Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
DuncinToffee · 31/07/2023 22:28

Ah yes, the good old 'this is not the brexit I voted for', yet you would vote for it again, why? What are the benefits?

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:32

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 19:45

I voted for Brexit. If they held another vote now, I'd vote Brexit again.

I find it therapeutic to admit that on Mumsnet

...because there is literally no-one (except DH, who has thankfully forgiven me!) that I could ever admit that to in real life. No-one. People would never understand. A lot would judge. To meet me absolutely no-one would ever guess I had or would vote Brexit and I actually think a few friends would distance themselves. Which is sad :( I'm still the same me!

I believe you. I don't think you're a troll just on a wind up about how great brexit is. The scales fell from my eyes ages ago on this. Leave voters will NEVER change their minds about brexit, it doesn't matter how much damage it does. There's a big overlap between Leave voters, anti vaxxers, climate change deniers and flat earthers and no amount of evidence will change their opinions. The thing that gets me most about these people though is the arrogance. I'm just an ordinary person, I can't imagine, even for a minute, thinking I know better than the vast majority of nobel prize winning economists, or climate scientists, or historians on Ireland, or constitutional experts, about their subject.

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:35

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 22:18

I voted brexit and I love the NHS and have worked in and for the NHS for over 20years.

Brexit has been incredibly poorly executed and managed. That is not the fault of brexit. It is the fault of those implementing it.

Do tell us, how would it have been implemented better?

CoffeeRevelsForever · 31/07/2023 22:36

Oh dear, a that's not my Brexit - what did your Brexit look like @HaveToHideAsAnon ? And who did you think could implement it? The buffoons leading the Vote Leave campaign?

Alexandra2001 · 31/07/2023 22:42

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:32

I believe you. I don't think you're a troll just on a wind up about how great brexit is. The scales fell from my eyes ages ago on this. Leave voters will NEVER change their minds about brexit, it doesn't matter how much damage it does. There's a big overlap between Leave voters, anti vaxxers, climate change deniers and flat earthers and no amount of evidence will change their opinions. The thing that gets me most about these people though is the arrogance. I'm just an ordinary person, I can't imagine, even for a minute, thinking I know better than the vast majority of nobel prize winning economists, or climate scientists, or historians on Ireland, or constitutional experts, about their subject.

^this 100% .... Very few people have the humility to admit they were wrong, despite the evidence.... whatever the subject.

If Brexit had been a roaring success, i doubt too many remainers would be falling over themselves to say they were wrong either.... i'd like to think i would but i also can't be sure.

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 22:44

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:32

I believe you. I don't think you're a troll just on a wind up about how great brexit is. The scales fell from my eyes ages ago on this. Leave voters will NEVER change their minds about brexit, it doesn't matter how much damage it does. There's a big overlap between Leave voters, anti vaxxers, climate change deniers and flat earthers and no amount of evidence will change their opinions. The thing that gets me most about these people though is the arrogance. I'm just an ordinary person, I can't imagine, even for a minute, thinking I know better than the vast majority of nobel prize winning economists, or climate scientists, or historians on Ireland, or constitutional experts, about their subject.

I'm not an anti vaxxer, climate change denier or flat earther!!! :)

I also am not arrogant. I don't think I know better than people. I'd love to sit and chat with experts on both sides, understand more. I've also listened extensively to a lot of remain arguments and understand this position and why many people voted this way (since that is what I'm exposed to as I don't know anyone on the brexit side), though I'm sure there are many arguments I haven't heard, but I'd gladly listen to more and try and understand more.

My observation is that some people (not all I'm sure) that are remain, appear to have quite a negative opinion of those that voted for brexit and a judgemental attitude which is not only sad, but it means those of us that did vote brexit cannot talk about it. We are made to feel stupid and ashamed. We are lumped in with other ostracised groups that are also ridiculed and looked down on. If we want to change people's opinions we need to hear them and discuss them, not force people into silence and make them feel like fools.

ilovesooty · 31/07/2023 22:49

So @HaveToHideAsAnon what are the benefits of Brexit then?

DuncinToffee · 31/07/2023 22:52

If we want to change people's opinions we need to hear them and discuss them, not force people into silence and make them feel like fools.

Go on then, why did you vote Leave and what are the benfits of Brexit

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2023 22:53

But what did you think you were voting for and how could it actually be achieved @HaveToHideAsAnon? Where was the evidence that you were voting for a set list of changes, as defined by an independent source that actually had the power to deliver what was suggested?

You were basically voting for the contents of a sealed box, which wouldn't be opened until after you had made your decision. It could have been free unicorns for everyone, or a rusty nail, no-one could say.

One good analogy I heard at the time was that all the different EU member states were like children, who'd all been given different colour lego bricks. The children then played together happily for some time until one of them had to go home, at which point the child stood up and said 'my lego bricks are the white ones, and I want all them back now'.

endofthelinefinally · 31/07/2023 22:54

I would like a leave voter to explain why they voted leave. Specific reasons relating to trade, public services, the economy. Why and how would a lengthy leaving process result in a better outcome?
I would really like to understand because I honestly can't think of a single positive outcome.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 31/07/2023 22:54

Well it’s not surprising that leavers are “made to feel stupid and ashamed” - making a stupid decision which has only had negative impacts is absolutely something to be ashamed about. Didn’t make anything better for anyone, just enabled an idiocracy to take power, weakened the UK and weakened our economy.

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:55

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 22:44

I'm not an anti vaxxer, climate change denier or flat earther!!! :)

I also am not arrogant. I don't think I know better than people. I'd love to sit and chat with experts on both sides, understand more. I've also listened extensively to a lot of remain arguments and understand this position and why many people voted this way (since that is what I'm exposed to as I don't know anyone on the brexit side), though I'm sure there are many arguments I haven't heard, but I'd gladly listen to more and try and understand more.

My observation is that some people (not all I'm sure) that are remain, appear to have quite a negative opinion of those that voted for brexit and a judgemental attitude which is not only sad, but it means those of us that did vote brexit cannot talk about it. We are made to feel stupid and ashamed. We are lumped in with other ostracised groups that are also ridiculed and looked down on. If we want to change people's opinions we need to hear them and discuss them, not force people into silence and make them feel like fools.

Almost everyone I know who voted leave is a full on raging racist, maybe you're lucky you don't know Leave voters, the negative opinion Remain voters have of Leavers didn't come from nowhere.

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:59

I predict @HaveToHideAsAnon will flounce off in a minute, without supplying any of their well reasoned and stand up to scrutiny arguments in favour of brexit.

Endlesssummer2022 · 31/07/2023 23:01

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 20:20

IMO, Brexit is not the cause of the cost of living crisis or many other problems facing people today. COVID, the shit-show of the conservative party, Liz Truss's accidental loss of billions, incompetent policy makers, and a government against brexit that is trying to implement it half heartedly and almost intentionally badly, are the reasons for your hardship.

Though I understand you are unlikely to agree.

But everything including the governments response to Covid was a result of Brexit. We would never have had the governments we’ve had post 2016, without the Brexit vote.

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 23:04

ilovesooty · 31/07/2023 22:49

So @HaveToHideAsAnon what are the benefits of Brexit then?

Well I have in the past, under a different username, given my opinions on the benefits that there could be, of a brexit well managed.

However, I was a bit if a lone figure. People piled in to ridicule me, shout me down, tell me how stupid I am, make all kinds of unfounded assumptions about me (from being a racist to an anti-vaxxer) and call me a troll. So I've learnt to not comment. To keep my username anonymous and to never ever speak about my views in real life. The only person I feel able to discuss my opinions (on what, IMO, the benefits of a well managed brexit could be) with, is my husband. It makes me sad that this how society is really.

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 23:07

I bet if we could turn the clock back, but give the bloke in the OP knowledge of how things would unfold, he would 100% vote Leave again, and then be completely bewildered as to why he still can't just move easily to Italy.

DuncinToffee · 31/07/2023 23:08

So much for If we want to change people's opinions we need to hear them and discuss them, then.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2023 23:09

So tell us about the benefits of a well managed Brexit, how it could be achieved and to what timescale?

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 23:10

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 22:59

I predict @HaveToHideAsAnon will flounce off in a minute, without supplying any of their well reasoned and stand up to scrutiny arguments in favour of brexit.

No flouncing here. I'm not a flouncer :) Why would you assume that?

No-one has been particularly welcoming and non judgemental towards me, so I could understand why someone of my view might want to flounce off. But I am not keen to live up to your impression of me. So I will leave when I feel like going to sleep (which might actually be soon as the eye lids are drooping!) I will not flounce! I will leave gracefully (it's a shame our government flounced out, rather than leaving Europe a little more gracefully, but there we go!)

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 23:11

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 23:04

Well I have in the past, under a different username, given my opinions on the benefits that there could be, of a brexit well managed.

However, I was a bit if a lone figure. People piled in to ridicule me, shout me down, tell me how stupid I am, make all kinds of unfounded assumptions about me (from being a racist to an anti-vaxxer) and call me a troll. So I've learnt to not comment. To keep my username anonymous and to never ever speak about my views in real life. The only person I feel able to discuss my opinions (on what, IMO, the benefits of a well managed brexit could be) with, is my husband. It makes me sad that this how society is really.

Does it not give you any pause for thought at all, that you feel you can't tell anyone you voted leave because they'd think you were thick?

endofthelinefinally · 31/07/2023 23:20

What were/ are the benefits of Brexit to the NHS? Or even just one benefit?

ilovesooty · 31/07/2023 23:21

So we have yet another Leave voter who can't tell us what the benefits are.

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 23:27

Kendodd · 31/07/2023 23:11

Does it not give you any pause for thought at all, that you feel you can't tell anyone you voted leave because they'd think you were thick?

Sure! I question myself all the time. I've felt pretty low once or twice when I've done a bit too much over thinking and wondered if I truly am a waste of space. Then I remember that actually I have some strengths. I'm kind, loyal, caring and friendly (in real life). I remember, when I pause to think, that it's pretty unpleasant of people to call others thick, to judge them based on nothing but a political.opinion, to shout them down without really hearing them. I also remind myself that intelligence isn't really a concept well understood or necessarily something to be revered.

As it happens, as far as 'intelligence' goes, I was once a member of mensa! It got me a job I needed at the time, and then I left. I have an IQ of 155 which apparantly, as far as an objective measure of 'intelligence' is concerned means I'm not 'thick". However, 'intelligence isn't really to me, all about a number or a measure on some test. I have little confidence (perhaps if I am truly honest, that's a second reason I joined MENSA for a year, in addition to it helping me secure a job, I wanted to prove something to myself), I can be quite an anxious person, I clearly don't hold the mainstream view on some topics (brexit being the main one), I lack common sense and I am not always very assertive. So I do think in some ways I am thick.

I don't know if that's the answer you were after kendodd. If I am your definition of thick, then I guess I'm thick. Not sure how calling me that helps anything though.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2023 23:51

Well that's all lovely, but please tell us about the benefits of Brexit that you voted for.

We're all waiting.

HaveToHideAsAnon · 31/07/2023 23:52

Ok, well I think it's been about 50 minutes since kendodd predicted I would 'flounce off in a minute'. I'm quite tired now so am heading off to bed and therefore leaving the thread. Not flouncing (though I quite like the visual I'm getting around that!! Maybe I will try a flounce down the hall 🤣. Hec, what's wrong with a good flounce anyway!!? Yeah what the hell, here i go...flouncing! That's a great word isn't it? Flounce!... 🤣 Bring on the flouncing I say!!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread