Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disappointed in my ring and proposal.

506 replies

fungalinthejungle · 07/05/2020 21:24

Has anyone ever felt this way? I got engaged just before lockdown.

It was at home, just the two of us. No fanfare. And the ring is not exactly what I'd dreamed of. He then had a jam packed week at work so I barely saw him and then we went into lockdown.

So we haven't been able to see any family and friends but that's just one of those things.

I sound so ungrateful but I'd always dreamed of an amazing proposal moment and feeling excited and not disappointed when I saw the ring.

Ultimately I know that it doesn't really matter because we are getting married and I hate myself for feeling this way.

Has anyone else ever felt the same?!

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 08/05/2020 18:04

We had a low key proposal, he told me he wanted to buy me a ring for my birthday.
Which was cool and we then planned to announce it on my birthday on a weekend away when we got the ring.
So our parents knew but no one else till we posted the announcement.
So you could create the excitement by planning for a ring shopping trip when it's over and nice lunch etc.
My chap is Not a planner! I am the planner. And the world assumes he planned the birthday weekend engagement thing and I knew nothing about it. Bless!

Summerofloaf · 08/05/2020 18:11

Did you tell him what ring you did want? Otherwise he didn’t have much to go on other than you saying how nice another ring was (whether you meant it or not).

If you can’t talk to him about this it doesn’t bode well for good communications in future, does it.

Oldbutkicking · 08/05/2020 18:19

At least you weren’t having a discussion about income tax. We were saying that he was paying so much and I joked that if we got married he could have some of my allowance and pay less. I then said that I knew he didn’t want to get married and I was only joking and then he said that he did want to get married and I said ok. I hate my ring now too but it’s all we could afford. I got a small inheritance a few years later and bought myself a new one. He did help me choose it. Been so happily married for over 20 years. The proposal doesn’t matter one jot. Just get on with planning your big day.

CrisPbacon · 08/05/2020 18:21

Oh I dunno, my first date was via a trip to the tip and he proposed at the sewage works. At least I was under no illusions!

monkeycats · 08/05/2020 18:24

Why did he propose at the sewage works Cris? Why? Could he not have waited half an hour?

Headinthecloudsfeetinthemud · 08/05/2020 18:24

I’m glad and I wish you well. Do you think you’ll be able to have a heart to heart with your fiancé?

monkeycats · 08/05/2020 18:25

And how did you end up at the tip on your first date? Confused

fascinated · 08/05/2020 18:25

It’s five huge diamonds but that is smaller than your friends’? Oooft. Are you a celebrity or summat? Footballers’ wives?

Thisismytimetoshine · 08/05/2020 18:26

Why wouldn't you propose at the sewage works? That's a proper tale to tell your grandchildren Grin

SD1978 · 08/05/2020 18:28

Meh. The big proposal, the over choreographed wedding dance, gender reveal parties, OTT 1st birthday parties....l social media, movies and Americanism have a lot to answer for.....

Lifeasweknow · 08/05/2020 18:28

My proposal was a drunken one with absolutely no romance but I wasn't that bothered about it. I was however not keen on my engagement ring. People are allowed to not like things, regardless of who it came from and it certainly doesn't mean you love someone any less and shouldn't be marrying them. I ended up with a complete new set after having my kids. We've been married 8 years now and me not like the ring had zero affect on our relationship.

Middersweekly · 08/05/2020 18:35

I got proposed on the morning of my birthday by DH. It was very low key and sweet. Just the two of us sitting in bed. He chose the ring himself. Something I wouldn’t have chosen if I had picked myself but I loved that he had chosen it. I’ve worn it happily for 17+ years. It’s the thought that counts and the fact he chose it. There will be plenty of time for celebration after lockdown.

rainbowsandrage · 08/05/2020 18:43

It’s ok to be disappointed. I too had a basic ‘at home’ proposal and I absolutely hated the ring, BUT, 11 years later, I love my husband more every day and the proposal no longer matters to me. (Unfortunately I still hate the ring 😬 but my husband has no idea).

Picklesprout · 08/05/2020 18:43

My proposal was not big or glam but was perfect for me
I feel for men who are nervous of the big perfect proposal. My friend keeps trying to plan his but it never works out so he hasn't proposed. The private jet was double booked (seriously!) The hotel room he wanted wasnt available and so on
She just wants to get married and would be happy with being asked, but he wants perfection and 10 years on is still trying to make it

aliphil · 08/05/2020 18:56

I tease DH about his proposal occasionally, as it was a weekend when we'd been on a couple of beautiful romatic walks but he decided to propose when we were just sitting on his bed in a grotty student room! I was a bit dusappointed but ultimately it doesn't matter. We will have been happily married for 18 years next month.

monkeycats · 08/05/2020 19:03

It’s always the same on any thread about proposals. People come on and say, “Oh my DH just lobbed a Haribo at me and shouted, “Oi, book the registry.”

I remember one woman on here who seemed genuinely delighted to reveal how her DH proposed to her while she was on the toilet Confused

Meanwhile, in the real world, most men do actually propose in a reasonably normal fashion.

No, the length of the marriage will not be determined by the proposal situation, but some women seem to be under the delusion that a crap, thoughtless proposal is actually preferable or more genuine Confused Their main evidence for this seems to be the fact they’ve so far steered clear of divorce.

If someone proposed to me while I was on the loo, I would have been livid. That would be it.

I’m no princess and I’m not one to stand in ceremony in general, but my view is, if a man wants to marry you, the very least he can do is make the effort to ask you in a meaningful way. I mean, it’s not that hard is it? Buy a ring; create a moment; ask a question? It’s not rocket science. Call me old-fashioned, but that’s me and there it is.

When DH proposed to me I really wasn’t expecting it and I had no fixed ideas about how it should pan out, but now I’m older (18 years older), I really appreciate the fact he thought about it and tried to make it special because these moments stay with you. We were on some cliffs over the sea in my home country and we sat on a bench to see the view, but he got on one knee and said some lovely things which so still remember and the thing is, when you have moments like that (any moments) it helps you get through the rough times. The ring he gave me was a platinum diamond solitaire, but he wouldn’t have minded if I’d wanted to change it (I didn’t as so don’t really wear gold).

He later admitted he’d been super nervous about proposing for weeks. OP, I think this might have also been the case with your DH. Maybe the nerves just overwhelmed him a bit in the moment? I think your ring sounds lovely. I’m sure he wouldn’t mind if you told him you wanted gold though. He probably just wants to make you happy.

The main thing, I always think, is not the actual actions themselves, but the intention behind the action (if that makes sense)? He hasn’t just proposed on a whim. He’s tried to get you a ring he thought you’d like based on a comment you made about your friend’s ring. And at least he actually went to the trouble of formally asking you which, if we are to go by MN, is a great hardship men shouldn’t have to put themselves out to do these days. No, we should either ask them ourselves, or just be happy with a quick business-like mention of the subject and preferably no ring, no party. Nothing.

So, in the parallel world that is MN, your partner is streets ahead already Grin Try looking at it this way. Change the ring if you need to. Congratulations!

SmileyClare · 08/05/2020 19:07

Isn't the purpose of mumsnet for people to vent anonymously In part but you might be getting confused with NetMums. Wink

In AIBU you'll get refreshingly honest (sometimes blunt) replies. That's the beauty of it. Not everyone will pat your hand, ok hun and agree with you. Sometimes it's a much needed dose of reality.
Hopefully the anecdotes on here and sensible advice from women who have been there and done that have given you some perspective Op.

It is a little off key to be nit picking over the way a partner proposed with 5 huge diamonds when we're in the middle of a pandemic that's destroyed many lives and many of us are facing financial ruin.

However, it has been light relief from all that so I have enjoyed reading all the comments. Smile

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 08/05/2020 19:08

Well I never got either and we've been married 44 years in August. We'd been together a few years and it was not the norm to just live together so we kind of just decided to get married. He was like, you don't want a ring do ya? I just went along with it. Anyway, 40 years later I put it on the line and told him I want a ruby ring in lieu of an engagement ring I never had! It's 1970s vintage so appropriate, better late than never eh? Good job he's gorgeous and we still love each other to bits

MacBlank · 08/05/2020 19:08

I see you CHICKENED out of going for a vote, cos I think you know what it'll say.... YABU

want to know something???

My fiancée's ring cost less than £15 , yes, you read that right. See were both disabled and scraping by on disability benefit. Unlike some who seem to get thousands each month, we don't, we get little more than those on job seekers. Not even her being a cancer patient is enough to get more!

So on her birthday a couple years ago, I proposed as I was handing her, her birthday gifts.

Thing is, not only is the ring her taste, but to her it wasn't about cost or a fat solitaire (over priced due to huge stockpiles of diamonds to artificially keep the price high) it's about us, and love.

People at her.old job (she was working at the time) thought it was really expensive (admittedly it does look good) and she thought it funny, that they couldn't tell the difference.

So.for you to come here looking for sympathy, cos.you WANTED a big fat show off ring, and prob a 5 star meal, and the whole restaurant looking at you. That wasn't something my fiancee wanted, she would have been embarrassed if I'd done that to her.

Get a life and be happy, and stop being so bloody greedy.

Do you love the person?
Do you want to spend the rest of your life with them?
Then cut the crap and be happy.

livefornaps · 08/05/2020 19:15

Lollllloooohhhh, jeez @MacBlank, going for the jugular.much?

fungalinthejungle · 08/05/2020 19:15

@MacBlank you need to relax.

I didn't want to huge public show or everyone looking at me? I literally said it would have been nice if he went down on one knee and said a few nice words....

But congrats on the £15 ring making you superior to anyone that spent ££.

Thanks @monkeycats - you and a few others seem to make sense. I have loads of friends in real life who got engaged in normal (not OTT) romantic ways and have nice dine. They are all nice down to earth non greedy people!

@SmileyClare glad my life provides light relief. I clearly know this is a first world problem and I'm sorry that you and others face financial ruin. It's horrible and not fair.

OP posts:
OVienna · 08/05/2020 19:16

MacBlank A heavy dose of sanctimony makes a wrist-slapping thar much more effective, I find. Seems you agree!

livefornaps · 08/05/2020 19:16

@fungalinthejungle, i,.too.have.enjoyyed.this thread, hope you are feeling happier.

DinosApple · 08/05/2020 19:17

I wouldn't stress about the proposal, and it sounds like he tried to get the right ring. Perhaps you're deflated because you can't gather with friends and family for a celebration?

DH proposed to me after a pub quiz, under the stars. I knew it was coming as I had seen a ring like liked coming up for auction. I asked him if he'd like to put a commission bid on it 😂.

The first thing we did after we got back was have an argument about where to get married (I won).Wink

fungalinthejungle · 08/05/2020 19:18

@OVienna I could barely get through that post without laughing. Who can get that wound up about a stranger online.

They didn't read any of my posts properly and just ranted based on an assumption.

I want a smaller ring and a few nice words. Lock me up!

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.