Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step mother gifting half brother his ‘birth right’ inheritance

396 replies

Undertherainbow00 · 04/06/2022 20:01

I just need somewhere to vent - I’m sure I will be shot down for being unreasonable but maybe someone will see my point of view or will enable me to view this through a different lens…
Family history in brief - step mother has been in my life since just before I turned five (I’m now 43) and she and my father began dating. My parents marriage broke down because of his alcoholism but being the 80’s, the judge decided he could still have my sister and I every other weekend. As a side note, step mother was eight years younger than my father and was approaching her 21st birthday when they got together. She too had a problem with alcohol but they masked their problems to the wider outside world… Her parents were not happy that she was dating an older man who was divorced with two children. However, as time went by, her parents (mainly her mother) warmed to my sister and I. When I was fourteen, my father and step mother had their child, a son. I should add that at this point neither of them drank but my father still had his uncontrollable temper that was often directed at me. She actively encouraged his discipline methods but would also be there to comfort me through my tears.
I fell pregnant at sixteen and to my astonishment both my father and step mother were supportive of my choice to keep the pregnancy. However, it could been seen as fulfilling a prophecy of their making… Problem child, pregnant at sixteen. I would just like to add, any problems I had were directed at myself - eating disorder, self harm and suicide attempts.
I completely got my life together once I was pregnant - worked and set up a home on my own.
That was all many moons ago now and since then I have made an attempt to improve my life chances. I returned to education as an adult and I have a career. However, at the ripe old age of forty three - I have never owned or have been in a position to save a deposit for a house.
Step mother engineered hers and my father’s will like this - their house split 50/50 her share to my half brother and my father’s 50 % share split three ways between all three siblings. Fair?
Anyway, her parents died several years back and left her a significant inheritance. She bought her two siblings out of the parents house as she didn’t want to sell it at that point. Today she has told me that she is selling it as my half brother is very anxious about approaching thirty without owning his own property. She is gifting him the entire proceeds of the house sale - a minimum of £500,000. I just sat there listening to her monologue of how much of his income is wasted in rent - I really can’t relate can I?
She waffled on that it was his birth right as they were his grandparents.
I feel SO angry as their property was bought from the sale of my parents house - so by that logic, my sister and I should have a greater share of their house.
My step mother has always spouted that she loves us all the same but words and actions are completely at odds with the reality of what our lives have been.
I feel bitter that I have forgiven them for their appalling behaviour when I was a child and I have never shared my experiences with my half brother. I have stood back and watched him have everything in life that I didn’t but this has really rocked me and I feel terrible for feeling like this. I am jealous that he will have a home of his own as I fear I never will.
I apologise for this ramble but if you got to the end - thank you! It was cathartic to just get it out of my head!

OP posts:
AskingforaBaskin · 04/06/2022 22:04

Pinkyxx · 04/06/2022 22:01

I don't disagree it's common. What I take issue with the fact that step families often feed children this notion that the step family is a 'family', that all children are equal. They aren't, cannot be and in my view it's best to simply be honest about that rather than mislead.

I can't imagine wanting my assets to go to someone else's kids, no matter how much I might care about them. In that sense, I agree with the SM in this equation - I'd do exactly the same. However I wouldn't mislead any child into believing I cared about them anywhere near as much as I do my own flesh and blood. I couldn't be complicit playing out some multi-year charade of 'nuclear family life' where unrelated kids 'play happy families' together and grow up believing they are all siblings on equal standing.

They are equal. They will all inherit from their one mother and one father

diddl · 04/06/2022 22:04

I don’t understand why the OP’s mum left the marital home and therefore losing her right to any claim.

was the dad still living with them until the divorce was finalised? Isn’t this unusual?

It's strange isn't it?

If so, sounds as if Op's dad was happy enough to screw over his ex & kids in the process!

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:06

@ClocksGoingBackwards word it how you like. Her brother will still receive 50% more. It would not have been something that me or my partner would've even considered. Guess everyone is different though.

AskingforaBaskin · 04/06/2022 22:06

Strangeways19 · 04/06/2022 22:02

If I'm reading it correctly I think people are misreading.
I think what OP is saying is that when her dad died the stepmum perhaps sold the house she was living in & bought her siblings out of their share of the grandparents house (step mum's parents).
So by selling now & giving her son the whole lot (I don't know where she's going to live unless it's with her son in his house), it bypasses her completely.

I might be wrong of course!

Her Dad is alive

MummyGummy · 04/06/2022 22:09

YANBU. Her son is already getting 500k, he’s taken care of & that’s perfectly reasonable as it’s from his grandparents. Their house should be split between the 3 children equally, anything else will understandably leave you feeling less valued & loved.
Just remember in a few years if she starts needing help in her old age that’s her son’s responsibility, not yours or your sisters.

Sae123 · 04/06/2022 22:10

I would feel exactly the same as you. I understand the logic behind your SM's decision, but I think it's mean to go on about your SB's housing situation when she knows yours.

I'm not in a blended set-up, and reading the thread there are different views. The ones where people say long term blending of families have equal shares in wills sits most comfortably with me.

WooNoodle · 04/06/2022 22:10

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 21:54

@whumpthereitis @WooNoodle How the hell do you know she is getting inheritance from her mother?

Her dad has three children, so one is going to get a 66% share of his estate, and the other 2 are getting splitting 33%. Yeah that's really fair.

Caveat, I'm not a money grabber or a selfish twat. Our will is a mirror will, so if one of us dies, it all passes to the other. My DP has a child, I don't. If he dies before me, she will still eventually receive 50% of our estate, even though everything passes to me. If I die first, then my sister's, or their children will also receive 50% when he does. See, fair.

I don't and haven't even mentioned any other inheritance but that is completely irrelevant. Dad can split his share however he likes and Stepmum can split her share however she likes.

Strangeways19 · 04/06/2022 22:10

AskingforaBaskin · 04/06/2022 22:06

Her Dad is alive

Oh I'm misreading then.

I am mum in a blended family & all kids are getting the same in the will. I guess that's personal choice though

Tothepoint99 · 04/06/2022 22:12

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 21:54

@whumpthereitis @WooNoodle How the hell do you know she is getting inheritance from her mother?

Her dad has three children, so one is going to get a 66% share of his estate, and the other 2 are getting splitting 33%. Yeah that's really fair.

Caveat, I'm not a money grabber or a selfish twat. Our will is a mirror will, so if one of us dies, it all passes to the other. My DP has a child, I don't. If he dies before me, she will still eventually receive 50% of our estate, even though everything passes to me. If I die first, then my sister's, or their children will also receive 50% when he does. See, fair.

Nope. Try again.

YetAnotherNam · 04/06/2022 22:14

@diddl , if he stayed in the family home and there was that clause, he probably made the OP’s mum life hell so that she would leave.

I just find it odd that she was the victim of domestic abuse and he was allowed to remain in the house. It sounds like it could have been dangerous.

Unless the mum didn’t report it.

Mellowyellow222 · 04/06/2022 22:15

You parents divorced when your dad was 28, maybe younger?

did he and your mum Own their home outright - or did they have a mortgage? I am guessing they had a mortgage and they split the equity - which probably wasn’t that much.

so your dad probably didn’t go into his second marriage with enough cash to buy a house outright. After living with his second wife for nearly forty years it is reasonable that they have Both contributed to the family home - splitting their halves amongst their children seems fair. It works in your half brothers favour because they are both his parents. You will also inherit from your mother.

as for your step brothers inheritance - did your dad contribute financially to the purchase of your step mothers parents home? If he did I can see why you might seek a little hard done by - but if he didn’t you have no connection to this inheritance.

life is sometimes unfair - your brother as an only child to his mother inherits more - you are one of three children to your father. You can’t expect to automatically inherit from step family.

stepuporshutup · 04/06/2022 22:15

Crankley · 04/06/2022 20:31

I think it's entirely reasonable. You have no blood connection with her or her parents. Presumably you will get an inheritance from your parents.

Yes I agree it is not part of your blood family

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:15

@WooNoodle apologies, I was responding to 2 of you off my comment. No, you didn't say there was any other inheritance. You asked if it was a fair world? Apparently not, in my opinion anyway.

Aprilx · 04/06/2022 22:16

The divorce settlement between your own parents many moons ago has nothing to do with this. Have you ever raised it as an issue before now? Why would your father the non resident parent have done better out of it?

Anyway it has nothing to do with your step mother gifting the inheritance from her parents to her son. Your parents 1980s divorce settlement has no bearing on that, why would it?

I don’t even think I can agree with the posters that say they can understand why you feel angry. I can’t, it all seems entirely fair.

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:17

@Tothepoint99 please honour your name and get to the point?

Tothepoint99 · 04/06/2022 22:19

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:17

@Tothepoint99 please honour your name and get to the point?

See Clockgoingbackwards

Villagewaspbyke · 04/06/2022 22:24

your father is still alive, no? The money that the step mother is giving her son is from her own parents. I think that’s entirely fair. Why would you expect that?

the parents divorce story doesn’t make any sense. Your parents were at most 28 when they divorced. Its unlikely they would have had much equity in a house. It’s not the case that your mum would have lost the right to a fair settlement in the 80s or now because she moved out the family home.

but anyway that’s irrelevant. You don’t have any right to inherit from anyone but why do you think you should get a share of your step parent’ s parents house? I have step kids in my family and no way would they expect that.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 04/06/2022 22:27

A couple of questions, what's your dad saying in all of this and will you inherit from your mum?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/06/2022 22:28

I'm sure it feels like crap.

I think lots of step parents wouldn't consider the step children once they have their own DC when passing on inheritance.

WooNoodle · 04/06/2022 22:28

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:15

@WooNoodle apologies, I was responding to 2 of you off my comment. No, you didn't say there was any other inheritance. You asked if it was a fair world? Apparently not, in my opinion anyway.

Ah I see.

For my situation it is entirely fair my child inherits from my hard work and my family's situation over my DSC. They can inherit from their dad and mum if she has anything to inherit. I think OP's situation has been complicated by the divorce settlement but that is not the step mums fault unless she was the solicitor handling the divorce.

WooNoodle · 04/06/2022 22:29

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/06/2022 22:28

I'm sure it feels like crap.

I think lots of step parents wouldn't consider the step children once they have their own DC when passing on inheritance.

I didn't even consider them before I had my DC.

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:29

@Tothepoint99 I'm well aware that the step-mum has every right to do what she wants with her share. However, I don't think it is morally or ethically sound to let one of your children get 2 3rds of an estate and the other two children to share a third. I wouldn't be married to the witch though. Is that ok or am I still not quite there? The OP asked if I thought she was being unreasonable, I don't, not when it concerns her father's estate anyway.

AskingforaBaskin · 04/06/2022 22:31

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:29

@Tothepoint99 I'm well aware that the step-mum has every right to do what she wants with her share. However, I don't think it is morally or ethically sound to let one of your children get 2 3rds of an estate and the other two children to share a third. I wouldn't be married to the witch though. Is that ok or am I still not quite there? The OP asked if I thought she was being unreasonable, I don't, not when it concerns her father's estate anyway.

So the father should disinherit his own son?

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 22:32

No one is actually entitled to an inheritance, though. The fact that someone may not inherit from their parent/s does not mean that it’s up to someone else’s parent to make it ‘fair’.

as shit as the original divorce settlement may have been, I’m not seeing how the stepmother is the villain of the piece. She came into the picture later, and based on the length of the marriage, half the assets are rightfully hers. If OP feels wronged it’s up to the father to make it right, not the stepmother who probably isn’t even aware of what actually happened (doubtful that her husband told her).

Sure, some stepfamilies may choose to divide everything up between all steps and biologicals, and if that works for them that’s great. It doesn’t mean that those who choose to divide it according to blood children are doing anything wrong though.

Villagewaspbyke · 04/06/2022 22:33

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 22:29

@Tothepoint99 I'm well aware that the step-mum has every right to do what she wants with her share. However, I don't think it is morally or ethically sound to let one of your children get 2 3rds of an estate and the other two children to share a third. I wouldn't be married to the witch though. Is that ok or am I still not quite there? The OP asked if I thought she was being unreasonable, I don't, not when it concerns her father's estate anyway.

The father is splitting his estate equally among his children and the step monther is leaving her estate to her child. Which is all fair enough imo.

Swipe left for the next trending thread