Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this to parents of only children

622 replies

LBirch02 · 25/08/2021 08:51

There are loads of only child threads here and especially parents feeling guilty about having and only child.

Well if anyone’s in this position I just wanted to say:

Children don’t need siblings and only children aren’t necessarily any different from children with brothers and sisters

I hope this helps at least one person

OP posts:
Imnewhere1991 · 25/08/2021 11:01

@mam0918

I was an only child for a decade - I HATED it and was very maladjusted and struggled to intergrate with other kids dispite being havily socialised (sent to day care and clubs etc...).

My friends who are only children are wierd. I love them but theres zero denying they have some issue with things like sharing or not getting their own way. Of course THEY arent aware of it though and think they are acting normal like everyone else but trust me everyone else notices, without knowing you would assume they are just a bit narcassistic.

My oldest was an only child for a decade due to infertility. It was fucking awful, the world is built for 2+ child families he was often the odd one out it was horrific to watch as a parent and frustraiting too. I would have given pretty much anything to give him a sibling and I now watch my children playing together and its the greatest thing in the world.

If you were maladjusted I'd suggest that was more down to a seperate issue rather than being an only child?

Even if you aren't an only child, you can still be 'weird' and 'narcisstic'.

Why is the world 'built for 2+ child families'? That's a pretty weird way to think that you just have a second one due to how the world apparently works.

Your post is very very strange.

nordica · 25/08/2021 11:02

Every family is different. I have next to no extended family at all as one of my parents is an only child too and the other had one sibling who never went onto have a family of their own. So the result is that I'm now in my thirties and most of the older family members have died. I've never had cousins. I'll never be an aunt. I haven't had any family gatherings to attend since I was a child, there's been no family WhatsApp groups or family wanting to have Zoom calls during lockdown.

So yes, I really wish my parents had considered this because it's not just a sibling I missed out on but the normal family stuff that is so important for other people. It's really strange not feeling like part of anything in that way. My other is in her late 70s so won't be around forever either...

plantingandpotting · 25/08/2021 11:02

Thank you, OP.

This is a constant niggling doubt right now, even though DH and I have gone over it multiple times and agree that we're happy as we are with one DD.

Societal pressures around this are relentless, from social media offerings of the 'perfect family' to unhelpful, dated views from the boomer generation.

I'm very happy to be self aware, protective of my own mental welbeing, and when to say 'this is enough for me'.

Also, for the preservation of the planet, I really hope that the stigma around only children and no children(!) sods off.

In terms of my own experiences, I'm 1 of 4, none of us get along particularly well or enrich each others lives in any way. Being the youngest I was raised markedly differently (better, honestly - more time, attention, money; not that that's everything but it does help, sadly) and there's lots of simmering resentment from older sibs.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 25/08/2021 11:03

blimey some sweeping generalisations on here.

My DDs have several friends who are 'only children'. Some are lovely, some aren't, just like their friends with siblings.

One things does stand out though ... they all seem to have an old head on young shoulders ... as someone else has said on here .. prob due to the amount of adult company they get.

Also, my close friends who only have one, have found it harder to 'let go' in their teens, there's too much involvement with them.

mam0918 · 25/08/2021 11:04

@mam0918

I was an only child for a decade - I HATED it and was very maladjusted and struggled to intergrate with other kids dispite being havily socialised (sent to day care and clubs etc...).

My friends who are only children are wierd. I love them but theres zero denying they have some issue with things like sharing or not getting their own way. Of course THEY arent aware of it though and think they are acting normal like everyone else but trust me everyone else notices, without knowing you would assume they are just a bit narcassistic.

My oldest was an only child for a decade due to infertility. It was fucking awful, the world is built for 2+ child families he was often the odd one out it was horrific to watch as a parent and frustraiting too. I would have given pretty much anything to give him a sibling and I now watch my children playing together and its the greatest thing in the world.

posted to soon meant to add:

Siblings may love or hate each other its also hard to predict or judge and how much is enviromental is unknown.

My mam 'hated' her many siblings until 4 of them died she misses them greatly now. She didnt realise how much impact they truely had on her until they where gone and shes now super close to her remaining sister.

Fiddliestofsticks · 25/08/2021 11:05

@Cocomarine

When I talk about sharing, I dont mean wrestling toys away to give to someone else. I always did the Montessori way. If a toy is being used right now then it isnt available for you. If my kid had a toy then it wasn't available for someone else. There was never a need to grab and keep hold because no one was going to take it off you and it was actually easier because they'd happily give it up after all little while of playing. If you told them they just hand it over, they'd cling onto it because that isnt fair.

When I'm talking about being able to share things out, I mean like choosing a movie or activity. With siblings, you dont always get the movie you want. There is compromise. You dont always get the family activity you want because there are other kids to consider. You learn how to manage that sort of situation. MRI scans show that only children have different brain structures for that sort of behaviour.

igelkott2021 · 25/08/2021 11:05

@Mousetown

Weird how so many people comment on the parents on only children allegedly not teaching their children how to share and be kind, but their own mothers didn’t teach them empathy and how not to be judgemental twats. 🤷‍♀️
Well quite.

And for all the moaning about only children being indulged, unable to share and deal with other people, the worst bosses I have had in my career had siblings. So I would say that bad behaviour is about your character, not about how many siblings you had.

I'm embarrassed for the people on here who are so prejudiced, badly informed and judgmental.

thisisnotmyllama · 25/08/2021 11:05

I grew up as an only (I was my mum’s only child but not my dad’s, but my half siblings are a generation older than me). I certainly wasn’t spoilt financially as my parents were never in a position to do that, but I did tend to get my own way quite a lot (not all the time). I can remember wanting a sibling when I was quite little but it was never an issue later. I definitely did have to learn to share in adulthood - in student shared houses, to be exact, and it was a baptism of fire. Hated that! I was always a terrible housemate, of the ‘Who moved my mug?’ variety. Grin It’s still something I struggle with tbh. On the other hand I’m very untidy if there’s nobody else there to see it. I think that’s more to do with my mother’s overindulgent parenting rather than being an only child specifically - although I guess she might have behaved differently if there had been more than one child. No way of knowing though.

These are the downsides. But: I’ve always been happy in my own company and don’t really understand loneliness - people talking about being lonely during lockdown is something I get on a rational level, and I can make the right noises when they say it, but emotionally I can’t relate to it at all. The last 18 months hasn’t bothered me, in that respect at least. Both my parents died relatively young after short illnesses, so I was lucky to avoid long-term caring duties, but god was I happy to have sole responsibility for the house, wills etc! (And frankly, very happy to receive the whole - albeit small - inheritance.) When I see the disputes that people get into over parental estates - including my half-siblings, over their mother’s house - I think, ‘No thanks, not for me!’

The only thing now is that with both parents gone, I do occasionally wish I had someone else who shares my memories or who could fill in the odd gap, but it’s not something I think about often. I have a cousin (also an only child, coincidentally) who sometimes messages me to reminisce about our shared grandmother and other family stuff, and old friends of my mum’s who are still alive, so that’s something.

My DS is also an only child, by accident rather than design. I always said I’d have more than one child but it just didn’t happen due to circumstances. Deep down though I’m quite relieved. I don’t think I’d have known how to raise siblings! I did make a point of a) socialising him with other kids extremely early (something my parents didn’t do as we lived in a remote area until I was 3), b) teaching him explicitly and repeatedly about sharing, and c) trying not to let him behave in an entitled way generally.

It’s hard though and I’ve caught myself repeating my mother’s mistakes more than once. All things considered, I’d say he’s a more well-rounded, sociable kid than I was at his age, although the lessons of early childhood are fading as he moves towards his teens. I do worry about him having to care for me or ExH later on, but that’s to do with our age. If I had two kids then I’d just worry about him having to care for us AND think about a younger sibling. He does like to be pampered a bit, but at his core he’s very tough and resilient, so I think he’ll be ok.

MadeOfStarStuff · 25/08/2021 11:05

YANBU

Of course some only children hate it and wish they had siblings.

But equally some people with siblings hate it and wish they were only children.

Parents have no way of knowing what their child might have preferred, they can only make the choice that’s right for them at that time and try to make the best of it.

Shelby10 · 25/08/2021 11:06

I am an only one. I have only one DC. I didn’t even really think about it being a positive or negative. I have lots of friends and so does my DC. Some fiends and family with siblings and close to each other and others not so. Some have disabled siblings so care for them now their parents are elderly. Over all a good mix of supportive friends and family (not necessarily siblings) is what makes life's challenges so much easier.

igelkott2021 · 25/08/2021 11:08

When I'm talking about being able to share things out, I mean like choosing a movie or activity. With siblings, you dont always get the movie you want. There is compromise. You dont always get the family activity you want because there are other kids to consider. You learn how to manage that sort of situation. MRI scans show that only children have different brain structures for that sort of behaviour

Yeah right. Utter nonsense. You do realise that only children have parents and other friends and relatives? Who watch things they want to watch? Or listen to music in the car that they want to watch?

You are right that an only child can do the activity they like - eg you don't have a sibling missing out on Saturday morning parkrun because their brother wants to play football (or vice versa) but even then it's not a given as the parents may not want to drive them or be able to pay for it. The idea that you get everything you want because you don't have siblings to consider just isn't true.

ghgEHND · 25/08/2021 11:08

I was an only child until I was 10 and now have an only child. I was definitely lonely as a kid but had lots of solid friendships so that helped. In my experience, you dont get as much exposure to sharing, taking turns and having to consider other people as an only. No matter how you parent, if you have two or more kids then you automatically force kids to do all of the above but not if you have an only. However, as an only you qo quickly learn that you need to play nice if you want to have friends i.e. other kids to play with. Sometimes I actually feel a bit sorry for only kids who need to be on best behaviour to get to play with other children i.e. because you have to be good to play with friends, whereas kids with siblings do bicker and fight with each other but still get to have a playmate around.

However, in later years I do really see much of a difference. I certainly dont think that it will be easier to look after our parents with my brother. We are too different, have never emotionally relied on him and he lives abroad. So to be honest I would actually prefer to be an only right now.

So in my experience I would have loved to have had a playmate/peer as a child but would prefer to have been an only as an adult because I do now have a peer i.e. DH. In practice, by the time one's parents are ailing most people have their own family units and dont need too much input from other people.

mam0918 · 25/08/2021 11:09

Imnewhere1991

Look at family tickets, family holidays, family rooms etc... they are all built for 2 or 3 child families or couples.

When have booked tickets to child events where DS had to pair up with an adult because all the other kids paied to their siblings, it happend often.

Our local cinema didnt even recognise 1 child non single parent families as families in their ticket sales, we had to complain because they had preset ticket packages and 2 adults 1 child wasnt even an option only 1 adult 1 child or 2 adults 2 children and up.

When you face it everyday you notice all these things.

Flatdisco · 25/08/2021 11:10

My partner is an only child and he's the most well adjusted person I know. Its utter crap it's somehow damaging to be an only child.

I honestly think in the majority of cases women (and it is women) want to have babies so justify it with needing a sibling for their child.

orinocosfavoritecake · 25/08/2021 11:10

It makes fuck all difference.

If it did, it’d turn up in statistics somewhere. Only children would be more likely to be in jail, or prime ministers (losing a mother early helps with that one), or doctors, or CEOs or something.

They do a bit better in school. That’s it.

ChloeDecker · 25/08/2021 11:10

Thank you OP. It’s nice to hear as a parent of an only child, amongst all the usual ‘spoilt, can’t share and no one to help in elderly years’.

I am one of three and both my parents have passed away. As one of my siblings live in Cyprus and the other is an addict who struggles on a daily basis, it was pretty much down to me for everything and the inheritance was still split three ways.
Both my in laws are only children and both moan about it constantly, yet they produced three children, one of which no longer speaks to anyone. They are still, however, highly vocal in voicing their negative opinions on me for only having one child.

None of us can predict the future. All we can do is try to be the best parents we can be, whether it is to 1 or 10+ children.

And be thankful we have a child(ren) at all.

Fivebyfive2 · 25/08/2021 11:10

Everyone is different, all family dynamics are different so sweeping statements don't really work here... You'll always get only children who were lonely, happy, kind, stubborn and siblings are close, resentful etc etc. I think what op means is, if having an only child is best for your family or if you sadly cannot have another, please don't let others make you feel guilty.

onlychildhamster · 25/08/2021 11:11

@mam0918 surely 2 adults 1 child wouldn't cost more than 2 adults 2 children. and for plane tickets, having 1 child is cheaper.

Allycott · 25/08/2021 11:12

As an only child I can say that up to the age of about 18 I envied my friends who had siblings, their homes always seemed so much more lively and we'll homely. On the flip side I feel that being as n only child has contributed to me being happy with my own company and a very independent - but I may have been like this regardless of siblings or not.

igelkott2021 · 25/08/2021 11:12

Anyway in the end being pregnant and raising a child is something that requires careful thought. Getting pregnant again isn't that easy, as people have posted here. I took the view that I had one healthy baby and I wasn't taking the risk of not being that lucky next time. And I was in one piece too and I didn't want to go through another pregnancy in case I didn't get through it unscathed. I quit while I was ahead.

I think people are far too blase about the risks of having children - both the effects of childbirth and the chances of having a disabled child, especially as mothers get older. We're not in Nazi Germany and you don't get medals for churning out babies to be cannon fodder. We have too many people in the world already and should be reducing our family sizes.

Arsebucket · 25/08/2021 11:12

I know that maybe siblings wouldn’t have made things easier with me having to deal with my father my whole life and even more so now he’s elderly.

But you know what? If I did have siblings and they washed their hands of him, it would have been easy for me to walk away too and have my own life.

Instead I have pressure put on me by everyone, his medical care, social services and my dad as his only family. The pressure to care for him as an only child is immense.

Walking away would cause me so much guilt. if other siblings had done so, I would have run for the hills and had my own life years ago. I’ve been his carer since I was a child, I’m 41 and I’ve never been free.

toomuchlaundry · 25/08/2021 11:12

@Fiddliestofsticks DS is an only, growing up he had to learn that not everything we did as a family completely revolved round him. So we would choose a holiday that suited all of us in some way, not just him, for example. Same with days out and just everyday things too

BoredNotPanda · 25/08/2021 11:13

I can spot an adult only child from miles! They are self-centred (not vicious or even aware of it!) and think that everyone owes them. There is a BIG DIFFERENCE.
Even when they are children, they are like mini-adults already, voicing their opinions, being interested in any adults conversations, asking lots of questions.
IMO, they are very very different.

Bumblenums1234 · 25/08/2021 11:13

Well I for one loved being an only child as a kid and I love it as an adult. I wouldn't change my upbringing for the world, had the most amazing parents and am not selfish, unpopular or lonely.

thisisnotmyllama · 25/08/2021 11:14

I forgot to add: I can almost invariably tell, when someone (adult) is an only child, once I’ve got to know them slightly (think colleagues etc). I couldn’t begin to explain how. It’s nothing specific or always the same thing which gives it away. I just KNOW, and I’m hardly ever wrong about it. It’s like I have some kind of only-child radar! Grin

And I always either love or hate these people (or sometimes love-hate, or hate at first but then love later). It’s never neutral anyway! It’s a very weird, visceral thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread