Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my sister needs to get a grip and grow the fuck up?

325 replies

BigtimeLittlesis · 14/07/2020 15:04

NC because this is definitely outing:

She's 36 and my only sibling.

For as far back as I can remember, she was the Golden Child in our family: sweet, pretty, popular, straight As at school, responsible kid, good school followed by good uni ...

... and then, she sort of developed late-onset puberty and hasn't really snapped out of it since.

Changed subjects / universities several times before graduating. Eventually qualified as a teacher. Got a job, hated it, resigned. Worked as a short-term supply on and off again for a while.

Then found her dream job working for a charity abroad. Did it for some years, was super happy because "people are just so much [insert any number of positives here] around here".

Mandate ended, came back, started teaching again, more of the same.

Ran off to developing country again.

So far so "maybe not a top performer at adulting, but so what?"

But, in the meantime, our parents got older. Mum suffered a hypertensive crisis and spent a week in ICU. Dad lost his job and struggled to find work again at age 60.

Sister would call me from her "escape from reality" paradise and demand I look after them. Which I do, to the best of my abilities. Sister berated me for not going to see mum often enough as she was recovering. Easy for her to say, being a long-haul flight away!

Here's where things come to a head:

Sister took off again in February. Yes, February. Now, granted, things developed fast around that time - but it's hardly as though the looming global crisis wasn't obvious. The situation developed and things got bad. Sister refused to return home. Mum and dad started to worry. Then I started to worry - not so much about her health but about the possibility of an economic crash with her being stuck in a developing country with no access to money that didn't depend entirely upon local cash machines continuing to work.

I ended up emotionally blackmailing her into getting a re-patriation flight for the sake of everyone's ease of mind. She's been silently judging me for "making her do this" ever since.

Now dad's brother has died. Now, I had pretty much no relationship with this man. But when dad asked would I come to the funeral I naturally said yes - not for my uncle but for my father. We've had a difficult relationship at times - but I feel terrible for dad losing his second sibling aged only 61.

Sister is, again, refusing to turn up and blatantly lying, saying she has "work obligations". She doesn't. Schools local to her are on summer break. Then she says she doesn't know the guy. True. But she knows our dad. Then she says dad was not always there for us either and she hates "family shit". Again, true as far as our less than stellar father is concerned - but also: do you really need to play at puberty at this precise moment? Kick people when they're down already?

I've had my fair share of rows with our father - and I was the black sheep child, the one who got all the criticism, not her. But it's just not the moment!

Long story short: I feel that I'm being forced into the role of the dependable, supportive, sensible daughter here because my sister somehow decided to enter puberty at age 21 and to keep it up for a decade and a half. They're her parents, too! She's missed mum's 60th, dad's 60th, mum almost dying, dad losing his job and needing to be financially rescued by me in order to keep the roof over his head, our grandfather dying and now our uncle dying ... and then she dares to berate me for not being there often enough???

WIBU to tell her she's being selfish and pubescent and needs to grow the fuck up - and that I'm not "default daughter" here just because I managed to get over adolescence some time in my early to mid twenties?

And, yes, I love her. Dearly so. But I'm also really hurt and feel I'm being taken advantage of.

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 14/07/2020 17:50

Take a deep breath....

Your parents seem to have fucked you both up

Just from your own words neither of you sound as though you have quite managed to hit full, emancipated adulthood. She's runnning and you're chained - and both of you blame the other!

If you want a relationship with her, a good one, one based on who each of you really are you need to stop and thnk about how you both seem to be fighting with your life's shape - the one both of your parents drew up for you!

If it helps, DSis have only just managed this, in our 50s. We were well and truly divided and conquered by our parents. We managed to talk it through when she arrived in floods of tears having realised why I had been so distant, almost NC for decades! She trusted I wouldn't tell her to fuck off, or laugh at her - she later said she didn't think she could have been so magnanimous! It has changed both our lives for the better.

So - do you think it is worth trying hard with your DSIS, to see if the two of you can find common ground and stop blaming each other for silly stuff?

Ethicalbluey45 · 14/07/2020 17:53

You need to have a conversation with your sister which frankly should have been had along time ago trust me you will feel much better everyone will be angry to start off but they will soon calm down and then follows the RESPECT . OMG i have just told you what i did with my sisters and brother 2 years on we are now talking baby steps , when it comes to the serious stuff i get asked and no more demands and being dumped on trust me they were piss takers makes your sister sound like a pussy cat

Roselilly36 · 14/07/2020 17:54

Totally get where you are coming from, golden child will always be so, my DH is testament to that, he’s also black sheep.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 14/07/2020 17:55

It all sounds highly dysfunctional. Why do you send your grown adult of a sister money? It's entirely up to your parents if they choose to do that, but why should you, just because you are a higher earner than she is? How has this come about? Is it that she asks for these things, as I'm not reading that from what you've described. It's almost as if your parents and you have fallen into this role of keeping her young and incapable. Demanding she come home because otherwise you'd all worry sick? Even taking on responsibilities for the running of her housing here, from the sound of it! She's not 17, she can sort her own shit out. Perhaps she now has no confidence in her own abilities if you have always gone in to rescue her. It's just really weird behaviour, OP. You just need to let her grow up. Stop giving her money for day to day living. If you want to spoil her on her birthday, then fair enough. But your behaviour is making her dependent on you, and it does sound like she travels to get away from that form of control.

Everyone else is right about your parents needing to look after themselves, and if thely can't then they can get cleaners, shoppers etc to help them.

As for you ordering her to attend the funeral. It's totally her choice, you are both adults and allowed to see things differently and come to the different decisions. It's as if you are being offended on behalf of your dad when really it isn't anything to do with you.

You just need to take a big step back from the entanglement of the individual lives and choices of your family members. You do you, let them do them.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/07/2020 18:00

The scapegoat versus golden child dynamic is as unhealthy as it's unfortunately common. It rarely does the golden child any more favours than it does the scapegoat.

Your sister has possibly recognized this and removed herself from the equation. It would be fully understandable for you to resent the two of you being cast in these roles by your parents (and once you're in them, sadly the dynamic is pretty much set in stone and won't change no matter how much you try to win their approval. So you try to do so by being dutiful, will likely receive no gratitude or appreciation for doing so, while the golden child abdicates their responsibility whilst still remaining the golden child and you're left resenting the whole lot).

It's not fair. In fact, it sucks on an almighty scale and the resulting resentment is entirely understandable.

The only thing I can suggest doing in circumstances such as these is to drop the rope. Put yourself and your mental health first, and let the others crack on. My sympathies are with you, as they are with anyone who finds themselves in this unenviable position Flowers

tenredthings · 14/07/2020 18:04

It's tricky. I support an elderly parent who was pretty unsupportive of us as kids. My brother is totally uninvolved and useless, even though he lives in the same country as DP and I don't. It's still me visiting way more often and phoning every day whilst DB does SFA.

I could massively resent my DB but I choose not to. I even get why he's not very involved as DP has always shown so little support or interest on our lives. I recognize that it's my choice to give more. I want to be the empathic, kind person I wish he had been. It's actually meant I've had the opportunity to make a better relationship with DP and hopefully teach my DC how to support elderly parents.

Give as much as you are willing to give and let your Sibling do the same. Resentment will just eat you up.

modernmystery · 14/07/2020 18:04

How is working abroad in 'developing countries' akin to an extended puberty? I've worked overseas almost my whole adult life in some of the most challenging locations in the developing world and have loved every second of it. I'm currently UK based but itching to get back out to field as soon as possible. My colleagues and friends I have met along the way are highly qualified, motivated and driven people - doctors, economists, teachers, diplomats, UN staff. My family are 'traditionalists' when it comes to life and work, but even they have been by and large supportive.

My partner was not repatriated during covid and has spent the last 6 months at post in an extremely challenging location. He has been fine, and never have I or any of his family considered 'emotional blackmail' to get him back. His sister had a stillbirth a few weeks ago but fully understood that he couldn't return for the funeral.

You sound very derisive of 'developing countries'. You know that a huge proportion of the worlds population do live and thrive in these places right? My ex was more of a homebody and would never have wanted to even visit, let alone move to, a developing country. I was born in a developing country, my family still live in one. I find this attitude so insufferable.

BacklashStarts · 14/07/2020 18:08

I am so on the fence. So much so I haven’t voted Grin

She IBU on thinking she can dictate from afar and you should be v firm with her on that. Say ‘that’s easy to say when you’re a long haul flight away.’ Etc as you have here. My mum used to pull this shit on my uncle being all ‘he’s useless he does do XYZ for parents’ he was there; she wasn’t!

But... you are overly invested in getting her to toe the line with your folks. She doesn’t have to have a relationship like yours with them. Step back from that, just say ‘I don’t know’ or ‘you’d have to ask her’. Don’t cover for us but also don’t take on the belief that there are things she ‘should’ do which you have to make up for. That’s all in your head. By all means agree or disagree with your folks if they complain but don’t get pulled into it. It’s really not on you if she gets stuck abroad. All you need in that situation is empathy - not to jump to helmet mode.

BacklashStarts · 14/07/2020 18:08

Helmet mode?? Helper mode!

rachelfrost · 14/07/2020 18:10

Stop giving your sister money.
Stop thinking she owes you certain behaviours.
You’re both adults now.

Tappering · 14/07/2020 18:15

Step back.

You are resenting your sister for treating you as a parent, whilst simultaneously enabling her behaviour.

Stop giving her money.

Stop making yourself accountable to her - if she starts sticking her oar in then tell her to back off and mind her own business.

Step back. I suspect you will be much happier for it.

StatementKnickers · 14/07/2020 18:18

YANBU but she will never change (I am in a similar situation) so you may as well lower your expectations, focus your energy on your parents and ignore her. And stop giving her money!

BilboBercow · 14/07/2020 18:20

Get some therapy op. I mean that kindly. You didn't come across well in your op but everything you've said is screaming out that your parents have really done a number on you AND your sister.
You have been so much at pains to point out how you are a success and your sister is a fuck up because you are still so full of resentment.

randolph78 · 14/07/2020 18:22

You need to make your own decisions and let her make hers. Don't accept her telling you what to do re: your parents in the future but also stop trying to control her. She does not see things the same way as you - accept that even if you don'e like it. Then maybe you can both start to treat each other with some respect.

mellicauli · 14/07/2020 18:40

Your Sister has the right idea - parents aren’t very old. You don’t need to look after them like this. Your Mum can support your Dad at the funeral. The can sort their own financial messes up. Go away and live your life. Phone them now and again. Meet up at Christmas and Easter. And yes, if they are ill you would visit, of course. You’ll throw away your life pandering to theirs if you are not careful. They could live til their 90s. You are signing up for 30 years of this crap, for no good reason.

HamishDent · 14/07/2020 18:44

I can understand your frustration. Siblings who make the decision to live in another country leaving their sibling to care for elderly parents are inherently selfish. There’s no getting away from that.

My brother had the cheek to tell me I ‘wasn’t alone’ whilst dealing with our mother having heart surgery earlier this year. I had to say to him that actually, I was ‘alone’ given he was 1000’s of miles away and being of no practical help whatsoever. If he wanted me to not be alone he should have got on a bloody plane and come home to help.

I totally get where you coming from OP.

rosegoldwatcher · 14/07/2020 18:45

Blowing your top with your sister will not change her life choices, it will not ease your responsibilities towards your parents, it won't make you feel less angry.

There's that old adage about not being able to change another person's behaviour, just your own reaction to it. Perhaps take a deep breath and carry on caring for your parents because you love them (as you clearly do), not because your sister won't/isn't in a position to do so.

As a side note - her missing their 60th birthdays is absolutely no biggy!

Porcupineinwaiting · 14/07/2020 18:48

Yes YABU

Butt out of her life. If you dont like her nagging you about your parents (YANBU about that) then tell her. If she carries on, put the phone down.

It's not "inherently selfish" to not shape your life caring for your parents, esp if they were not that great in the first place.

Veganforlife · 14/07/2020 18:51

They are your parents ,not your children ,YABU

HamishDent · 14/07/2020 18:52

It is if you expect your brother or sister to bear your responsibilities for you porcupine.

1forAll74 · 14/07/2020 18:57

Your Sister is totally different to you,and has gone about her life as she wanted to. A different personality, a different outlook on life. She may not match your high standards, but she doesn't have to. So no use getting in a state about anything.

diddl · 14/07/2020 19:01

" Siblings who make the decision to live in another country leaving their sibling to care for elderly parents are inherently selfish."

Op's parents aren't elderly.

It must have been quite unforeseen that they would need so much help whilst still so young.

My husband is an only child-we live abroad-whoops!

I8toys · 14/07/2020 19:03

Sounds like my DH's brother. Different jobs, different countries, never satisfied, constantly looking for something and never finding it. Left DH looking after his mum when his dad was going through a second heart valve surgery and critical. I am resentful of his brother not sure DH is but the extra stress DH was under at the time was horrendous. Some people only think of themselves unfortunately.

Iloveacurry · 14/07/2020 19:03

Honestly, you need to stop giving her money for a start.

Cherrysoup · 14/07/2020 19:04

YANBU to tell her to come home. She needs to get a job and stop accepting being supported by you and your parents, that’s pretty pathetic at her age. She had no right to harass you about not looking after your parents enough. Jeez, at 60, unless they have awful health issues, surely they don’t need it?