Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to dislike my niece?

229 replies

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 12:59

Please be kind because I know I sound absolutely awful but I'm looking for help to connect.

For some reason, when my DN was born (DH's sister's baby) I just felt so cold towards her. She is now 10 months. I made all the effort to ensure we saw SIL whilst pregnant, then as soon as baby was born (they live 2 hours drive away) and have seen her a few times. I feel so awkward. I thought that it was because I'm not maternal yet and it would come. But then my friends had a baby and I absolutely love him. I love playing with him, I love cuddling him, I love seeing him grow. So obviously there is some warmth in my cold heart.

I wonder if it's that I resent SIL and her DH, she hasn't necessarily done anything wrong but they are quite against my moral beliefs.
I am currently in therapy and one of my issues is 'rigid beliefs' which is what causes a lot of my OCD/Anxiety apparently. For example, they regularly make comments about nurses being unintelligent, not as good as doctors, they comment on ANYONE who is overweight for absolutely no reason, they make sweeping statements about certain religions / ethnicities (i.e. "I know that Nigerian nurses are lazier than British ones, just look at who has called in sick since coronavirus, it's an excuse, you don't see doctors doing that")

They have become uncaring towards anything in our lives or our animals who are our "children" (at present, maybe one day I'll have babies fingers crossed) - for example, they allowed them into a main road off lead when we were helping with the baby. They were lucky to not get hit by a car and didn't apologise. Our dog was attacked by another on the street and I was bitten when we went to get them groceries (to help out when they were exhausted as baby was just born), they didn't bat an eyelid when I came home covered in mud and bleeding. It was surreal.

I find SIL not particularly maternal so I cringe when they make baby noises etc, it feels so awkward. I then can't do it either because I feel awkward and cringe at myself. They tend to sit on their phones a lot and just let DN crawl around in another room until they hear a bang (last time we were there it was playing with bottles of wine that then smashed).

They're intelligent people, they love DN, they're good parents as far as I can tell (minus a few little incidents as above) and the first to have a child in DH's family. As a result there is a lot of attention on them constantly, for example, EVERY single message we send MIL gets a response with a picture of the baby. DH was always treated unfairly to his sister and it's caused a lot of issues along the way. For example, at Christmas everyone met up except him and he wasn't told or invited, they then denied it and said it was impromptu (his other brother lives in a different country).

Basically, I sound somewhat jealous(?), angry(?) but I really REALLY don't want it to affect my relationship with DN and I need to put it aside.

Has anyone felt like this before? DN has done nothing wrong and I want to be seen as someone she can rely on. DH is the same as me but doesn't particularly care about connecting.

I also don't want anyone to think I'm bashing SIL's parenting, I can't parent, I don't have children, I am just stating things that I think may contribute to my weird mindset.

OP posts:
Bubbletrouble43 · 18/09/2020 18:54

In the space of a year I had two nieces and a nephew born, one of the nieces is my dbs and the other two are bils so not a blood relation.... I was surprised by how much more affection I feel for my own dbs daughter than my other nieces and nephews despite the fact she lives so far away we only see them maybe 3 or 4 times a year and on videocalls, the others are localish and we see at least once a month. I wouldn't worry about it. Also sounds like her parents aren't your kind of people or ever will be. There's nothing wrong with you.

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 18:54

@Upstartcrones DP is aware of my feelings and cares even less for the baby than I do.

He thinks she's obese (not sure a baby can be but she's over the 100th percentile for weight and 0.4th for height) and as a result because she started crawling late (just recently) purely because she couldn't turn over, they're bad parents. His opinion goes more that way. Also they started solids at 3 months and he also doesn't agree with that. It's none of his business and I think it's because every one likes to go on about it he's had enough.

OP posts:
Cassilis · 18/09/2020 18:56

DP is aware of my feelings and cares even less for the baby than I do.

Wow.

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 18:56

@imfatletsparty we can go together Grin

OP posts:
Bubbletrouble43 · 18/09/2020 18:58

Er yes just to add, I don't have any negative feelings towards my other niece and nephew. They are toddlers and that would be weird. Sounds a bit mean to be insulting a 10 month olds weight tbh 😱

Bubbletrouble43 · 18/09/2020 18:59

10 months isn't that late for crawling either.

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 18:59

I don't know why everyone thinks my animals deserve attention and that this is the root of my issue? I love my dogs, my mum thinks they're the best thing since sliced bread. But they're dogs. Not humans. They are who I look after, keep healthy, plan life around etc. So my equivalent of children. But they aren't as I said, they are dogs.

I just never really liked children enough to want them yet, I am not broody. I am very maternal lately which has become apparent as my friends have had children - I absolutely adore these babies. They are gorgeous and wonderful humans.

I just don't get it from DN. I don't know why, I feel guilty for that. I don't want anything negative to happen. I do assume I'll warm a lot to her when she does stuff or shows a personality

OP posts:
Cassilis · 18/09/2020 18:59

He thinks she's obese

Jesus.

LilaButterfly · 18/09/2020 19:01

It has to do with your relationship with your sil.
I adore my sil and love her children, same with my best friends children.
But with other kids i dont really care or they annoy me depending on their behaviour.
I think its sweet that you want your relationship with your niece to be separated, but shes still very small and its a package deal with her mum atm.
I would try and keep in touch and maybe in time it will change

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 19:02

@user1471453601 haha I'm sorry this made me laugh. I have always had this issue describing her. It is because we didn't know her gender so we referred to her as "it" in the family. The parents had a different name but it was personal and not something for others to use

OP posts:
abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 19:03

@AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter omg I don't feel jealous at all. I was trying to diagnose the issue myself. So suggested some things. I do not feel jealous of a child. She is a tiny little innocent thing. I just don't get that feeling I see with so many people so close to their nieces.

OP posts:
abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 19:06

@EarringsandLipstick thank you so much Thanks

OP posts:
abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 19:07

@Cassilis it's not a drip feed, it wasn't relevant until you insinuated I'd want to ever do any harm to an innocent child or any human.

OP posts:
abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 19:08

@Bubbletrouble43 I don't know, not a parent, she wanted to crawl earlier but just couldn't because of her weight which has been the HV's concern.

OP posts:
ChelseaDaggers · 18/09/2020 19:14

Tbh, the more I read the worse this sounds...you clearly judge this baby's parents, as does your bf. Now they've had a baby, you and your bf are judging the baby, as you feel she is an extension of her parents. If they're all so dreadful, honestly don't bother having a relationship with them. Leave them be. It all sounds horrible. Find another way to entertain yourselves than ripping this family to pieces and speculating what better parents you'd make.

I say this when I strongly dislike my own sil and probably would end up judging her if I had to spend time with her. So, I don't!

I've never gotten so bad that I've thought tsk tsk, look how wrong their parenting is. Look what crap children they're raising. Which is kind of what you and your bf appear to be doing.

ClaudiaAndTheCauldron · 18/09/2020 19:18

@abigailsdinner

I think I understand how you feel.
I have a similar situation with my DN. she is 4 now.

I don't dislike her, but I have no inclination to be involved with her. It has been this way since she was born.
My relationship changed with my sister so much when she met her now husband and got married. I do not get on with her husband at all. He's an egotistical bully. I only see them at family gatherings maybe 3 times a year. It's really sad.

It's not my DN's fault. But for right now her and her parents are a package.

ameliajoan · 18/09/2020 19:28

This is an awful thread and you and your DP sound like awful people; calling a baby obese? Practically boasting about how little you care?

You need to sort yourself out if you have these kinds of feelings towards an innocent baby. There’s something not quite right.

GunsAndShips · 18/09/2020 19:33

I think this thread does a good job of highlighting that people don't know what ambivalence means. I think people are using it to mean uninterested or apathetic almost. It doesn't mean this. It means to have strongly contradictory feelings.

I love my nephews on Ds's side as much as I love my brothers children but the key factor is that I love my inlaws I suspect. In fact, two of my nephews aren't related biologically to any of DH's family but I love them in the same way as DH's biological nephews. As others have said, I think it's just related to how you feel about the parents.

ReallySpicyCurry · 18/09/2020 19:41

I'm sorry OP but I agree you need help. Frankly it sounds as though you feel that this baby is taking attention that you feel should be yours. I've had some awful family members at times, whom I have disliked, but I have never extended this dislike to their children, because I am an emotionally mature adult. I can't imagine feeling as you do about a baby. Your husband is just as bad - he dislikes her because he thinks she is obese? You sound really odd and ovedramatic and I would be interested in hearing the other side of the story

EarringsandLipstick · 18/09/2020 19:56

Frankly it sounds as though you feel that this baby is taking attention that you feel should be yours.

What? Where do you get this from?

CanIHelpYou · 18/09/2020 19:59

Why do people think you have to like and enjoy every single baby you meet? Some people just aren't that into babies for goodness sake.

I feel very indifferent about most babies I meet tbh.

LeaLoo82 · 18/09/2020 20:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/09/2020 20:27

Well @LeaLoo82 you sound singularly unpleasant yourself. 😠 there's no need for that.

Bluntness100 · 18/09/2020 20:31

DP is aware of my feelings and cares even less for the baby than I do.He thinks she's obese

I hope this isn’t real ,because this is nauseating. Seriously. What are we reading.

These people exist and walk amongst us?

RedHelenB · 18/09/2020 20:31

I think not wanting to cuddle any baby is weird sorry.