Does hot cross bun in child’s lunchbox replace sandwich?

[meaniemaybe]

DC normally has cheese roll, fruit, veg sticks, crisps, pack of little biscuits. Tomorrow I propose replacing cheese roll with buttered HXB and chunk of cheese. DH thinks replace biscuits with HXB.

Who IBU?

Hot cross bun is a sweet treat not a sandwich in my opinion

Sorry, but I think you are… hot cross buns are really sweet!

Replaces biscuits, definitely.

Hot x bun is a sugary treat.

I would class a hot cross bun as a cake so would put it in place of biscuits

No it's cake.

Is it one of the savoury hot cross buns?

id argue even if not it could be the equivalent of say a cinnamon and raisin bagel and a roll plus a hot x bun would be a bit much.

It's bready so I would replace the sandwich with it. Unlikely to eat a sandwich and HXB together

Our house would be on your side OP. Dh and ds often use a hot cross bun as the bread in a sandwich

I would have said the same as you. Hot cross buns, whilst sweet, are bread, so I wouldn't want a sandwich as well. When DC have had them, they've replaced the sandwich, but they don't tend to have a packet of biscuits. They would have hot cross bun, cucumber/carrot sticks, a cheese snack (babybel or equivalent), sometimes a boiled egg, and then a piece of fruit for their sweet thing.

Everyone will say it replaces the biscuits. I'm on the fence. I think with a chunk of cheese and maybe some plain oatcakes or some other crunchy non-sweet carb to replace the biscuits, it replaces the sandwich.

I have just eaten a hxb spread with marmite and grated cheese.

Oh egg is a good shout

Buttered HXB, veggie sticks, a piece of fruit, and a hard boiled egg is a perfectly good meal.

It’s the sweet thing.
I often put a Welsh cake in DS’s lunchbox for his pudding.

This is really surprising! They’re basically bread with a little bit of sugar in the dough and a few raisins, no? Bit of syrup glaze.

just checked and only 40 more kcals than the bread rolls I use. 17g more sugar which is 2 of those mini boxes of raisins. Hmm

I'd say it replaces the sandwich - otherwise it's like having two rolls (albeit one a bit sweeter than the other)

Hot cross bun isn't any worse than bread IMO. neither are a good lunch option.

I mean as a one off it would be fine to give it as a sandwich replacement but would make sure there was a really vibrant mix of veg and salad stuff too, definitely would forgo the biscuits.

Yes, it sweet but it replaces the sandwich as it’s bread and way more filling than biscuits. If I have a hot cross bun for lunch I don’t eat a sandwich too. It could probably replace both sandwich and biscuits if you are worried about sugar. With extra veggie sticks

I wouldnt imagine your ds will be able to manage a HXB and a cheese roll as it's a lot of filling carbs so maybe just add some kind of protein alongside it (some chicken bites or rolled up ham or an egg or something)

17g more sugar is loads! I'd definitely not put that and the biscuits in. I'd already voted for replacing the biscuits rather than the roll, but now I definitely think ditch the biscuits.

I'd say it replaces the sandwich. I had a hot-cross bun with cheese for lunch yesterday instead a sandwich.

A sandwich plus a hot cross bun is basically two sandwiches.

Another vote here for letting it replace both the roll and the biscuits. Some may have missed that you planned to put the cheese in separately anyway.

Yes, YABU! Have you ever visualised 17g of sugar, it’s quite a bit. Especially if you put biscuits in there as well. And BTW my dentist says that the middle class view that raisins are a better treat than chocolate has ruined many a child’s teeth, he says kids shouldn’t have raisins every day, it should only be at mealtimes and his preference teeth-wise would be a couple of squares of chocolate any time!

I'm assuming this will happen once ir twice a year at Easter?? In which case I'd go with you. My dc had a cinnamon swirl, chocolate and crisps for breakfast yesterday. Its hardly representative of their general diet!