Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse a school home visit?

625 replies

CoffeePlease93 · 16/10/2022 11:49

My son has just started school this year so I don’t know if this is the norm or not?

So apparently his school (not the teachers) does home visits with all the new parents to discuss any issues going on and for a chit chat (and probably just to be nosey around your home too!)

I have already had to reschedule once because we -all had COVID but I’ve got it coming up again now but it’s just such an inconvenience! I work from home, have a medical procedure coming up which I have several appointments beforehand and I also have a private issue going on (legal issues) which is requiring a lot of solicitor appointments and admin stuff at home at the moment too.

There has been no issues with my son at school whatsoever, he is doing amazingly well, glowing reports, I have brilliant communication with his actual teachers - I don’t need any extra support with anything and there is a parent’s evening coming up soon anyway.

I also have an extremely anxious dog who really stresses out if stranger’s come into the home (constantly barking, pacing up and down, sometimes wee’s - something we are working on but he came from a bad home previous to us).

WIBU to tell them I don’t need a home visit and this just isn’t going to work for me or will it be seen as bad and negative thing like I’m not co-operating or I’m being resistant etc?

And yes… I do tend to overthink everything which is why I’m asking!

OP posts:
CoffeePlease93 · 16/10/2022 17:43

@DeannaFromHumanResources right so I’m guessing you missed the part where my child won’t be there then?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 16/10/2022 17:43

Derbee · 16/10/2022 17:23

I know you’re riled up for some reason, but if you notice, I said “good luck to you and your children” because you have a lot going on, and initially it was too much going on to manage a quick meeting with the school (until people pointed out that it would be best to have the meeting).

You then also mentioned CAHMS.

You are clearly insecure to have taken it so badly. If I’d said “but all the best to you and your children” you could also read the worst into it. Likewise if I’d said “but hope you and your kids are happy” if you’re insecure enough, your response could be “my kids ARE happy, so fuck off”! Etc etc

My “good luck to you and your children” has clearly touched a nerve - but it says more about you than me. 😊

You’re antagonistic, sarcastic and argumentative, and rather unpleasant sounding at times.

Sure, you’re all about the support.

adriftabroad · 16/10/2022 17:44

Yep, bit of a personal attack IMO

CoffeePlease93 · 16/10/2022 17:44

@Pumperthepumper @Derbee exactly, she’s the one who started with her little aggressive message who seems to know all about me and my personality as a stranger off the internet! 😂

OP posts:
CoffeePlease93 · 16/10/2022 17:45

I think some people just write nasty and un helpful messages on here on threads just so they can take out their problems on someone else and not have to face the consequences…

OP posts:
DeannaFromHumanResources · 16/10/2022 17:46

CoffeePlease93 · 16/10/2022 17:43

@DeannaFromHumanResources right so I’m guessing you missed the part where my child won’t be there then?

🫣 oops sorry @CoffeePlease93 I don’t see the point then.

adriftabroad · 16/10/2022 17:47

OP I started a thread (I never do) when I saw on MSM that Sarah Beeny had breast cancer. I was so upset.
I got accused of implying her boys had beat her up in my OP.

It went very oddly.

gogohmm · 16/10/2022 17:51

It's fine to request to meet at school as you would find it easier, no need to go into a multitude of excuses. It's also easy to say I work until x time. If your dc goes to afterschool care they will know you work

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:55

@CoffeePlease93 just catching up on this thread. Interesting to see the variety of responses.

I'm starting a new school safeguarding role (social worker) and had planned to ring parents to introduce myself and come do a home visit.

I'm sure some parents will decline. I'm not sure what conclusions I will draw as it will depend on wider things like past referrals/child's needs/demeanour and reason for refusing the visit. I can't force anyone to allow me to visit but my visit would be to allow them to put a face to a name, show them that I am willing to come and give them the time of day as there has been staffing shortage, and yes, to see the home environment

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:56

And to see how the child presents at home and if there's anything I can do to support in school/any worries

Pumperthepumper · 16/10/2022 17:59

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:55

@CoffeePlease93 just catching up on this thread. Interesting to see the variety of responses.

I'm starting a new school safeguarding role (social worker) and had planned to ring parents to introduce myself and come do a home visit.

I'm sure some parents will decline. I'm not sure what conclusions I will draw as it will depend on wider things like past referrals/child's needs/demeanour and reason for refusing the visit. I can't force anyone to allow me to visit but my visit would be to allow them to put a face to a name, show them that I am willing to come and give them the time of day as there has been staffing shortage, and yes, to see the home environment

You’re going to ring all the parents of all the kids in your school and judge them on their ‘demeanour’ and how good an excuse they give?

namechangetheworld · 16/10/2022 18:27

Honestly, we never have guests because I'm embarassed of our tiny house. The idea of DD1's Reception teacher visiting sent me into a state of panic, but I never would have declined or insisted on cutting it short, because I knew that DD would have a lovely red flag next to her name before she even started school. We can all play faux naive and pretend it won't happen, but it doesn't look good does it?

I do find it weird that they want a whole hours visit though, ours was about ten minutes max - are you absolutely sure they're visiting the homes of all of the children in the class? It must be taking the weeks to get through everybody.

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 18:31

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:55

@CoffeePlease93 just catching up on this thread. Interesting to see the variety of responses.

I'm starting a new school safeguarding role (social worker) and had planned to ring parents to introduce myself and come do a home visit.

I'm sure some parents will decline. I'm not sure what conclusions I will draw as it will depend on wider things like past referrals/child's needs/demeanour and reason for refusing the visit. I can't force anyone to allow me to visit but my visit would be to allow them to put a face to a name, show them that I am willing to come and give them the time of day as there has been staffing shortage, and yes, to see the home environment

I understand if you cant say where you are but Id be interested to know

Are you a qualified social worker and do you work for a school under the education department? Im amazed they have the funding for that.

Or do you mean you are part of the wider safeguarding role within social services but have a number of schools that you link with?

Are your visits part of a current referral or open case as you mention safeguarding? If they're not I would wonder what remit this comes under?

Abraxan · 16/10/2022 18:34

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:55

@CoffeePlease93 just catching up on this thread. Interesting to see the variety of responses.

I'm starting a new school safeguarding role (social worker) and had planned to ring parents to introduce myself and come do a home visit.

I'm sure some parents will decline. I'm not sure what conclusions I will draw as it will depend on wider things like past referrals/child's needs/demeanour and reason for refusing the visit. I can't force anyone to allow me to visit but my visit would be to allow them to put a face to a name, show them that I am willing to come and give them the time of day as there has been staffing shortage, and yes, to see the home environment

Are you planning to visit the homes of every reception starter in the first few months of then starting school? Whilst their child isn't there, during the day?

What will you gain by doing the home visits rather than inviting the parents one by one into school for example?

I'm curious as to how much time it would take to go to every child's home and how much more beneficial it will be compared to seeing parents in school without the need for you visiting them across a wide area.

Abraxan · 16/10/2022 18:35

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 17:56

And to see how the child presents at home and if there's anything I can do to support in school/any worries

Op says her child won't be present during the appointment, iirr.

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 18:42

@Pumperthepumper it's not quite as simplistic as that, as I indicated. If a family is on CP and there are numerous neglect referrals and they refuse a home visit it would give me cause to think deeper. Surely it would for most people?

@bellac11 I'll be in a specialist autism, adhd and SEMH provision, I won't say which area but I will say up north. I am a qualified social worker, have worked in Child Protection and education in a couple of different roles. It's an academy with EHCP fees attached, in a deprived area, so they have more funding available and they have a few sites all with their own social worker. And two lead social workers to manage safeguarding training overall across all the schools and to provide supervision. They get consistently good ofsteds for their safeguarding management.

My visits will be entirely optional, and will be part of getting to know the families as otherwise I'll have little contact with some as there are a lot of taxi drop offs due to it being an send provision.

@Abraxan please see above. Not Year R visits. These are secondary age children.

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 18:44

@Abraxan also I can't invite parents in one by one necessarily as it's a secure specialist provision and too many unknown adults could upset the children.

hadtochangetothisone · 16/10/2022 18:46

limitedperiodonly · 16/10/2022 16:28

I know children are abused. This is not an excuse for someone to come round your house and check on you unless they have some other cause for concern. Though not an exclusive list that would include visible injury, extreme withdrawnness, unkemptness, inappropriate behaviour and possibly persistent lateness especially when accompanied by a primary-aged child not being accompanied by a parent.

What else are people who insist routine home visits are a good thing looking for? How long do they keep them up?

Not every child who is abused and deserving of help lives in a house with dog shit on the carpets and parents who get pissed before 10am. But if they do those signs are easier to spot than someone who is a psychological abuser but welcomes you in and gives you a fancy biscuit with your coffee.

Abuse can start at any time at any time in a child's life and usually starts with a change in circumstance like parents losing their jobs or developing a substance abuse problem or a single mother getting a new partner. Obviously not all change leads to abuse. Many parents respond heroically to it which is why it is always worth looking out for signs rather than routine home visits which are a waste of time and likely to be refused no matter how that looks.

So given all you have said (and you seem to have a realistic grip on how well hidden abuse can be) you think that a routine home visit is best NOT done ?

I can't see the logic.
Let's say out of 100 visits there is nothing to report in 99 visits . (Although it later comes to light that there is 'hidden dv in two of the posh houses with naive biscuits and filter coffee' ... but in one house there is serious and obvious neglect.

What would MN vote. ?
Sod the 'one' my anxiety, anti-socialness, work commitments, stressed dog are far more important.

Or

Rescuing one child out of a hundred trumps everything.

If you have nothing to hide then you should all get over yourselves and embrace vigilance regarding child protection. These children have NO ONE.. they rely on decent adults being vigilant.

The two posh families will be clever at hiding abuse. Doesn't mean we stop looking out for others .

Pumperthepumper · 16/10/2022 18:46

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 18:42

@Pumperthepumper it's not quite as simplistic as that, as I indicated. If a family is on CP and there are numerous neglect referrals and they refuse a home visit it would give me cause to think deeper. Surely it would for most people?

@bellac11 I'll be in a specialist autism, adhd and SEMH provision, I won't say which area but I will say up north. I am a qualified social worker, have worked in Child Protection and education in a couple of different roles. It's an academy with EHCP fees attached, in a deprived area, so they have more funding available and they have a few sites all with their own social worker. And two lead social workers to manage safeguarding training overall across all the schools and to provide supervision. They get consistently good ofsteds for their safeguarding management.

My visits will be entirely optional, and will be part of getting to know the families as otherwise I'll have little contact with some as there are a lot of taxi drop offs due to it being an send provision.

@Abraxan please see above. Not Year R visits. These are secondary age children.

Thats not what you said though - you said you’d decide based on their demeanour and their response to a potential visit. Are you psychic?

bellac11 · 16/10/2022 18:49

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 18:42

@Pumperthepumper it's not quite as simplistic as that, as I indicated. If a family is on CP and there are numerous neglect referrals and they refuse a home visit it would give me cause to think deeper. Surely it would for most people?

@bellac11 I'll be in a specialist autism, adhd and SEMH provision, I won't say which area but I will say up north. I am a qualified social worker, have worked in Child Protection and education in a couple of different roles. It's an academy with EHCP fees attached, in a deprived area, so they have more funding available and they have a few sites all with their own social worker. And two lead social workers to manage safeguarding training overall across all the schools and to provide supervision. They get consistently good ofsteds for their safeguarding management.

My visits will be entirely optional, and will be part of getting to know the families as otherwise I'll have little contact with some as there are a lot of taxi drop offs due to it being an send provision.

@Abraxan please see above. Not Year R visits. These are secondary age children.

Thats interesting and could be a useful service but I cant get my head around the visits being from a 'safeguarding social worker' if the child is not open to services based on safeguarding concerns.

Thats why Im questioning the remit and your authority in those visits.

Obviously if you're only visiting children who are already on chin or cp plans thats different.

Navigatingnewwaters · 16/10/2022 19:19

It’s standard round here, trust me they are not interested in seeing your house, simply doing their jobs 😵‍💫

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 19:26

@Pumperthepumper I said that demeanour would be part of that? Meaning that if I ring up and OFFER a visit, operative word being offer, then if they say something like 'f* off, no way I'm letting you lot near my house' that would raise alarms would it not?
Obviously I'm not psychic hence I can only go off the info that I have. Being a psychic social worker is but a dream.

@hadtochangetothisone I know you weren't replying to me but just wanted to say that as a social worker, sometimes a routine home visit can be just as telling. And also gives you time to talk to the parents.

@bellac11 My title would be DSL and school social worker. I have no authority to force a home visit but an authority and clearance to offer one iyswim? I would very much like the chance to get to meet the parents, as like I say, I won't see them at drop off most likely. And they aren't really able to come into school for visits except for on designated evenings/days.

bruffin · 16/10/2022 19:34

bingbummy · 16/10/2022 12:16

I've never heard of this. I did have a sit down with the school but that was in the school.

Where is this the norm? Is it small villages?

My DC are 25 and 27 and although their school didnt do this , it was certainly normal back then

putitinthefuckitbucket · 16/10/2022 19:35

Some schools do it here, some don't. Ours doesn't. But before they start in reception we get invited in, just us and the child to meet the teacher and see the classroom so they're not new to them on the first day. Even happened in 2020. We just tested first, masked up and distanced inside.

My child had a good look around, wrote on a chalkboard, had a chat with the teacher and then off we went!

That was beneficial I think. Not sure a home visit would have been really. But I wouldn't have declined it if they would have wanted to come. I think it's really important to have a positive relationship with your child's school and their teacher, which means both parties being as agreeable as is possible.

Pumperthepumper · 16/10/2022 19:35

HarvestTimeMuthafluffa · 16/10/2022 19:26

@Pumperthepumper I said that demeanour would be part of that? Meaning that if I ring up and OFFER a visit, operative word being offer, then if they say something like 'f* off, no way I'm letting you lot near my house' that would raise alarms would it not?
Obviously I'm not psychic hence I can only go off the info that I have. Being a psychic social worker is but a dream.

@hadtochangetothisone I know you weren't replying to me but just wanted to say that as a social worker, sometimes a routine home visit can be just as telling. And also gives you time to talk to the parents.

@bellac11 My title would be DSL and school social worker. I have no authority to force a home visit but an authority and clearance to offer one iyswim? I would very much like the chance to get to meet the parents, as like I say, I won't see them at drop off most likely. And they aren't really able to come into school for visits except for on designated evenings/days.

It wouldn’t ring alarm bells no, I’d imagine they had negative involvement with social work beige and (you’d hope!) a new person would try to fix that rather than immediately jumping to conclusions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread