of mind. No one needs to know you have them other than you. You don’t have to use them.

I had no pressure either way from the hospital, but when she clearly wasn’t getting enough and wasn’t alert from the jaundice, I had to step up the formula.

l enjoy breast feeding, she latches beautifully and I’m one of the few who genuinely believes it doesn’t hurt (for me personally) . She will feed multiple times a day for 15or so mins, or she’ll feed for a full hour, but there are days when it’s just not enough.

im genuinely glad it worked for you, but I can’t describe the panic we felt when we couldn’t get the milk she’d been having and she was dehydrated and jaundice, the fear that o was letting her down and making her ill because she wasn’t suckling for more than 5/6 strokes on the breast and would just sleep. It’s something I will never go through again. The bottles were recommended by a friend who has EBF from day one, but had a backup.

the hospital used SMA and the teats were too big for her so she wasn’t feeding well on those either.

LookItsMeAgain · 02/05/2024 17:31

Your baby, you are the mother here and what your MiL wants is dalooloo!

She can feed baby from expressed breast milk if she wants to feed baby in a few months time or baby is fed exclusively by you at all times but it's your decision, not hers.

What does your DH say about his mother's demands?

Artmumcreative · 02/05/2024 17:59

DH got home really late from work (he works in hospitality) and gave me a hug and said he's told me what my MIL's like and I don't have to see her. I suspect she'll worm her way in though, she's extremely forceful and I'm extremely kind.

OP posts:
Starlightstarbright3 · 02/05/2024 18:09

You need stock statements ready

that isn’t our plan .
we won’t be doing that .
No
I think you have to be blunt with people like this .

if you feel overwhelmed by her - tell Dh to have a word

PurpleH · 02/05/2024 18:14

If you do decide to ever do a bottle (you may need to or decide to combi feed or might express a breast milk bottle) I suggest you don’t let her feed it to the baby out of principle. She doesn’t get to dictate anything about YOUR baby, feeding included. Why do grandparents feel so entitled??

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 02/05/2024 18:32

Jesus Christ she can't feed your baby if you don't let her. You don't need to go NC or anything dramatic.

Did she really come over and tell you you "need" to bottle feed? Or just that she'd love to feed the baby.

Either way just smile and nod and do what you what this is your baby not hers.

sandyhappypeople · 02/05/2024 18:32

PurpleH · 02/05/2024 18:14

If you do decide to ever do a bottle (you may need to or decide to combi feed or might express a breast milk bottle) I suggest you don’t let her feed it to the baby out of principle. She doesn’t get to dictate anything about YOUR baby, feeding included. Why do grandparents feel so entitled??

This.

To be honest the less said about it the better, don't get drawn into a discussion with her, I really hope it all goes how you want it to, but anything can and does happen and you don't want her to think that if you do end up bottle feeding that she then has free reign to do as she likes with your baby, you may need to stand up to her and make sure your DH is fully on board to fight your corner no matter what, over lots of different issues by the sounds of it!

FWIW I wanted to breast feed and really struggled, could never figure out really why as I had supply, I persevered for 6 months by exclusively pumping in the end so she was bottle fed, but to be honest it was nice for my DH as he got to feed her too. There were so many ups and downs during that process though and at times I felt a complete failure, my sister never could breastfeed either and she felt like a failure for it.

My point is, try not to put all your stock in breastfeeding, as sometimes it just doesn't happen, and that's fine, but it can be hard to come to terms with, especially if you've got people like your MIL waiting in the wings to say I told you so, best to keep your options open and tell your MIL to get stuffed whatever happens!

Hotchocolateand5marshmellows · 02/05/2024 18:37

Yanbu. I'd avoid conversations about it and just carry on with breastfeeding once baby arrives and explain that's what you're doing. Mine wouldn't even take a bottle after 6 weeks of breastfeeding.

It might be worth buying a couple of bottles and a breast pump though in case you ever want to try pumping and feeding your baby that way.

LightDrizzle · 02/05/2024 19:12

Artmumcreative · 02/05/2024 17:59

DH got home really late from work (he works in hospitality) and gave me a hug and said he's told me what my MIL's like and I don't have to see her. I suspect she'll worm her way in though, she's extremely forceful and I'm extremely kind.

That’s a great update!

Feel no guilt about saying no. I’d definitely tel l her that if you bottle feed for any reason, it will only be you and sometimes DH feeding as per current advice.

AVFC4eva · 02/05/2024 19:14

Artmumcreative · 01/05/2024 21:34

I plan to exclusively breastfeed and have had this plan since before DH and I conceived. MIL came over today when DH was at work and told me that I need to have a bottle and formula. She desperately wants to feed my baby (once she's born!!!) but I want to breastfeed and I always have wanted to. I have friends that exclusively formula-feed and that's totally fine, they have medical reasons for not breastfeeding, and I appreciate that some people don't want to or can't breastfeed. I feel like MIL wants to take over my role as my baby's mother. Am I being unreasonable?

My mother in law was a bit like this. Expecting me to allow others to feed. I just ignored her and cracked on. She got over it. It's not her business. She's been a mum.

Frangipanyoul8r · 02/05/2024 19:15

“That’s a nice idea but that won’t work for me” I find is a good way of saying no to pushing MILs

Noseybookworm · 02/05/2024 19:22

Artmumcreative · 02/05/2024 17:59

DH got home really late from work (he works in hospitality) and gave me a hug and said he's told me what my MIL's like and I don't have to see her. I suspect she'll worm her way in though, she's extremely forceful and I'm extremely kind.

Surely there's a midway between letting her walk all over you and not seeing her at all? You say you're 'extremely kind' but that doesn't mean you can't stand up for yourself. Just tell her firmly and calmly what you plan to do and you will appreciate the family's help and support in feeding the baby yourself. Once she sees that you're prepared to be assertive and speak your mind, I bet she'll back off.

Getonwitit · 02/05/2024 19:22

YABU but only because you didn't tell her there and then that you will be breastfeeding your baby and what anyone else wants is not important. Stick up for yourself and our baby.

Whatifthehokeycokey · 02/05/2024 19:58

Your mother in law had her chance to feed her children as she wished. Now it's your turn.

StaunchMomma · 02/05/2024 21:31

Whatifthehokeycokey · 02/05/2024 19:58

Your mother in law had her chance to feed her children as she wished. Now it's your turn.

Exactly this.

Tell her it's not her choice to make. End of.

Flopsy145 · 02/05/2024 21:58

It's not her decision and the weirdest thing here is she thinks that it is. I would be distancing myself from her tbh she sounds very overbearing. Feed your child how you like, even if she was bottle fed you absolutely do not have to let you mil feed her if you would rather do it yourself. She's yours and your partner's child, no one else has a say

BoudiccaOfSuburbia · 03/05/2024 07:25

OP: being ‘extremely kind’ in this context means putting your baby and your baby’s needs first. Your decision is to breastfeed (if all goes well) as your way of giving your baby the best start in life.

You don’t compromise your baby’s needs to satisfy your MIL’s wants.

makiandmango · 03/05/2024 09:13

BoudiccaOfSuburbia · 03/05/2024 07:25

OP: being ‘extremely kind’ in this context means putting your baby and your baby’s needs first. Your decision is to breastfeed (if all goes well) as your way of giving your baby the best start in life.

You don’t compromise your baby’s needs to satisfy your MIL’s wants.

This.
You have so many great suggestions here as to what to say if she brings it up again. She gets absolutely no say in how you feed your baby.

ItsAStateOfMind · 03/05/2024 09:26

OK, this might not work for everyone, but this has worked for me.

I have had a few overbearing and controlling people in my life. Also, a few very negative people who criticised my decisions. On one side I had someone trying to take over my baby, and on the other I had people saying "your baby isn't getting enough milk", and "jarred food is better than home made". I could have easily caved, but I didn't because of a few factors;

  1. I soon realised that I didn't know what I was doing when my baby was born. I had read loads of books up until the day of birth, but after that I didn't have a clue. Have good resources to hand; books, someone you trust, Mumsnet and be ready to ask questions. Get on MN and ask; "how do I do this?" That way people who think they know better, but don't, can't influence you. For example, when someone pushed back about me breastfeeding, I had hard facts about the benefits not only to stubbornly shore up my own decision, but to shut others up.

  2. Get your DH on side. I am BFing, this is what you need to do to support me. You need to bring me drinks, set up the sofa, tell your mum this is what we are doing, don't be making comments to my wife.

  3. Prepare for breastfeeding. What do you need? Are you going to pump? What's the most effective pump, how are you going to store it? You might want to pump and freeze so you have back up. That way if baby needs extra, you have it, rather than someone looming over you telling you to formula feed.

I know this sounds like great lengths but it really helped me. Just because someone had a baby 30 years ago doesn't mean they know what they were talking about. In fact, I was amazed at how outdated some opinions were.

Lsquiggles · 03/05/2024 09:57

"No I won't be doing that". The end.

Put boundaries and expectations in place now before she tries to manipulate you when baby is here

J0S · 03/05/2024 10:08

Artmumcreative · 02/05/2024 17:59

DH got home really late from work (he works in hospitality) and gave me a hug and said he's told me what my MIL's like and I don't have to see her. I suspect she'll worm her way in though, she's extremely forceful and I'm extremely kind.

Of course you don’t have to see her! Your maternity leave is for the physical and mental health of you and your baby, it’s not for anyone else . Your MIL has no rights whatsoever here.

Don’t have her to visit at all unless your husband is there, she is is his family not yours. She cannot “ worm her way in “ unless you let her . She cannot crawl through the keyhole and she’s not going to smash down the door or window is she ?

So she can only get in if you are foolish enough to allow her . So let your husband speak to her and arrange visits when he is home.

If she phones you, don’t pick up.

If she texts you, forward it to your husband to deal.

If she arrives at your front door when she is not invited, don’t answer the doorbell.

If she confronts you outside your house, say “ I’m afraid this isn’t a good time Betty as I’m just going out to an appointment, please arrange a time with Dh. Otherwise you will have a wasted journey “.

If she asks you in person “ can I come over next Tuesday , say “ I’m sorry that doesn’t work for me. Why don’t you speak to Dh and arrange a date with him, he will have his diary “.

If she says to your husband “ I phoned @Artmumcreative 47 times this week and she didn’t pick up “ , he needs to say “ she is busy with baby right now, it’s best to call me”.

You do all this very politely and calmly. You don’t need to argue with her or confront her - it won’t work as bullies thrive on fights and arguements and you will never win.

Just drop the rope and keep passing it all back to your husband.

It’s his mother, he needs to deal. I promise you that 99% of MIL problems can be dealt with by this firm, clear and polite approach.

If you had a lovely MIL who treated you with good manners and respect then you wouldn’t have to do this. But you don’t, so you do.

Nasty bullies don’t like other people having boundaries and they will kick back, call you weird or controlling ( yes you have a right to control your own life and your own tiny baby ) . But that’s what happens when you bully others - they either set up very firm boundaries or they go LC or even NC.

Remember @Artmumcreative , the more “ forceful “ she is and the more weak you are - the more you need to hold your boundaries. And no, doing what she wants rather than what’s best for your baby isn’t being “ kind “.

As soon as that baby is born, your first priority needs to be your baby’s welfare - not your making yourself look good to your MIL. You need to put baby first over your own self image and your need to be seen as nice.

Because for most people who say the are “ extremely kind “ - that’s what it’s about . They want to have an image of kindness and goodness - not that they actually want to make the sometimes tough decisions that life requires.

Often the “ kind “ people are the one who want others to do difficult things for them so they don’t have to.

Baby needs your “ kindness “ more than anyone in the world. Yeah I know that’s a hard gig, but it comes with being a mum.

And after baby , you need to be kind to yourself and then your husband . If you don’t start the way you mean to go on, this woman will make your life a misery. You will be on here in a few months complaining that she is running your maternity leave and precious time with your baby. And you and your Husband will be constantly fighting over her.

So put on your big girl pants now - you have many years of parenting ahead of you.

Cygnetmad · 03/05/2024 10:10

it's a non issue. your baby, your choice. I wouldn't even discuss it with her or justify my choices. it has nothing to do with her.

CHEESEY13 · 03/05/2024 10:12

She must have an un-diagnosed psychological condition. Or just wierd.

But, YOUR baby therefore YOUR rules.