Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be disappointed by my cousin exbridesmaid

246 replies

firstnamechange2020 · 21/12/2020 11:45

I am an only child so growing up so my cousin was the closest thing I had to a sister and up until i was 6 the same could be said for her. Sadly now I am once again the closest thing she still has to a sister. Us growing up close is not the problem I just thought it would be needed to keep in mind for context so that i make it clear this is a very very very close relationship we had. We even shared a room growing up for a long time.

when she got married 10 years ago I was thrilled for her. I flew all the away to asia for a full month as I was a bridesmaid. I followed all of her wishes to the point. I did not complain about my hair, my nail colour selected by her, the dress she wanted me to wear. I said yes to it all as I understood this is her day and I am here to support her.

Before the wedding I bought her a nice Tiffany's necklace as my gift as i loved her dearly and was happy to get her what I hope is a once in a life time gift. My DM was with me and I asked her if she remembered me buying this just to check I had not somehow got confused with things... it was 10 years ago after all.

3 years ago my boyfriend proposed and I of course said yes. I pretty much told my cousin right after telling my dm just because of how important she is to me. I asked her to be my bridesmaid. Now I will understand if I was wrong here but I did not make her my maid of honour. This was not because me not loving her but because she was all the way in the US. She won't be here for any of the usual bridesmaids duties plus she had a family so this really was more of a symbolic role when it comes to her.

I created a group chat for me and all three of my bridesmaids ( my cousin and both of my future sister-in-laws). I showed them some dresses that I liked as bridesmaids dresses and said I was of course going to pay for them and I wanted these to be one of the gifts I give to them. i took their in put in what colour and what style they would prefer (no pink or light colours) I tried to incorporate as many wishes as I could. Both the other bridesmaids loved the dress I chose in the end as did most people I showed. My cousin said in the group chat she is worried about not fitting into the dress. I kept telling her not to worry and once we get the measurements I will make sure it fits. Again she says in the group chat she is worried about not fitting can she please wear her own dress (by this point I was wondering if she was pregnant with a third child) I again explained saying I will make sure it fits. Fiancé privately told me that his sister did mention to their dad and she found my cousin was being rather rude to me by that point.

One year on she messaged me saying with her daughter being flower girl and her son being pageboy she would prefer it might be easier if she was not a bridesmaid as the kids are so young. I said of course and I fully understood that she wants to be able to make sure the kids are comfortable. I asked her if she would like me to hire a babysitter so she and husband can enjoy the evening do without worrying about the kids etc. She was coy about giving me an answer with a lot of she will let me know closer to the time (hindsight this should have been a first clue what is to come)

So around January she calls for a long chat saying her husband is just starting a new job and might not be able to come it is just her and the kids (they knew the date for 18 months by this point). I said I was very sorry and if the trip would be too hard on her own with the kids I would of course fully understand (a lot of tears saying how she wished it could be different and a lot of me being supportive and saying I understand and I know she cares for me)

This week we talked again and I was saying how much I was looking forward to next year after I had to cancel the wedding this June. She looked kind awkward on the video call and dropped the bomb that due to this pandemic she and the kids would not come either. I assumed it was just her being worried about risks and said right away to not be silly I fully understand she needs to do what is best for her and her family. She then said she was planning to take a kids back home (in her eyes) Asia in the summer (date of my wedding) with her husband as life is just a bit more normal there and my wedding would just not be the same without the ability to travel Europe like she wanted for her and the family. I was a bit taken aback by this point but said I understand her putting her kids needs first. We talked a bit more and talked about family and she said she felt so sorry for my dm who is caring for me gran right now and how we both (my mum and me) just need to be a little bit more selfish. I just nodded and agreed. I asked what her kids would like for christmas so I could still get it to them on time. In the end I picked a mario lego set and a electric pet unicorn for them to enjoy as well as a switch game for her and her husband to play and maybe play with the kids.

This is the same cousin where I dropped everything here in the UK to look after her in the US after her sister passed away and I stayed with her for a full month till one of my other cousins would take over and stay a week or two... (yeah i was the only one to drop everything for a month out of friends and family) I just spend my days keeping her company and being the support she needed. When my mum asked if she took me to see any places I told her no and that I was here to look after my cousin not to go on holiday etc.

She mesaged me asking if I liked pandora. I mentioned I once had one and still have the charms but the chain broke but it's not really a issue as I wear my fitbit these days. At this point she generously messages saying she would love to give me a new pandora bracelet as a wedding gift. Now i did remember giving her a Tiffany necklace for her wedding so this did feel a bit Hmm but fiancé pointed out maybe she was sending multiple charms with it too etc that she wants to create a special bracelet of our memories etc. I nodded and agreed still wanting to see the best in her. (got the wedding gift today it is a cinderella bracelet they well and two charms. still need to thank her for them... the heart says 'family forever and always')

there is part of me that just wants to stop making an effort by this point and I already told fiancé this is the last year I am sending them anything for Christmas. It feels mean and I feel like I am punishing the kids for her behaviour but I really feel like my kindness and understanding is being taken for granted by now. I really was desperate to remain close as I really have distanced myself from the rest of my family due to their selfish tendencies but I really am not sure how to feel about my cousin by this point.

OP posts:
Nancydrawn · 21/12/2020 13:17

@ZoeTurtle

I really have distanced myself from the rest of my family due to their selfish tendencies

I think you have a very, very warped idea of normal behaviour and cut off anybody who doesn't treat you like the sun shines out of your arse.

You're going to end up very lonely if you don't readjust.

I agree with Zoe here, OP. I don't know your full back story, but you say you're low contact with everyone in your family other than your mum and this cousin. Think carefully about what cutting off this relationship will do—that's half of your family connections.

I might also ponder whether this is a pattern with you: intense energy from your end, very high expectations of behavior and reciprocity, and willingness to cut someone off completely if they don't live up to those expectations.

(Of course there could be good reason why you're low contact with almost all of your family—now, all of your family except for your mother. But I would do some self-searching as well.)

MrsWooster · 21/12/2020 13:18

Come back in a couple of years, when you have a family, and update.

cherryunripe · 21/12/2020 13:18

@firstnamechange2020

It's not about the cost of the gift but that basically I have put in a lot more effort into this relationship then she has and she has been down right rude by this point
How much effort you put into the relationship is your decision. She has children now, priorities change. Honestly, you just sound spoilt and petty.
DreamyDreamer333 · 21/12/2020 13:21

Both of your situations have changed considerably since her wedding 10 years ago. She lives in another country, with 3 kids so you can't expect her to drop everything so that she can fawn over you for a month. Also you don't know her financial situation so the comment about the Pandora bracelet seems a bit catty.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 21/12/2020 13:21

Hmm I wonder if the rest of your family are actually selfish or, like im this situation, you just expect too much of people.
I'm still not sure why your gift was better than hers? Also, like you said, she is taking her children home to asia, not going on holiday. Sorry but your really is just a wedding day and its not that important.

firstnamechange2020 · 21/12/2020 13:21

Thank you for all the in put. I actually do appreciate the gift now and reanalyzing I think it was more about her behaviour leading up to this but I do get that I need to step back. Thank you everyone on here for pointing these things out

OP posts:
bridgetreilly · 21/12/2020 13:22

You are about to get married. Why are you giving her 100% of you? Your fiance should come first, as rightly, her husband and children come first for her.

Coyoacan · 21/12/2020 13:24

OP, people are answering for your own good. You have seriously misjudged how much family members are able to do for each other, especially when they live thousands of miles apart and are not in your extremely fortunate financial situation.

If you keep on cutting off everyone who is not able to meet your exacting standards, you will end up lonely and alone.

SharonasCorona · 21/12/2020 13:25

I think there is more of an expectation for Asian people to fly over for weddings for close family. Certainly it would have been unthinkable for me not to fly thousands of miles for my siblings weddings.

I think it's more likely OP has ended up as the scapegoat of the family, but of course only OP can say.

Hoppinggreen · 21/12/2020 13:29

Your response is interesting OP
You have decided from now on that you won’t put as much effort in, fair enough but it seems to me that you are only doing so because you dont get as much back
You should put as much effort in as you want in expectation of not much/ nothing in return. Your relationship sounds very transactional.

JanewaysBun · 21/12/2020 13:31

OP sorry if I missed the answer - are you Indian? If so MN is not the place to ask as most people are white and don't get it, much more family expectations!

If you are yanbu but all you can do is back off. X

M4J4 · 21/12/2020 13:31

@Hoppinggreen send presents year after year to people who never send you anything? Fuck that.

Happygogoat · 21/12/2020 13:31

Sorry but it's entirely different being a bridesmaid when you are childless (ie you to her). It was never going to be equally reciprocated because her priorities are so vastly different now. You can still be closed in new ways but try not to focus so much on this.

If sounds like she does care for you, but has other priorities. Not unreasonably.

You're out of order to sniff at Pandora vs Tiffany - she didn't ask for that and is trying to get you a special gift within her means.

Bumpsadaisie · 21/12/2020 13:31

I was struck by the way you write about her - its as if she is your partner, almost. It sounds too emotionally close - and you sound a bit obsessed about her and all these details.

She on the other hand has three children and the painful reality will be (sorry to say this, but its the truth) that she is not nearly as invested in you as you are in her.

You're getting married yourself - nows the time to focus on your fiance and your plans - enjoy a relationship with your cousin by all means but don't allow yourself to obsess over it.

CheetasOnFajitas · 21/12/2020 13:32

Was she already married when you rushed over to support her after her sister’s death? Do you really think that having you there disrupting her family’s day to day life was a good thing? Her husband was there to support and comfort her and you probably inhibited that process. She was prevented from getting back to normality because you were there keeping life out of the ordinary. Did she actually ask you to come?

WhatKatyDidNxt · 21/12/2020 13:32

This is probably just the start of it. You’re probably best extracting yourself now. I too had a close friend, once she got married she kind of gave up on our friendship. It’s like people check out when they have got married etc and feel like they don’t have to make any effort. In contrast, you aren’t allowed that luxury and need to give 100% or they get irate. Quit while you can! My ex friend got annoyed when l wouldn’t dance to her tune all the time

MiddleClassProblem · 21/12/2020 13:33

I’m Indian and wouldn’t be like this...

Whattimeisdinner · 21/12/2020 13:33

Yuck.
I think in your mind 'Effort' = 'Money spent of gifts'.
What a horrible way to live.

Whattimeisdinner · 21/12/2020 13:34

'on' not 'of'

Thehollyandtheirony · 21/12/2020 13:37

She has small children, her life is probably exhausting.
I’m not surprised she can’t be bothered with a three year engagement and whatsapp groups about colour schemes.

Dominicwestsscooter · 21/12/2020 13:38

@firstnamechange2020

It's not about the cost of the gift but that basically I have put in a lot more effort into this relationship then she has and she has been down right rude by this point
It clearly is the price of the gift. You could actually say that her gift has more thought in it because she’s chosen the charms specifically for you.

You sound a bit spoilt and grabby. She’s putting her children first, that’s what being a mother is about. I know when you’re getting married it’s the most important thing in your life, but it’s really just a load of expense for the guests, especially if they have to travel overseas to get there.

Also I don’t know of any adult mother who would want to be a bridesmaid. I would definitely feel a bit stupid stood there in a bridesmaid dress. Maybe your cousin feels the same.

Try and have a little perspective. It’s your wedding, but in the grand scheme of the shit show people are going through current it’s an expensive side show.

SharonasCorona · 21/12/2020 13:39

Again, stepping in here due to cultural divide. There are different expectations for Asian weddings.

There is an etiquette that says when a woman gets married, her mum and dad give gold necklaces (not simple chains but actual necklaces, with earrings) to each girl/woman in the extended family.

OP fulfilled that norm by getting a Tiffany's necklace. The cousin has reciprocated in a much cheaper fashion, and therefore the message could be taken as 'you are not a valuable family member to me'.

People are calling things 'yuck' when they don't understand the subtext.

SecretSpAD · 21/12/2020 13:39

she's got used to you making the effort and her not having to match it.

And this is the bottom line. I had something similar with a cousin I was close to as a child. After being let down several times I gave up. Haven't seen her or her family for over 20 years now and frankly don't give a damn.

Mommabear20 · 21/12/2020 13:40

Wow! 😳 it must be lonely up on that pedestal you've built for yourself.

firstnamechange2020 · 21/12/2020 13:40

@JanewaysBun no but close to China and Japan on my mums side. I guess it is part of the problem that my mum is very traditional in that sense and has raised me as such while my cousins in the US are more western and I guess view family as more casual which is also reflected by their parents so my mum does 70% of the care work my aunt chips in here and there maybe 30% of an effort to care for her mother and my uncle himself does not lift a finger nore does his wife... Reason I am low contact is because her being treated like Cinderella by most of the family

OP posts: