Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to dislike my niece?

229 replies

abigailsdinner · 18/09/2020 12:59

Please be kind because I know I sound absolutely awful but I'm looking for help to connect.

For some reason, when my DN was born (DH's sister's baby) I just felt so cold towards her. She is now 10 months. I made all the effort to ensure we saw SIL whilst pregnant, then as soon as baby was born (they live 2 hours drive away) and have seen her a few times. I feel so awkward. I thought that it was because I'm not maternal yet and it would come. But then my friends had a baby and I absolutely love him. I love playing with him, I love cuddling him, I love seeing him grow. So obviously there is some warmth in my cold heart.

I wonder if it's that I resent SIL and her DH, she hasn't necessarily done anything wrong but they are quite against my moral beliefs.
I am currently in therapy and one of my issues is 'rigid beliefs' which is what causes a lot of my OCD/Anxiety apparently. For example, they regularly make comments about nurses being unintelligent, not as good as doctors, they comment on ANYONE who is overweight for absolutely no reason, they make sweeping statements about certain religions / ethnicities (i.e. "I know that Nigerian nurses are lazier than British ones, just look at who has called in sick since coronavirus, it's an excuse, you don't see doctors doing that")

They have become uncaring towards anything in our lives or our animals who are our "children" (at present, maybe one day I'll have babies fingers crossed) - for example, they allowed them into a main road off lead when we were helping with the baby. They were lucky to not get hit by a car and didn't apologise. Our dog was attacked by another on the street and I was bitten when we went to get them groceries (to help out when they were exhausted as baby was just born), they didn't bat an eyelid when I came home covered in mud and bleeding. It was surreal.

I find SIL not particularly maternal so I cringe when they make baby noises etc, it feels so awkward. I then can't do it either because I feel awkward and cringe at myself. They tend to sit on their phones a lot and just let DN crawl around in another room until they hear a bang (last time we were there it was playing with bottles of wine that then smashed).

They're intelligent people, they love DN, they're good parents as far as I can tell (minus a few little incidents as above) and the first to have a child in DH's family. As a result there is a lot of attention on them constantly, for example, EVERY single message we send MIL gets a response with a picture of the baby. DH was always treated unfairly to his sister and it's caused a lot of issues along the way. For example, at Christmas everyone met up except him and he wasn't told or invited, they then denied it and said it was impromptu (his other brother lives in a different country).

Basically, I sound somewhat jealous(?), angry(?) but I really REALLY don't want it to affect my relationship with DN and I need to put it aside.

Has anyone felt like this before? DN has done nothing wrong and I want to be seen as someone she can rely on. DH is the same as me but doesn't particularly care about connecting.

I also don't want anyone to think I'm bashing SIL's parenting, I can't parent, I don't have children, I am just stating things that I think may contribute to my weird mindset.

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 18/09/2020 16:38

Sounds like you just dont like them and this baby is merely an extension of them, therefore you feel indifferent. I wouldnt worry too much about it. I would spend less time with them, if that's how you feel about them.

imfatletsparty · 18/09/2020 16:44

"Also, after I had my DS’s I wouldn’t have noticed an atomic bomb explode outside my house never mind someone coming in covered in mud. They had just had a new baby, they would’ve been tired and most likely overwhelmed. Also how is it anyone else’s fault that your dog was attacked?

OP, you sound so self centred it is untrue, so much dislike towards a baby but I guarantee if someone made a negative comment about one of your animals you’d be ballistic. I really would speak with your therapist, as you strike me as wanting everyone to conform to you and your ways Of thinking."

Unless one of the side effects of having a baby is a loss of vision, how does anyone NOT notice someone coming into their house (after doing THEM a favour but you know, selfish) covered in blood?!

Bluntness100 · 18/09/2020 16:48

OP has expressed nothing that makes me think her real feelings are anything more than meh

Really? You just think meh when someone says to you they feel so cold towards a baby and dislike them? That’s also concerning for you. I guess you’re aware the fact you also have issues and think this is normal doesn’t mean it is, right?

I also wonder, as a pp said, if this decision was already taken before the baby arrived, they don’t like my “babies” so I won’t like theirs.

There is though a big difference between not paying animals attention and disliking an actual baby. And pets aren’t babies.

There is clearly something else going on here for the baby to be the focus of the ops dislike and coldness. I suspect a deep seated envy of the attention, the child, and what she represents. The first grandchild, the one who gets all the attention , just another way foe the sister to be the favourite, and possibly a very big reminder than the ops pets aren’t actually babies.

mrsmuddlepies · 18/09/2020 16:53

I agree with Bluntness (I often do)

Upstartcrones · 18/09/2020 16:57

I completely agree with Bluntness

Disliking (and let's be clear that's what the OP put then back tracked) a specific baby is not normal. Not liking children in general is something completely different.

It's good the OP is in therapy but I do think you need to be honest with your DP as this is a worrying trait. I'd want to know if my partner felt this way before having kids with them.

EnormousGinplease · 18/09/2020 16:57

I don't particularly like our nephew ... my sil son. Something about him just doesn't warm your heart, I thought it was just me but finally asked my DH how he felt about him, his response was as cool as mine. I do think it's connected to how you feel about the parents. My sil and husband are very materialistic and somewhat selfish, this rubbed off onto them raising a spoilt rude child/adolescent.

maryd84 · 18/09/2020 16:59

Why would anyone feel a coldness or dislike towards an innocent baby and say she's not cute or pretty.

You're very odd. I think therapy is a good idea🤨

Havaiana · 18/09/2020 16:59

@EnormousGinplease conveniently omitting age of nephew?

imfatletsparty · 18/09/2020 17:03

As long as OP isn't actively being cruel or harming this child in anyway I don't see what the big deal is. Maybe I need therapy too.

EnormousGinplease · 18/09/2020 17:06

[quote Havaiana]@EnormousGinplease conveniently omitting age of nephew?[/quote]
He is now 19. Of course no opinion on him as a baby other than I had my own young children to love so my attention was never fully on him but I thought the relationship would develop over time ... it never did and like I said that absence has been noticed by everyone in my own family (5 of us in total)

MandosHatHair · 18/09/2020 17:11

*Why would anyone feel a coldness or dislike towards an innocent baby and say she's not cute or pretty.

You're very odd. I think therapy is a good idea🤨*

Please don't have your own children until you have adressed these issues. Sounds like you are jealous of the attention the baby is getting over you and your pets. Of course your in laws will be more interested in thier grandchild than you or your animals.

PizzaAndCake · 18/09/2020 17:14

I used to be a nurse and I personally would not associate with anyone who said they thought nurses were stupid. They also sound like a bunch of racists. These are the type of people I cut off.

Bluntness100 · 18/09/2020 17:18

He is now 19

Why do you remotely think that disliking an adult relative is remotely the same as disliking a ten month old baby? Or it was remotely relevant ?

OldGreyBoots · 18/09/2020 17:22

For what it's worth I don't think you sound out of order OP. I couldn't muster up the enthusiasm to get excited about someone else's child, and I don't find babies cute. I don't think that should be treated as if it's a criminal act Hmm

BloggersBlog · 18/09/2020 17:23

I am presuming that @EnormousGinplease felt the same towards the nephew when he was a baby/young child and is saying she still feels the same now

Upstartcrones · 18/09/2020 17:25

she's not expected to be excited but actively disliking a baby is indicative of deeper issues.

Can you honestly not see the difference? Getting jealous because your pets are not getting the same attention as a baby is a red flag somethings not right.

BreatheAndFocus · 18/09/2020 17:27

I don't find babies cute. I don't think that should be treated as if it's a criminal act

But OP does like her friend’s baby. It’s just her DN she dislikes.

I think that’s different,

Notfeelinggreattoday · 18/09/2020 17:31

I must be quite unique as i care about by nephews on my husbands side , i am closer to two more than the others as I get on better with That sil and infact she has split with dh brother but we are still in touch with her and kids and i see them regularly
But as neither you or your dh like his sister and husband why even bother to maintain a relationship

UniversalAunt · 18/09/2020 17:35

It’s OK not to like your SIL & BiL - nowt unusual there - & by extension not to feel strong warmth or love towards their baby.

Clearly you are capable of feeling & showing interest, warmth & affection to your friends & their beloved baby - nowt unusual there.

What I suggest that you consider upon is that the indifference you feel towards your DN is a reflection of the indifference your SIL & BiL have towards their own child.

At earliest stages, babies who are well enough loved learn to communicate in such a way to encourage more of that sustainable affection & love, & in turn become more lovable to others. Perhaps you find that your DN is not so loveable as she has not had those early experiences?

Not you or your DN’s fault. Perhaps you are more sensitive & tuned in than others as you are in therapy so reflecting deeper & experiencing personal growth.

Bluntness100 · 18/09/2020 17:39

Perhaps you find that your DN is not so loveable as she has not had those early experiences

Wow did you seriously just suggest this child is not loved and doesn’t get affection so it’s the mothers fault and the op is just sensitive to these things?

Seriously, you wrote that?

Leftsideright · 18/09/2020 17:45

I love mine so much more than my partner's sisters child. I don't dislike her at all. But she's spoilt compared to mine. She's the apple of my partner's mums eye. She was the first born and is favoured over my kids. I am more pissed of with the adults who have not given my kids an equal relationship and somehow seem beneath her.

I also disliked a friend's kid from her being 18 months. Again that's because her mum allowed her to be feral at my house. She also let her hurt my baby. So I stopped seeing them. She is the only toddler I've disliked. Met them a few times last year and she's six now and still an absolute whinging, miserable cry baby lol. Really gets on my nerves.

Any other kid I absolutely love to see.

user1487194234 · 18/09/2020 17:45

I am fond enough of my DHs nieces and nephews but it is not anything like the very close bond I have with my own

Pumpkinpie1 · 18/09/2020 17:47

Good for you recognising that you have issues and seeking support - not easy.
Focusing on yourself and your husband , building a solid foundation is much more important than DH family politics & drama.
10 months is a drop in the ocean and I think you recognise how flawed family attitudes and actions understandably are colouring your perception . There is no reason to think your niece will grow up to be like her parents, your husband didn’t & you love him x
Distancing yourselves emotionally from the drama will help you gain perspective. After all his family drama can only be important if you allow it to taint your happiness as a couple.

Dominicgoings · 18/09/2020 17:50

@BreatheAndFocus

I don't find babies cute. I don't think that should be treated as if it's a criminal act

But OP does like her friend’s baby. It’s just her DN she dislikes.

I think that’s different,

This. OP you need to discuss this in more detail with your therapist. And your DP. Ambivalence and ‘meh’ feelings towards other peoples kids are perfectly normal. Your feelings are much more intense and odd. You either make a choice to cut ties and stop focusing on how much you dislike the baby or you get help to deal with your feelings.
user1471453601 · 18/09/2020 17:50

You say "it was playing with bottles of wine .." In your opening post.

is the "it" in question the neice? If so, you'd maybe like to think about what using such a dehumanizing word for a person says about you