Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Russel has spoken

1000 replies

Whyismyfacealwaysdry · 22/09/2023 22:31

On Instagram, has anyone seen? What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 10:03

tiggergoesbounce · 23/09/2023 08:10

It's like being suspended pending investigations

Most people get paid while suspended?
They dont cut off your income while they investigate.

He's self employed and makes his money by uploading a conspiracy theory video onto youtube every once in a while.

The advertisers who provide him with revenue don't have any kind of obligation to carry on paying him, that's ridiculous. How would it even work? All his social media accounts are monetised and he pulls in money from all sorts of companies who put ads on them.

It isn't ethical for him to profit from the allegations.

MagentaRocks · 23/09/2023 10:09

Marchitectmummy · 23/09/2023 06:36

Why is it worrying, none of us know what he has or hasn't done.

Im not a fan of his but boy are the media able to take someone down at speed. I find that infinitely more worrying.

You only have to watch a few minutes if his so called comedy to see what a misogynist he is, that’s what is worrying that so many people, including women who blindly believe he is innocent despite the things he has openly talked about.

BertieBotts · 23/09/2023 10:10

benoticanarsed · 23/09/2023 09:05

Sorry i have two more questions? I'm autistic. These are genuine I'm not trying to be funny.

What's happened recently for the women to come forward now?

Are the police involved?

There might not have been anything specifically that caused women to come forward now. It's just that it's often difficult for sexual abuse victims to report immediately after the abuse happens. For one thing it can be immensely disempowering and make you feel like you don't have the right to say anything or complain. For another it can be very traumatic to relive it, many people are just glad that it is over. In some cases victims may not realise that what they went through was classed as rape/sexual abuse until much later when the realisation might come through therapy, thinking about their past, something which made them see it differently etc.

Some people are making comments insinuating that there's something significant about the fact people have come forward with allegations now, because they believe Russell's persona that he's built up over the last few years and the idea that he's exposing super secret government conspiracies.

For me, I don't think there's much weight in that theory. He has a YouTube channel where he claims to point out issues with "mainstream thinking" but it's not very joined up or consistent, he flits about from one topic to the next basically based on what's trending and it all seems very view based. To his viewers he puts across that he's this big threat but I don't think any of the "elites" that he refers to care or know really who he is. It's all just an illusion to make people think they are in some secret club and feel special.

Personally I think it's much more likely that the victims are just older now and more able to recognise that what they went through was abusive.

Its5656 · 23/09/2023 10:11

Also I do have sympathy for his wife and I think most people do.
I don't think the media have turned on him I think his victims have used the media to be heard and this has resulted in him losing advertising deals with Yotube.
He can of course sue for loss of earnings or he get a regular job like anyone else.. Or retire.. He's made millions, and sit back and pray the police don't come knocking. I'd be shitting myself if I were him.
My own rapist has a wife and two children.. I like to think I did them a favour by speaking out but have no idea what they think of me.. it's not my problem and I refuse to feel bad about that.

Maatandosiris · 23/09/2023 10:13

GCAcademic · 23/09/2023 09:22

More gaslighting mantras. “The fundamental pillars of our society” are broken. Rape has been decriminalised in this country.

No, the justice system needs to be improved, especially around sex crimes but that does not require or excuse vigilante mentality.

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:13

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 09:50

Im not a fan of his but boy are the media able to take someone down at speed. I find that infinitely more worrying.

He hasn't been "taken down" by the media. He's free to say and post whatever he wants, just certain outlets are deciding that he shouldn't be able to make a profit from it. They're private companies, they can choose to do this.

He's not prevented from saying what he thinks or getting his message out to his fans and I find all the comparisons to countries where freedom of speech genuinely is restricted pretty gross.

Tbh I don't think anyone should be able to make a career out of pushing conspiracy theories because it's caused and is causing endless harm (including genuine risk to life), but I have no idea how this can be regulated.

You mean like most popular journalists then?

sweetgingercat · 23/09/2023 10:15

I’m happy for the courts to decide if he’s rapist although I note his lawyers haven’t issued libel proceedings.

His comedy though, is massively misogynist and deeply unpleasant. I’m really glad it has been removed from streaming sites…

Maatandosiris · 23/09/2023 10:16

MagentaRocks · 23/09/2023 10:09

You only have to watch a few minutes if his so called comedy to see what a misogynist he is, that’s what is worrying that so many people, including women who blindly believe he is innocent despite the things he has openly talked about.

You can tell the difference between “blinding believing” someone and wanting actual justice through the justice system though can’t you????

Maatandosiris · 23/09/2023 10:17

sweetgingercat · 23/09/2023 10:15

I’m happy for the courts to decide if he’s rapist although I note his lawyers haven’t issued libel proceedings.

His comedy though, is massively misogynist and deeply unpleasant. I’m really glad it has been removed from streaming sites…

Might need to remove quite a few politicians (on all sides and all sexes) then as well

CountZacular · 23/09/2023 10:18

I really want to see the death of ridiculous repeated mantras. There is NO trial by media. It has been reported by investigative journalists - journalists who wouldn’t go live with their accusations unless they felt comfortable that would stand to scrutiny if he were to sue them. He is not incarcerated. He is still allowed platforms to ramble on (just not all with monetise him). He clearly still has a large, deluded following. There is no trial.

We know conviction rates are awful. We know it’s even worse trying to report something historic. We know that, again and again, women have not been believed when a man is influential in any way. Despite that, the absolutely desperation to defend this gaslighting idiot is sickening.

Journalists can print what they want but they risk defamation law - which includes very hefty fines, legal fees and a risk to their career. There was not done lightly.

And I do welcome this. The police aren’t know for believing and protecting women. The CPS has absolutely shocking conviction rates. But the victims have a right to feel vindicated, other victims have a right to know they are not alone and future women have a right to know they could be potential victims. I believe he is a gaslighting rapist (like someone said above) and nobody gets to police my believes with misused mantras like ‘innocent until proven guilty’.

But ultimately that’s MY opinion. You don’t have to have the same as it’s not a trial by media.

Blueink · 23/09/2023 10:24

hollyblueivy · 23/09/2023 06:12

I think what's happened is that he isn't banned from posting on these platforms, but any income stream he was benefitting from have been stopped. Therefore he is asking people to go to another platform where he is able to receive financial support.

Can anyone confirm this or provide any other information?

A couple of us already did say this upthread.

‘Supporting’ him on rumble equals financially.

He’s free to post on Youtube but it currently won’t generate an income for him.

He doesn’t need the money.

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 10:25

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:13

You mean like most popular journalists then?

Feel like these glib comments are unhelpful in a debate about this.

Which "popular journalists" are you referring to?

I maintain the point that being able to profit from conspiracy theories is incredibly problematic, as it incentivises people to push out more and more controversial content and leads to genuine consequences like risk to life (have posted before about some of the scientists who experience this).

If a journalist works for a regulated media outlet, there are generally restrictions on what can be reported and how much evidence is required. This is why places like Talk TV keep getting slapped on the wrist - they allow their journalists to report any old nonsense.

newnamethanks · 23/09/2023 10:27

The BBC has been happy to play parts of his latest video several times during its morning news. RB is wearing his Messiah dress and spouting about being cancelled. Well, I wish he was, I dont want to see or hear him on my TV. Those that do, refer to BBC who will tell you where to find him.

bombastix · 23/09/2023 10:31

It's the same rubbish. Rewarded for outrage. Once it was sex. Now its mysterious elites. People are just so credulous about him: to me it's transparent it's the same mode of manipulation.

Worked once. Do it again in a different area: make money.

LikeARainstorm · 23/09/2023 10:31

Maatandosiris · 23/09/2023 10:17

Might need to remove quite a few politicians (on all sides and all sexes) then as well

Oh my goodness, there are politicians 'of all sexes' performing routines about how good it is to choke a woman with your penis til her mascara runs?

Yes, please take them off streaming sites too.

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:37

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 10:25

Feel like these glib comments are unhelpful in a debate about this.

Which "popular journalists" are you referring to?

I maintain the point that being able to profit from conspiracy theories is incredibly problematic, as it incentivises people to push out more and more controversial content and leads to genuine consequences like risk to life (have posted before about some of the scientists who experience this).

If a journalist works for a regulated media outlet, there are generally restrictions on what can be reported and how much evidence is required. This is why places like Talk TV keep getting slapped on the wrist - they allow their journalists to report any old nonsense.

Look at what happened to Cliff Richard. That was media driven. We have a huge issue with the media in this country being biased and unfair.

I personally don’t find ‘he’s a rapist, he’s like Charles Manson’ comments to be helpful.

twelly · 23/09/2023 10:40

CountZacular · 23/09/2023 10:18

I really want to see the death of ridiculous repeated mantras. There is NO trial by media. It has been reported by investigative journalists - journalists who wouldn’t go live with their accusations unless they felt comfortable that would stand to scrutiny if he were to sue them. He is not incarcerated. He is still allowed platforms to ramble on (just not all with monetise him). He clearly still has a large, deluded following. There is no trial.

We know conviction rates are awful. We know it’s even worse trying to report something historic. We know that, again and again, women have not been believed when a man is influential in any way. Despite that, the absolutely desperation to defend this gaslighting idiot is sickening.

Journalists can print what they want but they risk defamation law - which includes very hefty fines, legal fees and a risk to their career. There was not done lightly.

And I do welcome this. The police aren’t know for believing and protecting women. The CPS has absolutely shocking conviction rates. But the victims have a right to feel vindicated, other victims have a right to know they are not alone and future women have a right to know they could be potential victims. I believe he is a gaslighting rapist (like someone said above) and nobody gets to police my believes with misused mantras like ‘innocent until proven guilty’.

But ultimately that’s MY opinion. You don’t have to have the same as it’s not a trial by media.

Fair point about the use of the word "trial" however, there is a fine line between how any person/event is reported - a non-celebrity could have their life ruined through the way issues are reported in the press. There have been cases where this is happened and where the individual has taken action through the courts. Ignoring this specific current case details as we don't know the truth we need to look at the ways that people are treated when an allegation is made - that is fair.

BlurredEdges · 23/09/2023 10:46

loulouljh · 23/09/2023 09:47

Whether he is guilty or not of what is alleged we don't know. What has happened, however, is utterly disturbing. This could happen to anyone whose views do not align with the powers. Utterly chilling.

How many women need to speak out to be believed?

His ex girlfriend wrote a fucking book about it ffs.

Sickening rape apologists on here. I fear for the women in your lives.

BlurredEdges · 23/09/2023 10:48

twelly · 23/09/2023 10:40

Fair point about the use of the word "trial" however, there is a fine line between how any person/event is reported - a non-celebrity could have their life ruined through the way issues are reported in the press. There have been cases where this is happened and where the individual has taken action through the courts. Ignoring this specific current case details as we don't know the truth we need to look at the ways that people are treated when an allegation is made - that is fair.

It's not 'an' allegation, though, is it.

It's many, many women, sharing traumatic detailed testimonies with evidence. Consistent stories from a great number of women going back decades.

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 10:48

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:37

Look at what happened to Cliff Richard. That was media driven. We have a huge issue with the media in this country being biased and unfair.

I personally don’t find ‘he’s a rapist, he’s like Charles Manson’ comments to be helpful.

But that's a seperate point - you were previously talking about "popular journalists" but they're not saying "he's a rapist, he's like Charles Manson". Obviously if that was currently being reported in the media that wouldn't be fair nor appropriate.

You can't control people's reactions and all these posts on social media and forums are a real problem for everything, not just in this case.

tiggergoesbounce · 23/09/2023 10:50

If a journalist works for a regulated media outlet, there are generally restrictions on what can be reported and how much evidence is required. This is why places like Talk TV keep getting slapped on the wrist - they allow their journalists to report any old nonsense

But alot of MSM also acknowledge that the money they earn off the lie, far outweighs any pay out that will be slapped on them (including their tiny apology they need to print for destroying lives) its worth the fine.

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:51

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 10:48

But that's a seperate point - you were previously talking about "popular journalists" but they're not saying "he's a rapist, he's like Charles Manson". Obviously if that was currently being reported in the media that wouldn't be fair nor appropriate.

You can't control people's reactions and all these posts on social media and forums are a real problem for everything, not just in this case.

Edited

I wasn’t saying they were the same thing. It was more a comment on how it’s interesting that it isn’t being called out as ‘not helpful.’

I am also not trying to control people’s reactions. What a weird thing to say. Just like you, I am simply replying to things I don’t agree with.

IClaudine · 23/09/2023 10:56

Josell12345 · 23/09/2023 09:43

To the muppet who said he was a gaslighting rapist- what a ridiculous comment . Hes neither been charged or found guilty.

For me its the timing. Why wasnt this brought out at the time. Just hold onto it all until hes hovering right over the target, calling out msm/globalists/usa politics/war for what it is and suddenly its time to silence him!
See this for what it is.

So the woman who was raped went to a rape crisis centre and had the evidence frozen in case in the future Brand challenged the msm/globalists/usa politics/a future war?

Seems realistic.

augustusglupe · 23/09/2023 11:08

augustusglupe · 23/09/2023 07:47

Oh so you’re saying that RB is not cooperating with the police?!
How do you know that? I would’ve thought that would be headline news?!!

You quite clearly don’t have a clue whether RB is ‘cooperating’ with the police or even if the police have been in contact atall.
Don’t make things up.

lightpineapple · 23/09/2023 11:11

SatsumaNightmare · 23/09/2023 10:51

I wasn’t saying they were the same thing. It was more a comment on how it’s interesting that it isn’t being called out as ‘not helpful.’

I am also not trying to control people’s reactions. What a weird thing to say. Just like you, I am simply replying to things I don’t agree with.

Eh? I'm not saying that you were. I was just pointing that people's reactions to news can't be controlled, and yes this is a real problem in the age of social media and the internet.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread