Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the most of the best men don't use dating apps?

167 replies

Heytheredeliah · 02/07/2022 13:57

I am actively trying online dating at the moment and most of the men on there are just rude and awful. The messages I get are weird or rude. The conversation sometimes starts off fine and then goes weird. I have met so many great guys in real life, but they always seem to have girlfriends or are married. They are handsome, kind , clever and have good careers.

When I go on dating apps, I just don't seem to find guys like that on there. I feel quite lonely and I would love to have a partner. I have been on so many awful dates with guys I have met online.

AIBU to think that the best men with lots going for them (good looks, kind, good job etc) are rare on dating apps?

OP posts:
RiojaRose · 04/07/2022 11:35

Thank you @FloydPepper !

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/07/2022 12:11

DillonPanthersTexas Any suggestions of high end Michelin star type restaurants as a first date

This will depend on your finances and on the social circles you move in. Amongst some of my friends, no-one would bat an eyelid at this. Many people prefer to eat at a top quality restaurant rather than a slightly cheaper less reliable one. I appreciate that some women might be looking for a free meal, but just agree to pay half in advance in that case?

I can afford to go to high end restaurants as do the circles I move in. For me first dates were a coffee or midweek drink somewhere, a low stake date as someone up thread phrased it, a pre date meeting if you will. I did not want a full dinner date first as to be blunt if it works out to be a poor match it can be a very long evening indeed. Also, despite all the 'let go Dutch' on a date folk on here the fact is that 'out there' there are a sizable number of women who still expect the bloke to pay for first dates even when OLD. If you are proactive with OLD it is not uncommon to have multiple dates in a short space of time, it can get quite expensive if you are not careful. If I am going to pick up the tab for a high end restaurant I would at least like to have met the person first and know that there is an initial connection/attraction and that there is a reasonable chance that the evening will be enjoyable. Just because I can afford to eat out at nice places it does not mean I prepared to throw money around because some person I have not yet met fancies going to Le Gavroche. I also kind of want the person I am dating to like me for who I am and not due to what swish restaurant I can take them to. If a potential date refuses to meet for a coffee and insists on an upmarket establishment that to me is not a great sign.

A reluctance to move from messaging to an actual phone call. I always insisted on speaking first before meeting. If you can't hold a conversation on the phone you will struggle in person.

Thankfully I only used OLD for 3 weeks and am not single, but a man I'd never met wanting my telephone number and insisting on grilling me over the phone would be a complete red flag. I don't even have phone conversations with my closest friends! Are you quite old? What a strange thing to say. Who uses the phone now? It sounds cringeworthy to do this with a complete stranger, whereas a coffee in a public place where you see all the nuances of facial expression and don't risked being stalked by a nutter who has access to your phone number is a much safer idea for women. tbh I'd be more of the opinion that any man who demanded my phone number and a phone conversation and refused to meet up in person wasn't discerning enough about the number of women they were chatting to and was likely to be a timewaster, and block him.

Who said anything about 'grilling' anyone on the phone or 'demanding' their number? It's a simple get to know each other chat. If they did not want to talk on the phone then no problem, I respected that and we went our separate ways. Also, they are not complete strangers either, you have by that stage swapped multiple emails/messages and are slowly getting a 'feel' for the other person. However, I found on a few occasions the woman I had been corresponding with did not match up with the person I met in real life. That funny, witty person in writing was in person introverted, shy and difficult to have a flowing conversation with. Crafting an interesting written message in your own time is quite different to having a live conversation. You can also pick up plenty of nuances and build a decent picture of someone on the phone. As others have pointed out, I did not want a pen friend yet some people seemed quite happy to spend weeks swapping emails without any real intention of meeting in person. Suggesting a chat on the phone, for me, helped weed out the timewasters. As for 'nutters' with your number, you just block them.

Suggestions of meeting at your house as a first date.

Do women actually do this as well? Who on earth would offer to go round to a complete strangers' house? Do they try and get payment for it? There were so many men suggesting it on OLD that I got seriously creeped out by it and stopped using it. Even having to listen to those suggestions was soul destroying.

I agree. And yes some women did suggest meeting for a date at either my or their homes. It freaked me out as well and I declined.

Anyway, these are just 'my rules' and they have served me well. Others will have their own boundaries and rules.

FunDragon · 04/07/2022 12:20

I’ve not used OLD but going off friends’ experiences, it sounds like a huge proportion of men on OLD are really open, angry misogynists. Proper Incel types who really hate women. Presumably they haven’t been able to find girlfriends because they hate women!

JenniferWooley · 04/07/2022 14:06

A quick lunchtime swipe through tinder produced the following:

a man who looks old enough to be my dad claiming to be my age

a man looking for his partner in crime (a phrase that instantly gets a left swipe)

a man looking for something long term but a FWB situation is fine if available

a man that looks like they need rehab (genuinely seen less jakey looking actual jakies)

a man whose pics are all groups so I no idea which one he is hoping it's the one with the beard but won't swipe right in case it's the geriatric with the walking frame

a man whose children are his 🌎 with obligatory pictures of said children (I'd expect them to be so not sure why the declaration is needed & pics of kids are a no no on a dating site in my book)

a man who is in the area for 48 hours & looking for a hook up

a man who is currently renovating a van to go on a murder spree touring the country

FFS no wonder I'd rather go to bed with a cup of tea & a good book!

I'm just looking for a decent guy, around my own age, that I find reasonably attractive, with a job, own house (doesn't even have to own it just not living with parents/friends in a bachelor pad), own car (been there done that with a non-driver & it was a nightmare) & wants to do normal shit like dinner, movies, days out, the odd weekend away etc

MinglingFlamingo · 04/07/2022 14:10

JenniferWooley · 04/07/2022 14:06

A quick lunchtime swipe through tinder produced the following:

a man who looks old enough to be my dad claiming to be my age

a man looking for his partner in crime (a phrase that instantly gets a left swipe)

a man looking for something long term but a FWB situation is fine if available

a man that looks like they need rehab (genuinely seen less jakey looking actual jakies)

a man whose pics are all groups so I no idea which one he is hoping it's the one with the beard but won't swipe right in case it's the geriatric with the walking frame

a man whose children are his 🌎 with obligatory pictures of said children (I'd expect them to be so not sure why the declaration is needed & pics of kids are a no no on a dating site in my book)

a man who is in the area for 48 hours & looking for a hook up

a man who is currently renovating a van to go on a murder spree touring the country

FFS no wonder I'd rather go to bed with a cup of tea & a good book!

I'm just looking for a decent guy, around my own age, that I find reasonably attractive, with a job, own house (doesn't even have to own it just not living with parents/friends in a bachelor pad), own car (been there done that with a non-driver & it was a nightmare) & wants to do normal shit like dinner, movies, days out, the odd weekend away etc

Omg I could have written this post last night!!

fghj149 · 04/07/2022 14:15

I met my husband on one and don’t regret it at all. We have had mutual friends for years but we had never met or heard of each other and probably wouldn’t have ever met had it not been for the app. Neither of us were into online dating either. We both went on one date from it before meeting each other. Don’t write them off, a whole variety of people use them and there are good people out there.

SalaciousRumour · 04/07/2022 14:21

DillonPanthersTexas that all sounds perfectly reasonable but I'd suggest that your insistence on the telephone call is going to appeal to only women who can be easily told what to do or who maybe aren't in employment or in a very demanding job or who are older. Younger generations just do not speak on the phone. And tbh if some man I'd never met started telling me to use my free time after work on phone calls, I'd tell him to get lost. I spend all day at work on and off the phone and I have no desire to do it all evening. Phone calls tend to get quite drawn out and IMHO if a man is doing so much online dating that he has to weed out women with phone calls before even meeting up, I'd write him off. Text messages, emails, other types of messaging tend to be quick and easy and not use up half your evening. So for that matter is meeting for a quick coffee and while its nice to be told that your potential date doesn't see enough in you to bother paying for half his dinner, if he can't be bothered to invest in a coffee then he wouldn't have the personal character that I'd be looking for.

Thankfully, I've always been able to meet potential dates through my profession or sports and interests.

JenniferWooley for some reason, a high proportion of the men on Tinder in my area are completely bald, have remarkably round heads and pose with their tongues sticking out! Loads of them. I've also noticed that its only the bald ones who have photos with their tongues sticking out. I'm actually wondering if the tongue sticking out thing is some kind of local custom, although I'm not in New Zealand, I'm in Scotland.

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/07/2022 15:17

SalaciousRumour

You are projecting quite a bit there! We are talking about a 10-15 min phone call, not some all day or all evening telethon! Also, to assert that those who can pick up the phone are somehow meek, unemployed time rich old people is an odd conclusion to arrive at. I would rather a short phone call then a few hours of my time wasted on a meeting with somebody I have zero connection with, something that could have been determined on said phone call. The women I have dated in the past and are generally drawn to are confident, independent with their own careers and interests, they had no issues chatting and establishing a bit of a rapport on the phone before meeting in person.

I have no issues buying a coffee or drinks on a first meeting or indeed paying my own way generally, I did raise eyebrows though when someone I have never met was suggesting that instead of a coffee or a glass of wine I drop £300 plus on a Michelin starred restaurant, to me it just came across as a bit rude and grabby.

SalaciousRumour · 04/07/2022 15:21

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/07/2022 15:17

SalaciousRumour

You are projecting quite a bit there! We are talking about a 10-15 min phone call, not some all day or all evening telethon! Also, to assert that those who can pick up the phone are somehow meek, unemployed time rich old people is an odd conclusion to arrive at. I would rather a short phone call then a few hours of my time wasted on a meeting with somebody I have zero connection with, something that could have been determined on said phone call. The women I have dated in the past and are generally drawn to are confident, independent with their own careers and interests, they had no issues chatting and establishing a bit of a rapport on the phone before meeting in person.

I have no issues buying a coffee or drinks on a first meeting or indeed paying my own way generally, I did raise eyebrows though when someone I have never met was suggesting that instead of a coffee or a glass of wine I drop £300 plus on a Michelin starred restaurant, to me it just came across as a bit rude and grabby.

But you're clearly perennially single with a lengthy history of failed dates behind you, so it might be time to figure out what you're doing wrong. The fact that several women on this thread have told you that they would rule out a man who insists on telephone calls (even a FaceTime would be better) would tend to indicate that there are lots of women out there who wouldn't either. I think a lot of women try to avoid serial online daters too. Who wants to here about women who tried to get you to go to expensive restaurants that you were suspicous of? It doesn't make you come across well.

D0lphine · 04/07/2022 15:26

Hi OP I met my partner on bumble. He is late 30s I am early 30s.

I actually managed to meet some other nice men online. They were all nice really just not for me.

I think I was very straightforward (blunt!) about what I wanted on my profile. I also had lots of rules for who I would talk to and was absolutely ruthless in enforcing those rules! Basically are they a decent human with no fucking about haha! For example, if someone had no profile / a shit profile I wouldn't speak to them.

At your age I'd honestly be quite chilled about meeting someone. What else do you have going on? Do you want to travel, work abroad, change career, save up for a flat? If so now is the time to do it!

SleeplessInEngland · 04/07/2022 15:40

I'm not smug about many things in my life, but I must admit to being really relieve I never had to do OLD. It sounds like a fucking nightmare, and people suggesting that you have to be 'disciplined' and treat it like a job search only make it more bleak.

SleeplessInEngland · 04/07/2022 15:43

MinorWomensWhiplash1 · 02/07/2022 15:55

@LoveLarry No I don’t think it is the same for women actually. Personally I believe there are a lot more eligible single women of all ages out there compared to men. Sorry if you’re a bloke. As a group you really need to up your game imo.

Unless you think the average woman is simply more eligible than the average man how is the above even possible, mathematically? Eligible mean and women will cancel each other out and won't be in the OLD pool.

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/07/2022 15:47

But you're clearly perennially single with a lengthy history of failed dates behind you, so it might be time to figure out what you're doing wrong. The fact that several women on this thread have told you that they would rule out a man who insists on telephone calls (even a FaceTime would be better) would tend to indicate that there are lots of women out there who wouldn't either. I think a lot of women try to avoid serial online daters too. Who wants to here about women who tried to get you to go to expensive restaurants that you were suspicous of? It doesn't make you come across well.

Again you are projecting, and getting it very wrong. I am married, I met my wife via OLD. Before I met her I went on numerous dates (I assume like most people running the OLD gauntlet or did everyone hit the jackpot on date one?), some dates at the start of the process were crap because I was a bit naïve and did not do my due diligence. Over time, as well as taking advice from friends who were also OLD I managed to work out a few basic strategies that helped eliminate the timewasters and oddballs. After that the dates I went on were much more enjoyable, they might not have ended in a romantic long term relationship but I certainly did not view them as 'failed' as I had pleasant time meeting some interesting people outside of my usual social circle, some of which went on to became good friends as we did have loads in common. People upthread were asking for advice, I gave my views, some (including yourself) objected to the phone call in advance element, and that's fine, you do your thing that works for you, what I did (including a phone call) worked for me. Unlike what has been suggested on here, I did not 'demand' or 'tell' someone to get on the phone, I politely asked if they fancied actually talking rather then pinging messages back and forth, if they said no, I did not sulk, get angry or throw my toys out the pram.

motogirl · 04/07/2022 15:50

For middle aged men it's ok, most were in the same position as me, single after long relationships. I met my now dp. But I paid for a better company, the free ones were terrible

stuckdownahole · 04/07/2022 15:54

Heytheredeliah · 02/07/2022 15:57

@MinorWomensWhiplash1 I agree with you completely. I know so many lovely, attractive, successful single women. Can't say the same for men.

I'm a bloke and part of the problem is that, as the ageing process takes its toll, women can cover their imperfections quite well with nice clothes, make-up, hair. Men who go bald and get fat don't have the same resources to improve their appearance - the main one is lots of gym time and that requires considerable free time and energy.

Honestly, with most everything else settled in my life, the idea of giving up stuff that I actually do enjoy to slog away on a treadmill for months is not appealing unless it comes with some kind of guarantee of dating success (which of course it doesn't).

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 04/07/2022 15:54

SalaciousRumour · 04/07/2022 15:21

But you're clearly perennially single with a lengthy history of failed dates behind you, so it might be time to figure out what you're doing wrong. The fact that several women on this thread have told you that they would rule out a man who insists on telephone calls (even a FaceTime would be better) would tend to indicate that there are lots of women out there who wouldn't either. I think a lot of women try to avoid serial online daters too. Who wants to here about women who tried to get you to go to expensive restaurants that you were suspicous of? It doesn't make you come across well.

Erm.
Lots of women requested moving to a call before meeting.
Even dp requested a call at 12am.
To check if I was married.😬😂
I told her no.

1VY · 04/07/2022 16:16

My dear OP, you are a student, please get off dating apps, stop looking for a BF or husband and enjoy your life.

Work hard on your studies and career, fill all your free time with friends, going out , hobbies, travelling, working, sports and volunteering. You shouldn’t be lonely at university, there are so many options open to you. Go out and join some clubs / groups now.

You will never get this time back, please don’t waste it chasing sad blokes online who just want a shag / phone sex / pics. If you are not in a good place yourself, OLD will destroy you.

Why on earth are you keen to be tied down when the vast majority of your peers ( 22, doing a good course at a good university ) are out enjoying life ? Please get some counselling and work on your self esteem.

exceptmeandmymonkey · 04/07/2022 16:24

OLD was great for me. I am shy/introverted, wasn't into the bar scene, and because of the nature of my work I never met people there. I found that once I was out of university/grad school, I never met people "naturally" and most of my hobbies were things enjoyed by women.

Met my husband of 10 years OLD (guardian), met previous long-term partners on other sites. I tended to date men who, like me, were geeky but nice people who wanted LTRs (the other guy I went on one date with before my husband was a very nice Oxford PhD just out of a LTR). First meetings were always quick and public (like coffee for an hour) and when I didn't get on with someone, it was usually for reasons of no chemistry or different paths. I went maybe 3 unpleasant dates out of 50 over 10 years of off-on dating. I really can't understand the stories from people who exclusively find married men or perverts on OLD as that wasn't my experience, but it sounds awful!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 04/07/2022 16:32

stuckdownahole · 04/07/2022 15:54

I'm a bloke and part of the problem is that, as the ageing process takes its toll, women can cover their imperfections quite well with nice clothes, make-up, hair. Men who go bald and get fat don't have the same resources to improve their appearance - the main one is lots of gym time and that requires considerable free time and energy.

Honestly, with most everything else settled in my life, the idea of giving up stuff that I actually do enjoy to slog away on a treadmill for months is not appealing unless it comes with some kind of guarantee of dating success (which of course it doesn't).

Sorry, I disagree, you don't need a wig, being slim is preferable to being fat. It has all kinds of physical and mental health benefits.
Unhealthy habits like overeating and drinking take their toll on men later on, but you can reverse that process.

LAtalante · 04/07/2022 16:40

A friend met her OH on the Guardian Soulmates website after about 5 years of getting disillusioned. I think that's gone now, not sure if anything's taken it's place.

He's a good egg on all fronts, I believe. Nice guy, kind, secure, honest, good career and work/life/hobby balance. Nice looking and good social skills. I'm just posting because there's a few diamonds in the mine I guess!

MissConductUS · 04/07/2022 16:45

He's a good egg on all fronts, I believe. Nice guy, kind, secure, honest, good career and work/life/hobby balance. Nice looking and good social skills. I'm just posting because there's a few diamonds in the mine I guess!

This was my experience too. There are good, normal men on dating sites. You just have to push through the dross.

AllTheDancers · 04/07/2022 16:58

Heytheredelilah I'm a bloke and part of the problem is that, as the ageing process takes its toll, women can cover their imperfections quite well with nice clothes, make-up, hair. Men who go bald and get fat don't have the same resources to improve their appearance - the main one is lots of gym time and that requires considerable free time and energy.

You don't need a gym to lose weight or be fit. Most sports take place outwith gyms. I met my DH through a cycling club. Many of my friends met their husbands through sporting hobbies. Very few of us use gyms regularly.

Honestly, with most everything else settled in my life, the idea of giving up stuff that I actually do enjoy to slog away on a treadmill for months is not appealing unless it comes with some kind of guarantee of dating success (which of course it doesn't).

30 minutes a day exercise and eating well is hardly slogging away. Perhaps women are wary of taking on likely health issues/Type 2 diabetes in the future?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 04/07/2022 17:52

Pinkerty · 02/07/2022 15:34

OLD is not for the faint hearted and I had my fair share of nightmares but I met my DH online so there are some good ones - you just have to have the will to battle through the crap!

...which, unsurprisingly, is true of any way of meeting people, including just kinda living.

JenniferWooley · 04/07/2022 21:06

@SalaciousRumour I'm also in Scotland & get a fair number of bald blokes showing up could be the same ones

My own personal favourite is men who insist on either a practically naked selfie complete with Chippendale pose or a photo of them in bed (again bare chested) as their profile pic - automatic left swipe in either case.

In all fairness it's not just OLD, looking around my family & friends OH's there's not many men that I'd put up with in a relationship or maybe I'm just really fussy.

MinglingFlamingo · 04/07/2022 21:18

I came across one the other day which was a bloke taking a photo of himself in the mirror... with a bank of urinals behind him