Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect parents to collect their child from my house

349 replies

Kanoe2 · 23/09/2023 00:34

DD friends use our house as a hang out in the evening after school. They are early teens. They don't have dinner with us but do have snacks and will leave between 6-8pm.

One of the friends has an expectation I will give her lift home every night. Her parents have never picked her up. She will only walk home if my DD escorts her. With the evenings drawing in I don't want my DD walking in the dark alone once she has dropped her home.

I have told this child that she needs to arrange getting home with her parents if she wants to come over. I am told by the child parents will collect her. Then on the evening, it will be an excuse why they can't collect her and I have to drive her home.

I have told DD if this child can not get home then she will no longer be able to come over everyday. This has caused tension between the girls.

AIBU?

OP posts:
CuriouslyMinded · 26/09/2023 09:37

UsingChangeofName · 23/09/2023 00:42

When she turned up, I'd be really clear "Sorry Issy, I won't be able to take you home this evening. Can you phone your Mum now and let her know so she can decide to either pick you up before 7, or does she want you to walk back home now, while it is still light?" then stand over her whilst she gets her phone out.
Repeat each time, until she gets the message.
Help your dd to see it makes no sense that her friend can't walk alone, but that her friend is expecting her to walk alone, so she can point that out to her friend if she raises it.

This ☝️ 100%

barofsoap · 26/09/2023 09:40

"Not seen the parents"
"not sure if anyone there when she gets home"
"parents don't want friends around the house"

red flags - something odd there, are the parents having an alcoholic binge every afternoon and are incapable of collecting her

Elfblossom · 26/09/2023 10:29

Pfannkuchen · 23/09/2023 00:41

I would love to know the reasoning of the people who voted "YABU".

Because ... others think calling a 12/13 yo child a 'cheeky fucker' instead of 'quite literally A child'.

And an OP who 'hadn't even considered that the child might have shitty parents or any other reason to not want to walk alone.

I know it's 'Mumsnet' but I'm always astounded and often disappointed by how utterly devoid of empathy so many here are. The few that aren't keep me hopeful but Jeez! Too much 'I'm alright Jack & Fuck you' for me - even when it comes to children!?!

Kanoe2 · 26/09/2023 12:08

@LookItsMeAgain yes I spoke with the parents when I dropped off yesterday.

Basically they said they 'don't taxi their kids around' if their kids choose to go out then its on them to arrange how they get to where they are going and get home again. Got told alot of 'they need to learn to be independant' 'you can't wrap them up in cotton wool'. They have a 17 yr old son who was raised the same way and it done him no harm. So on an so forth.

They didn't ask me to drive their daughter home - I choose to this. True.
There daughter has legs, she can walk. Also true.
They have never told their child they will collect them so have never provided any excuse why they can collect them.

They are relatively new to the area, having moved from a small village. We are in a large town that is split between 'the old town' where I live and 'the new build estate' where they live. The school campus stretches across the boarder of two areas so they are divided. They were completely nieve to where I lived and that whilst it takes there daughter 5 mins to get to school and the school is at the end of our road, it isn't a 5 min walk to and from my house as once the school campus is closed you have to divert around it which is 30 mins each way. They also don't understand the dangers of the area. On paper and during day light it's a nice area with lots to offer, I'm sure the sales pack for new estate sold the dream but We have a high density of youths, they congregate in large groups after dark, alot of violence and anti social behavour. Dispersal orders and stop and search powers are common which pushes the groups into the residential areas where we both live. I stood explaining this - Why do see no dog walkers, no street runners, absolutely no one on the streets after dark?!?! Why do you think the school teachers line the roads around the school for drop off and kick out?!?!

It's not gang warfare by any stretch but there is a problem. You need to be street smart and you need your children to be street smart. Personally, the approach they took with their son when living in a quieter village isn't appropriate for their daughter living here - but ultimately that's their decision.

I've left it that she is welcome over but I will not be dropping her back and I am not comfortable for her to leave my house by foot after dark.
If she's walking, my daughter will not be accompanying her (they didn't know about this, turns out this is the child asking my daughter to walk with her as she doesn't want to walk alone)
If she is walking she has to leave in time to get home before it gets dark.
When the clocks go back she will not be able to come over unless she is collected by them.

I feel quite bad. I know this girl will have fear of missing out as DD and her friend are here. I just made the assumption that her parents would collect as others have done and I do when DD goes elsewhere. We have had other kids over who couldn't be collected but their parents have always approached me and asked if I can drop off and offered thanks, there's been no thanks here, or have told their kids they have to be home by a certain time to be in by dark, dinner etc this child doesn't seem to have a curfew.

To everyone commenting about having kids over everynight. I don't mind having friends over and much prefer that I meet and know DD friends to speak with. As i said we already have one child over as reciprical agreement which benefits me aswell. Another friend or couple of friends added to this makes no difference but i need to be clear moving forward that im not comfortable with children leaving my house after dark to walk long distances and expect them to be collected.

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 26/09/2023 12:16

Great parents. So the 17yo male was OK with these rules in 'a small village' and now they are expecting the same rules to apply to a 12yo F in what sounds like a bit of a dodgy area. Poor kid. Good that you have put rules down, shame kid will be missing out.

MariaVT65 · 26/09/2023 12:17

Thanks for updating us OP :)

This is tough and I feel sorry for the child. Surely any good parent would put their child’s safety first over independence in this case.

But I think you’ve made the right decision in standing your ground!

Shinyandnew1 · 26/09/2023 12:21

If she's walking, my daughter will not be accompanying her (they didn't know about this, turns out this is the child asking my daughter to walk with her as she doesn't want to walk alone)If she is walking she has to leave in time to get home before it gets dark.When the clocks go back she will not be able to come over unless she is collected by them.

What did they say to these bits?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 26/09/2023 12:22

Very well handled OP.

SafferUpNorth · 26/09/2023 12:24

MariaVT65 · 26/09/2023 12:17

Thanks for updating us OP :)

This is tough and I feel sorry for the child. Surely any good parent would put their child’s safety first over independence in this case.

But I think you’ve made the right decision in standing your ground!

Exactly this. Well done OP. The parents are ridiculously oblivious to their 12 year old's movements, and being totally unreasonable with their approach of 'it worked for our 17 year old son in a small, safe village, so it WILL work for our 12 year old daughter in a busier town with greater distances and dangers'. Poor kid.

BUT.... not your circus, not your monkeys. Stick to your boundaries, as no doubt you'll get blow-back from your daughter and her friend. Just keep insisting over and over again that she walks herself home before dark.

Theydontknowthatweknowthattheyknow · 26/09/2023 12:24

I'm not a helicopter parent at all OP but I think these parents are totally naive. Most/all UK suburbs are not safe for a 12YO alone at night. Even one-off is bad but if she made a habit of it then this kid's movements could become quitr predictable making it quite easy for predators. There's a time and a place for promoting independence. This isn't it. I think you're right to make clear that you're playing no part in it. Sadly for the child she goes home before dark. End of. This doesn't sound like a parent who cares about her kid being independent she's just lazy

SafferUpNorth · 26/09/2023 12:27

PS: I hope they thanked you for running their daughter home without their knowledge?

Daffodilsandtuplips · 26/09/2023 12:52

I’d stop her coming at all. “
“It isn’t always convenient for me to take you home. If your parents can’t or won’t pick you up or arrange for someone else to then I’m afraid the after school visits will have to stop. You say your parents don’t want you walking home in the dark and I can see their point. But neither am I happy with dd walking you home then having to walk home in the dark herself. If it’s not safe for you then neither is it safe for dd”

Kanoe2 · 26/09/2023 12:53

Shinyandnew1 · 26/09/2023 12:21

If she's walking, my daughter will not be accompanying her (they didn't know about this, turns out this is the child asking my daughter to walk with her as she doesn't want to walk alone)If she is walking she has to leave in time to get home before it gets dark.When the clocks go back she will not be able to come over unless she is collected by them.

What did they say to these bits?

They just told me they didn't ask my daughter to walk her home and then just agreed to the other bits.

I think I'm going to have to check every day how she's getting home.

OP posts:
Kanoe2 · 26/09/2023 12:54

SafferUpNorth · 26/09/2023 12:27

PS: I hope they thanked you for running their daughter home without their knowledge?

No, no thanks given.

OP posts:
Absolutelyridiculous · 26/09/2023 12:57

It amazes me that with all the publicity of being aware of grooming gangs and aware of where your children are , what they are doing , who they are seeing and talking to on social media, that these parents seem to be happy in not knowing exactly where their 12yr old daughter is , every night after school. How would they know if she wasn't being picked up from school with one of these gangs? She is a vulnerable child. I would be concerned. If she doesn't come to yours one night, will that leave you worrying about where she is?
I don't know what the answer is. But it's a real concern.

StillWantingADog · 26/09/2023 13:04

MariaVT65 · 23/09/2023 05:21

I had potential sympathy with this girl in case she might have a really difficult situation at home, and that’s why she’s at your house every evening. But as soon as she said you’re being rude, I lost that sympathy and I’d now be hesitant to invite her round at all.

This.

Wildhorses2244 · 26/09/2023 13:10

There’s your answer to why she was so defensive then - she clearly knows that what her parents are doing is unreasonable/ dangerous but doesn’t know how to change it.….

Wildhorses2244 · 26/09/2023 13:12

I think that your boundaries are reasonable but I’d say go gently with this girl. I think she’s been lying to you about various bits because she feels unsafe to walk home alone and knows her parents won’t help her.

StillWantingADog · 26/09/2023 13:12

Having seen the update I feel sorry for the friend - (apart from her thinking you are rude)
I think you’ve done all you can

it is a bit awkward (from the girls’ pov) with the situation with the other friend however you justify this well as you and the third parent help each other out. I think a serious chat with your dd is required so that she understands all of this as on the face of it it’s odd that one friend is helped with lifts and the other is not.

Blondeshavemorefun · 26/09/2023 13:23

Kanoe2 · 26/09/2023 12:08

@LookItsMeAgain yes I spoke with the parents when I dropped off yesterday.

Basically they said they 'don't taxi their kids around' if their kids choose to go out then its on them to arrange how they get to where they are going and get home again. Got told alot of 'they need to learn to be independant' 'you can't wrap them up in cotton wool'. They have a 17 yr old son who was raised the same way and it done him no harm. So on an so forth.

They didn't ask me to drive their daughter home - I choose to this. True.
There daughter has legs, she can walk. Also true.
They have never told their child they will collect them so have never provided any excuse why they can collect them.

They are relatively new to the area, having moved from a small village. We are in a large town that is split between 'the old town' where I live and 'the new build estate' where they live. The school campus stretches across the boarder of two areas so they are divided. They were completely nieve to where I lived and that whilst it takes there daughter 5 mins to get to school and the school is at the end of our road, it isn't a 5 min walk to and from my house as once the school campus is closed you have to divert around it which is 30 mins each way. They also don't understand the dangers of the area. On paper and during day light it's a nice area with lots to offer, I'm sure the sales pack for new estate sold the dream but We have a high density of youths, they congregate in large groups after dark, alot of violence and anti social behavour. Dispersal orders and stop and search powers are common which pushes the groups into the residential areas where we both live. I stood explaining this - Why do see no dog walkers, no street runners, absolutely no one on the streets after dark?!?! Why do you think the school teachers line the roads around the school for drop off and kick out?!?!

It's not gang warfare by any stretch but there is a problem. You need to be street smart and you need your children to be street smart. Personally, the approach they took with their son when living in a quieter village isn't appropriate for their daughter living here - but ultimately that's their decision.

I've left it that she is welcome over but I will not be dropping her back and I am not comfortable for her to leave my house by foot after dark.
If she's walking, my daughter will not be accompanying her (they didn't know about this, turns out this is the child asking my daughter to walk with her as she doesn't want to walk alone)
If she is walking she has to leave in time to get home before it gets dark.
When the clocks go back she will not be able to come over unless she is collected by them.

I feel quite bad. I know this girl will have fear of missing out as DD and her friend are here. I just made the assumption that her parents would collect as others have done and I do when DD goes elsewhere. We have had other kids over who couldn't be collected but their parents have always approached me and asked if I can drop off and offered thanks, there's been no thanks here, or have told their kids they have to be home by a certain time to be in by dark, dinner etc this child doesn't seem to have a curfew.

To everyone commenting about having kids over everynight. I don't mind having friends over and much prefer that I meet and know DD friends to speak with. As i said we already have one child over as reciprical agreement which benefits me aswell. Another friend or couple of friends added to this makes no difference but i need to be clear moving forward that im not comfortable with children leaving my house after dark to walk long distances and expect them to be collected.

So @Kanoe2 basically your dd friend lied

Lied about asking to pick up

Lying about them saying having your daughter walk her back as scared to walk in dark

Her parents sound harsh in some ways but not caring how she gets home

I get they did it with eldest in a smaller /safer town and went to teach her independence

I would have a strict chat to her and telling the truth and you won't be lied to

and then if your dd really likes her and wants to spend time with her to suggest one evening that she comes round a week and you take home by 7

As be too dark to walk then

If not they spend time at the weekends or wait till light again at 7pm

Kanoe2 · 26/09/2023 13:24

Wildhorses2244 · 26/09/2023 13:12

I think that your boundaries are reasonable but I’d say go gently with this girl. I think she’s been lying to you about various bits because she feels unsafe to walk home alone and knows her parents won’t help her.

I completely agree. She's a nice girl and now I understand alittle more of the 'why' bits and pieces make sense. I'm not even annoyed that she called me rude now.

In all honesty I will probably be quite strict for a couple of weeks and see if any thing changes with the parents collecting her. If not I'll probably have a chat with the girls and we'll sort something that works for me and means she can come over and ve involved but not every night

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 26/09/2023 13:56

Thank you OP. A MN with a big heart. Sounds perfect to me x

Therealjudgejudy · 26/09/2023 14:30

Thanks for the update op. Your are doing a very noce thi g accomodating your daughters friends like this

1mabon · 26/09/2023 14:56

Be upfront and tell the parent/s straighthat you are not prepared to drive the child home, it's their responsibility to fetch and don't go back on your word, stand firm.

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/09/2023 15:13

God they’re idiots, aren’t they? Poor girl. I agree with your approach and think if you can find a compromise with the girl it would be good.

Swipe left for the next trending thread