This is exactly what I think. I think ‘dog whistle politics’ sums up the Tories’ approach to transgender issues really well.
I think the Tories have created and encouraged a moral panic over transgender people. It is entirely overblown and being used for political purposes, as the Tories are fully aware that transgender issues is a very sensitive and divisive issue and they are succeeding in making it more so.
This sounds a bit like the panic created over AIDS in the 1980s. Whilst that did sound like a frightening time to be living in, it led to a lot of absolutely unwarranted and upsetting consequences for gay men, such as being socially ostracised and generally very badly treated. I was born in the 90s, so wasn’t around in the 80s, but I’ve read and watched a lot about the AIDS epidemic and its impact.
I do realise that incidents do happen where men take advantage of women-only spaces, target vulnerable women or compete in women’s sports, to give a few examples, and they then escape the consequences that would have applied to them as men because they say they are transgender.
However, my main feeling on this is that it’s really important to put this into perspective. It’s important to remember that these sorts of incidents are really rare. Whilst they are frightening, they are not at all commonplace.
I think we owe transgender people our respect and kindness as they are human beings and need to be treated as such. Some of the press coverage I’ve seen - and the comments I’ve heard from people - makes it sound as if transgender people are not actually human, which is awful and upsetting.
The other thing that I often think when I’m thinking about this is that men already attack and kill women quite often, so if a man wants to attack, rape or kill a woman, why would he go to the enormous trouble of identifying as a woman when he could just as easily do it (and very possibly get away with it) as a man?