Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

First ever post. Am I being unreasonable?

274 replies

Babybear1787 · 10/09/2021 08:20

Apologies all but I’m going insane and need your help.

Me and OH both 34 being together nearly 3 years. Both divorced previously and I’ve a nearly 5 year old and then we’ve just had a baby in July and fair to say we’re really happy.

I’m a only child and close with my parents, he is with his parents but also has a older brother who got married to his wife in 2019. When we met they were abit weary but accepted as long as he was happy, we then ended up building quite a nice relationship. We’d go for meals out as a 4, with his parents and even went away for the night together.

Just before covid and a few months after their marriage, brothers wife became pregnant. We were so happy for them and little girl arrived September 2020.

October 2020 me and OH discussed also having a family together. He had no children, after lockdown and seeing my son on his own I didn’t want him to be a only child like me and the decision was made to start trying with a view that it would take a few months and probably have a baby towards end of 2021. In fact it happened immediately 🙈 hence baby born in July.

Once everything ok at 12 weeks (week before Christmas) we told family. Both parents shocked but so happy another grandchild will be coming. OH told brother, his reply “bit soon”. I told his wife and her reply “I would of thought brothers parents would of had longer to enjoy our child first”.

To not taint our happiness we let it go, unfortunately tho it ate away at my partner because then over the course of my pregnancy they disappeared off the face of the earth. We heard nothing from
them and it became quite clear there was a problem.

Present day/this week, brother wife removed both me and OH off social media. It came to an head as clearly there was a problem.

OH spoke to brother who confirmed they didn’t like we had our baby as soon as we did, they told us it was their time and we essentially stole the limelight. My OH is in disbelief, his parents have never had any favourites with them or grandchildren they’re so fair. He then told OH that his wife did that on social media because we don’t like enough pictures of their daughter.

Me and OH don’t use this social media platform often but can’t understand why it’s an issue. Apparently I liked a picture of their daughter with wife’s brother and nothing else. I genuinely can’t even recall this and can only assume it’s been clicked in error as I don’t make a habit of liking stuff and I don’t always see it.

Anyway both brother and wife say they’re over it but wife won’t be socialising with us unless for family occasions and brother will try build relationship with OH alone. We don’t find this acceptable, we have said we are too upset and still amazed at their views (which apparently they’re entitled too) to then pretend to play happy families when necessary.

Apparently we need to accept we’ve upset them too, they’re allowed these views and we need to now move on and get on for their mum and dad.

Both me and OH disagree with this.

Sorry for the lengthy post but the question is who’s the unreasonable one? Are we in the wrong?

OP posts:
TillyTopper · 10/09/2021 11:13

Your SIL and BIL sound very strange - unless there is a massive backstory here. Honestly, I'd stop worrying and enjoy the peace and quiet from them. Just see your PILs and leave it at that - families don't always get on but no need to push it. Just accept they don't want to engage and don't worry.

MLMbotsno · 10/09/2021 11:14

@WimpoleHat

They sound like 8 year olds - “you can’t have a party at the same place as meeee”. Bonkers.
This, they sound like toddlers.

Ignore them and focus on your own family.

atotalshambles · 10/09/2021 11:14

Some people go a bit crazy when they first have children. I would minimize contact with them but try to keep civil. My experience is that once kids get older and no longer at the cute stage all this craziness is forgotten!

FatCatThinCat · 10/09/2021 11:23

I remember feeling that twinge of ... whatever it is ... when my BIL and his wife announced they were expecting 3 months after us. It lasted for around 2 seconds seeing as I'm no 5 and grew out of the 'foot stamping it's not fair' stage a long, long time ago.

YANBU and your inlaws are bonkers.

WorriedMama101 · 10/09/2021 11:24

How old are they?! They sound doolally.

Oh you've taken our limelight Get the eff out of here with that BS!!

Enjoy being with your family, OP. They sound jealous!

FairFuming · 10/09/2021 11:29

This is actually insane. They need a good wobble

BluebellCockleshell123 · 10/09/2021 11:31

They are utterly batshit. How sad for you, your DH & the PILs.

I had a big group of cousins on one side of the family and there’s less than a year between 3 of us! We were all pretty close and grew up having a great time at family dos.

Some serious PFB and attention seeking behaviour going on with your BIL & his wife.

SafferUpNorth · 10/09/2021 11:32

It's nothing more than petty, childish jealousy by the sound of it. They told you as much - that they're upset you stole their limelight.

It's ridiculously childish, so the only thing for you to do, as adults, is ignore it and rise above it. Don't pander to them and don't play their game.

Yes, go to family gatherings arranged by your PIL if they're going too. No need to talk to them. But if you're arranging something, only invite family members you genuinely want there (ie not them).

And if anyone else in the family asks you what's going on, just be very frank

Staryflight445 · 10/09/2021 11:43

Narcissism at its finest.

Leave them to it, don’t look back.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 10/09/2021 11:48

I agree that they are totally unreasonable but there isn’t anything to do about it that won’t hurt your in-laws. Smile and nod, make polite conversation when you see them. It’s a shame the cousins won’t get to hang out much.

I think they will see sense when they are out of the new parent phase, possibly a second child arriving. Leave the door open

fourquenelles · 10/09/2021 11:51

1989 - me, my sister and my four female cousins all had babies. It was wonderful with not a sign of "thunder being stolen". So sorry you are goung through this OP. It's bonkers.

Notbeforemycoffeeplease · 10/09/2021 11:51

I find this really disturbing - they’re upset you had a baby that didn’t accord with their expectation of how long their own child should be ‘enjoyed’ by their grandparents? This is unbelievably selfish, jealous and toxic behaviour. What about your own happiness and the fact you have also had a baby? Unless there are some other issues brewing away here (and even then their behaviour would at best be disgusting) I’d say you are well rid of such ‘family’ members.

Outnumbered99 · 10/09/2021 11:53

No, you are NBU. At all. They are batshit. and also, having cousins the same age is ace!!
You're better off out of it Id go NC.

blubberyboo · 10/09/2021 11:54

Somebody needs to tell them that social media is not real life.

They are controlling:
Controlling when another couple have a child.
Controlling what sort of relationship another couple have with the family.
Controlling how much love a set of grandparents can share with all their DGCs

They are trying to control an imaginary stage.

Ask them when it would have been acceptable for you to have a child within their timeframes..how ridiculous

sadie9 · 10/09/2021 11:57

To be honest, don't waste your time trying to 'analyse' why the brother in law and his wife have got the hump over this.
I suspect from the family dynamics you have described that the Older brother has harboured resentment about his parents having another baby to usurp him. He was always jealous of the younger brother (your husband) and believes his parents 'preferred' your husband.
The Older brother was delighted with the attention he got from his parents over having a grandchild. They were 'delighted' with him for something he did. Then younger brother comes along and produces a baby and lo and behold the parents are all over this child as well.
It's in the older brother's interest to discredit his younger brother in the eyes of the parents 'look what he did to me! It's not FAIR!'

Your brother in law sees himself as a victim and possibly he has married another 'victim' or a compliant people pleaser. Maybe she does what her angry and resentful husband tells her!
I would try to keep a cool head. You are dealing with anger directed at you but in reality you didn't cause that anger. It was caused many years ago.
My advice is simply keep saying 'it wasn't our intention to upset anyone' and for the sake of family gatherings try to keep the communication channels open.
I think you might fare better with the sister in law than the older brother because I'd say he's the one who's driving this campaign.
It'd be nice if the two cousins could have a relationship, therefore don't burn any bridges now too hastily, take a compassionate, mature view without compromising yourselves too much.

Cocogreen · 10/09/2021 12:08

You poor thing. They have lost their marbles.
If you can, just don't react. Stealing their limelight? What a pair of drama queens.
Upsetting for you both, and the poor PILs who probably can't understand it either.
I'd just agree to your husband seeing his brother on his own if he wants to. Only see them at big occasions. Hopefully they come to their senses. Honestly I wouldn't waste time on them, and they sound like they want drama - I can't imagine why, something missing in their lives. Weirdos.

Magicstars · 10/09/2021 12:10

So strange of them! My DSis announced her second pregnancy while I was expecting my PFB- I was & am grateful for cousins close in age. I can only suspect there is more to this, Mh issues/ fertility problems that have caused a lot of heartache?… something is amiss here.

millymoo1202 · 10/09/2021 12:15

They’re nuts! At least you won’t need to seen them very often

Christinatherabbit · 10/09/2021 12:16

How utterly ridiculous and odd. Is the wife very young? Does she have any other issues going on like problems with mental health etc? Has anything else happened in the past between the brothers (or you and them) and this is an excuse for cutting contact?

LBirch02 · 10/09/2021 12:17

YANBU OP! I could scarcely believe what I was reading when you posted about the ‘likes’ on Facebook issue!!

ChaosTrulyReigns · 10/09/2021 12:17

What awful behaviour from your in-laws.

I really hope that these children will be at different schools.

Imagine that level of narcisstic parenting when the children are in the same school year at the sane school. Problems ahoy

LBirch02 · 10/09/2021 12:19

The wife is behaving how my mum would’ve behaved!

cadburyegg · 10/09/2021 12:23

I agree with the consensus, they are absolutely stupid for depriving their child from having a relationship with a cousin close in age. And who knows, you might have helped each other out with childcare when they are older. Completely ridiculous.

My DC only have 1 cousin who lives on the other side of the world. I would love for them to have family playmates so can't stand this kind of crap.

grannybee55 · 10/09/2021 12:26

Pathetic, childish, entitled and such a shame to deprive the cousins of a good relationship.

But I've seen this before. I am friends with two SILs who both have two kids each and both sets of kids were born within a few months of each other, I feel for the grandparents who have to make sure they treat the kids exactly the same to the point where one can't get a gift without the other cousin and if they babysit for one set of parents the others bitch and moan about it so they have to offer for them too even if it's not needed.

People are bonkers.

I would fully encourage a reconciliation between your oh and his brother but personally I wouldn't get involved.

BoredZelda · 10/09/2021 12:26

She didn't like that the attention was off her. To this day, she likes to be centre of attention. I / we could not care less. We see them at events even though they live closeby. She doesn't like me, don't know why.

I’d assume it’s because you think she is an attention seeker who got pregnant because you did. However well you think you hid your opinion, you haven’t. Becoming pregnant just to get attention is pretty extreme. I doubt it is something people actually do.

Both of us have literally begged and cried to them

If you have literally done this, then no wonder they are keeping their distance. I wouldn’t want to be around people who literally beg and cry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread