Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the penny hasn't dropped yet, for many people, that the trade in new petrol and diesel cars is really ending in 6 years

823 replies

JadeClade · 25/07/2023 21:17

I think the price of second hand cars will go through the roof, at first, when new cars are no longer available, and people buying new homes now really do need to be factoring in where they are going to charge an electric car, and all sorts of preparations and plans are simply not being made

YANBU - we need to be planning and preparing, as individuals and society.
YABU- we don't need to think about it.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
PurpleButterflyWings · 26/07/2023 11:09

justgettingthroughtheday · 26/07/2023 00:49

@Lunar270 you are talking absolute bollocks! There is zero chance of this legislation still being in place in 2030. Petrol and diesel cars will be sold indefinitely. Hell half the cars already ordered may not have been bloody delivered by then at the rate car manufacturers are currently going.
There is no way the infrastructure will be in place. Nor the batteries. The mining of minerals for batteries takes place in some of the most volatile places around the world and is in no way remotely environmentally friendly. Don't be fooled by the bullshit that electric cars are in any way better for the environment- they are not. Not least because the resources being used to produce the electricity in the first place funnily enough are still fossil fuel based! So your rubbish that electric motors are more efficient is ridiculous. Unless that electricity has been produced using all renewable sources (and don't include solar in that because the panels themselves are not environmentally sustainable) then the efficiency is exactly the same.

Electric cars are just another method of green washing. Stop being fooled by the bollocks being spouted!

This. ^ ... From his point I am actually ignoring @Lunar270 I cannot BELIEVE the sheer ROT she is spouting. It's worrying that someone may actually believe her! Shock

Superpinkflowerpower · 26/07/2023 11:09

@LameBorzoi Funny I'm still waiting for you to give me some actual In-depth reply as to why a Toyota hybrid is still the worst of both worlds?

It seems you have zero evidence to back up your post. Being one of the most reliable cars' on the road with excellent mileage, all facts by the way.

Why is its worst of both worlds, some facts and details would be nice not just one liners.

PurpleButterflyWings · 26/07/2023 11:11

LittleDitto · 26/07/2023 05:10

ok so insomnia has put me in a right fucking mood so I’m tired and ranty, but, Society is now really being bullied in so many different ways and it feels like so much of our freedoms are gradually being taken from us.

I can’t afford £30/40k for a brand new new electric car. I don’t want to take a loan out at 50 for one either, which is what most people have to do if they want a new car. These electric cars run entirely on computers, and computers are fucking unreliable and you’re forced to upgrade them every few years because they get old”,

I live and work rurally. I rely on a 4X4 for my work. I’m 30 miles from my nearest city. To get there by bus (no other public transport available) it currently costs me £20 for a day return.

chances are by the time this comes into force the NHS will have crumbled beyond redemption…so what will you spend your life savings on? A new car or your future healthcare or save for a care home to see you into old age? I heard on the news today that by 2050 (I think!) there will be about a 37% increase of people living with chronic illnesses. They don’t know how the NHS will fund it.

We’ll all be fucked over by the robots eventually anyway.

fuck I’m tired!

I hate the world.

The end.

This. ^ I am SO sick of life some days. Constantly battling against the elements, and the cost of living/energy prices/petrol prices..,

Also worrying about the NHS, not being able to get a GP appointment, no fucking NHS dentists left anymore, mortgage rates sky high, rent for a shitty private let is £1000+ a month, when it was £550 four years ago, and now this trying to force fucking electric vehicles on us.

Well yeah OK then, we'll all have one for FREE, and we all need our own electric charging point. Until you can come up with that (whoever is trying to force this cunty thing on us,) then FUCK OFF!

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:11

Alexandra2001 · 26/07/2023 11:07

The problem will be fuel...... why import and have the facilities to sell as we do now, for a product with diminishing sales?

Either got to up the price (& will make more switch to EVs) or reduce the number of outlets.

The issue is how to charge millions of EVs when so many people do not have off street parking....

I don't know about this new automobile thing, where will we get petrol for them all? Horses are much better because grass grows on the side of the road.

Goldenspearmint · 26/07/2023 11:11

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:06

You sound like those people in 2005 who kept talking about how this smart phone thing wasn't going to take off.

I manage a major infrastructure project for a living.

What have I said, that is incorrect? 🙄

Lunar270 · 26/07/2023 11:13

PurpleButterflyWings · 26/07/2023 11:09

This. ^ ... From his point I am actually ignoring @Lunar270 I cannot BELIEVE the sheer ROT she is spouting. It's worrying that someone may actually believe her! Shock

What, compared to the unverifiable clap trap that you posted on page one and keep blurting out.

I'm happy to go through each one of your statements in detail if you like. But ignoring is potentially easier for you because you're just going to look a bit silly.

Goldenspearmint · 26/07/2023 11:14

Lunar270 · 26/07/2023 11:13

What, compared to the unverifiable clap trap that you posted on page one and keep blurting out.

I'm happy to go through each one of your statements in detail if you like. But ignoring is potentially easier for you because you're just going to look a bit silly.

So when are you going to bring any intelligent and informed facts to this discussion?

All you do is reply sarcastically to every one with no facts of your own Mmmmm.

Alexandra2001 · 26/07/2023 11:14

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:11

I don't know about this new automobile thing, where will we get petrol for them all? Horses are much better because grass grows on the side of the road.

Who put 50p in the idiot?

Bonfire23 · 26/07/2023 11:15

@LameBorzoi most people don't do it themselves though. But they still need to follow the service schedule so warranty isn't affected

Truemilk · 26/07/2023 11:16

It's all a big massive con, just like the government itself

PuzzledObserver · 26/07/2023 11:16

Disclaimer - I’ve been driving an EV for 2.5 years and I love it. I have a home charger, which is by far the easiest option, as I plug in and charge on a cheap overnight rate whenever I need to. With a range of over 300 miles in summer, 250 in winter, realistically the only time I need to use public charging is when I’m away from home. So I’m in the bracket for whom charging is not an issue.

What about the rest?

Around 65% of UK homes have off street parking, and the 35% that don’t will include a higher proportion of non-car owning households. So say 70% of car owning households have off street parking.

The average car does around 8,000 miles a year, and with middling EV efficiency that’s going to need 2,500kWh of electricity. On a 7kW charger that’s 360 hours of charging, just over 7 hours a week.

So if a workplace has 100 employees bringing a car to work, 70 of them can charge at home, the other 30 can meet their charging needs by plugging in one day a week at work. If the workplace can provide 6 chargers, it would, at a stretch, cover the charging needs of the whole workforce. Call it 10 to avoid contention and help out visitors.

You don’t offer free charging at work - you make it cost of the electricity or just a bit more, that will dissuade those employees who do have home chargers from using the workplace ones, and leave them for the people that need them.

Of course, not everyone can charge at work, but a similar ratio applies to other car parks where people leave cars for long periods of time. If 1 space in 10 has a charger, that will be more than enough. Probably 1 in 20 would do.

There also need to be more high-power charging facilities - and government needs to get its finger out on that and provide both policy and investment for grid upgrades, planning etc, to remove the bottle necks which currently exist. That’s where the main thrust of the ‘forward planning’ needs to be. At the moment, those are mainly on major roads to cater for drivers on long journeys. They could also be added to some or all petrol stations, and they then become an alternative solution for local residents without off street parking.

Technology is improving all the time - new battery technologies which are both more energy dense and faster to charge are coming. Prices are coming down - you don’t have to pay £30K for an EV. Quite apart from the fact that you don’t have to buy a new car - you can now get an entry level family size EV with a range of over 200 miles for around £20K.

By 2030, I think there’s a good chance you will be able to buy a family EV with a similar range to today’s petrol models, with a faster charging speed (add 300 miles in 20 minutes), for much the same price as a similar spec petrol car today.

Lunar270 · 26/07/2023 11:20

PurpleButterflyWings · 25/07/2023 21:25

Not gonna happen. Very few people can afford £30K plus for a new electric car, and the infrastructure is just not there. I have seen many news reports and documentaries this past couple of years, one just tonight - about how there are way WAY too few electric charging points for electric vehicles.

They take too long to charge too. 6-10 hours some of them. Even if it's reduced to half an hour, we cannot realistically have a society where every car takes half an hour to 're-fuel.'

Everyone having electric vehicles by 2030 is not going to happen.

Now let's just start with this corker.

For starters, legislation isn't for everyone to own an electric car by 2030. Please do post the factual legislation that stipulates this. You probably can't because you've completely misinterpreted government plans 🤦

Noone needs £30k to buy one as there are used examples, just like other cars. There'll be more by 2030 as well.

EV's can take 18 minutes to add 300 miles. Or 6-10 hours. Does a toilet break on the motorway take much less than 18 minutes? 6-10 hours is fine if you charge overnight, or at work, shopping mall or any other place where you spend time not driving.

I think I need to ignore you really as it's clear your understanding is completely off.

Lunar270 · 26/07/2023 11:21

Goldenspearmint · 26/07/2023 11:14

So when are you going to bring any intelligent and informed facts to this discussion?

All you do is reply sarcastically to every one with no facts of your own Mmmmm.

Read my previous posts. Plenty there.

Bonfire23 · 26/07/2023 11:26

@PuzzledObserver I think the issue is what off road parking counts as
I have off road parking, but it's nowhere near my home. Apartments have off road parking but it's usually a giant car park not near to charge

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:28

Superpinkflowerpower · 26/07/2023 11:09

@LameBorzoi Funny I'm still waiting for you to give me some actual In-depth reply as to why a Toyota hybrid is still the worst of both worlds?

It seems you have zero evidence to back up your post. Being one of the most reliable cars' on the road with excellent mileage, all facts by the way.

Why is its worst of both worlds, some facts and details would be nice not just one liners.

I don't need many words, because it's very very simple.

The good thing about EVs is that they are simple, with far fewer moving parts than an ICE. No high pressure, high temperature systems. This makes them less likely to break, and you don't really need to service them.

Hybrids have an engine. This means that you have to service it. You also need a gearbox ( breakable and expensive) which EVs do not need.

All these extra parts and the battery make them more expensive than an ICE to buy. If I were buying an ICE, I would buying it because it was cheaper than an EV. If I buy a hybrid, I'm spending more money, but I'm not getting the advantages of not having an engine.

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:29

Bonfire23 · 26/07/2023 11:15

@LameBorzoi most people don't do it themselves though. But they still need to follow the service schedule so warranty isn't affected

No, Tesla recommends changing the cabin filter yourself.

Cucucucu · 26/07/2023 11:31

There is one big point nobody seems to be talking about here . The fact EVs won’t last near anywhere what diesel will last , all my previous diesel cars lasted over 200 000 miles one over 300 000 , not to mention they did 60 mpg and where a bargain to run so in reality we will need to change cars more often meaning more batteries , more slavery and more waste . Anyone thinking EVs are the future really has been brainwashed .
Not to mention I had to pick a hybrid as my last car as no diesels are being made , so despite being “greener “ it consumes so much more , so I’m using 40% more petrol than I did diesel.

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:34

Cucucucu · 26/07/2023 11:31

There is one big point nobody seems to be talking about here . The fact EVs won’t last near anywhere what diesel will last , all my previous diesel cars lasted over 200 000 miles one over 300 000 , not to mention they did 60 mpg and where a bargain to run so in reality we will need to change cars more often meaning more batteries , more slavery and more waste . Anyone thinking EVs are the future really has been brainwashed .
Not to mention I had to pick a hybrid as my last car as no diesels are being made , so despite being “greener “ it consumes so much more , so I’m using 40% more petrol than I did diesel.

My Tesla Y with an iron phosphate battery is expected to last for 500,000 to 1 million miles.

Bonfire23 · 26/07/2023 11:34

@LameBorzoi definitely varies between cars! Another brand is serviced every 2 years/21k and needs the pollen filter and brake fluid doing and then the standard checks of brakes/tyres etc
Cheaper obviously than most servicing but still around £250 at a main dealer

Superpinkflowerpower · 26/07/2023 11:35

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:28

I don't need many words, because it's very very simple.

The good thing about EVs is that they are simple, with far fewer moving parts than an ICE. No high pressure, high temperature systems. This makes them less likely to break, and you don't really need to service them.

Hybrids have an engine. This means that you have to service it. You also need a gearbox ( breakable and expensive) which EVs do not need.

All these extra parts and the battery make them more expensive than an ICE to buy. If I were buying an ICE, I would buying it because it was cheaper than an EV. If I buy a hybrid, I'm spending more money, but I'm not getting the advantages of not having an engine.

@LameBorzoi
Oh where do I start 🤔

I asked you about Toyota hybrids specifically,

Toyota Hybrid Transmissions – No Gears, No CVT Belts.
Toyota Hybrids – No Starter
Toyota Hybrids – No Alternator
Toyota Hybrids – No Timing Belt
Toyota Hybrids – No Accessory Belt
Toyota Hybrids – No Conventional AC
Toyota Hybrids – No Turbochargers
Toyota Hybrids – No Power Steering Pump

Toyota has built its reputation on quality, durability, and reliability. They are the most reliable cars on the road fact.

Mine have brilliant mileage and 10 years warranty and is one of the most reliable cars on the road fact.

So I`ll ask you again what is the down side?

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:40

Superpinkflowerpower · 26/07/2023 11:35

@LameBorzoi
Oh where do I start 🤔

I asked you about Toyota hybrids specifically,

Toyota Hybrid Transmissions – No Gears, No CVT Belts.
Toyota Hybrids – No Starter
Toyota Hybrids – No Alternator
Toyota Hybrids – No Timing Belt
Toyota Hybrids – No Accessory Belt
Toyota Hybrids – No Conventional AC
Toyota Hybrids – No Turbochargers
Toyota Hybrids – No Power Steering Pump

Toyota has built its reputation on quality, durability, and reliability. They are the most reliable cars on the road fact.

Mine have brilliant mileage and 10 years warranty and is one of the most reliable cars on the road fact.

So I`ll ask you again what is the down side?

You still have a complex, high pressure, high temperature system. An engine, fundamentally, runs on a series of small, contained explosions that is transmitted into rotary force. That is inherently an unstable system. No amount of stuffing around the edges changes the basic physics of the situation.

Cucucucu · 26/07/2023 11:45

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:28

I don't need many words, because it's very very simple.

The good thing about EVs is that they are simple, with far fewer moving parts than an ICE. No high pressure, high temperature systems. This makes them less likely to break, and you don't really need to service them.

Hybrids have an engine. This means that you have to service it. You also need a gearbox ( breakable and expensive) which EVs do not need.

All these extra parts and the battery make them more expensive than an ICE to buy. If I were buying an ICE, I would buying it because it was cheaper than an EV. If I buy a hybrid, I'm spending more money, but I'm not getting the advantages of not having an engine.

That’s such BS , EVs still have massive issues , mist if my colleagues have EVs and one just had their car catch fire , most fixes are more expensive than a fuel car since nobody will touch them apart from the main dealer . The reason people are forced to have hybrids is because diesel where discontinued on most brands so we are trying to keep the fuel price down ( and still being ripped since most cars are nit more economical than a a diesel ) .
EVs are in no way suitable for rural locations , telling me they charge 200 miles in 20 minutes won’t solve anything since 20 minutes is still 10 times longer than it takes me to fill up a tank and do 800 miles . 200 miles is also what lots of us rurally do in a single day so exactly how is it paying £20 or more a day to change a car cheaper . Not to mention the pay per mile charge will eventually be here .

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:47

Timing belts - well, however you do it, you still need to get fuel, air, electricity, and a piston in the right place at the right time. That's complex.

Gears? An engine has to spin at a high speed before it can provide torque. If you want the engine to provide energy at low speeds, you need some kind of translation system. Electric motors don't need that. They can provide torque without excess rotation.

Cucucucu · 26/07/2023 11:47

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:34

My Tesla Y with an iron phosphate battery is expected to last for 500,000 to 1 million miles.

But will it last ? If I’m made to go EV Tesla is still my go to followed by Toyota so that’s good to know . But I’m still not convinced is in any way cheaper

Superpinkflowerpower · 26/07/2023 11:52

LameBorzoi · 26/07/2023 11:40

You still have a complex, high pressure, high temperature system. An engine, fundamentally, runs on a series of small, contained explosions that is transmitted into rotary force. That is inherently an unstable system. No amount of stuffing around the edges changes the basic physics of the situation.

So the proven history and fact that they are the most reliable cars on the road, is some thing your completely ignoring. Yet you seem to claim they are inherently an unstable systems but history and facts state other wise.

Your sating they are unreliable but real world reliability and facts say otherwise.

As a consumer they are perfect for low fuel use, highly reliable and brilliant warranty, affordable.

You cannot argue black is white if you have nothing to back it up, IE real world live data to share.