Page 7 | To think Taylor Swift is overrated?

AngeloMysterioso · 04/06/2024 00:02

ZenParent · 03/06/2024 14:19

Of course you are not being unreasonable.

Her music is bland mainstream pop, there is nothing particularly innovative or creative in what she produces, and nothing in her lyrics shouts as exceptional either, it's just average pop lyrics targeting teenagers.

The point is that today's music industry is not really about the music itself, but much more about the stage persona, their social presence, the ability to teenagers to relate with them.

What has happened in the last 20-30 years in Korea and Japan, with the music being dominated by the "Idols" is now taking over the music industry in USA and Europe.

To be a music star, you need to be good-looking, young, fit, need to be great on the stage, good at dancing, performing and cultivate your social presence. Being a musician is a really minor part of that, and to some extent, irrelevant.

Most of the current stars have limited music knowledge, can hardly play an instrument and from a strictly perspective of their musical talent, mediocre at best. But that is now what the industry is about today, it is about creating idols.

Compare that to 40 years ago for example, where you could be one of the greatest band in the world and have as your frontman Mark Knopfler, not exactly the sexiest man in the world, but a genius with a guitar on his hands.

Today he would have zero chances of success, no one cares if you can actually play an instrument.

You’re talking utter crap.

Her music is definitely not targeted at teenagers. In one of the first lines in the first song of her new album she calls herself a functioning alcoholic. She sings about sex. She sings about death. She sings about miscarriage. She sings about misogyny and patriarchy and sexism. Definitely not lightweight teeny bopper fare. But that’s a criticism frequently levelled at her by people with only a very superficial awareness of her discography who caught a verse of Shake It Off on the radio ten years ago and figured that was all she had.

And yes there is an appetite for not outrageously talented but beautiful people in the popular music realm, as there has always been… but that doesn’t mean that talented but ungorgeous people never get through. One of the biggest male stars today is an average looking ginger bloke from Ipswich who makes a point of his shows being just him and his guitar on stage. One of the biggest female stars is a young woman who makes a point of wearing baggy clothes and no make up, with crazy dyed hair.

Anotherparkingthread · 04/06/2024 09:07

AngeloMysterioso · 04/06/2024 00:02

You’re talking utter crap.

Her music is definitely not targeted at teenagers. In one of the first lines in the first song of her new album she calls herself a functioning alcoholic. She sings about sex. She sings about death. She sings about miscarriage. She sings about misogyny and patriarchy and sexism. Definitely not lightweight teeny bopper fare. But that’s a criticism frequently levelled at her by people with only a very superficial awareness of her discography who caught a verse of Shake It Off on the radio ten years ago and figured that was all she had.

And yes there is an appetite for not outrageously talented but beautiful people in the popular music realm, as there has always been… but that doesn’t mean that talented but ungorgeous people never get through. One of the biggest male stars today is an average looking ginger bloke from Ipswich who makes a point of his shows being just him and his guitar on stage. One of the biggest female stars is a young woman who makes a point of wearing baggy clothes and no make up, with crazy dyed hair.

Show quote history

Recently it's been found out she's been using tactics to supress other female artists. So I don't know she has much business singing about misogy and sexism.

JamSandle · 04/06/2024 09:18

I'm not a fan of her music but I like her. I think she deserves her success and is mostly a great role model for girls.

beguilingeyes · 04/06/2024 10:09

I don't care how great a guitar player Mark Knopfler is/was....Dire Straits were one of the dullest bands there ever was. You couldn't escape that bloody Brothers In Arms album in the 80s. Instant Mogadon.

ZenParent · 04/06/2024 14:09

beguilingeyes · 04/06/2024 10:09

I don't care how great a guitar player Mark Knopfler is/was....Dire Straits were one of the dullest bands there ever was. You couldn't escape that bloody Brothers In Arms album in the 80s. Instant Mogadon.

You may not like the Dire Straits, that's fine, but that's not the point.

Mark Knopfler basically re-invented how to play guitar, as his picking technique just didn't exist before they way he did it.
He brought something new to the world of music, which has then been copied by thousands of guitarists all over the world and millions of people loved that because of his talent, not because of anything else. That is the point.

Taylor Swift isn't talented at playing any instrument, neither possess a particularly impressive voice, so what are we left with? Her songwriting skills? Neither that I am afraid.
Her music is written by an army of people, so with all likelihood what we hear is mostly written by Max Martin, Shellback and the Fairbrass brothers.. these are the same exact people that write the vast majority of the pop music which is in the top chart since the early 2000s, and which are performed by the "idols" people recognize. Max Martin and his aids have cracked the code on how to write pop music and they have been doing time and again for the last 25/30 years now... but it's always the same music, just with minor differences.

There is no innovation in harmony, melody or lyrics in anything she does.. there is a lot of terrific talent in commanding a presence on the stage, and running a massive musical business. She's exceptional, just not at music, but at entertainment, showmanship and business.

Karmaisaqueen · 04/06/2024 14:35

It’s that time of the week folks 😂

DaisyHaites · 04/06/2024 14:38

IncompleteSenten · 29/04/2024 12:43

From a singing pov I think most pop stars are, tbh.
There's very few amazing vocalists.
But that's only part of the job. Pr is another part and she and her team are first class in that area and cannot be said to be overrated. They have carefully created what could actually be called a cult of followers. People who worship her and become quite deranged in support of her.
Because of that she's currently worth what? Over a billion according to Google.

Overrated? You can't deny that from a marketing perspective, that is some bloody good going. I think that aspect is massively underrated if anything.

Edited

This. She’s a broadly appealing pop artist which on its own may make her seem overrated.

But she is an incredible business woman that has made her brand about way more than the music and her and her team are some of the greatest talents in marketing. I honestly don’t think her business acumen can be applauded enough.

DaisyHaites · 04/06/2024 14:45

ZenParent · 04/06/2024 14:09

You may not like the Dire Straits, that's fine, but that's not the point.

Mark Knopfler basically re-invented how to play guitar, as his picking technique just didn't exist before they way he did it.
He brought something new to the world of music, which has then been copied by thousands of guitarists all over the world and millions of people loved that because of his talent, not because of anything else. That is the point.

Taylor Swift isn't talented at playing any instrument, neither possess a particularly impressive voice, so what are we left with? Her songwriting skills? Neither that I am afraid.
Her music is written by an army of people, so with all likelihood what we hear is mostly written by Max Martin, Shellback and the Fairbrass brothers.. these are the same exact people that write the vast majority of the pop music which is in the top chart since the early 2000s, and which are performed by the "idols" people recognize. Max Martin and his aids have cracked the code on how to write pop music and they have been doing time and again for the last 25/30 years now... but it's always the same music, just with minor differences.

There is no innovation in harmony, melody or lyrics in anything she does.. there is a lot of terrific talent in commanding a presence on the stage, and running a massive musical business. She's exceptional, just not at music, but at entertainment, showmanship and business.

Show quote history

Isn’t her music latterly renowned for being written by her and her two producers? As distinct from the majority of pop music which is churned out?

I think some of her older albums had songs ‘manufactured’ in this way, but I think her rise has come more on the back of her writing herself.

I’m still not saying that she’s particularly talented at song writing (although she is good at it), but I think she should get credit for her contribution.

SummaLuvin · 04/06/2024 14:48

that time again when it feels suitable to point out that her 3rd album was entirely self written with no collaborators as by only 19 she was already fed-up with the presumptions and accusations that she wasn't responsible for much of the songwriting.

AngeloMysterioso · 04/06/2024 15:31

ZenParent · 04/06/2024 14:09

You may not like the Dire Straits, that's fine, but that's not the point.

Mark Knopfler basically re-invented how to play guitar, as his picking technique just didn't exist before they way he did it.
He brought something new to the world of music, which has then been copied by thousands of guitarists all over the world and millions of people loved that because of his talent, not because of anything else. That is the point.

Taylor Swift isn't talented at playing any instrument, neither possess a particularly impressive voice, so what are we left with? Her songwriting skills? Neither that I am afraid.
Her music is written by an army of people, so with all likelihood what we hear is mostly written by Max Martin, Shellback and the Fairbrass brothers.. these are the same exact people that write the vast majority of the pop music which is in the top chart since the early 2000s, and which are performed by the "idols" people recognize. Max Martin and his aids have cracked the code on how to write pop music and they have been doing time and again for the last 25/30 years now... but it's always the same music, just with minor differences.

There is no innovation in harmony, melody or lyrics in anything she does.. there is a lot of terrific talent in commanding a presence on the stage, and running a massive musical business. She's exceptional, just not at music, but at entertainment, showmanship and business.

Show quote history

Taylor Swift isn't talented at playing any instrument,

in your opinion

neither possess a particularly impressive voice,

in your opinion

so what are we left with? Her songwriting skills? Neither that I am afraid.

In your opinion. And there are literally millions of people around the world who disagree with you.

Her music is written by an army of people, so with all likelihood what we hear is mostly written by Max Martin, Shellback and the Fairbrass brothers..

Taylor Swift has written 243 songs across 11 albums, of which 21 (that’s fewer than 1 in 10) credit Max Martin and/or Shellback as a co-writer. None of which have been on her last four albums.

The Fairbrass brothers are credited as co-writers on Look What You Made Me Do for no reason other than the chorus being similar to I’m Too Sexy.

Her main collaborators on her last four albums have been Jack Antonoff and Aaron Dessner, with the occasional guest artist on one or two tracks. Not exactly an army…

So- once again- you’re talking utter crap.

Original poster

BillieTheFish · 04/06/2024 15:33

She plays a guitar doesn't she??

OP posts:

beguilingeyes · 04/06/2024 15:40

Mark Knopfler may well have done all of those things. It doesn't make his songs any less dreary. Technique isn't everything.
It's all about the songs.
You can play Neil Young's entire catalogue with about seven chords, but I'd rather listen to him any day.

OldHabitsDieScreaming · 04/06/2024 16:55

Her music is written by an army of people, so with all likelihood what we hear is mostly written by Max Martin, Shellback and the Fairbrass brothers.

It really, really isn't. That's just simply a false statement, easily checked.

Her voice - well, in my opinion her voice is utterly gorgeous and affecting. She may not have some of the technical fripperies of a Beyonce or whoever; she tends not to belt or use a load of vibrato, etc but she has a fantastic range and beautiful clarity / articulation. Her breath control is something else. Her voice suits the music she writes.

And as for making a spurious comparison with Mark bloody Knopfler - wtf? It's almost as funny as the poster on another recent thread who got their knickers in a twist about TS not having written Bohemian Rhapsody.

I'm interested as to why you revived this thread to slag off an artist that you hold in contempt - and clearly know fuck all about anyway. Still, you're not the first, and I don't expect you'll be the last to spend their precious time whining online about a woman who has the bare-faced audacity to... release popular music that doesn't float your personal boat.